A Lesson In Advertising From The Eighteenth Century > NetSparsh

Home
>
Advertising
>
A Lesson In Advertising From The Eighteenth Century

A Lesson In Advertising From The Eighteenth Century

Back in the 1760s, the great Dr Samuel Johnson delivered himself of the dictum that 'promise, large promise is the soul of advertising'. It's a good thought, a great thought; and I contend that what was true then is equally true today. But it seems to me that modern advertisers are tying themselves into unnecessary knots in an attempt to reach audiences which they believe are becoming increasingly indifferent to their blandishments.

Well, yes, markets are turning deaf ears and blind eyes, but they always have done, though not for the reasons generally espoused by the world's marketers. I am convinced that despite all the sophisticated research and marketing effort that goes into advertising these days, the real reason that markets are indifferent to advertising is because much of it ignores the many splendoured principle that people don't buy products, they buy the benefits of owning those products.

Today, the great proportion of advertisers don't deliver sales messages, they tell what they hope are emotive stories with which the market can empathise, then they drop the product in as an afterthought, hoping that enough emotional cross-communication has been achieved for people to reach for their credit cards. That it doesn't and people won't has resulted in huge advertising budget cut-backs in the developed world in recent years. Only a manufacturer who has taken leave of his senses will throw even more money at a strategy that doesn't work.

The strategy responsible operates under the title Emotional Sales Proposition (ESP), thought in some quarters to be an advance on the Unique Sales Proposition (USP) which, on the contrary, does actually work. What has been overlooked or, more likely, ignored, is that in developing the principle of the USP in the late 1950s, the brilliant Rosser Reeves was striving to replace an advertising strategy that had been in situ for 30 or so years and was fast running out of steam. What was the device he was hoping to supersede? Well, by any other name, it was the emotional sales proposition. I won't bore you with the detail, but if you'd like to find out more, you should lay your hands on Reeves' book, Reality in Advertising (MacGibbon & Kee ? 1961). It could be an eye-opener.

So, it's true ? the one thing we learn from history is that we never learn anything from history. Let's go back to Dr Johnson. It's worth remembering that the kind of advertising old Sam was talking about in the 18th century was fairly innocuous and largely unexceptionable. It could be read in coffee- house flyers, in chapbooks and in rudimentary newspapers; and it consisted of sales messages as diverse as where to get your wig powdered and the date of the next public hanging at Tyburn. Even so, the products and services on offer were as important to the people of the time as mobile phones and computers are to us.

In the human condition, nothing much changes. Our egos still need to be massaged and we are all in hot pursuit of happiness. Only our methods for achieving these goals, only our technologies, vary with time.

So the next time you are tempted to commit advertising, think about Sam Johnson and give your market a reason for owning your product. A good reason.

About The Author

Patrick Quinn is an award winning copywriter with 40 years' experience of the advertising business in London, Miami, Dublin and Edinburgh. He publishes a FREE monthly newsletter, AdBriefing. Subscriptions are available at: http://www.adbriefing.com

In The News:

Warc predicts that Google and Facebook will make $176bn from advertising this year Bizcommunity.comAmazon's Next Move to Boost Its Advertising Business Motley FoolAmazon eyes digital advertising, to sell video adds on app to take on Google, Facebook The News MinuteAmazon to compete with Facebook and Google in advertising business | Cryptopolitan CryptopolitanAmazon to introduce mobile ads, in a threat to Google, FB Times of IndiaView full coverage on Google News

Upper Funnel Advertising: How to Use Display & Video Ads to Boost Awareness Search Engine JournalLearn the common advertising tactics used to target customers at the top of the purchase funnel and build awareness of your brand, product, or *service* .

Asia’s AnyMind pulls in another $8M and expands into outdoor advertising TechCrunchAsia-focused marketing startup AnyMind Group has landed a further $8 million in funding to close out its Series B round and expand into new verticals.

In 2020, Native Advertising will be More Programmatic and Mobile - but Less Social Social Media TodayA report, recently published by eMarketer, presents its predictions by juxtaposing 2018 numbers with 2020 estimates. It concludes that in 2020, native ...

