Public Procurement and Very Private Benefits

In every national budget, there is a part called "Public Procurement". This is the portion of the budget allocated to purchasing services and goods for the various ministries, authorities and other arms of the executive branch. It was the famous management consultant, Parkinson, who once wrote that government officials are likely to approve a multi-billion dollar nuclear power plant much more speedily that they are likely to authorize a hundred dollar expenditure on a bicycle parking device. This is because everyone came across 100 dollar situations in real life - but precious few had the fortune to expend with billions of USD.

This, precisely, is the problem with public procurement: people are too acquainted with the purchased items. They tend to confuse their daily, household-type, decisions with the processes and considerations which should permeate governmental decision making. They label perfectly legitimate decisions as "corrupt" - and totally corrupt procedures as "legal" or merely "legitimate", because this is what was decreed by the statal mechanisms, or because "this is the law".

Procurement is divided to defence and non-defence spending. In both these categories - but, especially in the former - there are grave, well founded, concerns that things might not be all what they seem to be.

Government - from India's to Sweden's to Belgium's - fell because of procurement scandals which involved bribes paid by manufacturers or service providers either to individual in the service of the state or to political parties. Other, lesser cases, litter the press daily. In the last few years only, the burgeoning defence sector in Israel saw two such big scandals: the developer of Israel's missiles was involved in one (and currently is serving a jail sentence) and Israel's military attache to Washington was implicated - though, never convicted - in yet another.

But the picture is not that grim. Most governments in the West succeeded in reigning in and fully controlling this particular budget item. In the USA, this part of the budget remained constant in the last 35(!) years at 20% of the GDP.

There are many problems with public procurement. It is an obscure area of state activity, agreed upon in "customized" tenders and in dark rooms through a series of undisclosed agreements. At least, this is the public image of these expenditures.

The truth is completely different.

True, some ministers use public money to build their private "empires". It could be a private business empire, catering to the financial future of the minister, his cronies and his relatives. These two plagues - cronyism and nepotism - haunt public procurement. The spectre of government official using public money to benefit their political allies or their family members - haunts public imagination and provokes public indignation.

Then, there are problems of plain corruption: bribes or commissions paid to decision makers in return for winning tenders or awarding of economic benefits financed by the public money. Again, sometimes these moneys end in secret bank accounts in Switzerland or in Luxembourg. At other times, they finance political activities of political parties. This was rampantly abundant in Italy and has its place in France. The USA, which was considered to be immune from such behaviours - has proven to be less so, lately, with the Bill Clinton alleged election financing transgressions.

But, these, with all due respect to "clean hands" operations and principles, are not the main problems of public procurement.

The first order problem is the allocation of scarce resources. In other words, prioritizing. The needs are enormous and ever growing. The US government purchases hundreds of thousands of separate items from outside suppliers. Just the list of these goods - not to mention their technical specifications and the documentation which accompanies the transactions - occupies tens of thick volumes. Supercomputers are used to manage all these - and, even so, it is getting way out of hand. How to allocate ever scarcer resources amongst these items is a daunting - close to impossible - task. It also, of course, has a political dimension. A procurement decision reflects a political preference and priority. But the decision itself is not always motivated by rational - let alone noble - arguments. More often, it is the by product and end result of lobbying, political hand bending and extortionist muscle. This raises a lot of hackles among those who feel that were kept out of the pork barrel. They feel underprivileged and discriminated against. They fight back and the whole system finds itself in a quagmire, a nightmare of conflicting interests. Last year, the whole budget in the USA was stuck - not approved by Congress - because of these reactions and counter-reactions.

The second problem is the supervision, auditing and control of actual spending. This has two dimensions:

  • How to make sure that the expenditures match and do not exceed the budgetary items. In some countries, this is a mere ritual formality and government departments are positively expected to overstep their procurement budgets. In others, this constitutes a criminal offence.

  • How to prevent the criminally corrupt activities that we have described above - or even the non criminal incompetent acts which government officials are prone to do.

The most widespread method is the public, competitive, tender for the purchases of goods and services.

But, this is not as simple as it sounds.

