Public Procurement and Very Private Benefits

In every national budget, there is a part called "Public Procurement". This is the portion of the budget allocated to purchasing services and goods for the various ministries, authorities and other arms of the executive branch. It was the famous management consultant, Parkinson, who once wrote that government officials are likely to approve a multi-billion dollar nuclear power plant much more speedily that they are likely to authorize a hundred dollar expenditure on a bicycle parking device. This is because everyone came across 100 dollar situations in real life - but precious few had the fortune to expend with billions of USD.

This, precisely, is the problem with public procurement: people are too acquainted with the purchased items. They tend to confuse their daily, household-type, decisions with the processes and considerations which should permeate governmental decision making. They label perfectly legitimate decisions as "corrupt" - and totally corrupt procedures as "legal" or merely "legitimate", because this is what was decreed by the statal mechanisms, or because "this is the law".

Procurement is divided to defence and non-defence spending. In both these categories - but, especially in the former - there are grave, well founded, concerns that things might not be all what they seem to be.

Government - from India's to Sweden's to Belgium's - fell because of procurement scandals which involved bribes paid by manufacturers or service providers either to individual in the service of the state or to political parties. Other, lesser cases, litter the press daily. In the last few years only, the burgeoning defence sector in Israel saw two such big scandals: the developer of Israel's missiles was involved in one (and currently is serving a jail sentence) and Israel's military attache to Washington was implicated - though, never convicted - in yet another.

But the picture is not that grim. Most governments in the West succeeded in reigning in and fully controlling this particular budget item. In the USA, this part of the budget remained constant in the last 35(!) years at 20% of the GDP.

There are many problems with public procurement. It is an obscure area of state activity, agreed upon in "customized" tenders and in dark rooms through a series of undisclosed agreements. At least, this is the public image of these expenditures.

The truth is completely different.

True, some ministers use public money to build their private "empires". It could be a private business empire, catering to the financial future of the minister, his cronies and his relatives. These two plagues - cronyism and nepotism - haunt public procurement. The spectre of government official using public money to benefit their political allies or their family members - haunts public imagination and provokes public indignation.

Then, there are problems of plain corruption: bribes or commissions paid to decision makers in return for winning tenders or awarding of economic benefits financed by the public money. Again, sometimes these moneys end in secret bank accounts in Switzerland or in Luxembourg. At other times, they finance political activities of political parties. This was rampantly abundant in Italy and has its place in France. The USA, which was considered to be immune from such behaviours - has proven to be less so, lately, with the Bill Clinton alleged election financing transgressions.

But, these, with all due respect to "clean hands" operations and principles, are not the main problems of public procurement.

The first order problem is the allocation of scarce resources. In other words, prioritizing. The needs are enormous and ever growing. The US government purchases hundreds of thousands of separate items from outside suppliers. Just the list of these goods - not to mention their technical specifications and the documentation which accompanies the transactions - occupies tens of thick volumes. Supercomputers are used to manage all these - and, even so, it is getting way out of hand. How to allocate ever scarcer resources amongst these items is a daunting - close to impossible - task. It also, of course, has a political dimension. A procurement decision reflects a political preference and priority. But the decision itself is not always motivated by rational - let alone noble - arguments. More often, it is the by product and end result of lobbying, political hand bending and extortionist muscle. This raises a lot of hackles among those who feel that were kept out of the pork barrel. They feel underprivileged and discriminated against. They fight back and the whole system finds itself in a quagmire, a nightmare of conflicting interests. Last year, the whole budget in the USA was stuck - not approved by Congress - because of these reactions and counter-reactions.

The second problem is the supervision, auditing and control of actual spending. This has two dimensions:

  • How to make sure that the expenditures match and do not exceed the budgetary items. In some countries, this is a mere ritual formality and government departments are positively expected to overstep their procurement budgets. In others, this constitutes a criminal offence.

  • How to prevent the criminally corrupt activities that we have described above - or even the non criminal incompetent acts which government officials are prone to do.

The most widespread method is the public, competitive, tender for the purchases of goods and services.

But, this is not as simple as it sounds.

