Dorothy Dunn and Primitive Art

The artist's of tribes of the Great Plains left their paper trail for centuries on rocks, cave walls, and buffalo robes and other animal skins. After contact with the white man the Native American artists began to use paper from the ledger books that traders used for record keeping, thus the term "ledger art".

The drawings were characteristic of the style that had persisted for centuries and culminated with the end of the proto-modern era of the Native American art movement.

It was at the end of this era and the beginning of the Modernistic era of the movement that Dorothy Dunn was teaching at the Santa Fe school. During her tenure she encouraged her students to continue the traditions of their predecessors in the "flat", or "primitive" art style. Here one can cite Dunn's unique concept of "primitive", and even more so her concept of "primitive art".

Anthropologists use the term "primitive" as a general category to describe cultures which had not achieved a certain standard (define modernity). For Dunn, a primitive was not a certain type of culture, but described individuals and objects indigenous to any, every, culture. The primitive subject was that gifted individual, or "seer" whom was able to discern the primitive objects relevant to their culture. These objects were also "primitives", and represented the signs, icons, or symbols of a culture. Thus, for Dunn, "primitive art" was the one to one relationship between the seer and the perceived set of primitive objects of their culture. Primitive was not a certain type of culture, but a certain set of variables occurring in every culture, and primitive art was an event that portrayed the values, or what was of importance in that culture. Thus, Dunn encouraged her students to carry on the tradition into the Modernist era.

Dorothy Dunn's concept of primitive art yields a definition that adequately depicts the problems and ambiguities in the usage of the term "primitive." She agrees with Boas' observation that in the broadest sense, every age has its primitives, its own interpreters and seers, and the assignment of the term primitive to these individuals is relative to the point of view based upon the knowledge of the observer. At the same time, she also cites Ralph Linton who denounces the commonly accepted connotation of the term "primitive" as assigning all primitives to the "childhood of art," but she seems to differ essentially from Linton's assertion that the "primitive" in "primitive art" is a relative term. Relational perhaps, but relative only in the sense that each culture defines its primitives according to its own set of values. The relational aspect is that primitive art occurs in every culture as an event between the seers, and that set of symbols, signs or designs which are iconic to that particular culture as its own set of primitives. The relationship is complex and is manifest in every society. This relationship defines the absolute in "primitive art." She summarizes this position in the statement that "Primitive is a relational term, conditioned by time and place, yet maintaining constant universal elements pertaining to frontiers."

Dunn notes that "Indian painting is the first art in history to have sprung, full-fledged, from the primitive into the contemporary world at a time when it was peculiarly compatible with both. Although it has won recognition as modern art, a consideration of some facts and assumptions in regard to primitive art may evaluate certain qualities of modern Indian painting which place it in a position of being old and new, primitive and contemporary." The reference to an absolute in primitive art is evident here, even though for the sake of communication she has to stumble over the common usage of the term "primitive" which she is trying to minimize.

In this regard Dunn states that the term "primitive art" calls for qualification. The qualification that Dunn employs is one that synthesizes the contrast between a diachronic and synchronic perspective of the term. In her usage of such terms as "time and place" and "frontiers" in contrasting the relative and universal aspects of primitive art she is indeed searching for a definition that would satisfy Fabian's demand for "allochronic determinations." If one were to isolate all instances of "time and place" diachronically (in linear, historical or temporal sequence) and apply them laterally, across cultural lines and the boundaries of possible worlds synchronically, and then abstract an intensive, characteristic notion of primitive as a universal concept, then one could have a definition that could be used comparatively at any given time and place, i.e. satisfying Fabian's demand for coevalence in discourse, and overcome any ethnocentricity a contemporary culture may have in its assessments and analysis of an object culture under study which lies at its frontier and depicts a different time and place.

The need for such qualification is summarized by Dunn in stating that "Anthropologists question certain implications of the expression" (primitive art) where a "consideration of tolerance" in the matter of "other civilizations" and "our own" may be comparatively based upon technical and material advancements, but overlook the fact that the lack of such advancements "might allow major emphasis upon esthetic and spiritual value." Here Dunn is to a degree once again segregating the primitive in a unique aspect, as she does in stating that "In primitive society symbolism is a special system through which ideas as images can be conveyed understandably to an individual or group," but her underlying supposition is that in every culture in every age society has its primitives; seers or interpreters who are the gifted individuals that discern and depict this special system of symbols. It is an event, a one to one relationship between the subject as a primitive interpreting the primitive as objectivity, and the event is a primal act.

