Dorothy Dunn and Primitive Art

The artist's of tribes of the Great Plains left their paper trail for centuries on rocks, cave walls, and buffalo robes and other animal skins. After contact with the white man the Native American artists began to use paper from the ledger books that traders used for record keeping, thus the term "ledger art".

The drawings were characteristic of the style that had persisted for centuries and culminated with the end of the proto-modern era of the Native American art movement.

It was at the end of this era and the beginning of the Modernistic era of the movement that Dorothy Dunn was teaching at the Santa Fe school. During her tenure she encouraged her students to continue the traditions of their predecessors in the "flat", or "primitive" art style. Here one can cite Dunn's unique concept of "primitive", and even more so her concept of "primitive art".

Anthropologists use the term "primitive" as a general category to describe cultures which had not achieved a certain standard (define modernity). For Dunn, a primitive was not a certain type of culture, but described individuals and objects indigenous to any, every, culture. The primitive subject was that gifted individual, or "seer" whom was able to discern the primitive objects relevant to their culture. These objects were also "primitives", and represented the signs, icons, or symbols of a culture. Thus, for Dunn, "primitive art" was the one to one relationship between the seer and the perceived set of primitive objects of their culture. Primitive was not a certain type of culture, but a certain set of variables occurring in every culture, and primitive art was an event that portrayed the values, or what was of importance in that culture. Thus, Dunn encouraged her students to carry on the tradition into the Modernist era.

Dorothy Dunn's concept of primitive art yields a definition that adequately depicts the problems and ambiguities in the usage of the term "primitive." She agrees with Boas' observation that in the broadest sense, every age has its primitives, its own interpreters and seers, and the assignment of the term primitive to these individuals is relative to the point of view based upon the knowledge of the observer. At the same time, she also cites Ralph Linton who denounces the commonly accepted connotation of the term "primitive" as assigning all primitives to the "childhood of art," but she seems to differ essentially from Linton's assertion that the "primitive" in "primitive art" is a relative term. Relational perhaps, but relative only in the sense that each culture defines its primitives according to its own set of values. The relational aspect is that primitive art occurs in every culture as an event between the seers, and that set of symbols, signs or designs which are iconic to that particular culture as its own set of primitives. The relationship is complex and is manifest in every society. This relationship defines the absolute in "primitive art." She summarizes this position in the statement that "Primitive is a relational term, conditioned by time and place, yet maintaining constant universal elements pertaining to frontiers."

Dunn notes that "Indian painting is the first art in history to have sprung, full-fledged, from the primitive into the contemporary world at a time when it was peculiarly compatible with both. Although it has won recognition as modern art, a consideration of some facts and assumptions in regard to primitive art may evaluate certain qualities of modern Indian painting which place it in a position of being old and new, primitive and contemporary." The reference to an absolute in primitive art is evident here, even though for the sake of communication she has to stumble over the common usage of the term "primitive" which she is trying to minimize.

In this regard Dunn states that the term "primitive art" calls for qualification. The qualification that Dunn employs is one that synthesizes the contrast between a diachronic and synchronic perspective of the term. In her usage of such terms as "time and place" and "frontiers" in contrasting the relative and universal aspects of primitive art she is indeed searching for a definition that would satisfy Fabian's demand for "allochronic determinations." If one were to isolate all instances of "time and place" diachronically (in linear, historical or temporal sequence) and apply them laterally, across cultural lines and the boundaries of possible worlds synchronically, and then abstract an intensive, characteristic notion of primitive as a universal concept, then one could have a definition that could be used comparatively at any given time and place, i.e. satisfying Fabian's demand for coevalence in discourse, and overcome any ethnocentricity a contemporary culture may have in its assessments and analysis of an object culture under study which lies at its frontier and depicts a different time and place.

The need for such qualification is summarized by Dunn in stating that "Anthropologists question certain implications of the expression" (primitive art) where a "consideration of tolerance" in the matter of "other civilizations" and "our own" may be comparatively based upon technical and material advancements, but overlook the fact that the lack of such advancements "might allow major emphasis upon esthetic and spiritual value." Here Dunn is to a degree once again segregating the primitive in a unique aspect, as she does in stating that "In primitive society symbolism is a special system through which ideas as images can be conveyed understandably to an individual or group," but her underlying supposition is that in every culture in every age society has its primitives; seers or interpreters who are the gifted individuals that discern and depict this special system of symbols. It is an event, a one to one relationship between the subject as a primitive interpreting the primitive as objectivity, and the event is a primal act.