Some countries publish international tenders, striving to secure the best quality in the cheapest price - no matter what is its geographical or political source. Other countries are much more protectionist (notably: Japan and France) and they publish only domestic tenders, in most cases. A domestic tender is open only to domestic bidders. Yet other countries limit participation in the tenders on various backgrounds: the size of the competing company, its track record, its ownership structure, its human rights or environmental record and so on. Some countries publish the minutes of the tender committee (which has to explain WHY it selected this or that supplier). Others keep it a closely guarded secret ("to protect commercial interests and secrets").

But all countries state in advance that they have no obligation to accept any kind of offer - even if it is the cheapest. This is a needed provision: the cheapest is not necessarily the best. The cheapest offer could be coming from a very unreliable supplier with a bad past performance or a criminal record or from a supplier who offers goods of shoddy quality.

The tendering policies of most of the countries in the world also incorporates a second principle: that of "minimum size". The cost of running a tender is prohibitive in the cases of purchases in small amounts.

Even if there is corruption in such purchases it is bound to cause less damage to the public purse than the costs of the tender which is supposed to prevent it!

So, in most countries, small purchases can be authorized by government officials - larger amounts go through a tedious, multi-phase tendering process. Public competitive bidding is not corruption-proof: many times officials and bidders collude and conspire to award the contract against bribes and other, noncash, benefits. But we still know of no better way to minimize the effects of human greed.

Procurement policies, procedures and tenders are supervised by state auditing authorities. The most famous is, probably, the General Accounting Office, known by its acronym: the GAO.

It is an unrelenting, very thorough and dangerous watchdog of the administration. It is considered to be highly effective in reducing procurement - related irregularities and crimes. Another such institutions the Israeli State Reviser. What is common to both these organs of the state is that they have very broad authority. They possess (by law) judicial and criminal prosecution powers and they exercise it without any hesitation. They have the legal obligation to review the operations and financial transactions of all the other organs of the executive branch. Their teams select, each year, the organs to be reviewed and audited. They collect all pertinent documents and correspondence. They cross the information that they receive from elsewhere. They ask very embarrassing questions and they do it under the threat of perjury prosecutions. They summon witnesses and they publish damning reports which, in many cases, lead to criminal prosecutions.

Another form of review of public procurement is through powers granted to the legislative arm of the state (Congress, Parliament, Bundestag, or Knesset). In almost every country in the world, the elected body has its own procurement oversight committee. It supervises the expenditures of the executive branch and makes sure that they conform to the budget. The difference between such supervisory, parliamentary, bodies and their executive branch counterparts - is that they feel free to criticize public procurement not only in the context of its adherence to budget constraints or its cleanliness - but also in a political context. In other words, these committees do not limit themselves to asking HOW - but also engage in asking WHY. Why this specific expense in this given time and location - and not that expense, somewhere else or some other time. These elected bodies feel at liberty - and often do - intervene in the very decision making process and in the order of priorities. They have the propensity to alter both quite often.

The most famous such committee is, arguably, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO). It is famous because it is non-partisan and technocratic in nature. It is really made of experts which staff its offices.

Its apparent - and real - neutrality makes its judgements and recommendations a commandment not to be avoided and, almost universally, to be obeyed. The CBO operates for and on behalf of the American Congress and is, really, the research arm of that venerable parliament. Parallelly, the executive part of the American system - the Administration - has its own guard against waste and worse: the Office of Management and Budget (OMB).

Both bodies produce learned, thickset, analyses, reports, criticism, opinions and recommendations. Despite quite a prodigious annual output of verbiage - they are so highly regarded, that virtually anything that they say (or write) is minutely analysed and implemented to the last letter with an air of awe.

Only a few other parliaments have committees that carry such weight. The Israeli Knesset have the extremely powerful Finance Committee which is in charge of all matters financial, from appropriations to procurement. Another parliament renowned for its tight scrutiny is the French Parliament - though it retains very few real powers.

But not all countries chose the option of legislative supervision. Some of them relegated parts or all of these functions to the executive arm.

In Japan, the Ministry of Finance still scrutinizes (and has to authorize) the smallest expense, using an army of clerks. These clerks became so powerful that they have the theoretical potential to secure and extort benefits stemming from the very position that they hold. Many of them suspiciously join companies and organizations which they supervised or to which they awarded contracts - immediately after they leave their previous, government, positions. The Ministry of Finance is subject to a major reform in the reform-bent government of Prime Minister Hashimoto. The Japanese establishment finally realized that too much supervision, control, auditing and prosecution powers might be a Pyrrhic victory: it might encourage corruption - rather than discourage it.