Some countries publish international tenders, striving to secure the best quality in the cheapest price - no matter what is its geographical or political source. Other countries are much more protectionist (notably: Japan and France) and they publish only domestic tenders, in most cases. A domestic tender is open only to domestic bidders. Yet other countries limit participation in the tenders on various backgrounds: the size of the competing company, its track record, its ownership structure, its human rights or environmental record and so on. Some countries publish the minutes of the tender committee (which has to explain WHY it selected this or that supplier). Others keep it a closely guarded secret ("to protect commercial interests and secrets").

But all countries state in advance that they have no obligation to accept any kind of offer - even if it is the cheapest. This is a needed provision: the cheapest is not necessarily the best. The cheapest offer could be coming from a very unreliable supplier with a bad past performance or a criminal record or from a supplier who offers goods of shoddy quality.

The tendering policies of most of the countries in the world also incorporates a second principle: that of "minimum size". The cost of running a tender is prohibitive in the cases of purchases in small amounts.

Even if there is corruption in such purchases it is bound to cause less damage to the public purse than the costs of the tender which is supposed to prevent it!

So, in most countries, small purchases can be authorized by government officials - larger amounts go through a tedious, multi-phase tendering process. Public competitive bidding is not corruption-proof: many times officials and bidders collude and conspire to award the contract against bribes and other, noncash, benefits. But we still know of no better way to minimize the effects of human greed.

Procurement policies, procedures and tenders are supervised by state auditing authorities. The most famous is, probably, the General Accounting Office, known by its acronym: the GAO.

It is an unrelenting, very thorough and dangerous watchdog of the administration. It is considered to be highly effective in reducing procurement - related irregularities and crimes. Another such institutions the Israeli State Reviser. What is common to both these organs of the state is that they have very broad authority. They possess (by law) judicial and criminal prosecution powers and they exercise it without any hesitation. They have the legal obligation to review the operations and financial transactions of all the other organs of the executive branch. Their teams select, each year, the organs to be reviewed and audited. They collect all pertinent documents and correspondence. They cross the information that they receive from elsewhere. They ask very embarrassing questions and they do it under the threat of perjury prosecutions. They summon witnesses and they publish damning reports which, in many cases, lead to criminal prosecutions.

Another form of review of public procurement is through powers granted to the legislative arm of the state (Congress, Parliament, Bundestag, or Knesset). In almost every country in the world, the elected body has its own procurement oversight committee. It supervises the expenditures of the executive branch and makes sure that they conform to the budget. The difference between such supervisory, parliamentary, bodies and their executive branch counterparts - is that they feel free to criticize public procurement not only in the context of its adherence to budget constraints or its cleanliness - but also in a political context. In other words, these committees do not limit themselves to asking HOW - but also engage in asking WHY. Why this specific expense in this given time and location - and not that expense, somewhere else or some other time. These elected bodies feel at liberty - and often do - intervene in the very decision making process and in the order of priorities. They have the propensity to alter both quite often.

The most famous such committee is, arguably, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO). It is famous because it is non-partisan and technocratic in nature. It is really made of experts which staff its offices.

Its apparent - and real - neutrality makes its judgements and recommendations a commandment not to be avoided and, almost universally, to be obeyed. The CBO operates for and on behalf of the American Congress and is, really, the research arm of that venerable parliament. Parallelly, the executive part of the American system - the Administration - has its own guard against waste and worse: the Office of Management and Budget (OMB).

Both bodies produce learned, thickset, analyses, reports, criticism, opinions and recommendations. Despite quite a prodigious annual output of verbiage - they are so highly regarded, that virtually anything that they say (or write) is minutely analysed and implemented to the last letter with an air of awe.

Only a few other parliaments have committees that carry such weight. The Israeli Knesset have the extremely powerful Finance Committee which is in charge of all matters financial, from appropriations to procurement. Another parliament renowned for its tight scrutiny is the French Parliament - though it retains very few real powers.

But not all countries chose the option of legislative supervision. Some of them relegated parts or all of these functions to the executive arm.

In Japan, the Ministry of Finance still scrutinizes (and has to authorize) the smallest expense, using an army of clerks. These clerks became so powerful that they have the theoretical potential to secure and extort benefits stemming from the very position that they hold. Many of them suspiciously join companies and organizations which they supervised or to which they awarded contracts - immediately after they leave their previous, government, positions. The Ministry of Finance is subject to a major reform in the reform-bent government of Prime Minister Hashimoto. The Japanese establishment finally realized that too much supervision, control, auditing and prosecution powers might be a Pyrrhic victory: it might encourage corruption - rather than discourage it.