In this Dunn has designated the interpreter within a culture as one who objectively identifies those elements that are the marks of that culture, and that the act is universal. While every society has its system of symbols, and certain images may be shared by diverse cultures, the same image may have different meanings cross-culturally or even have multi-references within a culture (The Zuni is a prime example). Every culture will iconize the sun and the moon, contrast the night with the day. The triangle has a range of meanings distinct in cultures as close as the Hopi and the Arapaho, or as diverse as its interpretation by the Western economist (The Greek letter Delta, signifying change). Yet, the act of the interpreter translating their culture's symbols into a communicable form is the absolute, universal, primitive act.

In this sense of the term "primitive" one is no longer referring to a category, or a term of allochronic discourse denoting temporal distance. It is not a qualifier for an object or culture, but is the object, subject, or act itself. Its sense is the act of the interpretation of symbols establishing a basis for and expediting the conveyance of intersubjective knowledge. Whether it is the interpreter within a culture translating a sign and conveying meaning to another interpreter within the culture, or an interpreter considering the system of symbols as an object language, the notion is that one is not dealing with a thing qualifiable as a primitive, but is identifying the primitive itself, and is what the logicians like to refer to as cross-identifications, or identifications of individuals across the boundaries of possible worlds, resulting in well-defined individuations or the objectivity of individuating functions.

This appears on its face to be actually quite useless. First, there is a set of objects within a culture the meaning of which is peculiar to that culture, and that particularity renders it non-informative for cross-identification with a set of particulars in another culture. The primitive act, conversely, is defined in such broad terms that it appears as nothing more than an abstraction that could not possibly produce any meaningful information. On a positive note, this sense of primitive has eliminated the temporal distancing with is denoted when used as a term of allochronic discourse, seemingly satisfying Fabian's demand for allochronic determinations (coevalance). Execution is problematic however, as the paradox of anthropological discourse displays itself when the term "primitive" is used, as Dunn often does, in the sense of temporal distancing in order to minimize or eliminate that very connotation.

By example, take another term of allochronic discourse that conveys temporal distancing. That term is "savage", or "savagery." Frank Hamilton Cushing used the term numerous times during his tenure as a participant observer at the Zuni Pueblo from 1879-1884 when reporting to his colleagues and superiors, and in various publications. In our own time he has been criticized for this as "wrong-headed" and "wrong-hearted." I hesitate to call these remarks wrong-headed or wrong-hearted, but in the very least they are incorrect, and any ethnologist/anthropologist worth their weight in salt should realize this. To summarize Fabian: Anthropological discourse about the "primitive" or the "savage" is not about people in the real world, at least not directly. First and immediately, it is about the primitive or the savage as an internal referent of a discourse or as a scientifically constituted object of a discipline. One must not confuse the logical content of a scientific language and the real world. That is, while temporal distancing creates its object for the anthropologist the synchronic of discourse projects its referent atemporally. In other words, Cushing was a scientist of the Victorian era using the scientific language of his time in order to communicate effectively with his colleagues, superiors, and general media audience. Communicative competence and valuing sociality guarantees its rationality and objectivity. As long as anthropological discourse does not confuse its own logical content with the real world then rationality is not violated by deviant utterances and the normative content of the discipline is maintained, thereby attaining rationality and objectivity through conformity.

The terms "primitive" and "savage" do pose differences, however, and is likely the reason, though not a justification for, the criticisms posed against Cushing for the use of the term. As Fabian points out in regard to the term "savage", "no amount of nominalist technicality can purge the term of its moral, aesthetic, and political connotations." It cannot be reduced to universal data.

"Primitive," on the other hand, is quite conducive to universalization. As Dunn notes, in an Indian society, there are no artists. As a medium for expression anyone may be a "creative participant in some capacity", and as such the groundwork for an inclusive base for interpretation of a communicable set of symbols is laid, providing an ontological basis of rationality. That is, the former abstract concept of primitive art as a primitive act has been provided with content. This should, to a reasonable degree, satisfy the ontologist and anthropologist alike. In the ontological sense rationality is viewed as "perspective- taking" and does not require objectivity. Objectivity requires agreement, or intersubjective validation through public reciprocal intentions, where the objectivity of claims is tied to their communicability. Objectivity becomes a "personal accomplishment" (Willard) and belongs to the anthropological sense of rationality as a social fact where forms of communication are used to express approval of someone's actions (aesthetic appreciation).

