Change, or Reinforce?

Do you know about the distinction - and it's a useful one - between communication that tries to reinforce and communication that tries to get change?

If you follow politics you'll already be familiar with this idea: Incumbents send messages that reinforce existing voter behavior, while challengers call for changes.

Any thoughtful marketing communication (and political communication is marketing communication) will be strongly influenced by this distinction, which affects not only the content, but also the presentation, and perhaps even the medium.

For example, suppose you own a bookstore and every couple of months you send a newsletter to all residences within a two mile radius.

Now, if you have good market share and you're profitable, you won't want to rock the boat. You'll want to reinforce existing behaviors (which include buying at your store).

On the other hand, if you just opened a new bookstore and need to take market share from other bookstores, then you want change existing book buying behavior.

Another example: Suppose your employee safety program has worked well for the past year and you want to maintain the practices that led to this longest-ever period without an accident. Your communication would reinforce. On the other hand, if the safety record was unacceptable, you would try to get change through your communication.

In a change situation, we want to upset the status quo, to challenge existing beliefs and ways of doing things. That means the words and style could be somewhat inflammatory.

We can do this by making bold claims or allegations: Just listen to, or look at, advertising claims like these: "If you shop at Joe's Bookstore, you may be paying too much!" or, "Drive a bit further and save a lot more at Jane's Bookstore!"

Change also might be hurried by painting negative scenarios , as in "Unless we get more efficient, senior management will outsource the whole department."

Tactically, change usually demands more communication, as in more often and more words or pages. As you can imagine, it takes more communication to drive change than to stay on the same course.

There are also tactics we can use to reinforce existing beliefs or actions.

To maintain the status quo we can stress a service record, as in, "Serving you with quality and service for 25 years." or "Your performance has been very good over the past year, Betty. Keep up the good work."

Reinforcement does not automatically rule out change; however, it emphasizes incremental and gradual change rather than major and abrupt change.

You can also appeal to shared values or experiences to reinforce. Nothing commits us to staying the course like emotional cues that link good times to the status quo. For example, consider the power of an advertising slogan that begins, "Remember when...." It connects a powerful, positive emotion with a product or service. By extension, the product or service offers an opportunity to relive that good time.

In summary, make a distinction in your communication between reinforcing and changing. Decide which way you want to go, and then choose the appropriate strategies, tactics, and tools.

Robert F. Abbott writes and publishes Abbott's Communication Letter. Learn how you can use communication to help achieve your goals, by reading articles or subscribing to this ad-supported newsletter. An excellent resource for leaders and managers, at: http://www.communication-newsletter.com

In The News:

Traditional Advertising, A Thing Of The Past? Not According To This Report  ForbesAccording to a report by the World Federation of Advertisers, given the statement “Looking ahead five years, I can imagine a world without traditional advertising ...
Instagram Advertising: Do You Know It, When You See It?  NPR"Micro-influencers" work with big companies to sell products on social media. Consumer groups are increasingly concerned that many posts on Instagram and ...
Startups Turn To Traditional Advertising For Attention  Crunchbase NewsOn the ride from the San Francisco International Airport into the city, drivers are greeted with a slew of billboards advertising various products from a credit card ...
From AI to blockchain -- Here’s how Indian advertising industry is embracing new technologies  MoneycontrolAI is offering personalised experiences like video bot or regional language voice bot and it is bringing down the cost of conversation and personalisation.
AD STARS 2019 receives over 20600 entries from 60 countries - ET BrandEquity  ETBrandEquity.comAsia- based advertising awards festival, AD STARS, has claimed that it has received 20,645 entries to this year's awards from 60 countries, up slightly from last ...
Looking back on the life of advertising legend Philip Geier  AdAge.comPhilip H. Geier, Jr., the long-time chairman and CEO of the advertising giant known as The Interpublic Group of Companies, died on Wednesday, June 19, at the ...
Gender stereotypes in advertising have been banned in the UK  Vox.comThe British advertising regulator gave agencies six months to eliminate stereotypes "likely to cause harm, or serious or widespread offense."
Editor's choice: The Drum Advertising Awards 2019 entries open  The DrumBack for its second year, The Drum Advertising Awards are here to give creativity and advertising the recognition it deserves, looking for the best of the best in ...
Changing the advertising storyboard  The HinduIn the aftermath of Cannes Lions, six advertising industry experts from India tell us how advertising is becoming more inclusive of people and technologies.
Dominic Grainger: My European digital advertising trends  The DrumSilicon Valley may be at the heart of the global digital advertising industry, but Europe appears to be driving the industry's path forward, at least with respect to ...
Ahead of IPO, Affle acquires mobile advertising company RevX  YourStoryAffle International, Singapore-based parent of 13-year old adtech company Affle (India), has acquired US based mobile advertising company RevX Inc for an ...
How Digital Advertising Markets Really Work  The American ProspectThis article appears in the Summer 2019 issue of The American Prospect magazine. Subscribe here.
Behavioural advertising is out of control, warns UK watchdog  TechCrunchThe online behavioural advertising industry is illegally profiling internet users. That's the damning assessment of the U.K.'s data protection regulator in an update ...
Olympic Games Are Getting More Competitive for Advertisers  The Wall Street JournalThe Olympic Games remain advertising gold—so much so that exclusive sponsorship deals are becoming much costlier for the world's most powerful ...
Rebranding advertising: time for a resurgence of the creative agency?  The DrumI started my career in the London advertising industry in the summer of 2009. At the time, adland in London was an exciting place to be. The city was awash with ...
The stories behind big Cannes Lion winners and the riskiest advertising moves of the year  AdAge.comAd Age sat down during the festival with the brains behind groundbreaking moves from the New York Times, Skittles, Adidas and HBO.
Study investigates lack of disclaimers on Facebook and Google's political advertising  Phys.OrgA cloak of mystery often shrouds the inner workings of technological giants, but sometimes clarity is in plain sight. A Virginia Tech research team recently ...
TVSquared Releases Direct-to-Consumer TV Advertising Performance Report  Yahoo FinanceTVSquared, the worldwide leader in TV attribution, released the findings of its 2019 Direct-to-Consumer TV Advertising Performance report. DTC brands are one ...
Digital advertising growth has hit a wall in Australia  AdNewsMagna says digital media is so mature in terms of usage and spend that growth rates are starting to plateau.
Are These Soho Billboards the Most Coveted Advertising Spots in New York City?  Yahoo LifestyleWe learned more about this buzzy corner of fashion-focused publicity, the media companies who manage it and the rise of out of home advertising. "Listen ...
If Facebook and Google don't fix their problems, advertising execs say they could go somewhere else  CNBCAd executives at the annual Cannes Lions festival say Facebook and Google need to do more to clean up the *content* on their platforms.
Local News KCPS ramps up advertising in effort to recruit more students Dia Wall 4:30  KSHBIt's tough to drive anywhere in Kansas City, Missouri, without seeing a billboard for Kansas City Public Schools.
LinkedIn introduces Objective Based Advertising  ClickZLinkedIn has officially announced the rollout of Objective Based Advertising (OBA), reconfiguring its Campaign Manager to keep advertisers' objectives at the ...
Adam Mosseri interview: Gayle King asks Instagram's head if they are listening to her private conversations — exclusive  CBS NewsInstagram head Adam Mosseri opened up to "CBS This Morning" co-host Gayle King about how the social media platform targets users.
Why Facebook, Google Advertising During 2016 Presidential Election Lacked Paid-For Disclaimers 06/25/2019  MediaPost CommunicationsA Virginia Tech research team has recently released details from its investigation into the roles that Facebook and Google played in digital advertising around ...