Advertising Week Europe Briefing: Audio’s coming of age DigidayBoth the proliferation of smart speakers and the popularity of podcasts are pushing advertisers to think harder about audio. Advertisers are now seeing voice as ...

Is Advertising Making Us Miserable? New Study Says It May Be So Cinema BlendReporting on movies, television, video games, and pop culture CINEMABLEND is the go-to source for today's plugged-in generation.

How measurable is online advertising? Phys.OrgResearchers from Northwestern University and Facebook in March published new research in the INFORMS journal Marketing Science that sheds light on ...

Amazon doubles down on TV advertising Marketing WeekAmazon is now TV's third-biggest spender, with total TV ad revenue reaching £5.11bn in 2018 thanks to increased investment from online businesses.

UK advertising powers ahead as exports hit £6.9bn The DrumBritain's stature in international advertising has been given a boost following the publication of new figures indicating that total exports rose to £6.9bn in 2017.

Clever Advertising Creatively Encourages Denver to Conserve Water My Modern MetSukle, a creative agency in Colorado, created a series of clever advertising campaigns that encouraged the people of Denver to conserve water.

Google fined €1.49bn by EU for advertising violations The GuardianGoogle has been fined €1.5bn (£1.3bn) by the EU for abusing its monopoly in online advertising, bringing the total cost of punishments imposed on the search ...

NBCUniversal, Sky team up to expand global advertising product Reuters(Reuters) - Comcast Corp is pooling the advertising power of its NBCUniversal and British-based Sky units to better target viewers worldwide, it said on Monday, ...

Re: No more infant formula advertising in The BMJ The BMJThis comes across as an arbitrary, irrational and knee-jerk action. Why exactly have these adverts been banned? I agree that the use of formula milk should be ...

Addressable TV Is Creating New Advertising Capabilities...And They Are Not Going Away ForbesFor anyone interested in the future of advertising, the capabilities of connected television (CTV) cannot be ignored. CTV is defined by ad software provider ...

Hardware Stores Find "True Value" In Hyper-Local Advertising ForbesTrue Value Company is embracing a “marketing-as-a-*service*” model, offering hyper-local and highly targeted marketing to stores as part of a larger program to ...

YouTube Facing Lawsuit That Alleges Toy Unboxing Videos Are “Abusive Advertising Practices” Aimed At Children TubefilterA Brazilian lawsuit filed against YouTube's owner Google is raising questions about whether toy unboxing videos are manipulating kids — and whether similar ...

BE Exclusive: Pepperfry advertising and marketing spend up 70% in FY19 ETBrandEquity.comThe online retailer claims to spend 60% on digital and the rest on traditional medium.

Purpose advertising: The best an ad can be? Aljazeera.comAn insight into the world of advertising and the challenge of striking a balance between purpose and profit.

Sam Ehlinger noticed maroon advertising at Austin airport NewsWest9.comTexas Longhorns quarterback Sam Ehlinger made an interesting observation upon returning from Spring Break.

Advertising watchdog rules fake autism 'cure' adverts must stop BBC NewsAdvertising watchdog the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has ordered 150 homeopaths operating in the UK to stop claiming they can cure autism.

A Few Pioneering Women Every Advertising Industry Pro Should Know ForbesAs we celebrate Women's History Month and continue to work toward a more equal playing field for women behind the scenes and depicted on-screen, here's a ...

Blockbuster partnership! How embedded advertising is helping Bollywood earn big Financial ExpressIn-film placements helping movie production houses recover costs, while also adding to the pre-release buzz.

Teikametrics adds hourly bidding optimization for Amazon advertising Search Engine LandBoston-based Teikametrics announced the addition of an hourly bidding solution for Amazon advertisers using Teikametrics Flywheel campaign optimization ...

Facebook settles 5 advertising discrimination lawsuits Marketplace APMIt's no secret that nearly all of Facebook's revenue comes from advertising. But did you know Facebook is accused of allowing advertisers to discriminate against ...

