The Distributive Justice of the Market

(1) Each person is to have an equal right to the most extensive total system of equal basic liberties compatible with a similar system of liberty for all.

(2) Social and economic inequalities are to be arranged so that they are both: (a) to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged, consistent with the just savings principle, and (b) attached to offices and positions open to all under conditions of fair equality of opportunity. "

John Rawls, "A Theory of Justice", 1971, p.302

Resources are scarce. This is the basic, dismal truth of the dismal science. The second truth is that people consume resources. A basic existential anxiety makes them want more resources than they can consume (the "just in case" principle). This raises the question of fairness, a.k.a. "distributive justice". How should resources be allocated in a manner which will conform to one or more just principles?

This apparently simple question raises a host of more complex ones: what constitutes a resource? what is meant by allocation? Who should allocate these resources or should this better be left to some Adam Smithean "invisible hand"? Such an invisible hand (working through the price mechanism) - should its mode of operation be guided by differences in power, in intelligence, in knowledge, in heritage? In other words: what should be the entitlement principle, how can it be determined who is entitled to what?

Everything constitutes a resource: income, opportunities, knowledge, brute power, wealth. Everything, therefore, is subject to distribution to individuals (natural persons), groups of people, certain classes. There are many bases for distribution, but the issue is HOW JUST these bases are and how can we ensure that we are distributing resources using a just distribution base.

We all face opportunities to acquire resources. In a just society, everyone is granted the same access to these opportunities. Access does not translate into ability to make use of it. Idiosyncrasies and differences between accessees will determine the latter, i.e. the outcome of such access. The ability to use is the bridge between the access and the accumulated resources. Given access and the capacity to utilize it - resources (material goods, knowledge, etc.) will accrue to the user.

There is a hidden assumption in all this: that all men are born equal and deserve equal respect and, therefore equal treatment. This is not self evident. It would have been probably hotly disputed by the 16th century aristocracy. As late as 1930, Jose Ortega Y Gasset thought that people should be given access to resources in accordance with their lineage, up bringing and social responsibilities. The mere fact of biological and mental existence does not endow anyone with rights. Should we equally respect the ignorant and the scholar, the criminal and the virtuous, the atheist and the pious, the male and the female, the old and the young - different societies will have different answers. Should the material wealth of these people reflect the different respect that they receive from society, is it the best, most efficacious measure of this respect? Moreover: what index will be used to measure the "equality" between people if an egalitarian view is adopted (everyone should have the same)? Communism (a strict egalitarian idea) foundered exactly on these issues: equal respect and agreed index. It also failed in establishing realistic timeframes. The wish to implement strict egalitarianism here and now transformed communism into the hideous Stalinism that it became.

One solution is to specify a "bundle" or "package" of goods, services and intangibles (like information or skills or knowledge). Everyone should have the same bundle and justice will be thus guaranteed. But will justice bring happiness and satisfaction in its wake? Not necessarily. During our life, we construct our own "bundle". It reflects our own preferences, priorities and predilections. None of us will be too happy with a standardized bundle, not selected by us.

This is precisely where trade and the market come in. It allows for the exchange of goods and services between holders of identical bundles. If I like books, but detest oranges - I will give my oranges to someone else in return for his books. That way both of us will be better off than under the strict egalitarian version.

Two problems become immediately evident:

First, there is no guarantee that I will find my match: a person who is interested in swapping his books for my oranges. Granted, the bigger the market, the more likely I am to find my trading partner. Still, illiquid markets or small ones inhibit the scope of these exchanges. The second problem is that both participants still have to agree on an index: how many books will be given in exchange for how many oranges? This is the price of the oranges in terms of books. The problem is not solved - merely simplified - by the introduction of money. Money makes matters more convenient - but it does not eliminate the necessity to negotiate. Market failures abound. In other words: money is NOT an index. It is merely a medium of exchange. The index - AS EXPRESSED IN MONEY - is the underlying agreement regarding the relative values of resources in terms of other resources.

Thus, indirectly, trading and the market are instruments of increasing happiness and welfare. The invisible hand is also a just and benevolent one. Money is a medium of exchange which increases happiness because it facilitates exchanges, makes life easier, increases our welfare by allowing us to get exactly what we want. We trade what we do not want, nor need - for what we both want and need. But money is imperfect. As Rawles has demonstrated (1971), it is incomplete when we attempt to measure intangibles and needs to be combined with other measures. For instance, how can we use it to measure opportunities?

