Parenting Your Teenager: When is it OK to Quit?

Q. My daughter is a junior in high school and has played an instrument and/or played in band all her life. Now all of a sudden she wants to quit lessons and quit band. Is this normal or a warning sign of something bad? Should we let her quit?

A. There are times when wanting to drop something that has been a big part of your life can indicate a problem in need of immediate attention. If there are any other signs that your daughter might be depressed or using drugs, then you will want to get her two appointments - one with her doctor and one with a family counselor who works with teenagers.

If she's not depressed and/or doing drugs, then dropping an instrument and band may be a decision that she is ready to make. Certainly she is old enough to make that decision, and she may have simply lost interest.

How to End Gracefully

You can tell her that if dropping the instrument and band is something she wants to do, there are two things she needs to do first.

The first is have her write a letter of thanks to the person who taught her the instrument and to the band director, thanking each for their time and effort and sharing what she has learned.

I suggest this for two reasons: It's simply a classy thing to do, and it may re-awaken in her the reasons she got involved in the band.

The second is to tell her she can quit band only after she finds something else to be involved in. It's quite fine to want to quit something, but at her age, it needs to be replaced with something else. This is because one of the strongest needs of kids and teens is to have a sense of belonging. This need is so strong that a teen will get it met some how, either in a positive place or a negative place.

By requiring that she find something else to be a part of, you are helping to make sure she finds a positive place to belong.

Leading parenting expert Jeff Herring is a teen and family therapist, parenting coach, speaker and syndicated parenting and relationship columnist. Jeff invites you to visit ParentingYourTeenager.com for 100's of tips and tools for parenting through the teenage years. You can also subscribe to his f'ree weekly internet newsletter "ParentingYourTeenager."

In The News:

