Winning The Whining War

Jason Meridith's two-year old son whines when he wants more juice. Brenda Kreuger's eight-year old daughter whines about having to take piano lessons. Connie Gustufson's daughter whines about not getting enough playing time on the softball team. Each parent finds the whining annoying, but is unsure what to do about it. In each case, the parent and the child could be helped by the following guidelines.

Do expect your child to whine. It is age appropriate at two, three, eight, thirteen, nineteen and every other age in between. Children will whine. Count on it.

Don't say, "Stop whining." That doesn't work. Children do not like being ordered around under normal circumstances. When they are whining, they like it even less. One thing worse than a whiner is a whiner that engages you in a power struggle.

Do say, "Madison, that is whining. Whining doesn't work with me. What works with me is to ask in a normal voice, with normal tone and normal volume. If you do that, sometimes you get what you want. Sometimes you don't. But it's your only hope."

Don't be surprised if you are tested. Your child will check you out to see if you meant what you just said. Show them that you do.

Don't cave. You may be tested more than once. Once your child realizes that whining doesn't work, he will drop the behavior. A child who fights, fights because that behavior works for him. A child who runs away from fights, runs away because that works for him. A child who gives excuses, does so because that behavior works for him. Show your child that whining doesn't work with you.

Do announce the living room, kitchen, your bedroom, and the car are whine free zones. Put up whine free signs if necessary.

Do allow your child to whine. Provide a whining area. Her bedroom will work well for this purpose. With a legitimate whining area, your child can continue to whine if she chooses and you don't have to hear it.

Don't whine to your spouse about your whining your child. You are always modeling. Your child learned whining behavior somewhere. Could it have been from you?

Do use a whine fine for older children. Assess each whiner $1.00 per whine. Keep it in a whine jar or whine bottle. Treat yourself to dinner out or a massage when the whine toll allows.

Do allow children to whine in a whining journal. Inform them that you will listen to all whining if it is written down.

Do praise your child when she asks in a normal voice, with a normal tone and normal volume.

Don't take children to stores, malls or relatives homes beyond their normal bedtime. You are asking for whining. Whining, both theirs and yours, increases with tiredness.

Do use preventative communication before you enter whine zones. Have a talk in the car before you enter the grocery store. Explain the purpose of the trip. Set the ground rules. Make your expectations clear before you enter the whine zone and you will experience less whining after you get in there.

Do inform your child that you are having trouble hearing when she whines. Tell her she is hard to understand when she chooses that tone. Tell her whining hurts your ears and they close down for whine protection.

Do make a copy of this article and carry it around with you. This will help you stay conscious that whining is a behavior you have made a commitment to eliminate.

Don't get discouraged. Whining is learned behavior. Learned behavior can be unlearned and with consistent use of these strategies, your child will learn new behaviors to replace it.

Reproduced with permission from Chick Moorman and Thomas Haller's monthy E-zine, The Response-Able Parenting Newsletter. All rights reserved worldwide.

Chick Moorman and Thomas Haller are two of the world's foremost authorities on raising responsible, caring, confident children. They are the co-authors of "The 10 Commitments: Parenting with Purpose."

Chick Moorman is a veteran educator who has invested more than 40 years working with children, parents, and teachers. More than 300,000 participants have attended his lectures.

Thomas Haller is a preeminent family and couples therapist. His private psychotherapy practice has specialized in couples and their families for over 25 years. Tom is a highly sought-after speaker on the topics of parenting and coupling. He is the director of the Healing Minds Institute.