Some say that all people should have the same resources at some initial point (the "starting gate"). What they do with these resources and how they plunder or increase their wealth is their business. The initial distribution should be equal - the end distribution should depend on the use made of the resources and, ultimately, on the users themselves. More egalitarian thinkers proposed that income should be equal in each time frame. But this raises yet another problem: even if the income is identical, what determines the accumulation of wealth is the USE made of the income. An example: a person who would use up all his income (not to mention borrow against his future income) - will, inevitably, end up poorer than a person who saved some of the money for rainy days. Finally, relative disparities of wealth will emerge. What then? Should the excess wealth be confiscated in order to equalize their positions? Perhaps, a society-wide law should specify how much can be saved and how much must be expended? This would limit freedom, show no respect to people, involve coercion and worse, conflict with what people desire and deserve to have (conflict with free will and free choice or with the freedom of expression as well as with basic rights, like the right to be content). It is better to effect an egalitarian distribution of wealth through taxation and welfare payments. These are redistributive mechanisms which reset the "wealth clock" within every time frame (at the end of every month or fiscal year). Still, is there any moral difference between confiscating and expropriating savings outright - and doing it through elaborate state apparatuses like the tax system? Not really. The anti-tax movements do seem to hold some moral grounds. That part of the tax revenues that is distributed to the less well off could easily be portrayed as punitive: it punishes enterprise, success, entrepreneurship, courage, foresight and many other virtues. Welfare, on the other hand, partly seems to reward dependence and parasitism.

We opened this article with Rawles' Difference Principle. For him, all the principles of justice are reducible to principles of distributive or retributive justice. This is far fetched. Many human activities are not income or money dependent. There are inherent inequalities between people which do not allow us to respect them equally. Moreover: what drives humans (and, maximizes the benefits to the least advantaged) is based on conflict and inequality. It is the same as in the physical world. Equality might motivate people in the short term. But than it atrophies and leads to social corruption and death. A useful lesson can be learned from the field of thermodynamics: an inequality of energy is required in order to generate motion and life. As energy dissipates and is equalized (a state of entropy) - all grinds to a halt and death prevails.

A moral question does arise regarding natural inequalities. The mentally retarded, the mentally insane, the hemiplegic and quadriplegic, the chronically ill - did not choose to be so. Dworkin (1981) proposed a compensation scheme. First, he postulated a model of fair distribution. In this model, all of us are given the same purchasing power and use it to bid, in a fair auction, for resources that best fit our life plan, goals and preferences. We are then permitted to use these resources as we see fit and although we may end up with disparate economic results, we cannot complain: we were given the same purchasing power and we could have bid for any other resource that we might have needed. Dworkin assumes that prior to the hypothetical auction, people are unaware of their own natural endowments but wish (and are able) to insure against being naturally disadvantaged. Their payments will create an insurance pool to compensate the less fortunate for their misfortune. This scheme is, at best dubious. We are usually very much aware of our natural endowments and of the natural endowments and liabilities of others. Therefore, the demand for insurance is not unanimous and equal amongst us all. Some of us badly need and want it - others not at all. If such insurance were available and were traded between willing buyers and sellers (who willingly forego resources to pay for it) - no moral problem would have arisen. But if such insurance is imposed upon those who do not need it or wish it and covers those who, ab initio, gave up no resources and did not invest work or effort in obtaining it - it is immoral. Such insurance is bought and paid for with a restriction of our freedoms and liberties. This, in effect, is the essence of most of the modern welfare programs. This is not to mention the practical problem of how to measure differences in natural endowments, how to distinguish them from acquired ones and who will determine what should be included in the list of natural disadvantages.

This is the philosophical basis of capitalism: that the market is wiser than any of its operators and participants. That humans do not need to bother themselves with constructing patterns of "just" distribution. That the market will reward justly those who deserve it (no matter which criterion for desert is used). Capitalism works, on the whole. Its truth value is substantiated by its continued existence and success.