Britain opted to keep the discretion to use public funds and the clout that comes with it in the hands of the political level. This is a lot like the relationship between the butter and the cat left to guard it. Still, this idiosyncratic British arrangement works surprisingly well. All public procurement and expenditure items are approved by the EDX Committee of the British Cabinet (=inner, influential, circle of government) which is headed by the Ministry of Finance. Even this did not prove enough to restrain the appetites of Ministers, especially as quid pro quo deals quickly developed. So, now the word is that the new Labour Prime Minister will chair it- enabling him to exert his personal authority on matters of public money.

Britain, under the previous, Tory, government also pioneered an interesting and controversial incentive system for its public servants as top government officials are euphemistically called there. They receive, added to their salaries, a portion of the savings that they effect in their departmental budgets. This means that they get a small fraction of the end of the fiscal year difference between their budget allowances and what they actually spent. This is very useful in certain segments of government activity - but could prove very problematic in others. Imagine health officials saving on medicines, or others saving on road maintenance or educational consumables. This, naturally, will not do.

Needless to say that no country officially approves of the payment of bribes or commission to officials in charge of public spending, however remote the connection is between the payment and the actions.

Yet, law aside many countries accept the intertwining of elites - business and political - as a fact of life, albeit a sad one. Many judicial systems in the world even make a difference between a payment which is not connected to an identifiable or discernible benefit and those that are. The latter - and only the latter - are labelled "bribery".

Where there is money - there is wrongdoing. Humans are humans - and sometimes not even that.

But these unfortunate derivatives of social activity can be minimized by the adoption of clear procurement policies, transparent and public decision making processes and the right mix of supervision, auditing and prosecution. Even then the result is bound to be dubious, at best.

About The Author

Sam Vaknin is the author of "Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited" and "After the Rain - How the West Lost the East". He is a columnist in "Central Europe Review", United Press International (UPI) and ebookweb.org and the editor of mental health and Central East Europe categories in The Open Directory, Suite101 and searcheurope.com. Until recently, he served as the Economic Advisor to the Government of Macedonia.

His web site: http://samvak.tripod.com

In The News:

Nancy Pelosi’s Political Flex  The New York TimesIn the On Politics newsletter, Nancy Pelosi has been showing her political muscle, provoking the president, penalizing the politicians who crossed her and ...
Your Politics Podcast - Brexit gets bumpy  RTE.ieAs Britain lurches closer to a no-deal Brexit, Aine Lawlor is joined by Political Correspondent Paul Cunningham, who has been covering the dramatic ...
'Does Only BJP Own Cows?' AAP, Congress Make Foray Into Bovine Politics as Elections Near  News18The newly formed Congress government in Rajasthan had recently announced that it would honour people who adopt stray cows, on Independence Day and ...
Diane Abbott accuses BBC Question Time of legitimising racism  The GuardianDiane Abbott has accused BBC Question Time of legitimising racist abuse after claims that the shadow home secretary was singled out before and during ...
Three Authors Consider Contemporary Politics, Anxiously  The New York TimesNew books examine disturbing trends in modern American society.
Politics Q&A: What happens now and how did Sweden get here?  The Local SwedenFor those of you trying to wrap your heads around the political situation in Sweden, here are the answers to the questions you might have.
Prashant Kishor’s Revamp of Bihar Student Politics Has JD(U) Renting Hotels to Prevent Defection  News18JD(U), which did not participate in the student union election last year, is contesting on all posts on this occasion. A local hotel has been rented in the city to ...
In A Chaotic Week For U.K. Politics, What's Next For Brexit?  NPRHere's what to know about key issues during this extraordinary and chaotic moment in British politics. The U.K.'s deadline to leave the European Union is March ...
Liberal senator gets Chicago consul-general job after quitting politics  The GuardianDavid Bushby's new appointment draws criticism from political opponents.
Trump's war on science: how the US is putting politics above evidence  The GuardianExperts say the administration is blatantly dismantling proven programs, and the consequences could be dire.
Tan Cheng Bock applies to form new Progress Singapore Party  The Straits TimesSINGAPORE - Former presidential candidate Tan Cheng Bock has applied to form a new political party.. Read more at straitstimes.com.
Technology near for real-time TV political fact checks  Virginian-PilotNEW YORK (AP) — A Duke University team expects to have a product available for election year that will allow television networks to offer real-time fact checks ...
Boris Johnson digs into the Donald Trump playbook  The GuardianReturn of the Slobbit, a tired film franchise, rolled its package of lies into the JCB factory.
Andrew Gillum, as he mulls future political plans, heads to Harvard  Tampa Bay TimesAndrew Gillum, the former Tallahassee mayor who narrowly lost in the race for Florida governor last year, is heading to Cambridge as he mulls his political future ...
The week of turmoil: How Downing Street calculated 228-vote defeat...but are determined to plough on regardless  Telegraph.co.ukIt was a resounding cheer that spoke volumes about the disconnect between politicians and the public they are elected to serve. At the end of a tumultuous week ...
UNC, Michigan State show how partisan politics is infiltrating university governance  Inside Higher EdAs disputes at North Carolina and Michigan State take partisan overtones, can boards, leaders, faculty members and lawmakers back away from polarization to ...
'Politics with Amy Walter' on the Friday Takeaway  Minnesota Public Radio News'Politics with Amy Walter' on the Friday Takeaway. The federal government is at an immigration impasse. The longest shutdown of the government in US history ...
Breezy And Irreverent 'Brexit' Captures Big Truths About Today's Politics  NPRBenedict Cumberbatch stars as the top strategist for Britain's "Leave" campaign in a new HBO film that offers a jaunty — if incomplete — take on the U.K.'s ...
Parenting through political activism: What's the impact on children when they grow up?  Appleton Post CrescentParents explain why they engage their kids early in political activism. Psychologists explain the impact.
Brigade Parade Ground: A tale of mammoth rallies, emotion, political statements  Economic TimesKOLKATA: From hosting public reception for Soviet leaders Nikita Khrushchev and Nikolai Bulganin to holding mammoth political rallies -- many of them on ...
No-deal Brexit could stem the supply of Mother's Day flowers  The GuardianMeet Brexit's latest potential victim: the Mother's Day bouquet. While the tumult in Westminster is keeping political pundits in clover, the decision by MPs to vote ...
Brexiters optimistic that May will stand firm on customs union  The GuardianBrexiter Conservatives and the Democratic Unionist party emerged upbeat from their meetings with Theresa May in Downing Street, convinced that the prime ...
Week In Politics: Trump Cancels Pelosi Trip To Afghanistan  WBURPresident Trump cancelled House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's trip to Afghanistan after she sent him a letter asking him to postpone the State of the Union address.
Law of Karma: After embracing desi style politics United Kingdom may be headed for partition too  Times of IndiaParliament is broken, we say in India. These days they say it more often in fair Britain, now looking distinctly less so. This week's goings-on have left sober ...
Revealed: UK patients stockpile drugs in fear of no-deal Brexit  The GuardianMinisters have been urged by top doctors to reveal the extent of national drug stocks, amid growing evidence patients are stockpiling medication in preparation ...