Will advertisers ever learn from YouTube advertising scandals? EconsultancyContinued YouTube scandals beg the question whether greater introspection on the part of advertisers is warranted when their ads appear next to problematic ...

The show goes on for in-cinema advertising: Brands use power of big screen Business StandardThe siren call of digital media had led many to believe that the era of in-cinema advertising was well and truly over. However, two reports launched in the course ...

Why Social Commerce Is Becoming ‘The Ultimate Form Of Advertising’ For CMOs—And What’s On The Horizon ForbesThe blur between *content* and commerce intensifies, and social-media platforms are working overtime to create opportunities for brands to turn consumers' ...

Facebook is creating a new advertising portal for housing, employment and credit advertisers and will remove 'hundreds' of targeting options Business InsiderFacebook has faced backlash from civil rights groups like the National Fair Housing Alliance (NFHA) and American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) that its platform ...

No more infant formula advertising in The BMJ The BMJBMJ 2019; 364 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.l1279 (Published 21 March 2019) Cite this as: BMJ 2019;364:l1279. Article · Related *content* · Metrics ...

PACIFIC Digital Group hauls in eight advertising awards PRNewswireSAN DIEGO, March 21, 2019 /PRNewswire/ -- PACIFIC, the Discovery Group, won eight American Advertising Awards for one brand campaign. The group is tied ...

Does ‘woke’ advertising need a wakeup call? YourStory.comWhat happens when brands want to be 'woke' in India, in an economy where 11 percent of the youth are highly conservative and 37 percent of them are ...

Data Privacy Backlash: Is Facebook Advertising Truly Evolving? MarTech SeriesFacebook is no different when it comes to providing building and providing privacy-related services. The leading social media advertising platform keeps ...

Advertisers Boycott YouTube — And If History Is A Guide, They'll Be Back Soon ForbesYouTube is facing criticism and an advertising boycott over objectionable *content* on its platform. Sound familiar? That's because advertisers have yanked their ...

Legendary advertising mogul Sir John Hegarty launches stinging attack on Facebook and Google This is MoneySir John Hegarty, one of Britain's original 'Mad Men' who co-founded agency Bartle Bogle Hegarty in the 1980s, has a new message for the world: the time has ...

Advertising Week Europe briefing: Broadcasters slowly unite against platform threats DigidayAt Advertising Week Europe, it seems broadcasters may be showing a more collective front against platform threats.

The future of native advertising is mobile The DrumNative advertising's ability to blend in with an end-user's *content* experience has made it extremely popular with brands. In fact, it's so popular that native made ...

Ex-Unilever boss Paul Polman: We need to bring humanity back to advertising Marketing WeekAdvertising has lost its humanity in the “rat race” to do things quickly, according to Unilever's recently departed CEO Paul Polman, who is calling for brands and ...

Youtube and youth advertising: Oversight and transparency for our newest babysitter Marketing LandIn today's world, consumers are (rightly) pushing for companies to be more thoroughly regulated. Transparency has become increasingly difficult to define and ...

U.S. lawsuit on hotels' internet advertising moves forward ReutersA federal judge on Thursday rebuffed a request by hotel chains including Hyatt Hotels Corp, Marriott International Inc and Wyndham Hotel Group to throw out a ...

Carphone Warehouse thwacked by UK Advertising watchdog for a Cyber Monday wobble The RegisterUK phone-slinger The Carphone Warehouse has received a slap on the wrist from the Brit advertising watchdog after an offer proved a tad too popular.

3 ways to lower your Amazon advertising ACoS Search Engine LandAmazon's advertising revenue topped $10B in 2018, creeping up right behind Facebook and Google, as the third largest ad platform in the U.S. The analysts ...

Identity and Advanced TV Have Reshaped Video Advertising AdweekJust when creatives wrapped their heads around data and programmatic, new technology is about to reshape storytelling again. While those first disruptive ...