The Libertarians adopted this view of human inability to dispense with justice by establishing a just pattern of distribution. Instead of imposing a pattern on society, they limited themselves to ascertaining that the market players engage in just acquisitions and in just exchanges. The market is just if the exchanges permitted in it are just and just actions always result in just outcomes. Justice is not dependent on a particular distribution pattern, whether as a a starting point, or as an outcome. Robert Nozick proposed his "Entitlement Theory" in 1974 which was based on this approach.

Still, one issue remained unresolved: the accumulation of wealth, ownership, why first owners should exclude others from owning the very same thing? What moral right to exclude others is gained from being the first?

Nozick advanced the Lockean Proviso: an exclusive acquisition of the outside world is just only if, following it, there is "enough and as good left in common for others". If the position of others is not worsened by the acquisition - then it is morally permissible. But that their situation is not worsened - does not mean that it could not have been better in an alternative situation (distribution). There is no morally plausible and defensible justification of the Lockean Proviso. Exclusive ownership is the result of real-life irreversibility. The first has the advantage of excess information, has invested work, time, effort. All these are irreversible facts leading to an irreversible situation: ownership. The act of owning involves investments and the latter relate to the future. Thus, we encounter another information asymmetry: we know nothing about the future and everything about the past. This asymmetry is known as "investment risk". By taking on investment risk - the first owner attains ownership. Ownership is the compensation for investment risk, setting the asymmetry straight. The situation of the others is ALWAYS worse off by the amount of profits that the owner makes. Profits reflect inherent inefficiency, an intrinsic compensation. There is a law of conservation of benefits, the situation is always win-lose. A product or service could always have been sold to the "others" for a profitless, lower, price, thereby increasing their well-being.

If we say, on the other hand, that ownership is the result of adding value to the world, of improving reality - it is only reasonable to expect it to equal all the value added which can be derived presently and in the future.

Equipped with this understanding of both our shortcomings (we are unable to construct a just distribution pattern which will also be practicable) and of our abilities (to barter investment risk for exclusive ownership) - we embarked on the long road to mature, full bodied, capitalism. We are still not there: visionaries keep popping up with new just distribution patterns, governments keep intervening, incomes keep being redistributed, ownership keeps being contested. But these are phenomena of the past. As capitalism demonstrates its inexhaustible ability to increase well-being and the inexorability of this trend of increase becomes evident - the more inevitable the outcome.

About The Author

Sam Vaknin is the author of "Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited" and "After the Rain - How the West Lost the East". He is a columnist in "Central Europe Review", United Press International (UPI) and ebookweb.org and the editor of mental health and Central East Europe categories in The Open Directory, Suite101 and searcheurope.com. Until recently, he served as the Economic Advisor to the Government of Macedonia.

His web site: http://samvak.tripod.com

In The News:

On Politics: Republicans Put the Squeeze on Steve King  The New York TimesThe House overwhelmingly approved a resolution condemning white supremacy, reflecting the anger toward the Iowa representative in both parties.
Political parenting can be mortifying – but the imperfections can be glorious  The GuardianAs a male politician in a Canberra seat, I'm aware my job is easier than a woman representing a marginal seat in WA.
Trump's war on science: how the US is putting politics above evidence  The GuardianExperts say the administration is blatantly dismantling proven programs, and the consequences could be dire.
Is AOC the Future of Politics? Is Trump?  The BulwarkThe home for the best of American conservative opinion. Curated commentary and analysis on news, politics, public policy, and culture.
Facebook tracks everything from your politics to ethnicity — here’s how to stop it  MarketWatchFacebook has promised more transparency about ads on its platform, but the majority of users are still in the dark about the kind of information that's been ...
The moment Theresa May loses crucial Brexit deal vote – video  The GuardianTheresa May has lost the vote on her crucial Brexit deal by 432 votes to 202 in what is the heaviest defeat of any British prime minister in the democratic era.
Billboard campaign reminds voters of MPs' Brexit promises  The GuardianBillboard posters featuring quotes by Theresa May and Brexiter MPs have gone up around Dover as part of a “guerrilla advertising” campaign designed to ...
Consumers Say Brands Shouldn’t Bring Politics to the Super Bowl  Wall Street JournalTwo-thirds of consumers call the Super Bowl an inappropriate place for advertisers to make political statements, according to a poll conducted by Morning ...
Karnataka political crisis deepens; Four Congress MLAs may resign today  Economic TimesThe Congress-JD(S) coalition in Karnataka received its first jolt on Tuesday with two independent MLAs withdrawing support to the HD Kumaraswamy-led ...
How books for teens are doing politics in 2019  Vox.comBooks for children have always been interested in politics. There is story after story about ruthless political manipulators and power struggles, stories in which ...
Svend Robinson's life in politics already spans decades  CBC.caBefore a spectacular fall from grace, Svend Robinson was once known as a maverick MP from B.C.. His announcement that he is returning to politics, after a ...
Politics, student poverty hampering New Brunswick schools, auditor says  The ProvinceFREDERICTON — New Brunswick's auditor general says the province's education system has been hampered by political interference and the challenges ...
'Off the incompetence scale': readers react to May's Brexit defeat  The GuardianReaders have been reacting to the prime minister's historic defeat and debating what might be next for Brexit.
No 10 rules out customs union before cross-party talks begin  The GuardianDowning Street has flatly ruled out customs union membership, before the cross-party Brexit talks Theresa May promised on Tuesday night have even begun.
Former New Democrat MP Svend Robinson wants to return to politics  CTV NewsFormer New Democrat MP Svend Robinson is attempting a political comeback, nearly 15 years after his theft of an expensive diamond ring brought an end to his ...
The Politics of Roma: Alfonso Cuaron Revisits Mexico's Turbulent History  Hollywood ReporterDirector Alfonso Cuaron and star Yalitza Aparicio guide The Hollywood Reporter through the city's Roma neighborhood as they break down how the political ...
PX column: Ex-Congresswoman Jean Schmidt makes a comeback in politics, launches 2020 campaign  Cincinnati.comEx-Congresswoman Jean Schmidt is ending her hiatus from politics. The Clermont County Republican has launched her 2020 campaign for this office.
The #10yearchallenge, but for politics  CNNWashington (CNN) The #10yearchallenge is the hottest trend sweeping Instagram, where users posts photos of themselves 10 years apart. Politicians aren't ...
Business leaders warn of 'supertanker GB' heading for the rocks  The GuardianCBI deputy Josh Hardie appeals to Tory MPs to shift position to avoid a no-deal Brexit, or risk further harm to the economy.
Why Trump's politics of turmoil is working for Republicans  9news.com.auTrump's politics of turmoil is still working well to shore up his base.
Jeremy Corbyn tables no-confidence motion after May defeat – as it happened  The GuardianPrime minister's Brexit deal is lost by 432 votes to 202.
Politics of Immigration  TownhallHere are a couple of easy immigration questions -- answerable with a simple "yes" or "no" -- we might ask any American of any political stripe: Does everyone in ...
Brexit amendment defeated after three others withdrawn  The GuardianThe only amendment to Theresa May's Brexit deal to be voted on in the Commons has been heavily defeated, after three other amendments selected for votes ...
Tory accuses pregnant Labour MP over pledge to attend Brexit vote  The GuardianThe Conservative vice-chairman Kemi Badenoch has provoked Labour anger after she accused the heavily pregnant opposition MP Tulip Siddiq of “making a ...
Congressional districts with more federal employees voted more heavily for Trump in 2016  Washington PostPresident Trump has repeatedly argued that his views of the shutdown are not colored by his assumption that most of those affected are Democrats, which is a ...
Facebook's new rules for employees re politics, bullying, religion  Business InsiderAmid scandals and employee discontent, Facebook is bringing in new rules on what its workers can talk about.