Chick Moorman and Thomas Haller are on a mission to empower parents, teachers, and care-givers so they can in turn empower the children they love and serve. To subscribe to Chick Moorman and Thomas Haller's monthly E-zine on Response-Able Parenting, go to http://chickmoorman.com

In The News:

Is tough love an effective parenting measure?  The New TimesTough love is a parenting approach that helps children realise that even though their parents have undying love for them, they won't just sit back and watch as ...
Parenting tips: How to deal with your child's 'never-ending' questions  Times NowFirrst-time parents feel like they are seated on the hot-seat while their child is Amitabh Bachchan at the quiz show and they are often the lone victims of the FAQs.
Parenting with presence  soprissun.comAs usual, our favorite Mexican restaurant was packed. The parents at the table next to us didn't even flinch as their kids raced around not just their.
Mom and Dad Are Fighting: The “Do You Like Piña Coladas?” Edition  SlateKatherine Goldstein joins to discuss her new podcast, The Double Shift.
Keep calm and don't carry on when parenting teens: Researchers look at how mothers and fathers control themselves (and their rising anger) in difficult interactions with their teenagers  Science DailyIn a new study, psychologists find that mothers and fathers who are less capable of dampening down their anger are more likely to resort to harsh discipline ...
Aspen Laugh Fest: Jo Koy on parenting, skiing and upcoming specials  Aspen TimesComedian Jo Koy can't go more than a few days without doing stand-up. When he does, withdrawal sets in.“When I take a week off I look like a crackhead.
When your child doesn’t want a birthday party  The Indian ExpressAll kids are different and some may outgrow the idea of a birthday party. There are various things parents can do with them to make their special day a ...
Triple P Parenting at Family and Childcare Resources of Northeast Wisconsin  WeAreGreenBay.comParents know that their children do not come with a manual.
Parents put 'intensive parenting' on a pedestal. Experts say there's a better approach.  Longview News-JournalImogen Dransfield's two sons don't get much sympathy from their mom if they tell her they're bored. Dransfield's own mother met the same complaint with an ...
Parenting workshop to focus on puberty  Jamaica ObserverTHE Parent-Teacher Association (PTA) of Ardenne High School and Maverick Communications Ltd are staging a workshop this weekend to guide parents in ...
uh-PARENT-ly Ep. 32 | Why helicopter parenting might not be so bad (and why NOT to move to Sweden)  WGN Radio - ChicagoIn his 1969 book Between Parent and Teenager, Dr. Haim Ginott talked to teenagers who said their parents hovered over them like helicopters. Since then the ...
40 Parenting Tweets From Celebrities That Prove Money Can't Buy You Peace.  Someecards NewsHere's the thing, even filthy rich celebrity parents still have to deal with the tyranny of growing children. No amount of couture toys, Ivy league educated nannies, ...
Parenting lessons from my over the top mother  MomtasticMy mom is extraordinary. Growing up, I would often see her as the villain and my dad as the hero. My dad was Mr. Clean, as he was a house-husband for a long ...
How parents can support kids who are appearing for board exams  The Indian ExpressDon't burden the child with your high expectations. Understand your child's academic limits and keep your expectations realistic. It's critical to keep your calm ...
Parenting advice people used to believe that you shouldn't listen to  INSIDEREveryone has an opinion about the "right" way to be a parent. Some outdated pieces of parenting advice range from misinformed to dangerous.
Peterborough author’s new book on parenting focuses on distracting digital devices  Global NewsIn her new book, "Happy Parents, Happy Kids," Peterborough author Ann Douglas offers insight as to how parents can cope raising their kids in a digital age.
SC legislature considers 'free-range parenting' bill, would change state's child neglect laws  WIS10COLUMBIA, SC (WIS) - A bill gaining attention in the South Carolina Statehouse would have the potential to change the laws in the state for parents and crimes ...
The parenting problem — what value do we place on caring?  Financial TimesThree books argue how improving the way society treats parents and their children is in all our interest.
Call for Australians to take an old-fashioned approach to parenting  NEWS.com.auAustralian parents are being urged to take a step back from the pressures of modern parenting and adopt a simpler approach to raising children.
Parenting Advice on Enforcing Rules for Kids: Trying to Follow Them Yourself  FatherlyA week of following my own rules for my children revealed that sometimes parent demands are arbitrary and unhelpful, but sometimes we need to follow them ...
Loose Women's Stacey Solomon reveals surprising parenting confession  HELLO! MagazineStacey Solomon is known for always being real and isn't afraid to open up about the bad as well as the good time. And this week, the Loose Women panellist ...