DuckDuckGo CEO testifies: Privacy legislation isn’t ‘anti-advertising’ Search Engine LandDuckDuckGo Founder and CEO Gabriel Weinberg testified Tuesday morning before the Senate Judiciary Committee on online privacy. The committee was ...

iPinYou Partners with Weibo to Provide a More Integrated Advertising Solution across Social and Programmatic Platforms PRNewswireWASHINGTON, March 21, 2019 /PRNewswire/ -- iPinYou, China's leading programmatic platform, recently partnered with Weibo to integrate their Chinese ...

New Zealand shooting: Facebook faces advertising boycott over live-stream CBS NewsTwo business associations in New Zealand say companies should stop advertising on Facebook after an anti-Islam terrorist used the platform to livestream his ...

Is Content Marketing Advertising? Social Media TodayThis seems like a simple question to answer, right? But the answer boils down to who you ask and how you define *content* marketing. Zara Curtis, Director of ...

DDB harks back to founding trio in new corporate identity Campaign IndiaDDB has unveiled a new corporate identity that invokes the founding principles of the three men who started the agency 70 years ago: Ned Doyle, Mac Dane ...

WHO urges governments to enforce bans on tobacco advertising, promotion and sponsorship, including in motor sport World Health OrganizationWHO is urging governments to enforce bans on tobacco advertising, promotion and sponsorship at sporting events, including when hosting or receiving ...

Digital out-of-home advertising is fracturing into many channels MarTech TodayDigital out-of-home advertising is evolving so far beyond just being video billboards that, like mobile, the channel category may soon split into multiple channels.

JW Player Expands Video Player Bidding Offering with Three New Advertising Partnerships MarTech SeriesJW Player, an independent video technology company, announced it has expanded its proprietary Video Player Bidding solution, adding three new advertising ...

Brand Spotlight Join Our Effective Local Advertising Seminar WRTV IndianapolisLearn how to effectively market and advertise your business. Do you own a business or make the advertising and marketing decisions for your company?

Facebook Announces 'Facebook Showcase' Premium Video Advertising Option Social Media TodayWhile Facebook's Watch platform hasn't yet become the traditional TV rival Facebook hoped it might, that hasn't slowed The Social Network's monetization plans ...

Has the Native Advertising Market Matured? eMarketerThe typical native display ad is mobile, social and purchased programmatically—and that's not expected to change over the next couple years, as the native ad ...

Advertisements Disparaging Another Product As Bad And Unhealthy Not Permitted : Delhi HC [Read Order] Live Law'The settled position in law is clear i.e. while puffery is permitted, disparagement and denigration is not'.

This Tool Helps Marketers & Advertisers to Track Traffic Quality Search Engine JournalThis is a sponsored post written by Finteza. The opinions expressed in this article are the sponsor's own. When online advertising replaced traditional ...

Ad fraud scam drains your phone battery and lets advertisers make money by running hidden video ads Daily MailA new report has uncovered a massive advertising fraud scheme that let made scammers serious cash, fooled marketing companies and killed users' ...

Digital advertising fraud ecosystem stirs up a $1.63-billion scam Business StandardRead more about Digital advertising fraud ecosystem stirs up a $1.63-billion scam on Business Standard. Online deception threatens to jeopardise the digital ...

The definitive guide to what’s in and out at Advertising Week Europe 2019 DigidayAdvertising Week Europe is here and with it comes four days of panels, parties and networking. To preview all the comings and goings, Digiday has compiled a ...

Leo Varadkar's spin unit behind huge rise in advertising spending The TimesThe taoiseach's department spent €1.8 million on advertising last year, up from €71000 in 2017, The Times can disclose.Government departments spent almost ...

How do you make money from podcasts? The pros and cons of advertising and subscriptions RecodeJacob Weisberg and Bethany McLean from Pushkin Industries and Marshall Williams from Ad Results Advertising discuss the booming audio biz on the latest ...

Kazerman Tapped for Advanced Advertising Post at Discovery Broadcasting & CableKeith Kazerman has been promoted to executive VP, digital sales, advanced advertising and research.

What Makes Flo From Progressive Effective? Lessons For Using Humor In Advertising. ForbesThe article offers insights into what makes humor in advertising work. Sean McBride or Arnold Worldwide and Professor Marc Weinberger are interviewed.