In this Dunn has designated the interpreter within a culture as one who objectively identifies those elements that are the marks of that culture, and that the act is universal. While every society has its system of symbols, and certain images may be shared by diverse cultures, the same image may have different meanings cross-culturally or even have multi-references within a culture (The Zuni is a prime example). Every culture will iconize the sun and the moon, contrast the night with the day. The triangle has a range of meanings distinct in cultures as close as the Hopi and the Arapaho, or as diverse as its interpretation by the Western economist (The Greek letter Delta, signifying change). Yet, the act of the interpreter translating their culture's symbols into a communicable form is the absolute, universal, primitive act.

In this sense of the term "primitive" one is no longer referring to a category, or a term of allochronic discourse denoting temporal distance. It is not a qualifier for an object or culture, but is the object, subject, or act itself. Its sense is the act of the interpretation of symbols establishing a basis for and expediting the conveyance of intersubjective knowledge. Whether it is the interpreter within a culture translating a sign and conveying meaning to another interpreter within the culture, or an interpreter considering the system of symbols as an object language, the notion is that one is not dealing with a thing qualifiable as a primitive, but is identifying the primitive itself, and is what the logicians like to refer to as cross-identifications, or identifications of individuals across the boundaries of possible worlds, resulting in well-defined individuations or the objectivity of individuating functions.

This appears on its face to be actually quite useless. First, there is a set of objects within a culture the meaning of which is peculiar to that culture, and that particularity renders it non-informative for cross-identification with a set of particulars in another culture. The primitive act, conversely, is defined in such broad terms that it appears as nothing more than an abstraction that could not possibly produce any meaningful information. On a positive note, this sense of primitive has eliminated the temporal distancing with is denoted when used as a term of allochronic discourse, seemingly satisfying Fabian's demand for allochronic determinations (coevalance). Execution is problematic however, as the paradox of anthropological discourse displays itself when the term "primitive" is used, as Dunn often does, in the sense of temporal distancing in order to minimize or eliminate that very connotation.

By example, take another term of allochronic discourse that conveys temporal distancing. That term is "savage", or "savagery." Frank Hamilton Cushing used the term numerous times during his tenure as a participant observer at the Zuni Pueblo from 1879-1884 when reporting to his colleagues and superiors, and in various publications. In our own time he has been criticized for this as "wrong-headed" and "wrong-hearted." I hesitate to call these remarks wrong-headed or wrong-hearted, but in the very least they are incorrect, and any ethnologist/anthropologist worth their weight in salt should realize this. To summarize Fabian: Anthropological discourse about the "primitive" or the "savage" is not about people in the real world, at least not directly. First and immediately, it is about the primitive or the savage as an internal referent of a discourse or as a scientifically constituted object of a discipline. One must not confuse the logical content of a scientific language and the real world. That is, while temporal distancing creates its object for the anthropologist the synchronic of discourse projects its referent atemporally. In other words, Cushing was a scientist of the Victorian era using the scientific language of his time in order to communicate effectively with his colleagues, superiors, and general media audience. Communicative competence and valuing sociality guarantees its rationality and objectivity. As long as anthropological discourse does not confuse its own logical content with the real world then rationality is not violated by deviant utterances and the normative content of the discipline is maintained, thereby attaining rationality and objectivity through conformity.

The terms "primitive" and "savage" do pose differences, however, and is likely the reason, though not a justification for, the criticisms posed against Cushing for the use of the term. As Fabian points out in regard to the term "savage", "no amount of nominalist technicality can purge the term of its moral, aesthetic, and political connotations." It cannot be reduced to universal data.

"Primitive," on the other hand, is quite conducive to universalization. As Dunn notes, in an Indian society, there are no artists. As a medium for expression anyone may be a "creative participant in some capacity", and as such the groundwork for an inclusive base for interpretation of a communicable set of symbols is laid, providing an ontological basis of rationality. That is, the former abstract concept of primitive art as a primitive act has been provided with content. This should, to a reasonable degree, satisfy the ontologist and anthropologist alike. In the ontological sense rationality is viewed as "perspective- taking" and does not require objectivity. Objectivity requires agreement, or intersubjective validation through public reciprocal intentions, where the objectivity of claims is tied to their communicability. Objectivity becomes a "personal accomplishment" (Willard) and belongs to the anthropological sense of rationality as a social fact where forms of communication are used to express approval of someone's actions (aesthetic appreciation).