The Future of Advertising – Vulnerability and Authenticity  Thrive GlobalReaching customers on a personal level and establishing a deeper connection.
Targeted TV Advertising Is Taking Off  The Wall Street JournalStreaming platforms allow companies to tailor their marketing to a bigger audience and with more precision than ever. That's causing advertisers to rethink their ...
Juniper: Digital Advertising To Hit $520B By 2023; Amazon To Grab 8% 06/24/2019  MediaPost CommunicationsGlobal spending on digital advertising will reach $520 billion by 2023 — up from $294 billion in 2019, according to a new forecast from Juniper Research.
10 questions with... Michael Moszynski, CEO of London Advertising  The DrumIn an attempt to showcase the personalities of the people behind the media and marketing sector, The Drum speaks to individuals who are bringing something a ...
How Will Facebook's Cryptocurrency Impact Its Advertising Revenues?  eMarketerAfter a year of rumors, Facebook confirmed its plans to create a financial system based off a new cryptocurrency called Libra. While the company derives a ...
Advertisers and digital media companies form a new Global Alliance for Responsible Media  TechCrunchMany of the major players in online advertising have come together to create an organization called the Global Alliance for Responsible Media, which is ...
Google’s Ad Dominance Explained in Three Charts  The Wall Street JournalGoogle is the major force at every layer between advertisers and websites, one reason the Justice Department is laying the groundwork for potential antitrust ...
Gender Stereotypes Banned in British Advertising  The New York TimesNo more commercials showing men struggling to do a load of laundry, or asking women if they are “beach body ready.”
Provincial budget printing, advertising totalled $125K this year  Melfort JournalThe provincial government spent about $125579 printing and advertising its latest budget, which put money into areas where it has faced criticism while at the ...
Thomasville tourism commission gets $40,000 for advertising  WGHP FOX 8 GreensboroTHOMASVILLE, N.C. -- Thomasville tourism is getting double in advertising money for this fiscal year. The city's tourism commission will have $40000 to spend ...
What if We All Just Sold Non-Creepy Advertising?  The New York TimesThe big ad-tech companies know how to sell ads without damaging privacy, but they choose not to.
Editor's choice: The Drum Digital Advertising Awards USA 2019 open for entries  The DrumThe Drum Digital Advertising Awards US is back for its annual quest to identify the very best in adtech and programmatic.
Affle International acquires mobile advertising company RevX  BusinessLineSingapore's Affle International Pte. Ltd. has acquired US based mobile advertising company RevX Inc.As part of the deal, the platform, assets, brand name, ...
Filmmaker Creates First Gender Fluid Commercial Spec To Break Stereotypes In Advertising  DeadlineThere are plenty of crowd-funding campaigns for TV and film projects, but as the demand for diversity and inclusivity becomes front and center, creators are ...
New media advertising policy to be launched soon: Firdous  Radio PakistanSpecial Assistant to the Prime Minister on Information and Broadcasting Firdous Ashiq Awan says the government is going to launch a new media advertising ...
Advertising may make people miserable, but it still has its uses  The EconomistWorkers keen to buy more luxury goods keep toiling away.
Instagram Lets Advertisers Promote Branded Content From Another Channel  Inc.Retailers can create ads using organic posts from other channels that have branded *content*.
What advertising means in the age of spatial computing  EconsultancyAdvertisers have long been experimenting with spatial computing. Sam Huber of Admix looks at what the near future may hold for ads in VR and AR.
Advertising and media execs really want Netflix to have ads  DigidayAdvertisers are confident that Netflix is going to one day have ads -- or, at the very least, they really, really want Netflix to have ads.
A guide to programmatic advertising  MobileMarketing MagazineTyrone Stewart takes a deep dive into programmatic, looking at the good, the bad and the ugly, and at where the technology is headed. In recent years ...
Google is testing a carousel format for its text-based ads  AdAge.comGoogle is testing a carousel format for text-based search ads on mobile, as the tech giant considers adding more inventory on tiny screens without disrupting ...
Advertisers under social media's influence  Economic TimesNEW DELHI: Advertising spending on social media influencers in India by brands is rising — driven by increasing popularity of *content* creators and proliferation ...
Jane Austin: why do people in advertising – especially CMOs – have to speak in riddles?  More About AdvertisingTrust was the most popular word at Cannes this year, the actual meaning of which covers a multitude of strategies and intentions. It is usually delivered with a.
Price extensions now supported in Microsoft Advertising Editor  Search Engine LandPrice extensions launched in Microosoft Advertising a little over a year ago, allowing advertisers to show products and pricing in text ads in mobile and desktop ...
What Advertisers Should Consider As U.K. Bans Harmful Gender Stereotypes in Adverts  ForbesLast week, a ban came into force for adverts featuring harmful gender stereotypes. As advertisers descend on Cannes for the industry gathering, Cannes Lions ...