On Cultural and Technological Parenting  ForbesWhat are the lessons we can learn from the uses of media and public debate that the Ohio father, Matt Cox, who made his daughter walk to school five miles ...
Parenting: Moment I realised my job as a mum  NEWS.com.auYou were in your pram and pointing at the sky. Thanks to that mysterious knack all parents have of understanding their child's early, garbled speech, I knew what ...
Sex Education and Parenting: What We Know  Psychology TodayThere is clear evidence that the foundations for sex education comes from parents and guardians at home.
PARENTING TODAY: Plan on organized chaos this Christmas  North Shore NewsI love Christmas. Most kids love Christmas. Now, what can you do to make it wonderful for you and your whole family? Whatever holiday you celebrate at this ...
Study: Biggest modern parenting challenge is monitoring child's online activity  WXYZ DetroitA University of Michigan study found that most parents would agree monitoring what their child is doing online is one of the biggest modern parenting ...
These Dads Show The Internet What Parenting Actually Looks Like  catcountry1073.comA father forces his child to walk to school after being kicked off the bus for bullying. Child abuse or good old fashioned discipline?
Billy Eichner Explains Parenting An LGBTQ Child In One Perfect & Poignant Tweet  RomperFor those of you who might not have heard, comedian Kevin Hart has been having something of a moment — and it's not a great one. The wildly popular ...
How to break the news of divorce to kids  The Indian ExpressWhen you break the news to your children that you are planning to go your separate ways, handle these conversations with maturity. Take care to find the right ...
How one parent helped change the conversation around parenting with a disability  ABC LifeOver the past two months, the series We've Got This has broken down barriers and challenged the misconceptions around parenting with disability.
Is there a parenting crisis in Kenya?  The StandardHeightening inflation, globalisation, conflicts, wars and modernity have had a significant impact on the family and more so parent-child relationships.
The trick to parenting independent teens requires more than just rules  Aleteia EN"How to raise an independent child with the right values," a video talk by Dr. Justin Coulson, inspires a discussion on effective strategies for parenting teens.
Positive Parenting: Do parents play favorites?  WQAD MolineIf you're a parent you've heard it before, when one of your kids gets something from you --- money or a present, even a Slurpee from 7-11, your other child ...
The Elf on the Shelf is everything that's wrong with modern parenting.  MamamiaI have flour in my hair. All day I've been pretending that it's dry shampoo, but it's not. Last night at 11pm, I dumped a pile flour onto a plate and squatted down to ...
Sophie Ellis Bextor insists she doesn't get parenting right all the time  Daily MailSophie Ellis-Bextor, 39, who is expecting her fifth child, has insisted she still has a lot to learn when it comes to parenting with her musician husband Richard ...
THE LIST: South Orange-Maplewood Parenting Center Toy Drive Needs Teen Gifts  The Village GreenThe SOMSD Parenting Center Toy Drive is, as always, in need of gifts for teens. “As we all know, they can be hard to please and hard to buy for!” wrote Principal ...
Positive Parenting: Sharing stories matters  WQAD MolineWhen you sit down to read or tell a story with your child, who takes the lead?
Parenting in the Present: 8 Questions Effective Parents Ask Regularly  PsychCentral.comParenting is a demanding role and one that requires constant reflection and adaptation. Children change and what worked in one stage of development most ...
Does screen time addiction rewire kids’ brains?  The Indian ExpressThe adolescent brain continually changes, or “rewires” itself, in response to daily experience and that adaptation continues into the early to mid-20s.
The Most Pointless Parenting Advice I've Received From Strangers In Public  RomperBeing a parent is hard. With the best preparation and resources and support, it's still a series of fumbling through until you sort of find your groove. And even that ...
Family: The Parenting Traps  Richmond magazineThere's nothing like the magic of the holiday season with little ones. Each twinkling light is a little more magical. Each carol sounds a little lovelier, every cup of ...
Our Kid’s Letter to Santa This Year Asks for a Sign of His Existence  SlateCare and Feeding is Slate's parenting advice column. Have a question for Care and Feeding? Email [email protected] or post it in the Slate Parenting ...
Amazon: Find a happy medium for parenting and technology by Rodeo Show & Wieden+Kennedy  The DrumA new spot by Wieden+Kennedy and directing duo Mccoy | Meyer aims to help experts share insights on how to raise kids with a healthy relationship to ...
Should Ohio divorce courts follow same standard in setting shared parenting?  The Columbus DispatchIdeally, couples who are separating or divorcing come up with a parenting-time schedule agreeable to all parties. But when they don't, Ohio judges might turn to ...
PARENTING: Gratitude yields health and social benefits  Sarasota Herald-TribuneWith Thanksgiving having passed, we may want a jump start on our New Year's resolutions. Research shows such a long list of health and social benefits that ...