Quoting Alice Corbin Henderson, Dunn states that in an Indian society, art is "possessed in common" and "totally lacking in individualistic concept." Thus, objectivity is enjoined with intentionality as personal accomplishment without a reference to the individual. This would satisfy a pedagogic sense of rationality in that in an Indian society "the surest way to make a prayer effective is to symbolize the matter prayed for" (Bandelier). If the prayer (the art of rhetoric) was effective, then it was handed down from generation to generation and its success justified its rationality.

Dunn contrasts Indian art and contemporary art in distinguishing "modern" society where the title of the artist may well be deserved with the capacity to impress representatively, whereas to artists of primitive societies "painting does not seek primarily to portray a subject in a given place and time in a more or less representationalist manner, but rather to stress the fundamental qualities of the object or power. It is concerned with the inner functions and meanings rather than the superficial appearance of nature, and it sets forth the essential aspects of a subject?the primitive artist gives right-of-way to the basic elements in his interpretation." Dunn then cites Linton who observed that the "insistence upon accurate naturalistic representation seems childish to the primitive artist who, although he admires technical skill, feels that it is being expended for trivial ends in an amplification of the obvious."

Two worlds, side by side. The Indian artist may say of the contemporary artist that they are in forgetfulness of their origins, and the contemporary artist may refer to a child like quality of the Indian's painting. Nonetheless, to Dorothy Dunn they are both primitive art, or better said, a primitive act, and both have their reason for being. "Each aspect which characterizes Indian painting as a primitive art has its own reason for being. Likewise, certain of these same features qualify Indian painting as modern. This seeming paradox may well be in the fact that international painting, for reasons of its own, increasingly evolves forms and styles, even concepts, not unlike those long and deeply developed by Indian artists."

And so it was that Dorothy Dunn followed her inclinations towards the "primitive" and encouraged her students at the Santa Fe school to preserve the authenticity of their heritage through long established modes of interpreting the primitives.

REFERENCES:

Dunn, Dorothy. American Indian Painting of the Southwest and Plain'sArea. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico, 1968.

Fabian, Johannes. Time and the Other: How Anthropology Makes Its Object. NY: Columbia University Press, 1983.

Hintikka, Jaakko. "The Semantics of Modal Notions and the Indeterminacy of Ontology". Synthese. 21: 408-424, 1970.

Willard, Charles. A Theory of Argumentation. Tuscaloosa and London: University of Alabama Press, 1989.

Chet Staley
Copyright 2005
amerindianarts.us
All Rights Reserved

In The News:

What Is Philosophy?  Economic and Political WeeklyA story about making the obvious a bit more obvious reveals the purpose of philosophy.
The History of Philosophy by AC Grayling review — updating Bertrand Russell for the 21st century  The TimesPhilosophers have always been an absent-minded lot. Thales of Miletus (625-545BC), the “Father of Philosophy”, was said to have been walking along gazing ...
Why Philosophy is Crucial to Understanding Theology  National Catholic RegisterA basic understanding of philosophy is needed in order to really understand theology. This may sound like a terrifying prospect, especially if you have ever had ...
Toronto Hires Two in Indian Philosophy  Daily NousThe University of Toronto Department of Philosophy has just hired two scholars who specialize in Indian philosophy: Jonardon Ganeri, currently professor of ...
Flourishing with Controversy: How Philosophy of Race Does It  Daily NousOne of the popular narratives about higher education is that the discussion of and disagreement over controversial ideas is imperiled, owing to the dominance of ...
REGINALD MJ ODUOR - The Contribution of African Philosophy to Conceptual Decolonisation: A Reply to Sanya Osha  The ElephantIn “Conceptual Decolonisation: Kwasi Wiredu's Disruption of Philosophy”, published in The Elephant on 25th April 2019, Sanya Osha argues that while the ...
Online Philosophy Resources Weekly Update  Daily NousHere's the weekly report on new entries in online philosophical resources and new reviews of philosophy books. Below is a list of recent updates, if there have ...
5 ways to live more sattva, the Ayurvedic lifestyle philosophy  Evening StandardIf Hygge is natural comfort and cosiness, then sattva is the natural goodness at the heart of life. Here, co-authors of SATTVA: The Ayurvedic Way to Live Well ...
Trans Women and Philosophy: Learning from Recent Events  Daily NousI am a trans woman and a philosophy grad student, and I have decided to leave the discipline and seek a non-academic job because of transphobia in the ...
Philosophy in a nutshell  LivemintWe know more about philosophy than we think we do. We come across Socratic thought in mindfulness meditation apps; we grapple with the philosophy of ...
Philosophers On the Ethics and Politics of Abortion  Daily NousThis year, nine U.S. states have passed legislation that bans early abortions in an attempt to provoke a challenge to the abortion rights protected by the 1973 ...
Why philosophy should be a carnival, not a museum  ProspectHistories of philosophy are the first thing recommended to newcomers to the discipline. As Jonathan Rée writes in his latest book, without them “no philosophical ...
Witcraft by Jonathan Rée and The History of Philosophy by AC Grayling review – head to head philosophy  The GuardianNot many histories of philosophy begin with Hamlet. Jonathan Rée, however, starts his new book in this unconventional way, largely because he is bored by ...
Repugnant conclusion: we should add more people to Earth’s population  Vox.comIf life is good, are we morally obligated to create more of it? Philosopher Torbjörn Tännsjö says yes.
Rihanna’s Work/Life Balance Philosophy Endorsed By… Donald Trump?  MTV.comPresident Donald Trump is notoriously online: It's there his constituents (and sometimes, his administration) has learned about everything from announcing ...
Witcraft by Jonathan Rée — undogmatic account of English philosophy  Financial TimesA tale of thinkers who put 'common humanity at the centre of the philosophical stage'
Lionesses lean into Phil Neville’s gruelling new England philosophy  The GuardianPhil Neville's England players can see the bigger Women's World Cup picture beyond his demanding, ball-monopolising tactics.
Reading Philosophy: Observations & Advice  Daily NousI didn't know that there is a field of study that counted as sensible the questions that were always in my head. Even more amazing is that the type of thoughts I ...
Analysis | Why 'Socialism' Is Both a Governing Philosophy and an Offhand Insult  Washington PostSocialism as a governing philosophy, an offhand insult, or both, is stirring politics again. From the U.S to the U.K. to Brazil and beyond, the term is being newly ...
Humanistic philosophy in action  The Jerusalem PostThe true test of Raoul Wallenberg's important legacy.
The philosophy of Dadaji Amiya Roy Chowdhury  Times of IndiaBy Devleena and Amitabha Bhattacharya Since 'Dadaji' Amiya Roy Chowdhury discouraged any cult following, having refused to set up any ashram or ...
Student Philosophers Travel to Greece · News  Keene State CollegeAncient philosophers discovered atoms, defended democracy, and questioned the nature of knowledge. But why should their views matter to us today?
Texas A&M philosophy camp helps students think outside the box  Bryan-College Station EaglePeople throughout the world read the Harry Potter book series and watch the movies, but this year's Texas A&M Philosophy for Children summer camp looked at ...
Life, Philosophy of Guru Nanak Dev discussed  Business StandardThe Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC) Saturday organized a seminar on the "Life And Philosophy of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji" here to spread ...
Winners of the 2019 Canadian Philosophical Association's Book and Essay Prizes  Daily NousThe Canadian Philosophical Association (CPA) last week announced the winners of its 2019 book and essay prizes. The book prize, offered every other year, ...
Joan Callahan (1946-2019)  Daily NousJoan Callahan, professor emerita of philosophy at the University of Kentucky, has died. According to her son, David Crossen, she died yesterday after several ...