In South Kashmir, Mehbooba Mufti revives the politics of mourning to win back support for PDP  Scroll.inThe former chief minister was once known for calling on families of militants to mourn with them. She has now resumed these visits.
'Just stop messing about': Hastings aghast at Brexit impasse  The GuardianWhether leavers or remainers, few in the town have good things to say about feuding politicians.
No to politics in Sinulog: Cebu City removes Imee Marcos posters  ABS-CBN NewsCebu City has taken down a poster of Imee Marcos for supposedly politicizing the religious festival 'Sinulog.'
The New York Times politics editor is building trust by tweeting context around political stories  Nieman Journalism Lab at HarvardYou can guess the kinds of complaints The New York Times gets about its political coverage. It's too biased, too liberal. Too much coverage of the horserace, not ...
At inaugural, Hogan calls for government ‘more noble than the politics of today’  Washington PostMaryland Gov. Larry Hogan used his second inaugural address on Wednesday to decry the divisiveness of Washington politics, implicitly criticizing President ...
How Business and Politics Intersect in India's Porous State  The WireAn excerpt from 'India's Porous State: Blurred Boundaries and the Evolving Business-State Relationship in India'.
Pig Politics: Episode 2  New Zealand HeraldIn this second episode of a four-part series, some people love the pigs while others are incredibly frustrated. Next episode on Tuesday.
May calls on MPs from all parties to 'put self-interest aside' – as it happened  The GuardianGovernment defeats Labour's no-confidence motion with 325 to 306 votes amid uncertainty over next steps.
Billboard campaign reminds voters of MPs' Brexit promises  The GuardianBillboard posters featuring quotes by Theresa May and Brexiter MPs have gone up around Dover as part of a “guerrilla advertising” campaign designed to ...
The #10yearchallenge, but for politics  CNNWashington (CNN) The #10yearchallenge is the hottest trend sweeping Instagram, where users posts photos of themselves 10 years apart. Politicians aren't ...
Parliament is no more diverse now than it was in 1988 as political staffer ranks explode  The Sydney Morning HeraldParliament is also in a time warp culturally and ethnically, a new study has found.
Consumers Say Brands Shouldn’t Bring Politics to the Super Bowl  Wall Street JournalTwo-thirds of consumers call the Super Bowl an inappropriate place for advertisers to make political statements, according to a poll conducted by Morning ...
Jeremy Corbyn’s politics are the ultimate manifestation of the ‘nirvana fallacy’  Telegraph.co.ukWe must now think the unthinkable. Such is the Brexit train wreck, the possibility of Jeremy Corbyn as prime minister has increased significantly. Imagine ...
Aww...Outpouring of support for Arun Jaitley shows politics bas ek khel nahin hai  India TodayWhen shows of goodwill and bonhomie replace the daily mudslinging, we get a glimpse of the truth: politics isn't usually personal.
Karnataka political crisis deepens; Four Congress MLAs may resign today  Economic TimesThe Congress-JD(S) coalition in Karnataka received its first jolt on Tuesday with two independent MLAs withdrawing support to the HD Kumaraswamy-led ...
The Political Benefits of Shutting It Down  The New York TimesIn the On Politics newsletter, a look at why both sides may be hesitant to reach a deal on the shutdown. Plus, fact-checking the president's border talk and an ...
Is Cow Politics Working in Uttar Pradesh?  NewsClickIn this special episode of Hafte Ki Baat, Senior Jounralist Urmilesh picks up the issue of cow menace in Uttar Pradesh.
BBC criticised for sticking with football over PM's Brexit speech  The GuardianThe BBC's former television news chief has criticised the corporation after it chose to continue showing an FA Cup match on BBC One rather than covering the ...
How Donald Trump's political landscape is actually perfect for Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez  CNNAt first glance, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has zero in common with President Donald Trump.
‘Think how bad of a husband you have to be to act this way’: Trump’s campaign manager unloads on George Conway  Washington PostA tweet by Brad Parscale took aim at the spouse of White House counselor Kellyanne Conway, a frequent critic of the president.
Take politics out of education, says teachers' union leader  CBC.caThe head of New Brunswick's teachers' union says the voices of teachers have finally been heard, following the release of a report by the auditor general calling ...
What are the alternatives to May's rejected Brexit deal?  The GuardianAfter Tuesday night's crushing defeat for Theresa May's Brexit deal, there is perhaps one thing on which almost all MPs can agree: there is no obvious ...
Yalitza Aparicio of ‘Roma’ and the Politics of Stardom in Mexico  The New York TimesThe film's star was on her way to being a teacher when she landed the role. Now she's part of a conversation about Indigenous people and inequality.
It's raining ‘federal fronts’: KTR-Jagan meeting muddies alliance politics, triggers conspiracy theories  Times NowA meeting between Telangana CM K Chandrashekar Rao's son KT Rama Rao and Andhra Pradesh's Opposition leader Jaganmohan Reddy has rekindled talk ...
DA trying to 'score political points' with #TheANCIsKillingUs billboard - Amcu  IOLAmcu said that a controversial billboard erected by the DA in central Johannesburg on Wednesday was a way of "scoring political points".