Inmates Get Parenting Lessons in Jail's Father Boot Camp  Spectrum NewsClasses teach nurturing, and loving without violence.
Kate Middleton & Prince William Just Used Their Signature Parenting Move During Their Latest Outing  PureWowKate Middleton and Prince William visited the Evelina London Children's Hospital orthopaedic and spinal surgery unit and used their parenting hack.
Ellen DeGeneres' Parenting Joke Gives Ashton Kutcher a Complex  E! OnlineThe host teases the actor and his 2-year-old son who never walks.
Parenting NI expert offer advice on how to have a happy family Christmas  The Irish NewsHow should parents deal with explaining who Father Christmas is, while still keeping Christmas magical? Father Christmas brings festive magic to households ...
Parenting: should you raise independent children the 'Swiss' way?  The Local SwitzerlandWhen a ten-year-old boy went missing for a couple of hours in Basel in November his mother was quick to post a photo and a plea for help on the Basel Expat ...
Report questions inequities in Ohio parenting plans; standards debated  Massillon IndependentThose standard, or default plans, vary widely by county. And too many of them — in more than 60 of 88 counties — reflect outdated approaches.
When parenting styles collide, what does it mean for your relationship?  KidspotWhat do you do when you don't agree on even the basic stuff?
PARENTING: What does gratitude look like?  Sarasota Herald-TribuneHaving celebrated Thanksgiving, this is the time of year when our nation starts paying attention to gratitude. We ask our kids to count their blessings and think of ...
Coast Line: Triple P Parenting seminar set Dec. 10 in Watsonville  Santa Cruz SentinelTriple P Parenting will teach the seminar “Raising Confident, Competent Children” from 6-7:30 p.m. Monday at the La Manzana Community Resources, 18 W.
FARMYARD PARENTING: How to teach kids the value of hard work  Warwick Daily NewsBROOK McCosker's dad was keen to teach her the value of hard work, so rather than give out pocket money, Malcolm purchased a pair of breeding sows and ...
How parenting affects antisocial behaviors in children  EurekAlertLess parental warmth and more harshness in the home environment can affect how aggressive children become and whether they lack empathy and a moral ...
How mediocre parenting keeps me sane over the holidays  The Week Magazine"We have come to banish darkness," begins a popular Hebrew children's song for the holiday. Once day turns to night, earlier and chillier than a mere few weeks ...
‘The Bachelor’ Alum Catherine Lowe Shares a Simple Trick to Get a Baby to Stop Crying  Us Weekly'The Bachelor' alum Catherine Lowe opened up to Us Weekly about how she gets her sons Samuel and Isaiah to stop crying — watch the video.
The marvels Marco Polo saw in India  The Indian Express"The nobles and great folks have their beds made of very light canework, and when they have got in and are going to sleep, they are drawn up by cords nearly to ...
What is Kate Middleton and Prince William's Biggest Parenting Challenge They're Facing Now?  The Cheat SheetThe Duke and Duchess of Cambridge have revealed what their biggest parenting challenge is now in raising their three children.
Eliza Hull on parenting with a disability  ABC LifeEliza Hull has spoken with other parents with a disability for her audio series We've Got This.
Positive Parenting: Learning music makes kids smarter  WQAD MolineFive years ago, psychologists at the Brain and Creativity Institute at the University of Southern California studied how learning music might affect brain ...
The challenge of parenting in a migrant caravan  The Conversation - CanadaThe psychological health of migrant children will be deeply impacted by their flight from gang violence, and the experience of crowded unhygienic conditions ...
PARENTING: Helping kids manage relationships  Sarasota Herald-TribuneOur relationships are one of the most important aspects of our lives. Great relationships with our family, at work, at school and in the community usually translate ...
What Is Permissive Parenting? - Experts Explain Permissive Parenting  GoodHousekeeping.comWhile permissive parents are often very responsive and loving, this parenting style is defined by having no rules. The term was developed by psychologist Diana ...
Mandy McCracken on parenting with disability and her 'wonderfully exciting' future  ABC NewsIn 2013, Mandy McCracken was a self-described "stay-at-home mum" with three daughters under the age of 10, when she got a blood infection. It led to sepsis, ...
Who Is Toodles? Answering One Of The Great Parenting Questions Of Our Time  RomperSince becoming a parent, I've been besieged with profound questions about the universe: how does one teach a toddler the meaning of consent? How, exactly ...
Parenting Education Project to be Expanded  Government of Jamaica, Jamaica Information ServiceMinister of State in the Ministry of Education, Youth and Information, Hon. Floyd Green, says the Parenting Education Project will be expanded to reach more ...
Hamish Blake: parenting book Raising Girls  KidspotThe Blakes seem like pretty good parents. Here's where they get their advice.
When your child has a crush, how should you react?  The Indian ExpressFor the teen or preteens, their feelings are very real and important. If they have a crush on someone, it is true love. If someone else has a crush on them, they are ...
