The U.S. Department of Justice vs. the Realty Industry, and Its Effect on Consumers

From the National Association of Realtors' Virtual Office Website policy, to laws and regulations in individual states across the country, the U.S. Department of Justice has been fighting since 2003 what it believes are illegal practices by the U.S. realty industry that harm the American consumer. The issues can be complex at times, but understanding what's going on can be very valuable when buying or selling a home.

The Virtual Office Website Policy

In May 2003, the National Association of Realtors (NAR) passed their Virtual Office Website policy which allows realtors to selectively exclude their listings from other websites. Later that same year, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) launched an official inquiry into the policy-concerned that the policy could lead to practices which were anticompetitive and monopolistic.

Realtors could now, for example, allow fellow realtors access to their listings, but deny access to other competitors who threatened the traditional business model of the realty industry-by undercutting the standard 6% commission, for example. Colluding with competitors in order to stifle others, however, violates U.S. antitrust law.

Two years later, the DOJ investigation into the policy is still ongoing. While the NAR has stated publicly that they believe "the opt-out provision is legal and appropriate" and that they would "go to court for as long as it takes," just five days after a May 9 Wall Street Journal report that the DOJ was preparing to finally bring suit in the case, the NAR authorized its leadership to develop a single, uniform policy governing the sharing of its listings.

DOJ vs. Local Realtor Organizations

While investigating the NAR's VOW policy, the DOJ has also been involved in a number of individual local cases.

In March 2005, the DOJ sued the Kentucky Real Estate Commission, challenging their regulation that prohibits Kentucky real estate brokers and sales associates from offering rebates and other inducements to attract customers. The DOJ charges that the regulation violates Section 1 of the Sherman Act by stifling competition and thus restraining trade. Fourteen other states have similar policies.

In April 2005, the DOJ sent an official inquiry to the Greater Tulsa (Oklahoma) Association of Realtors on charges of "boycotting"-refusal by traditional realtors to show homes listed by discount realty companies. While the practice is well-known to industry insiders, it's both an antitrust violation and a violation of the realtor's responsibility to their home buying clients.

Justice has also weighed in on debates in Oklahoma and Texas, who are considering bills that could eliminate many discount brokerage models by mandating that firms provide some minimum level of real estate services-bills championed by the realtor organizations in each state. Illinois already has passed similar legislation.

Effects of DOJ Efforts

At the root of all these cases is the issue of collusion. In order to maintain the current realtor-controlled market for home buying and selling, realtors, who are in all other respects direct competitors with one another, agree to "play nice" with other realtors, while at the same time excluding competitors who operate differently. That's a direct violation of U.S. antitrust law.

However, while the DOJ has continued to increase its investigations into antitrust behavior by the real estate industry, no suits have actually yet gone to court. The debate has been played out only in the media.

Still, even with no concrete results to show for them yet, their efforts have begun to shed light on the issues and to raise some valid questions about how the market works. More and more consumers are realizing that there are other, increasingly viable options for buying or selling a home. And those who still choose to go the traditional route are finding more realtors whose main focus is the customer and not simply the maintenance of a way of doing business.

In the long-run competition increases, and increased competition means both lower prices for consumers and also companies who work much harder to bring value to their customers. Realtors who fail to adjust to this new environment will find themselves out of business, but those who are able to best meet the needs of their customers will still find a market rich with opportunity.

Buyers and sellers will always need help through the complicated process of buying and selling a home. What is changing is who provides that help and how they do it-all to the benefit of the consumer.

Duane LeGate is president of House Buyer Network, one of America's largest networks of home buyers. Since 2002, they have helped more than 45,000 families and individuals who needed to sell a property fast-processing more than $7.5 billion in property during that time.

In The News:


Senate orders George Brandis to produce Bell Group documents – as it happened
The Guardian
Coalition focuses on energy in lower house after Scott Morrison says ACCC will investigate electricity retailers to help put a lid on power prices. As it happened. Updated 2h ago. George Brandis. The Senate voted 35-24 in favour of ordering the ...


Alaska Dispatch News

Politics is interfering with the rule of law, and that bodes ill for the United States
Alaska Dispatch News
Some 500 "sanctuary" cities and counties have decided for political reasons that federal immigration law does not fully apply within their jurisdictions. They have done so with impunity, believing that illegal immigration is a winning political issue ...


CBS News

The great divide: Politics in the Age of Trump - CBS News
CBS News
As this past week's battle over health care proves, the great divide in American politics shows no sign of healing, or even of quieting down. Our Cover Story is ...
Ted Koppel tells Sean Hannity he is bad for AmericaCBS News

all 63 news articles »

WBOC TV 16

Non merci: French voters reject corruption in politics - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -
WBOC TV 16
PARIS (AP) - French voters just won't tolerate corruption in politics anymore - that appears to be the message from the swift downfall of the country's powerful security minister. It's a notable shift from the past, when influence peddling seemed ...

and more »

Atlanta Journal Constitution (blog)

RIP Jon Richards, a conservative chronicler of Georgia politics
Atlanta Journal Constitution (blog)
Perhaps Jon's most lasting achievement was his mentorship of dozens of teen and college age students interested in politics. Jon devoted countless hours developing meaningful relationships with those desiring to be future leaders, helping them ...

and more »

Charleston Post Courier

Palmetto Politics: Former Gov. Haley's Statehouse corruption tweet last week spoke volumes about old scars
Charleston Post Courier
RQA refers to Richard Quinn's Columbia-area political consulting firm, Richard Quinn & Associates. Statehouse corruption investigators have requested documents from state agencies and companies that have hired Quinn and reportedly seized records from ...