Big Companies Freezing Their Advertising On YouTube Because Of Controversial Comments ForbesThere's a large number of videos on YouTube available to literary everyone, featuring the likes of children, mostly girls under the age of 13, practising ...

TAM Media Research, Israeli firm develop digital advertising measurement tools Economic TimesTAM Media Research, along with Israel-based business intelligence solution provider BI Science, has unveiled Digital AdEx, a *service* to monitor and provide ...

Google Fined 1.49 Billion Euros by EU For Unfair Advertising Rules, Third Penalty in as Many Years News18The European Commission, which said the fine accounted for 1.29 percent of Google's turnover in 2018, said in a statement that the anti-competitive practices ...

You're being used to steal $50 billion in digital advertising Fast CompanyA new report says digital ad fraud is bigger–and more sophisticated–than the industry is prepared to deal with.

LETTER TO THE EDITOR: For Florida’s restaurants, tourism advertising is key The Northwest Florida Daily NewsFor many restaurants like mine across the South Walton area, a fully funded VISIT FLORIDA could make the difference between shuttering the doors and growth.

The push and pull of travel advertising PhocusWireThe travel industry is no stranger to the ebb and flow of change. Consumer travel behavior has seen massive shifts with technological developments. Travelers ...

Advertisers say Facebook outage led to 'chaos' in buying AdAge.comFacebook advertisers say the outage at the social network caused "chaos" in the market and cost them a whole day's work as they were frozen out of ads ...

George P. Kell, a retired advertising agency copy director and outdoorsman, dies Baltimore SunGeorge P. Kell, a retired advertising agency copy director who earlier held posts with Project HOPE and a Washington, D.C., hospital, died March 16 from ...

Advertising effectiveness vs. efficiency: what is important? RaconteurFocusing on short-term wins has led to a growing efficiency bubble, leaving long-term advertising effectiveness by the wayside.

Duncan Garner: Good on advertisers pulling ads from Facebook NewshubOPINION: How on Earth does Facebook, Youtube and the like get away with publishing such heinous and offensive *content* like the killing of 50 people?

The Kraft Heinz Mess Is A Warning To Advertisers: You Can't Cost-Cut Your Way To Growth ForbesThere's a limit to how much a company can cut, but top-line growth (driven by investment in advertising) is infinite, at least until a brand reaches 100% market ...

Snapchat's private market thrills brands but not publishers AdAge.comNew premium ad platform has not led to riches for media partners even as advertisers access their best *content*. By Garett Sloane. Published on March 22, 2019 ...

Digital Hype Aside, Report Says Political Campaigns Are Mostly Analog Affairs The New York TimesOn average, candidates in the 2018 midterm races spent no more than 5 percent of their overall media budgets on digital advertising, according to a report by ...

If Tucker Carlson Keeps Hemorrhaging Advertisers He Might Soon Be Down to Just 'My Pillow' EsquireThe advertiser boycott of Fox News' Tucker Carlson has cost his show almost all of its major sponsors and forced Fox to advertise its own programming during ...

Martin Sorrell: Amazon's advertising business will be worth $100bn CampaignLiveAdvertisers are, like Brexiteers, looking to 'take back control' of their data, S4 Capital chief said.

Tech Firm Plans to Transform Advertising on Facebook, YouTube and Twitter Via Blockchain CointelegraphSponsored. Paying for the ultimate result of an advertising campaign, and not just impressions or clicks, has always been the dream of advertisers. There have ...

McDonald’s U.K. Mocks All Other Coffee Advertising in Its Amusing Ode to Simplicity AdweekWhen you think “gourmet coffee,” a few scenes are likely to come to mind: a meticulous barista sampling from a veritable chemistry set, perhaps. Or maybe ...

The Drum Digital Advertising Awards 2019 finalists The DrumThe Drum Digital Advertising Awards Europe 2019 judging has been and gone and we can now reveal the shortlisted hopefuls.