Timeouts are a dated and ineffective parenting strategy. So what's a good alternative?  Chicago TribuneThe timeout technique, used by parents for decades, exploded into the public domain in the early 2000s thanks to TV's "Supernanny" Jo Frost, who rebranded it.
An app for making parenting easier  QuartzAn app has arrived that focuses on parent's well being, not being better parents.
The parenting years haven’t flown by, actually. But here’s why I’m glad.  Washington PostI wouldn't trade these heavy-duty parenting years because they've changed all of us, and made us who we are.
Parenting with the end result in mind  Montgomery AdvertiserWhat would change in our parenting if we could see the future adults in these little people we are raising?
Never Look Too Good Or Talk Too Smart--Part II--Parenting Superpower  ForbesWho would you rather follow: someone who pretends to be perfect (when you know they're not), or someone who's made the same kinds of mistakes you ...
Reese Witherspoon's tough love approach to parenting  ABC NewsWhen it comes to parenting, Reese Witherspoon believes in full transparency.
Harsh parenting can be buffered by warm relationships with teachers, peers  Channel NewsAsia(Reuters Health) - - Children whose parents often threaten and criticize them are more likely to become defiant and aggressive, research shows.
Less Is More in Swim Parenting  SwimSwamYour kids will be happy, well-adjusted, self-sufficient and swim about the same or better than if you are overly involved.
Resolve to never use corporal punishment | Parenting With Pete  NJ.comSpanking children crosses a threshold that permits violence against children even if that violence is minimal.
Parenting praised after young girl writes touching apology letter to the police  Warrington GuardianTHE parents of an eight-year-old child who ran away from home but then wrote a letter to the police apologising have been praised online for their…
Ryan Reynolds says that parenting has made him a better person: 'I sort of miss being horrible'  INSIDERThe "Deadpool" star, who has been married to Blake Lively since 2012, opened up about parenting during an appearance on "The Ellen DeGeneres Show."
New urban parenting: Are 24-hour care homes the answer?  The ObserverI found my baby [then] five months old with a clot in the eye. Five months! At five months, a child cannot talk, cannot really do something harmful to the maid but I ...
Parenting Crisis Sends China's Moms and Dads Back to School  Sixth ToneSHANDONG, East China — Huang Wenjuan never thought there was anything wrong with her approach to parenting until her teenage daughter stormed out of ...
The top 'experience gifts' to give children this holiday season  CTV NewsInstead of the usual toys and clothing, parenting experts are encouraging families to give the gift of experiences to create lasting memories with their children.
On Parenting: Meghan Leahy took your questions about parenting  Washington PostMeghan Leahy, a parenting coach with Positively Parenting, joined On Parenting editor Amy Joyce to talk about parenting children of all ages. Amy Joyce.
Opinion: Don't like kids? Then stop chasing the parenting dollar  NewshubAnother week, another story about a cafe manager getting upset at crying babies, writes Emily Writes.
Different Parenting Styles & Friendships  FOX 31 DenverDifferent Parenting Styles & Friendships http://www.thecurrycenterllc.com/ ...
Dad sings ballad of regret over his parenting  Detroit Free PressToday, our son is very successful, but, just like me, it is go, go, go – he is always at work.
Indiana father writes book on 'Bare Minimum Parenting'  WTHRINDIANAPOLIS (WTHR) - If you're a parent, you've probably wondered once or twice whether you're doing the right things when it comes to raising your kids.
Ant Middleton's SAS guide to surviving parenting  HeartParents with young kids might want to take some tough love advice from SAS: Who Dares Wins star Ant Middleton.
Parenting Won't Be Like Anything You Imagined. It Can't Be.  RomperThis weekend I tried to sync my phone and I couldn't because it was too full of photos. Pictures of me, twice hugely pregnant. Thousands of pictures and videos ...
[PHOTO] 'Orville' Season 2 First Look: Isaac & Claire, Parenting Tips  TVLineHaving previously suggested that vaporizing Claire's children could tame the restless youths (and good), The Orville's Isaac seems to be offering a more ...
Can We Just Admit the Playground Is Parenting Hell?  ELLE.comIf you're a childless person who is fond of the idea of children, chances are you have walked past your local playground, peered inside, and smiled. Who can ...
Parenting Time Center opens all new Teen Room  14 News WFIE EvansvilleEVANSVILLE, IN (WFIE) - The new teen room at Evansville's Parenting Time Center is officially open. Mayor Winneke and several other community leaders were ...
'Panic parenting' fear drives women to freeze eggs  Chicago TribuneTrying to avoid "panic parenting" — having a relationship just to have a baby — is the reason why many single women freeze their eggs for non-medical reasons ...
Parenting involves a lot of tough choices. Deciding to see the world, though, was easy.  Washington PostThe past two and a half years have been a lot like navigating a Choose-Your-Own-Adventure book without the luxury of flipping back to page one to see how ...