Want to know why centre politics is stuck in the mud? Watch Comic Relief
The Guardian
Its failures mirror those of centrist politics so closely that any lessons we can learn from one will port quite easily to the other. So here goes: if Take That is still the nation's unifying boy band, then we are a nation in deep crisis. It's not the ...


Mirror.co.uk

Brexit Week is here at last: Mirror Politics morning briefing
Mirror.co.uk
Brexit Week is here at last: Mirror Politics morning briefing. Theresa May visits Scotland ahead of triggering Article 50 on Wednesday. Share. Jack Blanchard. ByJack Blanchard. 08:54, 27 MAR 2017. NewsOpinion. Theresa May faces a showdown summit with ...
Labour to set out tough new conditions for backing BrexitThe Guardian
Article 50: Brexit deal must meet six tests, says LabourBBC News

all 31 news articles »

USA TODAY

This week in politics: You don't have the votes
USA TODAY
"No forecasts, no hints" of his views on certain issues, from abortion rights to money in politics. The fact that he ruled differently than the Supreme Court on special education. But never forget Merrick Garland. While Gorsuch's nomination is expected ...

and more »

OCRegister

California's tribal politics - The Orange County Register
OCRegister
Gov. Jerry Brown, left at podium, with Senate President pro Temporare Kevin de Leon, address members of the media, before signing a bill creating highest ...
Essential Politics: Gov. Jerry Brown visits Washington, DC, Schwarzenegger blasts Trump's approval ratingsLos Angeles Times
Gov. Jerry Brown to Trump: 'You Don't Want to Mess With California'NBCNews.com

all 55 news articles »
Google News

Water Conservation, Retention and Better Policies

As the populations expand in Colorado outside of Denver, Las... Read More

The Economics of Cloning Armies or Super Families

Let's put the religious part of the debate for a... Read More

How to Become a Whistle Blower

Since the United States Government is promoting the whistle blower... Read More

Nurturing Global Disequilibrium

This brings to our consciousness, issues concerning the ever rising... Read More

Is it just hubris, or ...?

In what the Americans love to describe as the war... Read More

Smelter Closures In America Hurt Our Industrial Output

The United States is losing its industrial capacity quite rapidly.... Read More

Is This All There Is?

In today's Rants from Lance session I address the question... Read More

Politicians Are Like Car Sales People

Well, another election has come and gone in the US... Read More

Foreign Spies Troll Gay Bars in Washington DC for National Secrets

The use of homosexual men in the area of espionage... Read More

Trade Wars, China and Over Regulation At Home

We are seeing some trade wars brewing as American trade... Read More

Is America Bankrupt?

The US Dollar has been falling continuously in last year.... Read More

Iranian Elections - Roadmap To Continued Apathy

The recent first round of the Iranian elections somewhat resembled... Read More

Truckers Take Some Hits and Keep On Trucking

After 9-11 insurance rates on Independent Truck Drivers and smaller... Read More

Mr. Bin Laden: Tear this Wall Down

You say, you want to help the Palestinians, but most... Read More

Fact to Fiction: The Brutal Truth about the Practice of Stoning

"Like humans void of soul or mind, they jeered and... Read More

Accounting Nightmare at the FTC

Most government agencies cannot pass an audit of their expenses.... Read More

We Do Not Have An Upside Down Trade Deficit Because We Cannot Compete

Our trade deficit is directly proportional to our attacks on... Read More

The Dragons

I hope to provide a starting point for the serious... Read More

Experts?

ACCREDITATION: - Scholastic regimentation from the post WWII period has... Read More

Homeless, Trash, Drugs and Transient Issues

In Police Magazine I read a great article about transient... Read More

Oil Pipelines and Rates of Flow

How much oil can travel through a pipeline? It depends... Read More

Employment Legislation: Proposed Employment Law Changes - To Take Effect 1 October 2005

Proposed changes to the Sex Discrimination Act ("SDA") 1975 and... Read More

Lets Make Some Things Clear about John Thune/Dan Nelson/MetaBank MetaGate

Let's make one thing clear: This Dan Nelson Automotive fiasco... Read More

Genetically Modified Plants Could Become Sentinels for the Military

As concerns grow over the threat of bioterrorism and weapons... Read More

The Criminality of Transition

Lecture given at the Netherlands Economic Institute (NEI) on 18/4/2001Human... Read More