'Parenting in a Digital World' topic of free presentation  Coos Bay WorldBANDON - A free presentation of "Parenting in a Digital World" will be held from 6:30-8:30 p.m. Monday, Feb. 25, in the Bandon High School cafeteria.
Parenting throughout history could be weird, and downright dangerous: author  CBC.ca"Parenting" only became a verb in the last century, a fact that becomes clear when you look back at the history of how we used to treat our children. As much of ...
Q&A: A boy-girl sleepover in middle school? Just say no.  STLtoday.comQ: Our son is 12 years old and in 7th grade. He's been invited to a birthday sleepover with girls and boys next month. He's excited, but we have our concerns.
Revive Ministries to offer teen parenting courses  KSNB Local 4For those raising teenagers, it can be difficult to deal with all that comes with that process. That's why Revive Ministries is offering classes on how to navigate ...
Positive Parenting: Speaking 'Parentese' Helps Babies Learn  9&10 NewsA particular type of parental language can help parents boost babies' language skills. That's what researchers say at the University of Washington's Institute for ...
Dancing in the rain: The joys and jolts of parenting  Hindustan TimesChildren grow up and become individuals, but their essence remains the same.
Today's most common parenting mistakes | John Rosemond  Reno Gazette JournalA journalist recently asked me for the single biggest mistake being made by today's parents. I was tempted to say, “Having children,” but stopped myself ...
Here are parenting tips to learn how to raise a reader  Miami HeraldReading can transport and transform us, making us laugh (and cry), introducing us to different cultures, and encouraging us to see and think about the world in ...
Katie Price ignores latest parenting criticism as she shares adorable new video of daughter Bunny: ‘Beautiful moment’  CelebsNowKatie Price has snubbed her latest parenting criticism by sharing an adorable family moment with her daughter Bunny in new Instagram video.
8 quotes on parenting by comedians that will make you laugh out loud  The Indian ExpressParenting is hard, no doubt and can transform your life in ways you can't imagine. These hilarious punchlines from celebrated comedians will tickle your funny ...
Parenting Advice For Raising Good Kids Who Are Happy & Healthy | Lianne Avila  YourTangoRaising healthy and happy kids can be a challenge to some parents but taking these 6 parenting advice to heart will allow you to spend time with your children.
Khloe Kardashian annoyed by parenting critics  EWNKhloe Kardashian finds it annoying how she is constantly being challenged on social media about her parenting skills, including her choice to have her nails ...
Forget expert advice: ‘Weird’ things moms, dads do to win at parenting  WTOPLullabies not working? Try Ludacris. In “Weird Parenting Wins,” author and podcaster Hillary Frank ditches the expert advice and shares unconventional ...
Parenting Corner – Some tips to cope with ADHD related challenges  NewzHookAttention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder or ADHD affects the ability of a person to pay attention or focus on one thing for long. ADHD is a brain disorder that also ...
'If this was my job, I'd quit.': Mum's candid admission about parenting goes viral.  Mamamia"If this was a job, I'd quit." A stay at home mum's post about the realities of parenting and its challenges has gone viral.
Parenting a procrastinator? It’s more complicated than you think.  The Washington PostHave you ever received an email from your child's teacher letting you know she assigned a project that would be due in three weeks? And have you then asked ...
My Teen Daughter Is Dating Her Friend Who Practically Lives With Us  SlateCare and Feeding is Slate's parenting advice column. Have a question for Care and Feeding? Email [email protected] or post it in the Slate Parenting ...
'I loved being a mum to small children' - celebrity Emma Freud reveals joys and challenges of parenting  East Anglian Daily TimesShe is used to high pressure roles in television, radio and fundraising for Comic Relief.
Khloe criticised for parenting approach | Entertainment  Jamaica Star OnlineKhloe Kardashian is fed up of being criticised for her approach to parenting. TheKeeping Up With The Kardashians star finds it “annoying” how she is constantly ...
Fort Pierce Class in Fort Pierce teaches 'Secrets of Modern Parenting'  WPTV.comKimberly Eardley heads up "Families of the Treasure Coast" and is behind a course called the "Secrets of Modern Parenting."
Anne Hathaway is following Prince William-Kate’s parenting trick. Here’s how it helps  The Indian ExpressAnne Hathaway has started following the royal couple's practice of bending down to maintain eye contact with their children while speaking, she said in an ...
Stacey Solomon Admits She's 'Given Up On Parenting' This Half-Term – And We Can All Relate  HuffPost UKStacey Solomon's refreshingly honest post about “giving up” on parenting this half-term has been a hit with her parent followers on Instagram. The TV presenter ...