Quoting Alice Corbin Henderson, Dunn states that in an Indian society, art is "possessed in common" and "totally lacking in individualistic concept." Thus, objectivity is enjoined with intentionality as personal accomplishment without a reference to the individual. This would satisfy a pedagogic sense of rationality in that in an Indian society "the surest way to make a prayer effective is to symbolize the matter prayed for" (Bandelier). If the prayer (the art of rhetoric) was effective, then it was handed down from generation to generation and its success justified its rationality.

Dunn contrasts Indian art and contemporary art in distinguishing "modern" society where the title of the artist may well be deserved with the capacity to impress representatively, whereas to artists of primitive societies "painting does not seek primarily to portray a subject in a given place and time in a more or less representationalist manner, but rather to stress the fundamental qualities of the object or power. It is concerned with the inner functions and meanings rather than the superficial appearance of nature, and it sets forth the essential aspects of a subject?the primitive artist gives right-of-way to the basic elements in his interpretation." Dunn then cites Linton who observed that the "insistence upon accurate naturalistic representation seems childish to the primitive artist who, although he admires technical skill, feels that it is being expended for trivial ends in an amplification of the obvious."

Two worlds, side by side. The Indian artist may say of the contemporary artist that they are in forgetfulness of their origins, and the contemporary artist may refer to a child like quality of the Indian's painting. Nonetheless, to Dorothy Dunn they are both primitive art, or better said, a primitive act, and both have their reason for being. "Each aspect which characterizes Indian painting as a primitive art has its own reason for being. Likewise, certain of these same features qualify Indian painting as modern. This seeming paradox may well be in the fact that international painting, for reasons of its own, increasingly evolves forms and styles, even concepts, not unlike those long and deeply developed by Indian artists."

And so it was that Dorothy Dunn followed her inclinations towards the "primitive" and encouraged her students at the Santa Fe school to preserve the authenticity of their heritage through long established modes of interpreting the primitives.

REFERENCES:

Dunn, Dorothy. American Indian Painting of the Southwest and Plain'sArea. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico, 1968.

Fabian, Johannes. Time and the Other: How Anthropology Makes Its Object. NY: Columbia University Press, 1983.

Hintikka, Jaakko. "The Semantics of Modal Notions and the Indeterminacy of Ontology". Synthese. 21: 408-424, 1970.

Willard, Charles. A Theory of Argumentation. Tuscaloosa and London: University of Alabama Press, 1989.

Chet Staley
Copyright 2005
amerindianarts.us
All Rights Reserved

In The News:

Philosophy: The One Subject Harvard Should Require | Opinion  Harvard CrimsonThe things I learn in class at Harvard aren't so important in the grand scheme of things. Sure, Math 55 is a worthwhile experience — but if you haven't heard of ...
Lone Peak advances to semifinals with philosophy of 'nothing easy' for either team  Deseret NewsLone Peak earned a 65-40 win over Riverton in the 6A quarterfinals Wednesday. Maddy Eaton led all scorers with 26 points, while Abby Conlee and Makale ...
Philosopher of the Month: Plato [infographic]  OUPblogThis February, the OUP Philosophy team honours Plato (c. 427–347 BCE) as their Philosopher of the Month. Together with Socrates and Aristotle, Plato is ...
Philosophy: What exactly is a black hole?  Science DailyWhat is a black hole? A philosopher shows that physicists use different definitions of the concept, depending on their own particular fields of interest.
What We Are Reading Today: The Art of Philosophy by Susanna Berger  Arab NewsDelving into the intersections between artistic images and philosophical knowledge in Europe from the late 16th to the early 18th centuries, The Art of ...
Philosophy and sustainability science collide  Arizona State UniversityC. Tyler DesRoches is an assistant professor of philosophy in the School of Historical, Philosophical and Religious Studies and assistant professor of ...
Sarriball, a philosophy now critiqued in the intense colloquial style  The GuardianIn today's Fiver: Chelsea, the latest wheeze in Spain and Newport memories.
Philosophy Club: From News Headlines to Kanye West  Skidmore NewsCollege may be a time for learning big ideas, but it is also a time to interrogate them. And what better place to do so than Skidmore's Philosophy Club?
Marie Kondo's organizing philosophy and its connection to mental health - TMC News  Texas Medical Center NewsSince Marie Kondo's 2011 publication of The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up, which landed on the New York Times best-seller list after its 2014 publication ...
Jerome Smith remembers questioning the Civil Rights Movement's non-violent philosophy  WWLTV.comAs more activists were attacked and murdered, Jerome Smith remembers himself and other people in the movement questioning if non-violence would work in ...
Texas A&M football: New TE coach embraces Jimbo Fisher’s philosophy  Gig 'Em GazetteJimbo Fisher brought his pro style offense and physicality to Texas A&M football, and his new tight ends coach is embracing that 100 percent.
Commentary: The consolation of philosophy  NBC2 NewsOne of the consolations of philosophy, according to Boethius, is to seek happiness in misfortune.
Pine Pienaar's philosophy pays off ... | Pretoria News  Independent OnlinePine Pienaar may have a chequered history with the Bulls but when it comes to talking about his previous stint at the union, avoidance is his preferred method of ...
Solution to terrorism, climate change in Mahatma’s philosophy: PM Modi  The StatesmanPM Modi, who is on a two-day visit to South Korea, unveiled a bust of Mahatma Gandhi at the 134-year-old Yonsei University in Seoul on Thursday.
YDS 'Quadcast' explores how to reconcile religion & philosophy  Yale NewsBy Emily L. Judd. Yale Divinity School Professor John Hare joins the YDS podcast for its February episode, in which he discusses the relationship between ...
The 71st Annual Northwest Philosophy Conference  Pacific UniversityThe Northwest Philosophy Conference is held each fall, attracting philosophers from across the United States and abroad. The primary purpose of this ...
Department of Studies (DoS) in Philosophy, University of Mysore (UoM)  Star of MysoreValedictory of two-day National Seminar on 'The social and ethical dimensions of Gandhian philosophy,' Lakshmisha Tolpadi, Culture – Thinker and writer, ...
Pint-size philosophers  Penn: Office of University CommunicationsBy engaging with Philadelphia elementary students and high school teachers, Penn professor Karen Detlefsen is opening young minds to a new kind of ...
A Philosopher Asked Physicists: 'What is a Black Hole?' - D-brief  Discover MagazinePhysicists from various sub-fields don't agree on what defines a black hole. The disagreements aren't necessarily a bad thing.
Chiellini: Atletico Madrid have a philosophy that is more Italian than Spanish  MARCA.comAhead of Juventus' clash away at the Wanda Metropolitano on Wednesday night against Atletico Madrid, Giorgio Chiellini sat down with MARCA to...
The Japanese philosophy of kaizen offers opportunity for industrial development in Africa  Brookings InstitutionKaizen management training offers a path to productivity growth for African entrepreneurs, particularly those who cannot afford to employ highly-educated and ...
3 philosophers set up a booth on a street corner – here's what people asked  The Conversation - USThree philosophers put up a booth at the entrance to a New York City subway, so people could come to them with questions. They got hit with some real zingers.
A Philosopher Is Trying to Figure out What Black Holes Really Are  FuturismA philosopher wanted to unify the various field-specific definitions physicists have for black holes. He decided that the variety was good for science.
Night of Philosophy events are happening in 65 cities  QuartzThis weekend, French cultural institutes are sponsoring free intellectual rave parties in 65 cities across five continents. The Night of Philosophy and Ideas (La ...
Is 'The Good Place' Philosophy Accurate? - Philosophical Theories Behind NBC's 'The Good Place'  MarieClaire.comWe asked the resident philosophy consultant on 'The Good Place'—which just wrapped up it's third season on NBC—to teach us Ethics 101.