Shannon Phillips gets applause in Lethbridge on Bighorn, politics  CBC.caWith an election on the horizon, some voters in Lethbridge are already looking for answers ahead of a vote that is likely months away.
Jeremy Corbyn tables no-confidence motion after May defeat – as it happened  The GuardianPrime minister's Brexit deal is lost by 432 votes to 202.
Facebook tracks everything from your politics to ethnicity — here's how to stop it  New York Post Facebook has promised more transparency about ads on its platform, but the majority of users are still in the dark about the kind of information that's been ...
Post-truth politics is alive and well in Brexit Britain  CNNBrexit might actually get interesting. After two years of screaming into the wind, the UK's elected lawmakers finally get to do something useful.
I will never join any political party, says actor Prakash Raj  Moneycontrol.comRaj said he had decided to contest the election as an Independent from the Bengaluru-Central constituency as "I cannot stay in any party for more than three ...
PX column: Ex-Congresswoman Jean Schmidt makes a comeback in politics, launches 2020 campaign  Cincinnati.comEx-Congresswoman Jean Schmidt is ending her hiatus from politics. The Clermont County Republican has launched her 2020 campaign for this office.
Bangkok’s First Biennale: Politics, Temples and Sex  The New York TimesBANGKOK — In the waning weeks of this city's first biennale, original artwork continues to grace riversides, temples and shopping malls where tourists might not ...
Karnataka: Political war erupts as BJP, Cong-JDS allege poaching of MLAs  Economic TimesA *fresh* political war erupted in Karnataka Monday as the ruling Congress-JDS coalition and BJP accused each other of making a renewed bid to poach MLAs, ...
Trump points to a migrant caravan and unverified claim about Muslim prayer rugs as he continues push for wall  Washington PostThe president's arguments, in morning tweets, represented his latest attempt to portray a security crisis at the border using what Democrats have derided as ...
Resist the Lure of Theological Politics  The AtlanticInstead of applying religious certainty to public debates, Americans need to take a different lesson from their faith traditions.
Brexit: Theresa May's deal is voted down in historic Commons defeat  BBC NewsPrime Minister Theresa May's Brexit deal has been rejected by 230 votes - the largest defeat for a sitting government in history. MPs voted by 432 votes to 202 to ...
MALCOLM: Raced-based politics natural outcome of Trudeau's 'postnational state'  Toronto SunThis is what a postnational multicultural state looks like.On Wednesday, the Liberal candidate in the Burnaby South by-election resigned after sending a ...
Mamata Banerjee's mega opposition rally: New UP political alignment to reflect on Bengal stage  Moneycontrol.comHundreds of kilometers away from Uttar Pradesh, the state's new political alignment will reflect in full glory here on Saturday at the mega anti-BJP rally being ...
The Politics of Roma: Alfonso Cuaron Revisits Mexico's Turbulent History  Hollywood ReporterDirector Alfonso Cuaron and star Yalitza Aparicio guide The Hollywood Reporter through the city's Roma neighborhood as they break down how the political ...
VIDEO | 2019 State of the State: Carney touches on politics for the people, climate change, hints at state employee pay raise  WDEL 1150AMFrom climate change to education funding improvements to reducing recidivism rates and continuing pay raises for state employees, Gov. John Carney's 2019 ...
The digital activist taking politicians out of Madrid politics  BBC NewsOne file-sharing developer turned politician wants to hand decisions over to the people of Madrid.
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Is Setting Women Back Light Years In Politics  The FederalistVox dubbed her “the most buzzed-about first-term member of the House of Representatives,” and The Atlantic credited her with an “unusually transparent ...
Why No Deal Is the Real Deal: Brexit and the Politics of the Interregnum  The NationLeaving the European Union is the necessary goal of the left in Britain.
Shah Faesal wants to disrupt, reimagine politics in Kashmir  Economic TimesSRINAGAR: Shah Faesal, the 2009 civil *service* exam topper from Kashmir who has recently resigned from the *service*, on Friday said he wants to fight elections ...
In Assamese Singer's Protest, a Sign That BJP's Politics in Assam Has Run Aground  The WireAcross the North-East, the Centre is being questioned for attempting to blur the lines that differentiate communal and community consciousness.
'It's a shambles': the view from the country on Brexit now  The GuardianIn the wake of Tuesday's night's crushing defeat in the House of Commons for Theresa May's Brexit deal, we spoke to voters in three places that voted very ...
Republicans and Democrats Agree: They’re Winning!  U.S. News & World ReportOne factor working against a resolution of the ongoing partial government shutdown is that both sides think they have the other right where they want them.
Never mind her politics, Kate Bush’s music speaks for itself  The GuardianThe singer was wrongly branded a Tory, but why does it matter how our pop idols vote, asks freelance arts writer Fiona Sturges.
Yoursay: Political will and courage needed to turn tide of bigotry  MalaysiakiniYOURSAY | 'Harapan must do more to open rakyat's minds so we don't live in 'fear' of fellow citizens.'
Corey Stewart, the firebrand Virginia Republican, will leave politics in December  Washington PostStewart won't seek a fourth term as Prince William board chairman and says he'll stay out of state politics “for the foreseeable future.”