Two Philosophers Recognized During Queen's Birthday Honours  Daily NousTwo philosophers were among those recognized by British Queen Elizabeth II during her Birthday Honours this year. Sarah Broadie (University of St. Andrews) ...
New Institute for Philosophy in Tunisia  Daily NousThe Tunis College for Philosophy, a new institute in Tunisia dedicated to philosophical research, academic events, and the promotion of philosophy, opened in ...
Witcraft by Jonathan Rée review: an eccentric history of philosophy's great minds – and wild loons  Telegraph.co.ukJonathan Rée's book begins with the surprising revelation that it is an expanded version, long in the making, of a 1993 essay from Radical Philosophy, a journal ...
Representation at the APA  Daily Nous41 of 45 the APA's officers, or 91.1%, are from research universities. While I understand that research plays a central role in the discipline, this strikes me as ...
Practical philosophy  Deccan HeraldPhilosophy is often considered too esoteric. The fact is that all great philosophical thoughts are indeed profundity concealing immense practical wisdom.
Philosophy Club tackles modern, relevant...  soprissun.comThough the term might conjure images of stale coffee and late-night, candlelit discussions about the writings of Aristotle, Confucius, or Nietzsche, this.
George Will’s Political Philosophy  The New York TimesWill's “The Conservative Sensibility” sums up a lifetime of thinking about politics and culture.
Socrates in Love: the woman behind his philosophy  The B.C. CatholicWhen we think of Socrates, what first comes to mind is his trial and execution. Athens condemned him to death by hemlock in 399 BCE. Its citizens were looking ...
The Philosophy and Politics of Early Abortion in the US  Daily NousThe past months have seen successful legislative efforts in several states to criminalize early abortion. Emboldened by Brett Kavanaugh's appointment to the ...
Visualization of Gender Distribution in Philosophy Research Topics  Daily NousMaximilian Noichl, whose visualizations we've discussed previously (here and here) has produced one depicting the gender distribution in philosophy research ...
Philosophers Among Those Newly Elected to the American Philosophical Society  Daily NousThe American Philosophical Society (APS), the oldest learned society in the United States (“founded in 1743 by Benjamin Franklin for the purpose of 'promoting ...
Concordia Philosophy Issues Statement on Controversial "Bill 21"  Daily NousThe Department of Philosophy at Concordia University has issued a statement opposing “Bill 21: an act respecting the laicity of the State,” also known as ...
French philosopher Michel Serres dies at 88  FRANCE 24The philosopher, writer and academic Michel Serres died on Saturday June 1 at the age of 88.
De Regt Wins 2019 Lakatos Award  Daily NousHenk W. de Regt (VU University Amsterdam), has been named the winner of the 2019 Lakatos Award for his book, Understanding Scientific Understanding ...
You weren't born just to be 'useful,’ Irish president tells students  Big ThinkYoung philosophers don't exist to be useful, Irish president tells crowd at Irish Young Philosophers 2019 awards.
What is Virat Kohli's philosophy of success?  Economic TimesVirat Kohli believes in the simple theory — prepare the best you can to get the best rewards.
Sweden Will Live Or Die By Their Conservative Philosophy  DeadspinThe most famous United States result since the win in the 2015 World Cup final happened in Brazil in the summer of 2016. It was the Summer Olympics, and ...
For a philosophy of disinvestment  Economic TimesThere are reports of an alternative mechanism being instituted for disinvestment. What is needed is a credible philosophy of disinvestment, relating to strategic ...
How I learned to stop worrying and rediscover the ancient philosophy of Stoicism  SalonThe great insight of the philosophy of Stoicism: Shaping your character is the only thing under your control.
Sen. Bernie Sanders defends democratic socialism, reflecting internal Democratic battle over the party’s philosophy  The Washington PostPresidential candidate Bernie Sanders presented an expansive defense of democratic socialism on Wednesday, amplifying divisions among Democrats that ...
Philosophy talk  Times of MaltaJorge Giro will be discussing self and time through the perspective of Buddhism and modern neuroscience in Philosophy Sharing's talk for the month of June ...
The Increasing Irrelevance of Schools - Freedom Philosophy  Being LibertarianThe totality of human knowledge is so freely available that all of it now fits into a thin box in your pocket. In spite of this, leftists still demand that billions of dollars ...
Assistant Lecturer in Philosophy of Education job with MAYNOOTH UNIVERSITY | 167481  Times Higher Education (THE)Maynooth University is committed to a strategy in which the primary University goals of excellent research and scholarship and outstanding education are ...
Francisco Miró Quesada Cantuarias (1918-2019)  Daily NousFrancisco Miró Quesada Cantuarias, professor emeritus at the University of San Marcos, by some accounts Peru's “leading philosopher” and one of the most ...
Dean Hurley explores life after death on Philosophy of Beyond  FACTDean Hurley, perhaps best known as David Lynch's sound supervisor, has announced the second volume of his ongoing Anthology Resource series.
The Tunisian college of philosophy is born  The Arab WeeklyThe Tunisian academic and cultural communities have welcomed the Tunis College of Philosophy, which was founded to promote philosophy in Tunisia.
