A Lesson In Advertising From The Eighteenth Century

Back in the 1760s, the great Dr Samuel Johnson delivered himself of the dictum that 'promise, large promise is the soul of advertising'. It's a good thought, a great thought; and I contend that what was true then is equally true today. But it seems to me that modern advertisers are tying themselves into unnecessary knots in an attempt to reach audiences which they believe are becoming increasingly indifferent to their blandishments.

Well, yes, markets are turning deaf ears and blind eyes, but they always have done, though not for the reasons generally espoused by the world's marketers. I am convinced that despite all the sophisticated research and marketing effort that goes into advertising these days, the real reason that markets are indifferent to advertising is because much of it ignores the many splendoured principle that people don't buy products, they buy the benefits of owning those products.

Today, the great proportion of advertisers don't deliver sales messages, they tell what they hope are emotive stories with which the market can empathise, then they drop the product in as an afterthought, hoping that enough emotional cross-communication has been achieved for people to reach for their credit cards. That it doesn't and people won't has resulted in huge advertising budget cut-backs in the developed world in recent years. Only a manufacturer who has taken leave of his senses will throw even more money at a strategy that doesn't work.

The strategy responsible operates under the title Emotional Sales Proposition (ESP), thought in some quarters to be an advance on the Unique Sales Proposition (USP) which, on the contrary, does actually work. What has been overlooked or, more likely, ignored, is that in developing the principle of the USP in the late 1950s, the brilliant Rosser Reeves was striving to replace an advertising strategy that had been in situ for 30 or so years and was fast running out of steam. What was the device he was hoping to supersede? Well, by any other name, it was the emotional sales proposition. I won't bore you with the detail, but if you'd like to find out more, you should lay your hands on Reeves' book, Reality in Advertising (MacGibbon & Kee ? 1961). It could be an eye-opener.

So, it's true ? the one thing we learn from history is that we never learn anything from history. Let's go back to Dr Johnson. It's worth remembering that the kind of advertising old Sam was talking about in the 18th century was fairly innocuous and largely unexceptionable. It could be read in coffee- house flyers, in chapbooks and in rudimentary newspapers; and it consisted of sales messages as diverse as where to get your wig powdered and the date of the next public hanging at Tyburn. Even so, the products and services on offer were as important to the people of the time as mobile phones and computers are to us.

In the human condition, nothing much changes. Our egos still need to be massaged and we are all in hot pursuit of happiness. Only our methods for achieving these goals, only our technologies, vary with time.

So the next time you are tempted to commit advertising, think about Sam Johnson and give your market a reason for owning your product. A good reason.

About The Author

Patrick Quinn is an award winning copywriter with 40 years' experience of the advertising business in London, Miami, Dublin and Edinburgh. He publishes a FREE monthly newsletter, AdBriefing. Subscriptions are available at: http://www.adbriefing.com

In The News:


San Francisco Chronicle

Open up the black box of political advertising
San Francisco Chronicle
Those who would challenge false, hateful or misleading advertisements are rendered mute. They don't know what's been said, or to whom, because micro-targeted advertising happens out of public view. It's only through the efforts of diligent reporters ...
Mark Zuckerberg backs stricter vetting on political advertising after Russian ad purchasesWashington Examiner
Democratic senators preparing bill to deal with online political advertisingCNNMoney
Facebook Wants to Self-Regulate Political Advertising, Provide Russian Ads to CongressVariety
The Hill -BBC News
all 751 news articles »

Best of the week: Safari update underscores Apple's ambivalence about advertising
Digiday
Six ad industry groups wrote in an open letter to Apple last week that the move will sabotage the internet's economy. But because Apple makes most of its money from selling devices, unlike Google and Amazon, which bring in revenue from advertising ...


Business Insider

Adobe has hired a media buying veteran to help ramp up its advertising bona fides
Business Insider
At Adobe, his task will be to explain to the ad world why Adobe's one-stop shopping approach to digital advertising — the company offers brands tools for ad buying, data management, making ads and connecting with existing customers — is better than ...

and more »

The Indian Express

Apple has done a horrible job advertising the iPhone 8
BGR
Let's say you have an iPhone 7 or an iPhone 6s, what are the benefits of upgrading to the iPhone 8? It's an important question that Apple has curiously and clumsily failed to answer. Sure, tech heads who intently watched Apple's keynote last week can ...
iPhone 8 Durability Test - BEND TEST - Glass Scratch Video!YouTube
Apple admits to Apple Watch LTE problems just before it shipsThe Verge
Apple Watch Series 3 with LTE review: missed connectionsThe Verge
iFixit
all 510 news articles »