Maurizio Sarri clings to Chelsea job as rejection of philosophy spreads from players to fans  Evening StandardIf Davide Zappacosta is your answer, you probably don't understand the question. Maurizio Sarri's determination to live or die at Chelsea by his 'Sarri-ball' ...
1 Simple Philosophy That Could Revolutionize Your Company's Success  Inc.The reason I love this example is that, when I talk to Kevin, he's just so blunt and honest. He is his own target audience.
In the post-truth world, we need to remember the philosophy of science  New StatesmanFrom climate change to vaccination scares, what non-scientists believe about science is literally a matter of life and death.
What Are Love and Sex? Eight Answers from Philosophy  IAI NewsFor Valentine's Day this year, we/ve compiled a collage of extracts of classic and recent Western post-war philosophy, theory and ideas on sex and love – from ...
Cubs' new pitching philosophy | 02/07/2019  MLB.comMLB.com Cubs reporter Jordan Bastian discusses the new approach the club has taken in its pitching development philosophy.
Valencia boss Marcelino shares his thoughts on Celtic's philosophy ahead of Europa League tie  HITCCeltic take on Valencia in Spain on Thursday as they look to progress to the next round of the Europa League.
The Good-Enough Life  The New York TimesThe desire for greatness can be an obstacle to our own potential.
Philosophy professor analyzes Plato's vision of love and wisdom  UT The Daily TexanExploring the connection between philosophy and love was the central theme of philosophy professor Paul Woodruff's lecture Wednesday that analyzed Plato's ...
Elisabeth Camp of Rutgers University to Give Department of Philosophy 2019 Kraemer Lecture  University of Arkansas NewswireThe Department of Philosophy in the J. William Fulbright College of Arts and Sciences is proud to present the 2019 Kraemer Lecturer, Elisabeth Camp, professor ...
Expert Wealth Advisor Introduces Advanced Life Planning Philosophy for Business Owners  ForbesRocco A. Carriero Releases “Three Cords Approach to Life and Wealth Management for Business Owners” with ForbesBooks NEW YORK (February 1, 2019) ...
A philosopher argues that an AI can’t be an artist  MIT Technology ReviewCreativity is, and always will be, a human endeavor.
Gandhi convinced everyone with the philosophy of non-violence: Gururaj Karjagi  Mysuru CityTodayMysuru, February 21:- “Mahatma Gandhi convinced everyone with his philosophy of non-violence,” said the president of Academy for Creative Teaching, Prof ...
The White Sox Outdated Philosophy - White Sox and Stuff  ChicagoNowBy the end of last night, I was pretty done with the whole Machado situation. I had run through the stages of grief that being a White Sox fan necessitates.
Tareq Azim, Founder Of Empower, Discusses His Training Philosophy  CBS San Francisco(CBS SF)- Tareq Azim can't help but help other people. The son of Afghan refugees who settled in the Bay Area in the 1980's, Azim found a philosophy through ...
Everyday Philosophy  Boston ReviewEveryday Philosophy from Boston Review. No dead guys with beards in this reading list, we promise.
Democratic Socialism — philosophy of poverty | TheHill  The HillThose who criticize socialism for its failure to create wealth are missing the point.
Neck trouble, philosophy and defiance: A literary guide to middle age  The Irish TimesOur middle years have had a makeover thanks to some excellent recent literature.
How your philosophy degree can lead to a career in data science  Siliconrepublic.comJohn Hearty is the data science manager at NuData Security. Yet he started out more about Kant than code – he studied philosophy.
Philosophy Talk: The 2019 Dionysus Awards  KALWWhat movies of the past year challenged our assumptions and made us think about things in new ways?
Spring Philosophy Forum Series to Feature Dr. Paul Gould Feb. 8  Shawnee News StarThe spring 2019 Philosophy Forum series will begin Friday, Feb. 8, on the OBU campus in Shawnee. Dr. Paul Gould, author and lecturer, will deliver a talk ...
Comments from UGA philosophy student incite social media uproar  Online AthensThe University of Georgia has asked the state Attorney General's office to investigate a UGA philosophy graduate student as his controversial comments about ...
Philosophy professor's new book explores Brian Eno's 'Music for Airports'  Emory News CenterConsidering we mostly listen to music for pleasure, Brian Eno's “ambient music” works of the 1970s were a provocation. With slow and somewhat repetitive ...
Album review: Kate Soper’s ‘Ipsa Dixit’ probes the bounds of philosophy  San Francisco Chronicle“What is art?” is the first question posed in “Ipsa Dixit,” composer-performer Kate Soper's brilliantly probing musical-philosophical masterpiece, and things just ...
'Why Do History in Philosophy': MSU, visiting scholars to explore this question during upcoming conference  Mississippi State NewsroomMississippi State's Department of Philosophy and Religion is hosting the Mississippi Philosophical Association's annual conference Saturday-Sunday [Feb.
One Last Midnight: The Philosophy of ‘True Detective’  Film School RejectsTake a ride through Carcossa with this video primer on the cosmic horror and philosophy of True Detective.
Seahawks mailbag: Debating Seattle’s late-game offensive philosophy  The Seattle TimesAlso: which games will get on prime time in 2019? And a quick review of Seattle's tailback depth heading into the offseason.