Britain opted to keep the discretion to use public funds and the clout that comes with it in the hands of the political level. This is a lot like the relationship between the butter and the cat left to guard it. Still, this idiosyncratic British arrangement works surprisingly well. All public procurement and expenditure items are approved by the EDX Committee of the British Cabinet (=inner, influential, circle of government) which is headed by the Ministry of Finance. Even this did not prove enough to restrain the appetites of Ministers, especially as quid pro quo deals quickly developed. So, now the word is that the new Labour Prime Minister will chair it- enabling him to exert his personal authority on matters of public money.

Britain, under the previous, Tory, government also pioneered an interesting and controversial incentive system for its public servants as top government officials are euphemistically called there. They receive, added to their salaries, a portion of the savings that they effect in their departmental budgets. This means that they get a small fraction of the end of the fiscal year difference between their budget allowances and what they actually spent. This is very useful in certain segments of government activity - but could prove very problematic in others. Imagine health officials saving on medicines, or others saving on road maintenance or educational consumables. This, naturally, will not do.

Needless to say that no country officially approves of the payment of bribes or commission to officials in charge of public spending, however remote the connection is between the payment and the actions.

Yet, law aside many countries accept the intertwining of elites - business and political - as a fact of life, albeit a sad one. Many judicial systems in the world even make a difference between a payment which is not connected to an identifiable or discernible benefit and those that are. The latter - and only the latter - are labelled "bribery".

Where there is money - there is wrongdoing. Humans are humans - and sometimes not even that.

But these unfortunate derivatives of social activity can be minimized by the adoption of clear procurement policies, transparent and public decision making processes and the right mix of supervision, auditing and prosecution. Even then the result is bound to be dubious, at best.

About The Author

Sam Vaknin is the author of "Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited" and "After the Rain - How the West Lost the East". He is a columnist in "Central Europe Review", United Press International (UPI) and ebookweb.org and the editor of mental health and Central East Europe categories in The Open Directory, Suite101 and searcheurope.com. Until recently, he served as the Economic Advisor to the Government of Macedonia.

His web site: http://samvak.tripod.com

In The News:

On Politics: Supreme Court Hears Census Citizenship Question  The New York TimesThe Supreme Court's conservative majority seems poised to allow the Trump administration to add a question on citizenship to the 2020 census.
5 things to know for April 24: Sri Lanka, politics, UN, malaria vaccine, sitting  CNN(CNN) What does an earthquake on Mars sound like? Listen to a recording of a "marsquake," care of NASA's InSight lander. Here's what else you need to know ...
The Political Punch: Vijender, Deepa Malik and Rathore In Poll Fray - Leading The Pack  Economic TimesPopular belief says that sports and politics do not go hand-in-hand. However, in India, this happens to be just a myth. The world's largest democracy is where, ...
Our Brexit limbo has given us two new parties, but the same old politics  The GuardianNever mind the insurgent 'outsiders'. What we need is better politicians, not anti-politics, to get us out of this mess, says Guardian columnist Rafael Behr.
Hans Raj Hans: BJP's new Dalit face is versatile in music as well as politics  Economic TimesHans had a tryst with religion in 2006 when he became the head of the Dera Baba Lal Badshah at Nakodar. But he left in 2015 amid controversies.
See how film, sports and business find politics interesting - All the way from B'town  Economic TimesThe Congress fielded actress Urmila Matondkar from Mumbai North Lok Sabha constituency two days after she joined the party. Matondkar had joined the ...
Politics in a tea cup: Modi factor vs caste equation in Barmer  Economic TimesWith the morning tea served hot and *fresh* and newspapers by their side, the visitors passionately discuss politics. In northern India, tea and politics in any case ...
SNP politicians warn against 'rushing' change to gender act  The GuardianFifteen senior Scottish National party politicians, including the chair of Holyrood's equalities committee and three government ministers, have warned against a ...
Lyra McKee's funeral unites political leaders and aims to heal Northern Irish divisions  CNNThe funeral of murdered journalist Lyra McKee on Wednesday drew leaders from across British and Irish politics, in a church *service* aimed at uniting divisions.
Pete Buttigieg is on every podcast, and 2020's retail politics is increasingly happening in earbuds  Nieman Journalism Lab at Harvard“Podcasts are really hot right now, and I think underappreciated,” said Lis Smith, communications adviser to the buzzy Democratic presidential candidate Pete ...
Why Indian Muslims don't react to aggressive Hindutva politics  QuartzIn the past four years, we have been repeatedly told that Muslims' eating habits are anti-Hindu/anti-national as they eat beef; that Muslim men don't love, they do ...
Politics | Could Mayawati and Akhilesh Yadav change the dynamics of UP politics?  Moneycontrol.comUnlike the early 90s, the BSP-SP alliance has not been forged on the basis of any common social goal or vision. It is a result of an aggressive BJP pushing both ...
Politics | What to make of Kerala’s high voter turnout  Moneycontrol.comOn April 23 Kerala voted to select its 20 Member of Parliaments for the 17th Lok Sabha. What has taken political parties and observers by surprise is the voter ...
MoveOn founder: Seeing the divinity in everyone might give our politics a new start  Religion News Service(RNS) — I'm a secular person. As a co-founder of MoveOn, the political organizing group, I've talked for years about how most people want to do good and aim ...
Everyone’s practicing the politics of evasion on Social Security and Medicare  The Washington PostJust for the record, we ought to note that trustees for Social Security and Medicare recently released their annual reports. The two programs alone constituted 45 ...
On Politics: The Biggest Stories of the Week  The New York TimesFrom the Mueller report to 2020 fund-raising, it's been a busy week in American politics. Here are some of the biggest stories you might have missed (and some ...
Politics with Michelle Grattan: Caroline Fisher on the spin machines of #AusVotes19  The Conversation AUWhile the major party leaders seem to have curated their images, University of Canberra assistant professor in communications and media Caroline Fisher says ...
Pete Buttigieg: 'God doesn't have a political party'  CNNPete Buttigieg opened up about his faith Monday night, expressing confidence that he will be able to unite many different groups of people because "God does ...
Bernie Sanders just gave the best political answer on impeachment  CNNBernie Sanders didn't build his political career on pragmatism. But on Monday night at a CNN-sponsored town hall, he showed that his presidential candidacy ...
First past the post abets extreme politics, says thinktank  The GuardianThe UK's first-past-the-post (FPTP) parliamentary election system is broken and outdated and can no longer be relied upon to keep out extreme elements and ...
Remove politics of divisiveness, negativity: Priyanka Gandhi to voters in Fatehpur  India TodayCongress leader Priyanka Gandhi Vadra on Wednesday asked voters to help remove politics of divisiveness and negativity. She also told voters that they should ...
At a White House Tradition, Politics Color Everything but the Easter Eggs  The New York TimesWASHINGTON — At the White House Easter Egg Roll on Monday, President Trump ditched his escort — the Easter bunny — to take up a decidedly unfestive ...
Election at 20: assessing the high school satire's brutal politics  The GuardianReese Witherspoon's ruthless go-getter remains fascinatingly toxic in Alexander Payne's bleak and biting political comedy.
India's polarised politics: How two teenagers will vote after surviving the 2002 Gujarat riots  DAWN.comOn the night of February 28, 2002, two toddlers living in adjacent alleys were dragged out of a slum district in Ahmedabad in the western state of Gujarat that had ...