Stocks rally on average 30 percent when this happens in DC  CNBCPolitical uncertainty abounds, but LPL Financial senior market strategist Ryan Detrick says it's unlikely to shake Wall Street if history is any guide.
Many Americans say they want politicians to compromise. But maybe they don’t.  Washington PostCompromise is good in the abstract. But in reality? Maybe not so much.
Obscure pro-Brexit group spends tens of thousands on Facebook ads  The GuardianTens of thousands of pounds are being spent on pro-Brexit Facebook adverts with little clarity on who is picking up the tab, despite the social network introducing ...
Trudeau Says He Thought 2015 Election Win Would End ‘Divisive, Scary Politics’  HuffPost CanadaOTTAWA — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told a crowd in St. Catharines Tuesday that he was a tad naive after his election win, thinking his party's pledge to ...
US politics on the backs of refugees  Economic TimesThe US government has been shut for 24 days, now making it the longest shutdown in US history. The shutdown is over President Donald Trump's demand that ...
'What are you playing at?' The Commons Brexit debate in quotes  The GuardianSome of the more memorable lines from MPs' debate on Theresa May's Brexit deal.
Labour's powerful party political broadcast is out - and there's one thing it doesn't mention  Mirror Online'Our country' takes viewers on a journey from London to Snowdonia.
After Brexit vote: No 10 draws up secret contingency plans  The GuardianTheresa May's EU emissary, Olly Robbins, has been working up secret contingency plans for cross-party talks aimed at testing MPs' backing for up to six ...
House Democrats might need to impeach Donald Trump whether they want to or not  USA TODAYHouse Democrats can't decide Trump future based on what they think Republican senators might do. If there's evidence, they have a duty to impeach.
Like in UP, state politics may see Congress fight alone in Bengal  Economic TimesThe AICC has decided to “go slow” on the Bengal alliance talks, while fast-tracking various other state party units election preparations.
Post-truth politics is alive and well in Brexit Britain  CNNBrexit might actually get interesting. After two years of screaming into the wind, the UK's elected lawmakers finally get to do something useful.
America gawps at someone else’s political mess as Brexit defeat dominates the headlines  Telegraph.co.ukIn the end, not even the Russia investigation could keep Brexit out of the US headlines. Throughout Tuesday the cable news channels had been live-streaming ...
In Assamese Singer's Protest, a Sign That BJP's Politics in Assam Has Run Aground  The WireAcross the North-East, the Centre is being questioned for attempting to blur the lines that differentiate communal and community consciousness.
Opinion | Quota politics is the legacy of flawed priorities  LivemintWhen did India last see an agitation for better education and healthcare, unlike, say, the recent wave of protests over quota?
‘Football is a message of peace’: Saudi Arabia and Qatar put politics aside  The GuardianThe governments of Saudi Arabia and Qatar may be locked in a diplomatic stand-off but the countries are playing down off-field issues before their Asian Cup ...
Shah Faesal wants to disrupt, reimagine politics in Kashmir  Economic TimesSRINAGAR: Shah Faesal, the 2009 civil *service* exam topper from Kashmir who has recently resigned from the *service*, on Friday said he wants to fight elections ...
Brexit deal: how will the Westminster factions vote?  The GuardianIf the tribal divisions of Brexit are complicated enough, then things become even more atomised when it comes to how the various groups in the Commons might ...
2019 Baton Rouge politics: Group looking to improve government is all about nothing  Greater Baton Rouge Business ReportThere will be plenty of talk over the next three months about the desire to create a city-parish manager role as well as the need to come up with a new way to fill ...
MLA quits UCP over 'hyper-partisan, self-centred' politics  CBC.caRick Strankman is leaving the caucus to sit as an Independent, saying the UCP is putting "unwritten party interests" ahead of grassroots conservative principles.
Chris Christie accuses Jared Kushner of political 'hit job' in explosive new book  The GuardianExclusive: ex-New Jersey governor, who had prosecuted Kushner's father, was sacked as head of Trump's transition team.
Supreme Court sets low threshold for sentencing repeat violent offenders to stiff prison terms  Washington PostA divided Supreme Court on Monday set the bar low on the amount of violence needed to trigger longer prison sentences for some repeat offenders.
Resist the Lure of Theological Politics  The AtlanticInstead of applying religious certainty to public debates, Americans need to take a different lesson from their faith traditions.
On the border, Trump turns political in making case for his wall  NBCNews.comWearing a MAGA hat and harshly criticizing Democrats, President Donald Trump made the case for a border wall near the U.S.-Mexico line Thursday.
Never mind her politics, Kate Bush’s music speaks for itself  The GuardianThe singer was wrongly branded a Tory, but why does it matter how our pop idols vote, asks freelance arts writer Fiona Sturges.
William Barr Hearing: Senators Press Barr on Criminal Justice Overhaul  The New York TimesWilliam P. Barr appeared in front of the Senate Judiciary Committee on Tuesday for the first day of his confirmation hearing for attorney general. Mr. Barr pledged ...