Sixty Philosophers and Artists Exchange Ideas Overnight  HyperallergicOver 60 philosophers, authors, artists, and musicians come together this weekend at the Brooklyn Public Library for a full night of conversations and ...
Hygge, Lagom, Coorie: Which Lifestyle Philosophy Is Best for You?  Condé Nast TravelerThree years ago, the Danish phenomenon hygge became the must-chant mantra for the season of taking stock and self-care. The Scandi lifestyle, which ...
Man who helps countless hurricane survivors because of his “philosophy of generosity”  WECTWILMINGTON, NC (WECT) - Greg Pampell has a reputation for giving up his time to help others, especially in the aftermath Hurricane Florence. Pampell says he ...
Chris Russo Talks Holdup With Harper and Machado, Sports Media Philosophy  The Big LeadEvery weekday, Chris Russo hosts Mad Dog Unleashed from 3-6pm on SiriusXM's Mad Dog Radio channel 82 and High Heat at 1pm on MLB Network! He joins ...
Deadline day: 'Arsenal's transfer philosophy is a joke!' – Ex-Gunners star Charlie Nicholas slams loans for 'ninth richest club'  Goal.comArsenal have seen their transfer philosophy branded “an absolute joke”, with Charlie Nicholas questioning why the “ninth richest club” cannot do permanent ...
Waxing philosophical in English class with 'Thinking Experiments'  The Japan TimesIf you've ever taught English at a Japanese school, you'll likely be familiar with a certain kind of silence — pervasive and tinged with teenage ennui. Aut.
Port Macquarie Philosophy Forum returns in February  Port Macquarie NewsThe popular Port Macquarie Philosophy Forum returns in February.
Suing your parents for being born has philosophical support  QuartzA man is suing his parents for giving birth to him without his consent. That might sound ridiculous, but he has a point. The plaintiff behind the lawsuit, 27-year-old ...
Texas philosophy professor to speak on proof for existence of God  Daily NebraskanIt can be difficult to find satisfactory answers to the many philosophical, ideological and spiritual questions asked and debated throughout history. With guidance ...
WATCH: Eales, Bocanegra discuss Almiron transfer and Atlanta United’s philosophy  Dirty South SoccerNearly a week after Miguel Almiron's MLS record transfer to Newcastle United, Atlanta United have released a video of the club's two main decision makers ...
Pirates want new hitting coaches to 'recalibrate' offensive philosophy  Tribune-ReviewThe Pittsburgh Pirates exceeded most expectations in 2018, but within 24 hours of the season's completion they fired both of their hitting coaches. The result of ...
3-day fest on Gandhian philosophy to open on Friday  The StatesmanPlays, readings, performances, cinema, and discussions will mark the upcoming three-day festival themed on the life and ideology of Mahatma Gandhi.
Philosophy in the Screening Room  East Bay ExpressMia Hansen-Løve arrived at filmmaking through some fairly prestigious back channels. The daughter of two philosophy professors, as a teenager she formed a ...
Mesut Ozil: No place for German in Unai Emery's philosophy, says John Cross  SkySportsThere is no place for Mesut Ozil in Unai Emery's philosophy because he cannot be trusted, John Cross told the Sunday Supplement.
The New Brazil: Philosophical Divisions Should Not Hinder Bolsonaro's Free Society Agenda  ForbesBrazil may soon become the fastest-growing of the major Western economies. This is not the first time that investors have looked to this South American giant ...
Tom Byer's 'Soccer Starts at Home' philosophy brought to Houston Dynamo's youth  KTRK-TVParents of young athletes will get the opportunity to learn from Tom Byer and his "Soccer Starts at Home" philosophy.
Krishnamurthy '19: 'Philosophy, politics and economics' is overrated  The Brown Daily HeraldIn early May, the student-run Journal of Philosophy, Politics & Economics published its inaugural issue. In their foreword to the first volume, the editorial board ...
Chelsea news: Eden Hazard says he shares a better ‘football philosophy’ with Maurizio Sarri than Jose Mourinho  The IndependentEden Hazard says he enjoys playing under Maurizio Sarri more than Jose Mourinho as the Chelsea manager shares his “football philosophy”.
Sonia Gandhi: Bluff, bluster, intimidation philosophy of Modi govt  The Indian ExpressSonia Gandhi claimed that the last five years have been a time of unprecedented economic stress and social strain for our country.
How does Panthers' philosophy mesh with current NFL trends?  247SportsIf the National Football League's expressed purpose for the 2018 season had been to make explosive offense the most-important determining factor in a team's ...
Janack is Invited Phi Beta Kappa Speaker at Eckerd College  Hamilton College NewsEckerd College's Phi Beta Kappa chapter is celebrating its 15th anniversary this year, and to kick off the year, the chapter invited Marianne Janack, John.
Has Doug Ford been secretly studying political philosophy?  Toronto StarOntario premier Doug Ford may seem like a typical provincial thug, drunk with his power. But I'm starting to think there's more to it. Take the case of naming ...
Dan Haifley, Our Ocean Backyard: The philosophy of tide pools and our interconnected environment  Santa Cruz SentinelOn Saturday I was privileged to review “The Death and Life of Monterey Bay: A Story of Revival” by Stephen Palumbi and Carolyn Sotka, for an event for Friends ...
Google translate is a manifestation of Wittgenstein language theory  QuartzMore than 60 years after philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein's theories on language were published, the artificial intelligence behind Google Translate has ...