When No News Isn\'t Good News: What the Decline of Newspapers Means for Government  GoverningAbout one in five Americans now lack regular access to local media coverage. Studies show this is bad for politics, municipal debt -- and even the environment.
Americans see politics as the biggest economic threat: survey  Yahoo FinancePolitics has dominated the American news cycle for the past three years, and it's now dominating people's economic concerns. According to a recent survey of ...
LGBT groups and tech companies warn that a Texas bill could cost the state billions  CNBCThe LGBTQ community and major technology companies in Texas say a bill passed by the state's Senate is a license to discriminate. The measure, known as ...
To truly fight climate change, we need to totally reinvent politics  Wired.co.ukHumanity is facing three serious threats: a crisis of governance, the return of great-power competition and global warming. In the next ten years we will need to ...
Should authenticity matter in politics?  POLITICOMost of the time people just use it as a rationalization for liking or disliking a candidate.”
Politics Without Parties  Foreign PolicyIt has become a truism that political parties are the fundamental political actors in modern democracies, where elections are usually considered the main way for ...
Trump spurs an uptick in politicians leaving the GOP  The Washington PostFor years, party-switching generally went mostly in the GOP's direction. That hasn't been the case under Trump -- and many who have left the party blame him.
Bernie Sanders vs. Democratic establishment: the case for chilling out  Vox.comHe has a long track record as a fairly banal, reasonably effective, and reasonably popular legislator.
The ‘On Politics’ Mueller Report Cheat Sheet  The New York TimesFrom the On Politics newsletter: The Times read all 448 pages of the special counsel's report, so you don't have to. Here are the highlights.
Spain's Political Deadlock Is Forever  Foreign PolicyIn February, Spain's embattled Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez announced his decision to hold an early general election on April 28, effectively putting his office ...
On Politics: Complete Coverage of the Mueller Report  The New York TimesThe full report from The Times on the release of the special counsel's findings on the Trump campaign and Russia's election interference.
Connecticut political feud escalates into dueling urine tests  Fox NewsSome political feuds end with an election. This one ended with a urine test. Two local lawmakers in the Connecticut city of Bridgeport spent the last week hurling ...
The politics of Easter is powerful. Let's not forget it  The GuardianJesus was considered an illegal by the ruling authorities of his day. We would do well to pay attention to who is being called a criminal today.
Brexit adds to Northern Ireland’s broken politics  POLITICO.euThe main achievement of the Good Friday Agreement — the creation of power-sharing institutions — is not just unwell, but perhaps terminally ill.
Why are top political parties silent on misogyny and motormouths?  Economic TimesThough Priyanka Chaturvedi quit Congress over it, parties remain quiet on misogyny. Sadhvi Pragya meanwhile joins a long list of BJP politicians who have ...
Take race politics out of the Education system warns Minister  FBC NewsSpeaking to members of the Fijian Teachers Association yesterday, Education Minister, Rosy Akbar says Fiji needs teachers with strong moral values that will ...
Rachel Johnson and Gavin Esler to stand for Change UK  The GuardianThe anti-Brexit party Change UK has launched its European elections campaign, revealing a slate of 70 candidates that includes Boris Johnson's sister, ...
Change UK election candidate steps down over offensive tweets  The GuardianA second Change UK candidate for the European elections has stepped down within 24 hours of being announced after offensive tweets he apparently sent ...
Politics | It’s demoralising to see women politicians purveying patriarchy  Moneycontrol.comSmriti Irani's reduction of Priyanka Gandhi to but a token represented by her husband and brother is a derisive mockery of her identity.
Will Being Granted Special Status Solve Bihar's Problems?  The WireThe phenomenon of intertwined class and caste based politics is something new to Bihar, but political parties have failed to understand it.
Federal election 2019: Labor pledges to set up inquiry into water buybacks – as it happened  The GuardianScott Morrison is in Darwin shoring up the Coalition's Senate spot while Bill Shorten is in Townsville with a plan to allow casuals to convert to more permanent ...
Smaller parties have a surprisingly big impact on British politics  The GuardianBy influencing the policies of Labour and the Tories, my party effects change, whatever the result, says Hannah Peaker of the Women's Equality Party.
GUEST ROOM | 'SNL' Is Terrible Political Comedy for Our Terrible Politics  Cornell University The Cornell Daily SunSNL's political voice is in shambles, rendered toothless by the farcical politics of the Trump era.
How the Supreme Court’s Decision on the Census Could Alter American Politics  The New York TimesThe Supreme Court is reviewing whether 2020 census respondents should say whether they are citizens. Political maps based only on the citizen population ...
Leon: SA currently battling bad economics, very bad politics  EWNFormer DA leader Tony Leon told Eyewitness News it was an 'interesting coincidence' that both him and former President Thabo Mbeki campaigned for their ...