The Only 15 Best Parenting Books Worth Your Money  GoodHousekeeping.comIf the idea of raising a kid without some guidance seems daunting, these parenting books will get you through. These best books for new moms and dads will ...
How to teach kids the value of commitment  The Indian ExpressWhen should you let children follow their feelings and when do you insist on powering through with commitment?
Perhaps bad parenting was involved in shooting death of 7-year-old  Baltimore SunWe need to look at the parents in the killing of 7-year-old Taylor Hayes.
There must be a place in DNA for good parenting too  The Boston GlobeRe “Childhood trauma takes root in your DNA” by Kelly Kasulis (Ideas, Nov. 25): Where are the studies on how thoughtful, compassionate child-rearing also ...
What causes breathing problems in newborns and kids?  The Indian ExpressChildren suffer from infections and allergies, both of which lead to breathing problems. Respiratory infections are divided into upper respiratory infections (URI) ...
Fake it till you make it with parenting  The Sydney Morning HeraldIf you're like me, living with the curse of perfectionism, the criteria and markers for parenting leave you treading the murky waters of self-doubt.
Parenting with a disability — talkback - Life Matters  ABC NewsIn this episode of our series, We've got this: Parenting with a Disability, we take calls from those of you with lived experience as either children of parents with a ...
SPORTS PARENTING: Injury or fatigue is always a tough call  The Providence JournalWe sports fans love the gamers, the gutsy athletes who play through pain to help their team to victory.Think Curt Schilling and his bloody sock (not 38 Studios), ...
The Value Perspective: Five things parenting and investing have in common  www.professionaladviser.comNew and impending arrivals on The Value Perspective team - at home rather than at work - have prompted some discussion on the similarities between good ...
How parenting blogger Olivia White cuts out unnecessary Christmas spending  9HoneyOlivia White, from House of White, talks to us about how she saves money during the Christmas period. Read ...
Positive Parenting: Managing hectic holiday schedules  WMUR ManchesterThe holidays can be a busy time for families. Kate Guerdat, Ed.D., of the UNH Cooperative Extension, gives some advice on how to keep the family schedule ...
Supermom In Training: A few of my favourite things: Seasonal stuff  The Suburban NewspaperStill haven't decorated for Christmas? Don't worry - you still have 12 more days to whip your house up with a festive pretty stick! Try adding these cute seasonal ...
Dear tech companies, I don’t want to see pregnancy ads after my child was stillborn  Washington PostDear Tech Companies: I know you knew I was pregnant. It's my fault, I just couldn't resist those Instagram hashtags — #30weekspregnant, #babybump. And, silly ...
Happy birthday, Sushmita Sen: 6 times the single mother set parenting goals  The Indian ExpressOn Sushmita Sen's birthday, here's a look at how the actress is setting parenting goals as a single mother. Advertising. Sushmita Sen's adorable relationship ...
Better parenting is in the cards  UCI NewsUCI startup incubator helps doctoral student market innovative game promoting life skills.
If you build it, will they come? Solving the participation problem for parenting support  The MandarinOne of the best ways governments can lessen the impact of social and economic disadvantage on children is to intervene early and fund programs that give ...
Proper parenting and child abuse | Letters  Jamaica GleanerTHE EDITOR, Sir:Crime, violence and all other forms of abuse against our fellow men are heinous, and more so against our children. The situation is of such that ...
Our 2018 Guide to Surviving Toddlers  LifehackerParenting through the toddler years can sometimes feel less like a rewarding experience and more like waking up and going into battle every day. We've written ...
Classroom friendships may offset effects of harsh parenting: Study  The Indian ExpressThe study has found that angry, threatening and highly critical parenting is more likely to result in children with defiant, non-compliant and revengeful behaviour ...
Enduring Cancer While Parenting a Child  Curetoday.comI've been experiencing weakness in my right leg. Specifically, my leg has been giving out when I go down steps, and I've had to catch myself to keep from falling ...
Parenting: Melatonin may help you sleep. But is it safe for kids?  Charleston Post CourierAn estimated 419000 U.S. children now use melatonin, almost five times as many as in 2007.
Parenting tips for dealing with holiday stress  KSTU FOX 13 Salt Lake CityThe holidays can be a magical time with great food, favorite movies, fun traditions and decorations. But the holidays are also a busy time that can be stressful ...
Parenting By Nature more than just child's play  BarrieTodayParenting By Nature is located on Cedar Pointe Drive.
Babytalk: Parenting for Legends - Babytalk  ABC NewsAre we spending too much time worrying not enough time enjoying how wonderful it is to be a parent? Shannon Kelly White has 'Parenting for Legends' to help ...
Strategies for Parenting Kids Who Have Anxiety  CBC.caWhen we are anxious it's not that something is wrong with us. We just need to learn to understand and manage it better. Here are strategies that can help.