Will Harry and Meghan's Parenting Style be Similar to William and Kate's?  The Cheat SheetPrince Harry and Meghan Markle are having their first child soon. Will they borrow any parenting styles from Prince William and Kate Middleton?
The 8 Best Books on How to Raise Toddlers, According to Child-Development Experts  New York MagazineThe best parenting books on raising toddlers, according to child development experts, including titles from Adele Faber and Elaine Mazlish, Dr. Laura Markham, ...
Experts in parenting reveal the secrets on how to get kids to sleep on a plane  Travel WiresTravelling with kids is no easy task. This is exactly why several experts in parenting have put together a few pieces of advice on how to make things stress free ...
NRL Player vs. Parents: Is parenting harder than sport?  Now To LoveIn a new experiment, NRL star Kalyn Ponga proves Aussie parents work harder in a day than a professional rugby league athlete does during a match.
The Constant Gardener: Hein Koh Talks Parenting, Photoshop, and Her Sprawling Rockefeller Center Show -  ARTnewsA few weeks ago, on one of the coldest days of the year, anthropomorphic, one-eyed flowers began appearing all over Rockefeller Center in New York.
Reasons behind grey hair in child | Parenting Tips  ABP LiveThere are some health conditions that can cause gray hair in children. Vitamin B12 deficiency can also cause gray hair. Will it be a fruitful day for you? Will the ...
The surprising Indian origin of blue jeans  The Indian ExpressThe cloth, dyed blue with Indian indigo, came from Genoa in Italy, which led to the word jeans. When weavers from Nimes in Italy tried to reproduce it, their fabric ...
Whitman: Seventh Mom Project helps mothers share parenting-related struggles  Tampa Bay TimesI positioned earphones on my swollen belly, blasted Alison Krauss and prayed the boy in my womb couldn't hear me cry. I begged God to make the anxiety stop.
Hax: Resist the urge to be a parenting coach  Minneapolis Star TribuneAdapted from a recent online discussion. Dear Carolyn: My husband and I got married and had kids relatively young, especially by his family's standards.
33 Relatable Parenting Tweets From Molly Ringwald  HuffPostThe Brat Packer and her husband, Panio Gianopoulos, have three children.
Anne Hathaway follows Prince William and Kate Middleton's parenting playbook  USA TODAYMom of a 2-year-old son, Hathaway said she read about Kate Middleton and Prince William's way to make children feel empowered and followed their lead.
I love my child but I don’t love parenting. Will this change?  The Washington PostQ: I love my child. She is magic. But I don't love parenting. I just don't love this phase — she's 3½ , and, man, is it relentless. I miss the space to be still and alone, ...
Edith Bowman: Parenting is harder than anyone admits  Telegraph.co.ukWe asked the DJ and broadcaster, 45, what her childhood self would make of her life.
Russell Brand's 'inept' parenting is unacceptable and not at all cute  USA TODAYThe "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" star said he feels "inept" when parenting. All parents do. But they also learn basic childcare skills. So should he.
The Balance Of Parenting: How Best To Support Children’s Self-Regulation  Science TrendsYoung children are faced with learning to control their behaviors and emotions, which is a skill labeled self-regulation. You can see different levels of.
Rachel Brosnahan Defends Midge's Lack of Parenting on 'Marvelous Mrs. Maisel'  The Cheat SheetFans of The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel are beyond smitten with Rachel Brosnahan's character, Midge, but some have found fault with the lack of interaction the ...
'Parenting' is on its way out, child-rearing is coming back | Rosemond  Reno Gazette JournalThere is “parenting” and then there is bringing up, rearing or raising children. The difference is night and day; so are the outcomes.
Bringing Up Bebe Review: Why French Parenting Helps Kids Eat Normal Foods, Behave Themselves, And Sleep All Night  FatherlyAll the advice, tips, techniques from Pamela Druckerman's bestseller about raising kids in France, 'Bringing Up Bebe,' in 1000 words.
Stacey Solomon reveals she’s ‘given up’ on parenting as she shares pic of sons using THREE TV screens at same  The SunThe Loose Women panellist took to the photo-sharing platform to document her boys Zachary, 10, and Leighton, six, relaxing on grey bean bags while they took ...
Open Letter to Faculty of Color Parenting While On The Tenure-Track  Diverse: Issues in Higher EducationWe are compelled to write this open letter to our fellow faculty of color colleagues who are navigating tenure-track while raising little humans. As graduate st.
Kate Middleton just made a parenting confession that we can all relate to  HELLO! MagazineKate Middleton has spoken of how she was very naive as a parent and how important the early years of a child's life can be in preparing them for the future...