In Push for 2020 Election Security, Top Official Was Warned: Don’t Tell Trump  The New York TimesWASHINGTON — In the months before Kirstjen Nielsen was forced to resign, she tried to focus the White House on one of her highest priorities as homeland ...
PMQs understudies shine as MPs suffer collective brain fade  The GuardianDavid Lidington very capably reassured MPs that ministers had no immediate plans to do anything.
Full Show: Bidding War For Anadarko, And Ageism In Politics (April 24, 2019)  Houston Public MediaOn Wednesday's Houston Matters: A bidding war for Anadarko, our weekly political roundup, the age of political candidates, and HGO's world premiere of The ...
Bay Area political events: Legal marijuana, housing crisis  San Francisco ChronicleUpcoming political events in the Bay Area: WEDNESDAY. Legal marijuana: Is legalization of recreational use of marijuana a good idea? Panelists talk about the ...
Elizabeth Warren: Impeachment not about politics  CNNDuring a CNN town hall at St. Anselm College, 2020 Democratic party presidential hopeful Sen. Elizabeth Warren lays out why calling for President Donald ...
The Double-Edged Sword of 'SNL' and its Politics  PajibaA recent poll conducted in part by The Hollywood Reporter found that 39% of participants believed that Saturday Night Live had 'gotten too political' since ...
Politics of Election Manifestos  Economic and Political WeeklyNot only the actionable promises, but also the ideological *content* of the manifestos deserve scrutiny.
Steve King thinks he was persecuted for his political beliefs. He is not alone among conservative Christians.  The Washington PostComments from Rep. Steve King (R-Iowa) about being able to relate better to Jesus Christ after the lawmaker was accused of embracing racist views have ...
The Road to 2024: Youth Party Politics in America  Harvard Political ReviewOn January 20, 2017, Donald J. Trump became America's oldest first-term president ever, taking the oath of office at age 70. By the time the 2020 presidential ...
Joe Biden to enter 2020 presidential race with Thursday video announcement  The Washington PostFormer vice president Joe Biden is planning to enter the 2020 presidential race on Thursday, nearly finalizing the crowded field of Democrats with a candidacy ...
Arif Mohammad Khan: 'After politics, people will see the importance of Triple Talak Law and thank Modi for it, Nehru too would be pleased with Modi'  DailyOArif Mohammed Khan, former Union Minister in Rajiv Gandhi's govt, who famously resigned at the overturning of the Shah Bano judgment, spoke with Rohit E ...
State of the states: Adani, economics and personality politics  The Conversation AUOur “state of the states” series takes stock of the key issues, seats and policies affecting the vote in each of Australia's states. We'll check in with our expert ...
'I'm not a traitor, you are!' Political argument from the Founding Fathers to today's partisans  The Conversation - USUS history is filled with instances where one partisan side charges that the other side's positions will lead to national ruin. Now, both sides accuse the other of ...
On Politics: Mayor Pete, the College Years  The New York TimesThe roots of Pete Buttigieg's campaign for president can be found in his college writings, where he showed a fixation with the power of personality in politics.
Indian election 2019: Tamil Nadu restaurants shun politics talk  QuartzIt's frequent enough, in restaurants and cafés from Brooklyn to Delhi, to read signs announcing some variation of “no wi-fi, talk to each other.” In the southern ...
Politics over PM Modi's nukes not for Diwali remark  India TodayPeoples Democratic Party (PDP) chief Mehbooba Mufti on Monday accused Prime Minister Narendra Modi of lowering the standard of political discourse by his ...
Politics this week  The EconomistAfter almost two years investigating Russian interference in America's presidential election of 2016, Robert Mueller presented his report to William Barr, the ...
'Anything but politics': Election cuts no ice in Menzies' Mallee hometown  The AgeWhile the politicians are out chasing every vote, Tony Wright is on a journey of his own, meeting with ordinary Australians across regional Victoria.
The backstabbing brutality of Game of Thrones has taken over politics  The GuardianPolitics is a more visceral and primitive thing – The West Wing was a much better influence.
Caught in Political Mayhem, Canadian Farmers Cut Back on Canola  BloombergPolitics are having an unusually large impact in Canada's farming world this year as producers cut back on canola, durum wheat, soybean and lentil acres, ...
Actor Sunny Deol jumps into politics, joins BJP  Business Insider IndiaVeteran Bollywood actor Sunny Deol on Tuesday entered active politics, joining the Bharatiya Janata Party. Sixty two-year old Deol will likely fight from ...
Decision on politicians invoking armed forces in campaigning soon: EC sources  Economic TimesNew Delhi: The Election Commission will "soon" take a decision on complaints regarding political leaders invoking armed forces in campaigns, highly-placed ...
Dori Monson Faith and politics -- a dish best served separately?  MyNorthwest.comPoliticians often tie faith and politics together, but one former Bush administration member believes that Americans should be more careful about this.
Syracuse launches program to train veterans in political careers  Military TimesVeterans will learn valuable skills like campaign planning, fundraising, developing an issues platform and crafting policy.
Singh says childhood abuse steeled him for scrutiny and stress of politics  CityNews TorontoNDP Leader Jagmeet Singh said he decided to “take a chance” and share his story of childhood sexual abuse in hopes of helping other victims. He recounted ...