Kx technology to power anti-fraud platform from Machine Advertising  App Developer MagazineKx announces that Machine Advertising has selected Kx technology to power its anti-fraud platform. Using Kx, Machine is able to analyze hundreds of billions of ...
Advertising on our property  Network RailWith over 850 million passengers passing through our managed stations every year and 22 million railway neighbours, our properties offer a unique opportunity ...
Everything we know about Amazon's advertising business  Business InsiderA special edition of the Advertising & Media Newsletter.
Instagram Lets Advertisers Boost Organic Posts as Feed Ads  Search Engine JournalInstagram advertisers can now promote organic posts as ads that appear in other users' feeds.
Online Advertising for Big Brands Gets ‘Ugly’  The Wall Street JournalA lo-fi aesthetic spawned by amateurs spreads to big marketers trying to connect with their audience.
Advertising as we know it is about to change. Here's how marketers including Chipotle, L'Oreal and Marriott ar  Business Insider IndiaA new alliance including Facebook and Unilever formed to curb bad *content* online has some in the ad world nervous and confused. Lucia MosesJun 21, 2019, ...
A bad dose of woke-washing is infecting advertising  AdNewsUnilever CEO Alan Jope: Don't accept briefs for brands which don't walk the talk.
Cannes Lions: Is advertising bridging the digital vs traditional divide?  The HinduWith the 2019 Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity underway, a look into the jugalbandhi between the traditional and digital in the advertising world.
What Amazon’s Intention to Acquire Sizmek Means for the Advertising Industry  AdweekWhen Amazon announced the acquisition of Sizmek, it was seen as far from a footnote of a commerce behemoth picking up engineers from a bankrupt ad ...
Women's Sex Toy Startup Sues MTA Over 'Double Standard' in Advertising Rules  FortuneDame Products sued New York's MTA after it rejected an ad campaign for Dame's sex toys geared toward women.
Spotify now allows advertisers to specifically target podcast listeners  The VergeSpotify announced today that advertisers can now target ads based on the podcasts that people listen to. This means that unlike before, where advertisers could ...
Digital Advertising Trends To Watch In 2019 And Beyond  ForbesEarlier this month the Interactive Advertising Bureau assembled industry professionals for a day-long symposium in New York City. A slate of speakers ranging ...
How Facebook's Libra Will Turbo-Charge Its Ad Empire  FortuneFacebook has revealed the details of its Project Libra crypto coin, an ambitious plan to bring digital currency like Bitcoin to billions of people worldwide. The plan ...
Advertisers have got lazy and must be more creative says Verizon's chief marketer  CNBCVerizon's Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) Diego Scotti has said the ad industry needs to be more creative if it is to get people to watch advertising, or face more ...
CBS Sees Primetime, Late-Night Advertising Gains From Upfront (EXCLUSIVE)  VarietyDespite an array of new video options, Madison Avenue is still placing big bets on one of its standbys, fueling upfront surges at CBS.
5 ways to Leverage Facebook Advertising to Promote Your Real Estate Agency - RealtyBizNews: Real Estate News  RealtyBizNewsAre you looking for more leads for your real estate agency? Have you tried multiple marketing options with no results? If so, it's time to up the game.
Against Advertising  Jacobin magazineAdvertisers thrive on perpetuating a system that is ravaging the planet. We can do without them — and a lot of the junk they're trying to sell us. Times Square ...
Cannes Lions 2019: Advertising, badvertising and what the future holds for the industry  Best Media InfoOn Day 5 of Cannes Lions Festival 2019, Marisa Thalberg of Taco Bell, Julia Goldin of Lego and Marc Pritchard of P&G discuss the challenges prevailing in the ...
Post Brewing Targets Millennials With First Advertising 06/25/2019  MediaPost CommunicationsDenver-based regional brewing company Post Brewing Co. is launching its first-ever advertising campaign. The campaign is for Howdy Beer, which it describes ...
Complaint filed against Federer and other Instagram influencers  swissinfo.chA Swiss consumer protection organisation has filed a complaint against Swiss tennis star Roger Federer and several other celebrity “influencers”, accusing them ...
Google Lets Advertisers Promote YouTube Live Streams as Display Ads  Search Engine JournalGoogle is introducing a new ad format that lets marketers run YouTube live streams in display ads. Live stream ads can appear anywhere Google's display.
Facebook reaches deal with advertisers over bad video metrics  AdAge.comThe social network has agreed to a class-wide settlement over erroneous audience measurements used in ad-buying decisions.
Marketers Turn Up Podcast Advertising  The Wall Street JournalPodcasters continue to find growing interest from marketers, but their growth remains constrained by factors including a lack of independent audience ...
Have You Been Paying Attention? delivers 750,000 viewers for Ten, topping key advertising demos  mUmBRELLA*Continuing what's already been a successful season seven for Ten's Have You Been Paying Attention?, the show brought in 750000 metro viewers last night,
Brands and advertisers are scrambling to tap into TikTok  Fast CompanyDirector of U.S. marketing Stefan Heinrich is in Cannes on a mission to educate brands and advertisers on what the app is, and find out how ad creatives want to ...
‘Growth is really strong’: Starcom’s president of investment Kristina Lutz on podcast advertising  DigidayEarlier this month, the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) released a report on the state of podcast advertising with a prediction that its revenue will top $1 ...