The Tech Takeover of Advertising in One Chart
Visual Capitalist (blog)
But, despite these other initiatives and some diligent messaging, make no mistake – both Alphabet and Facebook are media companies that get their money from one source. Advertising makes up the vast majority of their business, and they've both become ...

and more »

STLtoday.com

Twitter won't run an anti-abortion group's paid advertising unless it scrubs its website of 'sensitive content'
STLtoday.com
In a letter to Twitter, attorneys for Live Action, known for its undercover investigations of abortion clinics, allege the social media platform wrongly applied its policies to censor advertisements that contain ultrasound images of fetuses, promote or ...

and more »

Forbes

Debunking Myths: Don't Count Out Traditional Advertising Channels; Embrace Them
Forbes
The widespread belief that web and social media ads are giving a higher ROI than the "old-fashioned" TV, press, and radio advertising is a costly myth. The myth hinges on the belief that the more precise targeting achieved by digital advertising not ...


The Disappearance Of Advertising-Supported Media
MediaPost Communications
What you will not see if you follow this link is advertising or sponsorship. No ad interruptions, no “brought to you by,” not even a sponsored message from the four-wheel drive cars journalists drove through the rough terrain or the hotels where they ...


Supermarket News

Albertsons taps Burgstahler as advertising VP | Supermarket News
Supermarket News
Albertsons Cos. on Thursday said it has appointed Guy Burgstahler as the its new VP of advertising. Burgstahler previously served similar roles with retailers ...

and more »

Advertising Week 2017 to Ring The Nasdaq Stock Market Closing Bell
GlobeNewswire (press release)
Advertising Week – the world's largest gathering of industry leaders across advertising, technology, business, entertainment, marketing, media and social good – kicks off its 2017 conference in New York this week and will visit the Nasdaq MarketSite in ...

and more »
Google News

How To Create Instantly Compelling Ads Every Time

Use This Quick 3-Question Evaluation Process, So You Can Be... Read More

Media, the Internet, Yellow Pages, and Your Business

If you are reading this article, chances are you could... Read More

The SKINNY on Radio Advertising

From meager beginnings in 1920, radio has grown with us... Read More

Understanding The Basics Of Advertising

I get the L.A. Times delivered to my door every... Read More

Finding Your Target Market

Achieving sales is probably the biggest challenge a web business... Read More

Boost Headline Believability With Specifics

Don't use vague generalities in your headlines. Be as specific... Read More

Raising Funds For Your Nonprofit Using An Annual Direct Mail Program

A good annual direct mail solicitation program can produce unrestrictive... Read More

If You Lost 70% of Your New Customers, Would You Notice?

Buyers Don't Rely on the Yellow Pages Like They Used... Read More

2005 Super Bowl Ads... Winners and Losers

Well, Super Bowl XXXIX is history. Too bad for the... Read More

Creativity and Getting Outside of the Box

Sitting in front of a blank piece of paper? Wondering... Read More

Advertising Your Holistic Business

The most basic answer is the same answer as to... Read More

Moving Message Display

Moving message display are designed to be installed into environments... Read More

Lamination of Signs

I suspect that everyone has an idea of what lamination... Read More

80% of All Advertising Is Wasted Due To This Common Mistake

You're flipping through this publication as you wait for your... Read More

Design Your Own Newspaper Ads

Many people in business lay-out (design) their own ads. That... Read More

Push vs Pull Advertising

Push vs. Pull Advertising - Understand the Consequences for your... Read More

Marketing Advertising, While Advertising Your Market!

Today in the Business world whether online or off, it... Read More

Free Publicity With Dogs, Cats, and Rats

Here's a fascinating idea.. Having noticed that there always seemed... Read More

Testimonials Convert Prospects Into Buyers

Big businesses get instant credibility with their well-known company name... Read More

Imaging Isnt Everything

Many home improvement contractors attempt to use advertising to expand... Read More

Classified Ads That Get Results

Classified ads do not have the big market appeal that... Read More

Online vs. Offline Advertising

Let's face it. Email marketing and publishing have became very... Read More

B2B Marketing Health and Elder Care Services

Quality Care Options is an established company advocating for the... Read More

Small Business Image

The single easiest way to increase sales is to look... Read More

Internet Advertising: How To Use The Golden Rule To Enrich Yourself.

What is the golden rule of internet advertising?Give, so you... Read More