Ferdinand questions England manager Southgate’s philosophy  Football ParadiseFormer England captain Rio Ferdinand has questioned whether Gareth Southgate's philosophy will lead the Three Lions to Euro 2020 success.
England vs Switzerland: Three Lions won't abandon philosophy despite Nations League errors says Joe Gomez  The IndependentJoe Gomez insists England cannot abandon their philosophy purely because of the defensive errors that cost them a place in the Nations League final.
Oddballs of English philosophy  Spectator.co.ukOddballs of English philosophy on The Spectator | Charles Kay Ogden once proposed that conversations would be conducted more efficiently if participants ...
Review: Take comedy, add philosophy, shake well  The Mercury NewsBy Ann Hornaday | Washington Post. In 1986 the Quebec filmmaker Denys Arcand made “The Decline of the American Empire,” a talky ensemble comedy ...
Analytic philosophy: the leading brand - The Philosopher's Zone  ABC NewsA quick scan of leading philosophy journals reveals that what passes for philosophy is selectively screened, with analytic philosophy clearly the dominant style.
Global Sikh Council: Sikh body to spread Guru Nanak’s peace philosophy through Geneva meet  The Indian ExpressTo commemorate the 550th birth anniversary of Guru Nanak (1469), the first guru of the Sikhs, World Council of Churches, Geneva, in collaboration with the GSC ...
Big read: Whanganui comedian Ray O'Leary on dark comedy, philosophy and making a living being funny  New Zealand HeraldThere came a point when Ray O'Leary realised it was never going to be quite the right time to give stand up a go. With a masters in philosophy behind him, ...
Philosophers: Consider Signing Amicus Brief on Insanity Defense  Daily NousDoes a state's abolition of the insanity defense comport with fundamental principles of justice and pluralist toleration?” That is the question taken up in an amicus ...
Can philosophy be cool? A Hyde Park debate series revives the art of the late-night dorm rap session  Chicago TribuneA portrait of Night Owls, the philosophy series at University of Chicago that has become a centerpiece of intellectual life in Hyde Park.
The political philosophy of Bangabandhu  Dhaka TribuneFor our generation who witnessed the birth of Bangladesh, it is a daunting task to express in words the unique role played by the Father of the Nation, ...
Philosophy Talk: The Limits of Tolerance  KALWWhat do we do with people with people with whom we radically disagree: tolerate, shun, or persuade?
Raul on his coaching philosophy: There are beautiful ways to win and there are other ways that aren't for  MARCA.comReal Madrid Castilla coach Raul Gonzalez has made clear that his coaching philosophy is not about winning matches at any cost. The Spaniard also...
Letters to the editor Monday: Getting philosophical about philosophy  Savannah Morning NewsGetting philosophical about philosophyI am lamenting the recent death of philosophy. It died upon two occasions.First, it died when upon hearing about the ...
Montreal Fringe: From the mortality of carrots to the philosophy of knives  Montreal GazetteThis year's festival slow dances us into the apocalypse, takes us on a Montreal safari and invites us into an apartment where magic goes hair-raisingly wrong.
Philosophy in the Bookshop – Nigel Warburton in Conversation with Naomi Wolf  Cherwell OnlineNaomi Wolf's new book, Outrages: Sex, Censorship, and the Criminalisation of Love, charts the development of censorship around sexual deviancy and morality ...
President of Ireland Speaks at Youth Philosophy Awards Ceremony  Daily NousToo many policy lobbyists have, often unknowingly, unthinkingly perhaps, accepted a narrow and utilitarian view of… education—one that suggests we exist to ...
Road cycling shoe design philosophy with Giro  SlowtwitchWe interview Eric Horton, Director of Design at Giro, to learn about their design philosophy and tech in cycling shoes.
Noah Webster's Dictionary-Reform Philosophy  The AtlanticIn 1789, Noah Webster called on the newly independent United States to claim its own national version of the English language.
Books interview with AC Grayling: “A great philosophical mind is one that belongs to a childish heart – always curious, always open”  BBC History MagazineMaster of the New College of the Humanities in London, Professor AC Grayling is a philosopher who has written and edited more than 30 books, including The ...
In teaching philosophy to preschoolers, college students aim to mend breakdown in civic discourse  Education DiveErik Kenyon is director of student and faculty engagement at the Hamilton Holt School at Rollins College. Sharon Carnahan is a professor of psychology at ...
Australasian Journal of Philosophy Reaches Out to Historians  Daily NousThe Australasian Journal of Philosophy (AJP) has been making efforts to publish more history of philosophy. The journal has long focused on contemporary ...
Adrian Bevington outlines Middlesbrough's plan for a 'clear philosophy' under Jonathan Woodgate  Gazette LiveThe head of recruitment spoke about the club's commitment to the Academy and a style of football.
Here's how Bruno Cucinelli (and his $5,000 blazers) became Silicon Valley billionaires' favorite designer  CNBCSilicon Valley, once known for tech workers donning hoodies and jeans, is starting to add more luxury fashion items to its casual aesthetic. Italian designer ...
The Unordinary Wine Philosophy of Bradford Taylor  Bon AppetitIf you're way more into natural wine now than you were a few years ago, you might have the owner of Ordinaire in Oakland and Diversey Wine in Chicago to ...