Facebook to Boost Ad Spending as It Tries to Restore Reputation  The Wall Street JournalFacebook may more than double its global advertising spending as it aims to rebuild trust after a series of privacy missteps and other controversies dented the ...
Mars's three-point strategy to improve gender equality in its advertising  Marketing WeekMars has outlined a three-part strategy to help improve gender equality in its advertising as it looks to “positively influence” society and “shape culture in a ...
Franklin County regional chamber launches advertising benefit at interstate rest area  vtdigger.orgNews Release — Franklin County Regional Chamber of Commerce June 24, 2019. Contact: Lisamarie Charlesworth, Chamber Manager (802) 524-2444 OR ...
Streaming news' golden age, Amazon's private-label tear, and Salesforce cozies up to advertisers  Business InsiderIt's a good time to be a news junkie. The social and streaming platforms are hungry for news programming because it can help build a loyal audience.
The Wing Lands in Boston and Finds an Advertising Double Standard  FortuneA planned series of subway ads ran into regulatory issues. One ad read, “The World was built for men. The Wing is built for you.”
FDA Finalizes Guidance on Advertising and Promotional Material Submissions  Regulatory FocusThe US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) on Friday finalized guidance on the requirements and recommendations for submissions of promotional materials ...
Project OAR’s bid to standardize addressable TV advertising moves into phase two  DigidayFor Project OAR to become the industry standard for how addressable TV advertising works, the organization needs as much support as it can get.
The Changing Culture Of Media Advertisements  ForbesHow has advertising from television to the internet changed how we view advertising over the years and how have our viewing expectations informed how ...
With digital advertising on the rise, here’s why brands prefer the medium  MoneycontrolDigital *content* consumption rose and the medium has become an obvious choice for advertisers. But segmented and personalised data and diverse viewership ...
Formula One forms global advertising partnership with Inskin  MobileMarketing MagazineThe world's most popular motorsport competition, Formula One (F1), has penned a deal with Inskin Media to bring its Pageskin ad formats to Formula1.com.
Will Addressable Advertising Stave Off A Decline In Television Ad Spending?  ForbesThe article examines how the advantages of addressable television are helping it to grow on traditional television in the face of stiff competition for advertising ...
Amazon is poaching Madison Avenue to build its advertising business  Business InsiderAmazon has 190 full-time advertising jobs in New York open, and it comes at a time of a lot of volatility at agencies.
Advertising Revenue on Gaana Has Been Consistently Growing at 100% YOY: Prashan Agarwal, Gaana  AdAge IndiaMusic streaming app Gaana is now leading the market with more than 100 million users who stream across 3.2 billion songs a month. There are around 150 ...
NBCUniversal offers refunds to programmatic advertisers following ad insertion error  DigidayNBCUniversal has notified advertisers of an error that may have led to the wrong advertisers' video ads running on the TV conglomerate's...
Comcast partners with Charter, Cox to advance targeted advertising  Reuters(Reuters) - U.S. cable provider Comcast Corp on Tuesday launched a program to further develop an advertising strategy that better targets audiences, as the TV ...
The Rise of Amazon Advertising Report - Business Insider  Business InsiderBusiness Insider Intelligence examines how Amazon's ad business is growing, and how it could take share from the Google-Facebook duopoly.
#MyTikTokStory: How TikTok is following YouTube’s steps in advertising  The HinduThe occasionally controversial but hugely popular app, TikTok, is eyeing advertisers by diversifying its *content* and following YouTube's footsteps.
Local advertising options for businesses in Oxford  In Your AreaIf you're a business in Oxford wanting to target a local audience, you have many options. Here is a run down of the best Local Advertising in Oxford.
For advertising, it's the season to fake it...  afaqsAbout this time of the year, advertising people are working furiously into the nights. Not because it is an important time of the year for clients or their businesses, ...
How advertising can repurpose itself to serve cities in more sustainable ways  The Conversation AUCompanies have an opportunity to reframe brand communications from the promotion of conspicuous consumption to becoming a regenerative force in urban ...
Advertisers Are Wary of Breaking Up Google and Facebook  Wall Street JournalAdvertisers have griped about the power Google and Facebook wield over the digital ad market. But they are generally wary of breaking up the tech giants.
APEX ARC Committee Aims to Double Size of In-Flight Advertising Market  APEX MediaThe in-flight advertising industry is currently worth around $200 million. But it's still a tiny fraction of the $600 billion global advertising market. APEX's Airline ...
Marijuana should be legal, but there are still good reasons to curtail pot advertising  Los Angeles TimesCalifornia's legal marijuana market is slowly growing, with more and more pot shops opening across the state to provide regulated and taxed cannabis to adult ...
Amazon rebrands IMDb TV as it ramps up pitch to ad buyers  DigidayWith a new name and more *content*, Amazon's IMDb TV is garnering more advertiser interest. But ad buyers still have questions that need answers.