Corey Stewart, the firebrand Virginia Republican, will leave politics in December  Washington PostStewart won't seek a fourth term as Prince William board chairman and says he'll stay out of state politics “for the foreseeable future.”
David Cameron: I don't regret calling EU referendum  BBC NewsFormer UK Prime Minister David Cameron says he does not regret calling the 2016 referendum on whether the UK should stay in the EU. But he regretted the ...
WHAT DO YOU WANT? Ireland CONDEMNS 'disorderly Brexit' and demands May regains control  Express.co.ukDublin has stepped up its preparations for a no deal in preparation for tonight's vote but urged the UK it must take immediate action to avert a hard Brexit.
Don't take political mileage from Kanhaiya case: Shiv Sena to BJP  Economic TimesThe Sena asked the ruling BJP to refrain from taking political mileage from the sedition case against Kumar, a former president of the Jawaharlal Nehru ...
The Shutdown Is Still Going On. So Are the Political Stunts  TIMENo one on Capitol Hill or the White House seems any closer to resolving the longest government shutdown in U.S. history.
Before Trump, Steve King Set the Agenda for the Wall and Anti-Immigrant Politics  The New York TimesThe Iowa congressman, who has used racist language and been denounced as a white supremacist, wrote the playbook on white identity politics and many of ...
Departing senators warn: There's a problem with the current state of politics  CNNAs departing senators said their goodbyes to Washington, a number of Democrats and Republicans took the opportunity to express concern about the state of ...
The Point Awards: The best and worst of politics in 2018  CNN2018 is almost over! We're going to make it to 2019! Hooray for us -- or something.
2018, GIF-wrapped: Top political moments of the year  CNNDuring his eulogy for former President George H.W. Bush, former Senator Alan Simpson emphasized the the importance of a good laugh. "Humor is the ...
Trudeau Says Politics Won't Factor Into Huawei 5G Decision  TIMECanada's Prime Minister said the decision on allowing Huawei to access to its next-generation wireless network won't be a political one.
Tucker Carlson has sparked the most interesting debate in conservative politics  Vox.comLast Wednesday, the conservative talk show host Tucker Carlson started a fire on the right after airing a prolonged monologue on his show that was, in essence, ...
How Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Shapes a New Political Reality  WIREDI'll just say it: Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is a social media marketing genius, and very likely a harbinger of a new American political reality. A summary for those ...
What our politicians are missing: India’s a land of cities, not villages  Economic Timesby Reuben Abraham and Pritika Hingorani It's an election year in India, with the world's largest polls expected in the spring. The focus of politicians is, as usual, ...
“We Did Not Come to Play”: Politics’ New Power Players Are Ready for a Fight  Vanity FairAs the most diverse class of freshman lawmakers in history settles in, Washington is preparing for war. Intra-party rifts are deepening. The executive branch is ...
The Political Insiders' Guide to 2019  POLITICO18 top analysts and strategists from both parties tell us what they'll be watching for in the coming year.
White Identity Politics Aren’t Going Anywhere  The New York TimesFor 50 years Republicans have battered the Democratic coalition, wielding the so-called southern strategy — built on racism and overlaid with opposition to ...
Swedish Political Deadlock Broken as Allegiances Collapse  Wall Street JournalEstablishment parties in Sweden closed ranks and agreed to form a government to block out an anti-immigrant party, possibly breaking a political deadlock that ...
Trump seeks to enlist a key surrogate in political fight over his wall — Border Patrol agents  Washington PostIn his political fight for a border wall, President Trump has enlisted a new group of surrogates to join conservative talk show hosts and Republican allies in ...
5 heartwarming moments in politics, even in 2018  CNNWashington (CNN) 2018 has been a tumultuous year in Washington — we've seen unprecedented turnover in the White House, the passings of two political ...
10% Quota: “No… But Maybe, Yes” Is Lose-Lose Politics For The Opposition  BloombergQuintAn amorphous “no … but yes” on the quota bill has left every opposition politician stranded in no-man's land. All the bragging rights on this have been turned ...
Shah Faesal Quitting Civil Services And Opting for Politics Comes as No Surprise in J&K  News18Shah Faesal emerged as a youth icon in Jammu and Kashmir after he topped the UPSC exam in 2010. On Wednesday, he surprised many, particularly people ...
Political figures celebrate Paddy Ashdown's energy, bravery and humour  The GuardianPraise for politician who transformed Liberal Democrats and oversaw peace in the Balkans.
Reservation politics: Why BJP played the 'general category' card  Economic TimesThe BJP's first aggressive foray into reservation politics by playing the 'general category' card hinges on three broad pivots, which would give a whole new spin ...
North Dakota Rep. Kelly Armstrong: 'The time for political posturing is over'  CNNThe 116th Congress was sworn in on January 3. Since then, The Point newsletter has been conducting a series of interviews with some of its *fresh* new faces.