Legendary architect Hafeez Contractor shares his vision and philosophy  India TodayLegendary architect, Hafeez Contractor's career spans more than three decades with over 75 national and international awards for excellence in architecture.
Column: Footwork and new philosophy could push Josh Allen in Year 2  Buffalo NewsThe young quarterback's attitude is positive and refreshing, perhaps a reason why so many Bills fans have taken to him.
SUU hosts free philosophy summer camp for middle school, high school students  St George NewsST. GEORGE — Southern Utah University will host the fourth annual Utah Lyceum from June 11-15. Every summer since 2015, SUU has planned, organized ...
100 Greatest Philosophical Spoilers (guest post by Richard Greene)  Daily NousThe less a work has to offer us besides information about happens in the end, the more reason we have to avoid spoilers for it. When it comes to philosophy, ...
Lifetime achievement award for Chinese philosophy scholar  UH System Current NewsRoger T. Ames received the 2019 John Dewey Society Outstanding Lifetime Achievement Award for his distinguished career as a scholar-practitioner, working ...
New Wind Instrument Philosophy Introduces Novel Possibilities for Musical Performance  Rensselaer Polytechnic InstituteAfter eight years of work, Jonas Braasch, professor of architecture and arts at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, has figured out how to play a soprano saxophone ...
Senior CPC official calls for advances in philosophy, social sciences - Xinhua | English.news.cn  XinhuaBEIJING, May 23 (Xinhua) -- A senior Communist Party of China (CPC) official Thursday called for efforts to achieve new advances in the development of ...
Greco from Saint Louis to Georgetown  Daily NousJohn Greco, currently the Leonard and Elizabeth Eslick Chair in Philosophy at Saint Louis University, will be moving to the Department of Philosophy at ...
Marcano living up to San Diego's philosophy | TinCaps | Journal Gazette  Fort Wayne Journal GazetteThe San Diego Padres have an offensive philosophy in the organization: Get on base any way possible. TinCaps infielder Tucupita Marcano, the Padres' ...
Gregg Williams brings fresh philosophy to Jets: 'Culture beats strategy'  Jets WireNew York Jets defensive coordinator Gregg Williams is bringing a *fresh* philosophy and coaching style to the Jets in 2019.
The Life and Work of Radical Philosopher Herbert Marcuse  WortfmWORT 89.9 FM, Isthmus, The Progressive magazine, and the Madison Public Library are sponsoring a candidate forum for all … [Read More...] ...
Philosophy di Lorenzo Serafini Resort 2020 Collection  Vogue.comLorenzo Serafini's mood board for Resort is plastered with 1980s pictures of Princesses Caroline and Stephanie of Monaco. It's a complete coincidence that ...
Euro 2020 qualifiers: Leonardo Bonucci backs Roberto Mancini's youth-first philosophy since taking Italy job  GoalThe former Man City boss has injected a *fresh* lease of life into the national team with his commitment to youth, according to the Juventus defender. Leonardo ...
Students Learn Philosophy of Philanthropy  SUNY Cortland News05/21/2019. Thirty-three SUNY Cortland undergraduates recently decided to give away $10,000 in real money to four Cortland non-profit organizations they ...
New Novel "Chemical Philosophy" by James Patrick Tobin Explores the…  Virtual-Strategy MagazineNEWBURY PARK, Calif. (PRWEB) June 10, 2019 James Patrick Tobin, a US Navy veteran and an avid participant in the theater, has completed his new book ...
Philosophy, doodles turned to abstract art  Deccan HeraldJyotsna Malhotra and Pooja Bhatt are among the many city artists showcasing their works at Cobalt Forum of Art and Music's group exhibition 'Artistic Diversity'.
Allen West: Socialism Is Philosophy of Control Freaks  CNSNews.comRetired Lieutenant Colonel in the United States Army Allen West (Screenshot)
What Can You Do With a Philosophy Degree?  Hartwick CollegeHartwick College Professor of Philosophy Dr. Stefanie Rocknak will be presented the Alex J. Ettl Grant from the National Sculpture Society this weekend.
Chicago Bulls: PJ Washington is a perfect fit for Jim Boylen’s philosophy  FanSidedIf the front office wants to make a move for an extra first-round pick, PJ Washington is a perfect prospect to add into this turning-the-corner rebuild.
Crash Course: Metaphysics & Epistemology of Race  Daily NousWelcome to another installment of the “Crash Course” series, this time on the metaphysics and epistemology of race. As with other installments in the crash ...
Tottenham should not throw philosophy ‘in the bin’ after Champions League defeat, says Lloris  Irish ExaminerHugo Lloris does not think Tottenham need to abandon their philosophy just because they lost the Champions League final. Spurs' biggest ever match ended in ...
Creativity At The Core Of Business Results: Q&A With ABI U.S. CMO Marcel Marcondes  ForbesOn the occasion of the 2019 Cannes Creativity Festival, I sat down with Anheuser-Busch InBev CMO, Marcel Marcondes, for his thoughts on creativity and ...
Why philosophers should take seriously the filthy and unclean  AlterNetby Thomas White Philosophy traditionally has been about 'higher' questions: what is knowledge? What is the meaning of justice? What is the nature of ultimate ...
Marcus Publishes Article on “Philosophical Method” - News  Hamilton College NewsAn article titled “Philosophical Method,” by Associate Professor of Philosophy Russell Marcus, appears in the current issue of The Philosopher's Magazine.