Politics or Principle: Congress Must Decide  The BulwarkWhat next? Now that both the American people and Congress have the Mueller report, what should be done? Or more acutely, now that Congress has this ...
Opinion | David Shribman: The dispiriting lockstep of political opinion  The Boston GlobeOur political figures are stuck perhaps more than ever in their own worlds and in their own words.
Politics as playground: Sportspersons who turned politicians - The Gambhir politics  Economic TimesFormer international cricketer Gautam Gambhir made his debut in politics as he joined BJP and is likely to be fielded from New Delhi constituency in the Lok ...
Only in Kerala: Twitter Hails Rare Photo of 'Political Amity' after Phase 3 of Polling  News18The viral image depicts a car which is riding on the road with all its windows and its hatch open. The occupants of the car can be seen waving the flags of three ...
Learning Barrio Politics at the Burning of Judas  Caracas Chronicles“Last year, we were attacked by colectivos because we were burning Maduro,” says Romel Martínez, Acción Democrática activist and community leader of El ...
Why I Am Not Voting for the BJP  The WireAn educationist looks back to his days as a schoolboy and the enduring lesson he learned about not looking at another human being only through the lens of ...
Secretive hard-Brexit Facebook campaign got 1m responses  The GuardianA million Britons responded to a secretive Facebook campaign for a hard Brexit overseen by Lynton Crosby's company, according to the information ...
Akshay Kumar's cryptic tweet sparks political speculation, actor says he is not contesting elections  Economic TimesMUMBAI: Bollywood star Akshay Kumar on Monday said he is getting into "unknown and uncharted territory" with something he had not done before, sparking ...
'Avengers Endgame': The not-so-hidden environmental politics of Marvel's apocalyptic blockbuster  CNBCTickets to the opening night of Marvel Studios' "Avengers: Endgame" are not the only scarce commodity involving the film. As the Avengers (at least some of ...
Tim Cook says that Apple donates $0 to political candidates and that he refuses to have a PAC because they 'shouldn't exist'  Business InsiderWhile Apple doesn't try to get particular politicians elected, it still spend millions annually on lobbying, records show.
From Kerala to Delhi, Bengali migrant workers have a place everywhere. Just not in Bengal’s politics  Scroll.inThe ruling Trinamool Congress takes notice only when a migrant is killed or murdered, especially in a BJP-ruled state.
How To Keep Things Civil (Or Not) When It Comes To Politics  NPRDon't talk politics with strangers, we're told. But these days, conversations with even those closest to us can be fraught. How are friends, families keeping things ...
Candid and completely non-political: Akshay Kumar to engage in a chat with PM Modi today  Economic TimesMUMBAI: A day after Akshay Kumar said he would be getting into an "unknown and uncharted territory" with something he had not done before, the Bollywood ...
Labour says Theresa May unwilling to offer key Brexit concessions  The GuardianLabour has accused Theresa May of failing to offer any substantive changes to her Brexit deal in cross-party talks, as Downing Street's hopes of a breakthrough ...
The Atlantic Politics & Policy Daily: Free-(College)-For-All  The AtlanticElizabeth Warren has a plan to cancel student debt, make public college free, and create a fund for HBCUs. Plus: Seth Moulton is officially running for president.
Change UK: ‘we’re the natural home of the remain alliance’  The GuardianNew party says it has received more than 1000 applications to stand in Europe elections from defectors from other parties.
Hogan, in New Hampshire, says he’s seriously considering a primary challenge to Trump  The Washington PostMANCHESTER, N.H. — Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan said Tuesday he is seriously considering a primary challenge to President Trump, saying the president ...
The Problem With High-Minded Politics  The AtlanticJohn Adams and John Quincy Adams's virtuous disdain for partisanship was at the root of their failures.
Week In Politics: Health Care, Southern Border  NPRWith the Mueller investigation behind him, President Trump has had a renewed focus on policy, from health care to Venezuela.
News Analysis: Arvind Kejriwal and 'all or nothing' politics  The HinduAAP's position on alliance with the Congress is not consistent with the objective that it claims - which is to weaken the BJP. Hence, a scrutiny of its position is ...
Bret Easton Ellis, the political outrage machine who has never voted for president  The Washington PostNEW YORK — Bret Easton Ellis wants you to know that he cares squat about politics. “I just cannot get that worked up over the absurdity of the president,” he ...
The Memo: Harris move shows shift in politics of gun control | TheHill  The HillSen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.) is the latest Democrat to demonstrate just how much the politics of gun control are shifting.
How the IRS Gave Up Fighting Political Dark Money Groups  ProPublicaSix years after it was excoriated for allegedly targeting conservative organizations, the agency has largely given up on regulating an entire category of nonprofits ...
Original Content podcast: On ‘Guava Island,’ Donald Glover mixes music and politics  TechCrunchIt was hard to know what to expect from “Guava Island.” Last year, Donald Glover and Rihanna filmed the mysterious project with director Hiro Murai (who's also ...
Tragedy and politics on Prince Edward Island  National ObserverElections on Prince Edward Island tend to be as predictable as the tides. In the 146 years since the province's first election after Confederation, just two parties ...