On the border, Trump turns political in making case for his wall  NBCNews.comWearing a MAGA hat and harshly criticizing Democrats, President Donald Trump made the case for a border wall near the U.S.-Mexico line Thursday.
Trudeau Says Politics Won't Factor Into Huawei 5G Decision  TIMECanada's Prime Minister said the decision on allowing Huawei to access to its next-generation wireless network won't be a political one.
5 heartwarming moments in politics, even in 2018  CNNWashington (CNN) 2018 has been a tumultuous year in Washington — we've seen unprecedented turnover in the White House, the passings of two political ...
The Political Insiders' Guide to 2019  POLITICO18 top analysts and strategists from both parties tell us what they'll be watching for in the coming year.
Before Trump, Steve King Set the Agenda for the Wall and Anti-Immigrant Politics  The New York TimesThe Iowa congressman, who has used racist language and been denounced as a white supremacist, wrote the playbook on white identity politics and many of ...
Congressional GOP conspicuously silent on latest Trump, Cohen news  Washington PostSo far, the Republicans who've said anything are regular Trump defenders such as Rudy Giuliani and Newt Gingrich.
White Identity Politics Aren’t Going Anywhere  The New York TimesFor 50 years Republicans have battered the Democratic coalition, wielding the so-called southern strategy — built on racism and overlaid with opposition to ...
Swedish Prime Minister Regains Power as New Political Landscape Beckons  Wall Street JournalStefan Löfven was re-elected as Sweden's prime minister, but the cross-party deal that he had to concede to in order to gain enough support will see his socialist ...
Two bright spots on the political landscape | Letters to the Editor  The Herald JournalTo the editor: Two bright spots appeared this week in what has become the dismal abyss of American politics.
“We Did Not Come to Play”: Politics’ New Power Players Are Ready for a Fight  Vanity FairAs the most diverse class of freshman lawmakers in history settles in, Washington is preparing for war. Intra-party rifts are deepening. The executive branch is ...
Trump Confronts the Prospect of a ‘Nonstop Political War’ for Survival  The New York TimesWASHINGTON — So it has come to this: The president of the United States was asked over the weekend whether he is a Russian agent. And he refused to ...
From Brexit and the U.S. Shutdown to Brazil's Gun Law: Political Focus  BloombergIt was a week of superlatives in politics. Prime Minister Theresa May's Brexit deal went down to the heaviest defeat ever suffered by a British government in a ...
EU UNDER ATTACK: Berlusconi RETURNS with warning Brussels ‘MUST CHANGE’  Express.co.ukSILVIO Berlusconi has gone on a scathing attack on Europe by claiming it has “moved away from western values” as the former Italian Prime Minister plots a ...
Political figures celebrate Paddy Ashdown's energy, bravery and humour  The GuardianPraise for politician who transformed Liberal Democrats and oversaw peace in the Balkans.
Tucker Carlson has sparked the most interesting debate in conservative politics  Vox.comLast Wednesday, the conservative talk show host Tucker Carlson started a fire on the right after airing a prolonged monologue on his show that was, in essence, ...
Power & Politics' top five political moves and misses of 2018  CBC.caAs 2018 winds to a close, it's time to take a look back at the year's biggest political events and errors, both at home and abroad. The Power Panel — Postmedia ...
Bidding Congress Farewell, Paul Ryan Laments Nation’s ‘Broken’ Politics  The New York TimesOn a valedictory tour, Mr. Ryan is putting a high gloss on a speakership of dubious accomplishment. He fulfilled his tax-cutting dream, but the deficit is soaring.
Akash will join BSP, says Mayawati on nephew's political comeback  Economic TimesTaking on allegations of nepotism levelled against her, Bahujan Samaj Party supremo Mayawati on Thursday announced that she will make her nephew Akash ...
Could we force politicians to tell the truth?  Open DemocracyPolitics is pre-truth not post-truth. Does the regulation of advertising provide some answers? People's Vote March in London, June 23 2018. Credit: ...
Black Voters, a Force in Democratic Politics, Are Ready to Make Themselves Heard  The New York TimesBALTIMORE — The first “Amen!” rang out after a couple of minutes, as Senator Elizabeth Warren, speaking to an almost all-black audience at Morgan State ...
Trump seeks to enlist a key surrogate in political fight over his wall — Border Patrol agents  Washington PostIn his political fight for a border wall, President Trump has enlisted a new group of surrogates to join conservative talk show hosts and Republican allies in ...
The Worst Political Predictions of 2018  POLITICOIf you guess at the outcome of anything, you're bound to be wrong a lot. There are certain things that it's fairly easy to predict far in advance, because they ...
What our politicians are missing: India’s a land of cities, not villages  Economic Timesby Reuben Abraham and Pritika Hingorani It's an election year in India, with the world's largest polls expected in the spring. The focus of politicians is, as usual, ...
Politics Podcast: Our 2018 Politics Awards  FiveThirtyEightIn this year-end installment of the FiveThirtyEight Politics podcast, the crew looks back on the year in politics and hands out awards for things like the worst…
10% Quota: “No… But Maybe, Yes” Is Lose-Lose Politics For The Opposition  BloombergQuintAn amorphous “no … but yes” on the quota bill has left every opposition politician stranded in no-man's land. All the bragging rights on this have been turned ...