Advertising on a Budget -- Part 3: Frequency, Frequency, Frequency

This is the third article of a three-part series. I'm... Read More

What Makes A Winning Online Ad?

Most people who have been involved with sales & marketing... Read More

B2B Marketing Health and Elder Care Services

Quality Care Options is an established company advocating for the... Read More

Advertising - Does it Matter?

When advertising, you need to sell your opportunity, your products... Read More

What Does Your Business Card Say?

Business cards are the most underutilized and misunderstood marketing tool... Read More

Top Design and Marketing Tips from a Branding Expert

This month, we wanted to share some general tips relating... Read More

3 Inside Secrets To Making You Richer Using Direct Mail!

Making money using direct mail isn't easy. And anyone who... Read More

Choosing a Print Mail Dealer

"Print & Mail is a type of service that... Read More

Turn Your Ad Copy into a Goldmine!

Today, more than ever, it is crucial that your ad... Read More

Direct Mail = Your Money, From Printer to Mailbox to Trash!

I did a quick, very unscientific survey of 25 of... Read More

Moving Message Board

Moving message boards are used in the areas where continuous... Read More

Offline Advertising Tips

Since most of us are always online and our business... Read More

Vinyl Banners for the Right Occasion

The sinage marketplace is competitive! Consequently, some companies are going... Read More

Electronic Display Signs

Electronic display signs are used nowadays in great extent to... Read More

Media Savvy ? Media Skills For Rural Women

The ability to lead, persuade and influence are integral skills... Read More

Bad Seduction - Advertising Techniques That Dont Work

I just read some advertising suggestions on an Internet marketing... Read More

Secrets of Getting Free Advertising

The opportunities for getting free advertising for your product or... Read More

Take Your Radio Ads to the Next Level

Most small businesses do not have a high powered advertising... Read More

Create Your Own Business Cards, Part 2

This is the second part of creating your own business... Read More

Marketing Messages with Add Zest & Appeal

Boring is one thing you can't afford to be when... Read More

Promotional Vehicles

It is difficult to miss a Hummer, but how many... Read More

How To Make Your Yellow Page Ads Work

I hear it often, "advertising in the Yellow Pages directory... Read More

Pros and Cons of Establishing an In-House Ad Agency

There have been several ads promoting books and reports on... Read More

6 Ways To Get More Sales From Your Advertisement

To bring great sales success, a great advertising technique is... Read More

Tips for Using Paid Advertising

Quite a few business out there can't survive without some... Read More