Laurie Anderson and Timothy Morton headline A Night of Philosophy and Ideas  Houston Chronicle We'd say “oui oui” to A Night of Philosophy and Ideas just to hear the keynote talk “It's Not the End of the World. That Was a While Ago,” by rock-star philosopher ...
Philosopher, cognitive scientist Daniel C. Dennett to speak at ETSU  Johnson City Press (subscription)Darwin's Strange Inversion of Reasoning and Human Intelligence” is the focus of the keynote address of East Tennessee State University's Darwin Day ...
Paris police arrest suspect in anti-Semitic attack on French Jewish philosopher Alain Finkielkraut  HaaretzYellow Vest protesters were captured on camera last week shouting threats and racial slurs against the thinker; suspect is a salesman from eastern France, ...
Senate bill would disallow personal/philosophical objections to vaccinations  KHQ Right NowLawmakers are discussing a new bill, which would eliminate a legal exemption from vaccinations for "philosophical or personal" reasons. Senate Bill 5841 ...
Benefits Philosophy  Wilkes Journal PatriotSummary—Tyson's global benefits policy is to provide a competitive and compelling benefits package to team members.
Ignatius Press: Providing religious and philosophical fuel for the mind for 40 years  Aleteia ENA look at the good works that Ignatius Press has conducted in celebration of their 40th year.
MSU philosopher named 2018 humanities teacher of the year  Mississippi State NewsroomA faculty fellow in the Judy and Bobby Shackouls Honors College and assistant professor in the Department of Philosophy and Religion is Mississippi State's ...
Your Loyalties Are Your Life  The New York TimesIn 1900, there were two great philosophers working side by side at Harvard, William James and Josiah Royce. James was from an eminent Boston family and ...
A decent proposal: Philosopher talks goodness at all-night idea festival  Brooklyn PaperCall him the voice of reason. How can you be a good person when it feels like you're in the Bad Place? The philosophy consultant behind the NBC afterlife ...
FCC's Digital Divide Report: 19M Reasons but the Biggest is Philosophical  MeriTalkThere are two fairly obvious ways–plus another great big one that is more philosophical in nature–to look at the announcement late Tuesday from the Federal ...
Your anxiety may be explained by neuroexistentialism  QuartzIt's not easy being human. It never was, really, if William Shakespeare is to be believed. In the 16th century, the playwright noted that “life…is a tale told by an ...
List of All Approved Public University Courses by Commission of University Education(CUE)  KenyansKenyans.co.ke has compiled a list of all approved academic programmes offered in chattered public universities in Kenya in accordance with the universities act, ...
3-day fest on Gandhian philosophy starts  Millennium PostCurated by renowned Hindi poet Ashok Vajpeyi, third extensive festival by the Sanatan Sangeet Sanskriti is themed 'Bapu Ki Dilli'
These were Albert Einstein's 5 favourite books  World Economic ForumTake a look at 5 of Albert Einstein's favourite books, from Ernst Mach to Johann von Goethe.
Jurgen Klopp's philosophy is making Liverpool leggy  Yahoo SportsTrevor Sinclair believes that Liverpool manager Jurgen Klopp's football philosophy of football played at high intensity is causing some of his Liverpool players to ...
Tata AIA's new brand philosophy is #RakshaKaranKiReet  Best Media InfoThe new brand philosophy is being articulated through a unique, TVC-led campaign conceptualised by Tata AIA and created by FCB Ulka.
Washington state House committee passes bill to ban personal, philosophical vaccine exemptions  Pharmacy Today, American Pharmacists Association, pharmacist.comA Washington state House committee on February 15 passed a bill to ban the personal or philosophical exemption for the vaccine against measles, mumps, and ...
Nasscom stops forecasting industry growth as it makes a philosophical shift  ETtech.comThe National Association of Software and Services Companies (Nasscom) will stop forecasting the industry's growth as it makes a 'philosophical' shift towards ...
Albert Einstein's Theory of Relativity was inspired by Scottish philosopher  Telegraph.co.ukAlbert Einstein was inspired to propose his Theory of Relativity after reading the works of a 18th century Scottish philosopher, it has emerged.
What philosophers have to say about eating meat  Petoskey News-ReviewWeWork, a co-working and office space company, made a company policy last year not to serve or reimburse meals that include meat.
Chili Davis' Situational Philosophy Resonating With Mets  metsmerizedonline.comAt the time of his hiring, many scoffed at the idea of Chili Davis taking over as the New York Mets' new hitting coach. His contact-first, situational approach.
Cleveland Browns: What is the draft philosophy for 2019?  NFL Spin ZoneThe Cleveland Browns made strides in the 2018 NFL Draft. As the 2019 draft draws nearer, the Browns should look to a different philosophy this year.
Tal Tsfany on the State and Future of the Ayn Rand Institute  The Objective StandardTal Tsfany is president and CEO of the Ayn Rand Institute. We recently spoke about his work there to date and his plans for the future of the organization.
The Atlantic Daily: How the Philosophy of Alexander Hamilton Explains the Green New Deal  The AtlanticThis goes back to Hamilton, the daddy of it all.” Plus Bernie Sanders is officially running for president, questioning the insect apocalypse, and more.
Mullen breaks down his philosophy on transfers  247SportsFlorida coach Dan Mullen broke down his philosophy on transfers, both into and out of his program.