The Safest Stuffed Toys for the Kids on your Gift List

Although it's hard to say when the first stuffed dogs... Read More

From Good to GREAT: Secrets On Becoming A Better Dad

While most fathers aspire to become the best Dads they... Read More

Defrazzle with Hug Therapy

"Hugging is healthy: it helps the body's immunity system, it... Read More

Motivation - The Key to Your Childs Educational Success

For the first year or two of life outside the... Read More

SMUT Spelled Backwards is TUMS

Why are more people, especially parents not outraged?I call it... Read More

Child Abuse - Survey & Comments

Beyond cases reported to authorities, little knowledge exists on the... Read More

Where Is Your Homework, Lisa?

Is Homework Really That Important?Dear Friends,I no longer teach in... Read More

Small Children, Languages and Myths

Our children are growing up bilingual in the French part... Read More

Whats in a Name?

My cousin boasts five names and I confess that when... Read More

Diapers: Do You Choose Disposable Or Reusable?

Diapers..Changing a dirty diaper is not the best part of... Read More

Are You Raising an Emotionally Intelligent Child?

Although many parents are concerned with our children's intelligence quotient... Read More

Using Diet, Counseling, and Attend to Overcome ADHD

When it comes to the treatment of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity... Read More

Being A Mum - It?s About Them And Not About You!

So you want to be a mum? Every time you... Read More

Toilet Terrors And Other Potty Training Fears

Potty training fears, often called toilet terrors, are common among... Read More

The ADD Child: Challenging Parents, Teachers and Friends

The ADD child exhibits a series of behaviors that are... Read More

Pay Attention! Its Your Most Important Job

Anyone can become a parent; there are no tests or... Read More

How Fathers Can Step Up to Fathering

When our oldest son was 2, my wife went out... Read More

ADHD Treatment: Strategy and Philosophy

If your child or teen has been diagnosed with Attention... Read More

Who Will Be Their Guardian?

If you are like most people today, you do not... Read More

Parents Dealing with Worry and Fear

Dear Vijay,I worry about not being a good parent. My... Read More

Successful Treatment Planning for Attention Deficit Disorder - ADD ADHD

O.K. So now you have taken the step of having... Read More

7 Ways to Survive the Start of the School Year

It happens every year. Just when you are settled in... Read More

Top Seven Tips for Back-to-School Success

Parents play a critical role in their child's success. These... Read More

How to Stop Bad Behavior Before it Starts

Coping with a child's bad behavior, perhaps more than any... Read More

The Disadvantages of Home Schooling

"Home Schooling ? Look Before You Leap"Are you considering home... Read More