The FIRST FAMILY of the United States

The Randolphs:Peyton Randolph was the first President of the United... Read More

Defending Middle Eastern Oil Refineries and Assets

An idea to defend oil infrastructure in the Middle East... Read More

Garbage in Garbage out; California Blackouts

Why did the California energy crisis happen? Who is to... Read More

Sweet Lies, The Aspartame Issue

Aspartame activists are constantly being attacked because all data are... Read More

Russian State Administration Gives New Facelift to Oil and Energy Resources

With the world's largest oil and natural gas reserves, second... Read More

Globalism and a Conspiracy

The globalist's are the new breed, the new generation if... Read More

Iran is Escalating the Conflict

Iran has threatened to raise America's fuel prices again. They... Read More

Shooting Around Corners with New Concept

Currently the United States has weapons, which can shoot around... Read More

No Child Left Behind needs to go Virtual

The No Child Left Behind can work if the Federal... Read More

Lost and Found in Gaza

The evacuation of Gaza is now completed, and the world... Read More

NASA and the Crisis Aboard MIR

Some people say that we cannot put a colony on... Read More

How Dogpoo is Changing The World

Perhaps a silent revolution is taking place, this time more... Read More

Cindy Sheehan ? President Bush and the Accountability Moment

Death may not be dignified in any light but the... Read More

Is it just hubris, or ...?

In what the Americans love to describe as the war... Read More

Franchising Democracy and Creating Cohesive World Government

There are so many problems with our perceived perfect checks... Read More

Mexicanizing America

A friend of mine, who lives in the thick of... Read More

Droughts, Dirty Water and Disease

When we go through periods of droughts we also have... Read More

China has the Answer to Environmental Dead Zones

Recently scientists have been watching the exponential growth of marine... Read More

Prison Abuses on Good Muslims

Well we have certainly been reading a lot about prison... Read More

Rugged Individualism vs Human Nature

"Rugged individualism" is actually a euphemism for Thomas Hobbes' baseless... Read More

The Contemporary Global Marketplace - IT, Software, and Services

"Had there not been outsourcing and utilization of cheaper resources... Read More

US Government Regulators and Aides with AIDS

All government regulators or diplomat who are in high risk... Read More

Are Illegal Mexicans Really Bad for America?

I've been thinking again. I know some of my readers... Read More

Trade Policy; Hurting Industry and Small Business

The steel tariff taxes a few years ago hurt industry... Read More

Responding to Article: Logic Class 101 Applied to the Minuteman Project

In response to Douglas Bower's article; Logic Class 101 Applied... Read More