Alumpeth Devi Temple of Kerala in India

Alumpeth temple is an ancient kalari temple of Sri Bhadrakali... Read More

Choice and Social Acceptance in Human Organizations

Let's discuss choice and social acceptance. I had the most... Read More

Visions Of Heaven And Hell On Earth

Let us now pessimistically endeavour to communication the sentient of... Read More

Nostradamus Saw

The Luciferians are the inner cabal of the Vatican according... Read More

Stranded Notions: Time And Philosophy Of The Individual

As I look back now, a long time seems to... Read More

The Concept of the Sublime in Eighteenth Century Philosophy

The development of the concept of the sublime as an... Read More

Why Im Glad Im Not a Minority Writer

I'll admit that I used to be jealous of my... Read More

Einstein and Eirugena

ALBERT EINSTEIN: - "I am satisfied with the Mysteries of... Read More

Joseph Brant and The Hegelian Dialectic

I admit I am only able to provide guesses as... Read More

The Pertinence of Nudity

Every kind of nudity is an abstraction. A man without... Read More

In Answer To: Words Of Encouragement

Throughout my life, I have always known that it is... Read More

The Magi

I find no real fault in Constantine's inclusion or plagiarization... Read More

Slavers Claim To be Slaves - Taxation

The United States of America was planned by elite members... Read More

Viewing from Anothers Perspective Sets Humans Apart?

Recently I discussed what sets humans apart from other animals... Read More

Infinity - Feynman

RICHARD FEYNMAN: - I had the great pleasure of watching... Read More

Life in the Universe; Part 1

Is there life ( extraterrestrial life or any other form... Read More

What Is Destiny? Is There Some Thing Called Free Will?

One of the greatest and everlasting debates of humanity has... Read More

The Animal and the Human

Recent DNA analyses have revealed that humans share a majority... Read More

Man Is Not An Island

Our thoughts do not take leave of absence.They are actually... Read More

William Butler Yeats

There are adepts outside of what is called alchemy who... Read More

Youre Wrong

Isn't it amazing how often you're wrong? I mean that... Read More

Darius and the US Postal Service

DARIUS: - Coins bearing his visage are found in the... Read More

Raindrops Keep Falling On My Web

I really believe there are things nobody would see if... Read More

Simple Words

The words, the thoughts, the processes go on and on.As... Read More

The Early Life of Jesus

INTRODUCTION:Yeshua bar Joseph or Yeshua ben Joseph has become known... Read More