The fine print: Impactful versus misleading advertising Forbes IndiaWhile these two terms, 'impactful' and 'misleading', may seem to have diametrically opposite effects on the consumer, it may surprise many that these words ...

Snap to drug advertisers: We're the friendlier social network CNBCTo win big pharmaceutical advertisers, Snap is positioning itself as a friendlier social network than Facebook and Twitter.

Best practices for targeted advertising: success factors for TV operations in the GDPR era VideonetWith advertising revenues under pressure, TV channels see targeted advertising as an exciting new opportunity. According to eMarketer, by 2019, personalized ...

15 Classic Campaigns From African-American Creatives That Helped Shape Advertising AdweekConversations surrounding diversity and inclusion—or, more pointedly, the lack thereof—have become a regular occurrence in the ad industry. Unfortunately ...

Facebook and ACLU Settle Over Biased Advertising News GhanaFacebook said Tuesday it has reached settlement with U.S. civil rights organizations including the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) over discriminatory ...

The advertising industry has a diversity problem – apprenticeships can help The GuardianIt's really important that our workforce reflects the kind of people that we're advertising to, says Sue Frogley, UK chief executive of Publicis Media.

NCS Chief Research Officer to Be Honored for Her Contribution to Elevating the Science of Advertising and Marketing Associated PressThis *content* is a press release from our partner Business Wire. The AP newsroom and editorial departments were not involved in its creation.

Some advertisers are quitting Facebook, chiding the company's 'despicable business model' CNBCSome businesses told CNBC they decided to stop advertising with Facebook and Instagram due to the company's user data and privacy scandals.

How streaming impacts digital advertising and consumer entertainment TechRepublicStreaming opens up new marketing avenues and revenue potential and is reshaping consumer entertainment in the process.

Seen and heard: Geo-tagging, elections boost out of home advertising Business StandardOut of home (OOH) advertising may well count as a relic in the age of digital media. And yet, innovative repackaging coupled with data-driven usage and an ...

Stop all advertisements featuring Hema Malini: RLD writes to EC Business StandardThe Rashtriya Lok Dal Saturday urged the Election Commission to stop all advertisements featuring cine star Hema Malini, who has been renominated as BJP ...

Junk food advertisers may escape pre-9pm ban as kids ‘don’t see enough ads to justify it’, suggests Gover The SunA GOVERNMENT-backed report says kids do not watch enough television to warrant junk food ads being banned before 9pm.

Battling Bans, China’s Huawei Goes on an Advertising Offensive The Wall Street JournalAs a challenge to key U.S. allies seeking to block it from rollouts of 5G networks, China's Huawei Technologies Co. unleashed an edgy ad campaign. The ads ...

Fixing Advertising’s Diversity Problem Shouldn’t Fall to Minorities AdweekDiversity is not hiring a person of color or a female executive to save a predominantly white company from public backlash. Diversity is not recruiting culture ...

Can the 'New' Facebook Hold On to Advertising Dominance? BloombergBrian Wieser, global president of business intelligence at GroupM, discusses how the evolution of Facebook Inc. impacts the social media company's advertising ...

UK ASA bans gambling advertisement for advertising gambling CalvinAyre.comIt's unfathomable that a gambling company could create an advertisement to promote gambling. The nerve of some people! However, that's exactly what has ...

Calling time on formula milk adverts The BMJBMJ 2019; 364 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.l1200 (Published 18 March 2019) Cite this as: BMJ 2019;364:l1200. Article · Related *content* · Metrics ...

WHO calls for more action to protect children from online junk food advertising The BMJBMJ 2019; 364 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.l1221 (Published 15 March 2019) Cite this as: BMJ 2019;364:l1221. Article · Related *content* · Metrics ...

Barricades on median: The wrong wall for advertisements The New Indian ExpressThe barricades on the median of the city will be disappearing soon.

The role of creative director in the new age of advertising The DrumWhenever I assemble my team for weekly update meetings, my creative team tell me they are concerned about selling in big ideas. They worry about the ideas ...

A Lesson In Advertising From The Eighteenth Century

Advertising Advertising