Platos Atlantis: Fact, Fiction or Prophecy?

Atlantis is often described as paranormal or mythical, but is... Read More

Extra Terrestrial Genetic Defect Myth

There is a large contingency of people who believe in... Read More

Nature of Visual Representation

Nature is often called "red in tooth and claw", this... Read More

Phony-Baloney Detection Lesson #2

Appeals to AuthorityListen to this quote by a guy I... Read More

Archetypes

DEPTH PSYCHOLOGY (ARCHETYPES): - "All material bodies are condensations of... Read More

Viewing from Anothers Perspective Sets Humans Apart?

Recently I discussed what sets humans apart from other animals... Read More

All That We Are... Are Labels

Within the confines of the known universe, a madness is... Read More

Culture and Knowledge

In eastern Cultures the passing of thought was considered valuable,... Read More

Joseph Bonaparte and The New Jersey Devil

Joseph Bonaparte and The New Jersey Devil:"Commodore Stephen Decatur was... Read More

Simple Words

The words, the thoughts, the processes go on and on.As... Read More

The Galileo Conspiracy: 5 Questions Your Science Professors Hope You Never Ask

As a young lad, I took on my first scientific... Read More

The Tree of Life and Allies

There are names in many languages and cultures or even... Read More

Darius and the US Postal Service

DARIUS: - Coins bearing his visage are found in the... Read More

Conspiracy Theorist

Rudyard Kipling on Masonry: "the closest thing to a religion... Read More

The Knowledge Filter

"[I often get] the feeling that the very concept of... Read More

Stranded Notions: Time And Philosophy Of The Individual

As I look back now, a long time seems to... Read More

Its Not Your Fault!

Saying goodbye is easy for the traveler. I am a... Read More

Youre Wrong

Isn't it amazing how often you're wrong? I mean that... Read More

The Concept of the Sublime in Eighteenth Century Philosophy

The development of the concept of the sublime as an... Read More

Evolution and Exorcisms

EVOLUTION: More surprising to me as I consider where my... Read More

Emerson and Plato

You might be surprised by the breadth and reach of... Read More

The Keltoi

The CIA's motto is "You shall know the truth and... Read More

Why Im Glad Im Not a Minority Writer

I'll admit that I used to be jealous of my... Read More

Raindrops Keep Falling On My Web

I really believe there are things nobody would see if... Read More

William Butler Yeats

There are adepts outside of what is called alchemy who... Read More