Train wreck: Healing for two and parenting with PTSD  SalonPTSD. Mild as far as these things go. Just a nanosecond flash of adrenaline when the subway jerks to one side or the other. Whoa, big turn, I thought to myself, ...
Teens need to text, talk with parents often to maintain youth resiliency after a divorce  Science DailyTexting, FaceTime and other popular communication methods among teens may help build supportive parent-youth relationships after a divorce, according to a ...
PARENTING: Nurturing our kids with healthy soul food  Sarasota Herald-TribuneOne of the most obvious jobs of parenting is to nurture our kids, and a major part of nurturing has to do with feeding them. Most of us understand that what we put ...
Carrie Bickmore posts Instagram photo showing the reality of parenting  NEWS.com.auCarrie Bickmore has shared a brutally honest post about the realities of parenthood — and people are loving it. The 38-year-old shared two contrasting images ...
The economic case against free-range parenting — and in favor of being a helicopter parent  MarketWatchWe love the idea of “free-range” parenting. Our childhoods in the 1970s followed this approach to the letter — and it was a lot of fun. Our parents did the bare ...
The Making Babies Trailer Gives You Permission to Laugh at How Hard It Can Be to Get Pregnant  POPSUGAR AustraliaThe path toward pregnancy is different for everyone. For some couples, it's as simple as having sex and unknowingly fertilising an egg. For others, it can feel.
LIVING WITH CHILDREN: Parenting or child-rearing? The difference is like night and day  GoDanRiver.comThere is “parenting” and then there is bringing up, rearing or raising children.
Hecht: Parenting little piggies  Asheville Citizen-TimesIf messiness is a sign of genius, as some studies say, then nearly every child I meet must be one.
A Parenting Intervention to Improve Positive Life Skills in Teen  AAP NewsWe are familiar with the risk factors that can put the infant of a teenage mother at risk, including adverse social determinants of health or simply lacking parenting ...
A Day in the Vegan Life of 'Bones' Star Emily Deschanel  LIVEKINDLY"Bones" star Emily Deschanel shares vegan parenting tips, what a day in the life of a vegan celebrity is like, and her transition to a plant-based diet.
On Parenting: Meghan Leahy took your questions about parenting  Washington PostMeghan Leahy, a parenting coach with Positively Parenting, joined On Parenting editor Amy Joyce to talk about parenting children of all ages. Amy Joyce.
Baba And Deedee: Why Some Parents Pick Titles Beyond 'Mom' And 'Dad'  HuffPost CanadaSome LGBTQ parents are shaking the monikers up.
PARENTING: Empowering the knight in our kids  Sarasota Herald-TribuneA major duty of parenting is to nurture our kids and part of the definition for nurture is to cultivate, support, encourage and train. There are many things that we ...
Rise of zero-waste parenting in Singapore | Video  Channel NewsAsiaFrom choosing cloth diapers over disposable ones to making their own organic remedies for cold and flu, these parents are trying to raise their children in an ...
Positive Parenting: The Power of Praise  9&10 NewsEveryone likes a little pat on the back. But new research shows praise can have an even bigger effect, with major benefits later on. Researchers looked at how ...
Pamela Adlon on Parenting: 'Kids Are Not Enough'  VarietyPamela Adlon says that while parenting is "incredible," having kids shouldn't stop a person's journey of self-discovery.
Parenting An Extrovert In An Introvert-Centric World  NPRMark Oppenheimer is a father of five. He recently wrote a piece for The Washington Post about how to raise an extrovert. He and his extroverted daughter Anna ...
How to Grant Your Child an Inner Life  The New YorkerJess Row writes about being parent to a teen in the digital age, and questions of a young person's right to a private life.
Similarities in Parenting and Friedreich’s Ataxia  Friedreich's Ataxia NewsColumnist Kendall Harvey shares some similarities she sees between life with kids and life with a progressive disease, affecting both humor and sanity.
Queen of Sweden visits parenting project  University of Cape Town NewsSweden's Queen Silvia delighted residents of Touwsranten, a small town in the Western Cape, and staff of the Seven Passes Initiative earlier this month when ...
Parenting classes offered at St. Luke's Jerome  KMVTJEROME, Idaho (KMVT/KSVT) St. Luke's in Jerome is offering a weekly parenting session that includes lectures, skills training and homework for parents of ...
The Bad News About Helicopter Parenting: It Works  The New York TimesNew research shows that hyper-involved parenting is the route to kids' success in today's unequal world.
'The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel': Rachel Brosnahan on Midge's Parenting  TVLine'The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel' star Rachel Brosnahan pushed back at fans calling her character Midge a 'terrible mother.'