The Gender Politics of Fasting  The New York TimesBoth Cesar Chavez and Simone Weil starved their bodies for spiritual and political reasons. Why is only one of them remembered as anorexic?
Harsh realities of politics derail dream of Middle East grand fondo  VeloNewsFormer Austrian pro cyclist's dream of a bicycle tour across Israel, Jordan, and Palestine put on hold due to increasingly fraught political climate.
Politics Podcast: Julian Castro’s Path To The 2020 Nomination  FiveThirtyEightJulian Castro, a former mayor of San Antonio mayor and a former secretary of housing and urban development, announced his candidacy for president on ...
Power & Politics' top five political moves and misses of 2018  CBC.caAs 2018 winds to a close, it's time to take a look back at the year's biggest political events and errors, both at home and abroad. The Power Panel — Postmedia ...
What’s Left? Young Burlington Progs Forge Ahead Without Jane Knodell  Seven DaysVoters at the Progressive Party caucus had a clear choice, City Councilor Brian Pine (P-Ward 3) told the crowd during the January 6 event in...
Bidding Congress Farewell, Paul Ryan Laments Nation’s ‘Broken’ Politics  The New York TimesOn a valedictory tour, Mr. Ryan is putting a high gloss on a speakership of dubious accomplishment. He fulfilled his tax-cutting dream, but the deficit is soaring.
Black Voters, a Force in Democratic Politics, Are Ready to Make Themselves Heard  The New York TimesBALTIMORE — The first “Amen!” rang out after a couple of minutes, as Senator Elizabeth Warren, speaking to an almost all-black audience at Morgan State ...
The Worst Political Predictions of 2018  POLITICOIf you guess at the outcome of anything, you're bound to be wrong a lot. There are certain things that it's fairly easy to predict far in advance, because they ...
LILLEY: Liberal candidate Karen Wang's resignation shows dangers of playing ethno-politics  Toronto SunKaren Wang's career as a Liberal Party of Canada candidate came to disastrous end on Wednesday as the party dumped her over stupid, and quite frankly ...
Five Political Predictions for 2019  RealClearPoliticsThe stock market is a roller coaster. There's a partial government shutdown. The president has taken to tweeting in ALL CAPS. Not even Nostradamus could ...
Politics Podcast: Our 2018 Politics Awards  FiveThirtyEightIn this year-end installment of the FiveThirtyEight Politics podcast, the crew looks back on the year in politics and hands out awards for things like the worst…
No-deal Brexit rehearsal in Kent 'a waste of time'  The GuardianA live rehearsal of an emergency traffic system that will be put in place to prevent congestion in Dover in the event of a no-deal Brexit has been described as “a ...
The Political Question of the Future: But Are They Real?  The AtlanticWhat happens when live-streams become the new fireside chat.
People with extreme political views have trouble thinking about their own thinking  Popular ScienceRadical political views of all sorts seem to shape our lives to an almost unprecedented extent. But what attracts people to the fringes? A new study from ...
Democrats Want to Run on Issues in 2020. But Does Beating Trump Matter Most?  The New York TimesA major question in the coming Democratic primary is which candidate will be the best antidote to Trump and Trumpism. Liberals may want to apply policy litmus ...
Politics Is Not Harry Potter  Jacobin magazineLiberals love Harry Potter because it presents a world they desperately wish was a reality — one where the magic of facts and reason and elite education were ...
Political chaos reaches DEFCON 2 in Washington  NBCNews.comOnly in Donald Trump's Washington is a looming government shutdown not the lead political story in America today.
Swedish parties strike deal to end political deadlock  The Local SwedenThe Centre Party has – together with the Green Party and Liberals – struck a deal with the Social Democrats which would allow Stefan Löfven to stay on as ...
The President’s McFeast  The AtlanticThe fast-food dinner Trump hosted was also an argument: about government, about political messaging, about himself.
Discriminating against migrants isn't just unconstitutional, it's also bad politics  Times of IndiaOne country, one market!” With that slogan, politicians of all parties cheered the launch of a unified Goods and Services Tax in 2017, ending the old era when ...
Democratic drive for gun control reflects rapidly changing political dynamic  Washington PostI've seen great courage when my life was on the line. Now is the time to come together,” former congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords said. Any legislation faces an ...
Brexit: MPs vote 308-297 in favour of amendment for three-day 'plan B' deadline - Politics live  The GuardianRolling coverage of the day's political developments as they happen, including Theresa May and Jeremy Corbyn at PMQs and the first day of the Brexit debate.
Trump wants his wall. Texas politicians, even some Republicans, are skeptical.  Washington PostAs President Trump heads to Texas to continue making his case for a wall along the Mexican border, he is facing mounting skepticism from those who would be ...
Trump Iraq Visit Is Called a Political Rally  The New York TimesWASHINGTON — During his surprise visit to American troops in Iraq and Germany this week, President Trump singled out red “Make America Great Again” caps ...
Angelina Jolie open to move into politics  The GuardianGuest-editing Radio 4's Today programme, the actor joked she has no skeletons left in her closet.