A Look Ahead to 2008 (Part I)

Just as everyone has breathed a sigh of relief at... Read More

Starbucks Monopoly

Is Starbucks a monopoly? It fits all the definitions. Does... Read More

The Morality of Using Stem Cells

One third of all fertilized eggs spontaneously abort and are... Read More

Is Inflation Harmful

Q. Should the Government be concerned if the CPI rises... Read More

Why the United States just doesnt get the United Nations

For years I have been amazed as I've listened to... Read More

Just War

In an age of terrorism, guerilla and total warfare the... Read More

Canning International Terrorists? Literally

Well here is a great new product, we first saw... Read More

A Component of Liberty is a Strong Social Contract with Governing Body

Recently I got to talking with a gentleman at a... Read More

Clearing Land Mine Fields from the Air

You know we have sent many, many army tanks with... Read More

Oil Prices Effect The United States Competitiveness

Just because we have been leading the World in innovation... Read More

Economics and Politics of Regional Droughts

It cities across America water is an issue, the flow... Read More

Wartime Britain & Things Look Bleak

This is the second of a series of four articles... Read More

Hawala, or The Bank That Never Was

I. OVERVIEWIn the wake of the September 11 terrorist attacks... Read More

Federal Trade Commission and Dismal Performance on Mergers

Most citizens agree that we need the Federal Trade Commission... Read More

Fuel Prices on the Rise

With gasoline prices at the pump climbing strongly into the... Read More

Free Markets, Wal-Mart, Over Regulation; What an interesting concept?

Unions are angry at the high salary of the executives... Read More

Truckers Take Some Hits and Keep On Trucking

After 9-11 insurance rates on Independent Truck Drivers and smaller... Read More

Mother Russia and Poland

When Boris Yeltsin spoke about an experiment that 'they' wrought... Read More

Pilot-Less and High Speed Train Transportation Systems; Better Strategy Needed

We recently saw another ferry accident, this one in NY... Read More

End Of History? Not Quite

A visitor to Moscow would be immediately struck by the... Read More

Discount Cigarettes and Cheap Tobacco from Europe to the UK

It never fails to amaze me. HM Customs and Excise... Read More

The G-8 and Other Figureheads

The Presidents Before Washington:From the moment that the first Declaration... Read More

Federal Trade Commission Partnerships Questioned

In many reports we see that the Federal Trade Commission... Read More

Going All Out to Win a War

Conventional warfare is getting to its limits. Soon wars will... Read More

Maryland Lawyers and Politicians Want More Regulations

We know that in Maryland, which some call "Merry Land"... Read More