10 Things You Can Do To Help A Shy Child

There are a few points about shyness in children which... Read More

Parents --- Your Childrens Report Card May Be Rigged

Under the "No Child Left Behind Act," public schools whose... Read More

Identifying Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder in the Classroom: Eight Things Teachers Should

Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is the phrase that is... Read More

A Legacy For Dakota

Have you heard the song; "I Hope You Dance"? It... Read More

Missing The Bus

As a step daughter and step grand daughter, I followed... Read More

Time Out for Adults

"Get down from the table top right now! What are... Read More

How to Silence Your Childs Inner Critic

Children do what feels good to them and follow their... Read More

Secrets from the Classroom: Avoiding Summer Learning Loss

In June, elementary school children across North America cheered as... Read More

The Recipe For The Making Of A Self-Assured Child: One Part Communication, Two Parts Love

Each child carries a unique picture of the self, shaped... Read More

Summer Camp Care Packages

Every summer our daughter goes to summer camp. She looks... Read More

What To Do With A 6 Year Old Smart Mouth Know It All

Just the other day, I was talking to some other... Read More

Ten Terrific Ideas for Rainy Day Fun

It's been raining for a week and the kids and... Read More

Nurtured by Love or Matured by Nature?

"There is nothing new under the sun," states Ecclesiastes 1:9.... Read More

The Twenty-First Century Parent

John was a 43 year-old sales manager at a large... Read More

Where Is Your Homework, Lisa?

Is Homework Really That Important?Dear Friends,I no longer teach in... Read More

Homeschooling ? Is It Worth It?

Suppose that you rearrange your life to homeschool your child... Read More

Illegal and Legal Drug Usage in the United States

How bad is the illegal drug problem here in the... Read More

Elephants and Teenagers

Something eerily familiar happened in KwaZulu-Natal's Hluhluwe-Umfolozi Park in Africa... Read More

Every Mom Worries

Sitterphobe "I never have a second to myself," this mother... Read More

Why Creativity and Self-Expression are Important to Little Kids

Can you draw a straight line? Most adults don't consider... Read More

Top Ten Things My Six Year-Old Son Has Taught Me (So Far...)

I've learned numerous, important lessons on life, motherhood and men... Read More

Ease Bug Bites with Easy Herbs

Summertime means insect bites and stings. Ouch! Take a leaf... Read More

Four Tips For Alleviating Back To School Anxiety

Back to school preparations are in full-swing. Soon, the first... Read More

The Graceful Art of Defrazzling - For Mothers

"I wipe my baby's chin with my college diploma and... Read More

Unschooling - the Benefits of Home Based Education

Home schooling benefits children. As a parent, I feel it... Read More