The Halakah and Neo Cons

These leaders like the Rothschilds who backed Crowley's Hermetic Order... Read More

If Terrorists Are To Become Slick Politicians, Yhey Need Time Rather Than God on Their Side

The number of countries in the world at the moment... Read More

Economic Illiteracy Can Be Very Costly!

I'VE ALWAYS ARGUED THAT ECONOMIC ILLITERACY IS VERY COSTLY.This is... Read More

Liquidity or Liquidation

Large parts of the world today suffer from a severe... Read More

The Elephant Roared and Brought Forth a Turd: A Case Against Democratizing the Middle East

The original vulgarity was bylined: ?The Constipation of America's Mid-East... Read More

Smelter Closures In America Hurt Our Industrial Output

The United States is losing its industrial capacity quite rapidly.... Read More

Economic Free Zones in Macedonia

Question: Dr. Vaknin ? is it true that you are... Read More

Global/Israeli Corruption!

What depth of blind insanity has inflicted itself upon Israel's... Read More

Constitutional Amendment Needed on Sodomy Laws

Many very nice and loving homosexual male couples want to... Read More

The Wage-Productivity Gap

The most damaging factor to our economy today is the... Read More

America Needs an Education Reinvention Bill NOW!

In order to build a stronger, more self-sufficient America, America... Read More

Plastics In Our Nations Dumps and Landfills

Long Term Environmental Effect of Plastics, Composites and Other Materials... Read More

Voting Pro-Environment is Good For Jobs, Health, and Security

There are many issues on the minds of US voters... Read More

Bird Flu may kill you and your family

We have heard a lot about the coming bird flu... Read More

Cops Want To Increase Marijuana Punishments?

Leave it to the Columbia City Police Officers Association in... Read More

Quick Thought on The Flow of Fuel and Costs

Without the flow of fuel our very mobile society comes... Read More

MORAL ARMORS Counterfeit 911: Refuting Michael Moore

Michael Moore asserts the following in his political film Fahrenheit... Read More

Bill OReilly: You Got This One Wrong!

I like Bill O'Reilly. I do. I have read two... Read More

Connecticut Does Not Need Further Income Tax Hikes!

Industrial Recruiting. The absence of a state income tax in... Read More

De-Population

Judgment and detective work requires thinking about possibilities. One of... Read More

UAV Targets, Aerial Dog Fights, Interception, Future of War Intelligence

The UAV, Unmanned Aerial Vehicle is hear to stay and... Read More

Famous Filibusters in Political History

The filibuster as a political delaying tactic has been a... Read More

The Criminality of Transition

Lecture given at the Netherlands Economic Institute (NEI) on 18/4/2001Human... Read More

Reprisal of the Bill of Proposed Electronic Crime Act 2004

The clause (c) of Electronic Crime Act 2004 has been... Read More

NASCAR to be Shut Down by FTC?

The Federal Trade Commission has very important Anti-trust Laws. They... Read More