Pay-Per-Click Fraud Exposed

Has anyone else noticed a disturbing pattern in your pay-per-click advertising campaign, of the same IP addresses clicking on your ad, spending one or two seconds on your website and then leaving?

That's called click fraud and it's a major problem among all of the pay-per-click search engines.

Click fraud is a scheme that takes advantage of online advertising programs like those offered by Google, Yahoo/Overture, Findwhat and others. A fraudulent website is set up and participates in programs like Google's AdSense program. Unlike legitimate websites that attract human visitors to the site, fraudsters use software "hitbots" or employ boiler-rooms of low-wage employees from other countries to generate clicks on ads, and then collect commission from pay-per-click programs.

In June, a federal grand jury returned an indictment against Michael Anthony Bradley 32, of Oak Park California who was charged with fraud and extortion for a scheme involving Google's pay-per-click program. Believe it or not, Bradley actually tried to extort Google into paying $100,000 for click fraud software he created called "Google Clique."

Click fraud hurts advertisers by driving up the cost of each click because many online advertising programs adjust the price of each click based on the popularity of a particular keyword and the number of competing advertisers. And depending on how popular your keyword is, it can take just a few minutes to register hundreds of clicks. Click fraud can quickly deplete your pay-per-click account and leave you with little or nothing to show for your expentiture.

In a recent filing to the Securities and Exchange Commission, Google acknowledged, "We are exposed to the risk of fraudulent clicks on our ads. We have regularly paid refunds related to fraudulent clicks and expect to do so in the future. If we are unable to stop this fraudulent activity, these refunds may increase. If we find new evidence of past fraudulent clicks, we may have to issue refunds retroactively of amounts previously paid to our Google Network members."

Now, in all fairness to the pay-per-click companies I've used in the past, I have to give credit where credit is due. Whenever I complained of click fraud, which was often, all of the pay-per-click companies, without exception, did the right thing and credited the stolen funds back into to my account. Ironically, I have not had a click fraud problem with Google.

You can reduce your risk of being victimized by click fraud, by regularly auditing your website's log files and immediately reporting suspicious traffic to the pay-per-click companies. If you are unfamiliar with analyzing your site's log files, there are some excellent software products available to assist you like ClickTracks, WebTrends, and AWStats. These products make it fairly easy to identify patterns in your website's traffic.

Recently, I noticed the same IP number clicking on my ad over and over again--often many times within just a few minutes. I did some basic detective work and discovered it was actually a competitor of mine devouring my pay-per-click dollars. I approached him with my findings and threatened him with law enforcement intervention, if he didn't cease and desist. He denied any involvement, of course. But I haven't had any problems with that individual since.

So, how did I find out who the culprit was? Easy.

When checking your log files, if you notice a lot of clicks from one IP address, you can trace its origin by visiting the American Registry of Internet Numbers. By feeding the IP address into their "Whois" search, they will tell you who has been assigned that IP address, and whether it's an actual IP or another business entity.

Should the IP address not be assigned to the Americas, you can verify RIPE Network Coordination Center for all Russian, European, and Middle Eastern registries, or the Asia Pacific Network Information Center. There are only three such sites, so you should be able to track the source.

However, if someone is using sophisticated software to generate clicks on your ad, it will probably be impossible for you to trace the IP address yourself. For example, according to alleged Google extortionist, Michael Bradley, "Holland Engine software was originaly written to allow spammers to conceal their orginating IP address from mailservers and to keep it from apearing in e-mail headers.

Holland Engine is the core of LincolnSX, the most powerful mass-emailing software, running at rates of 5 million e- mails per day per machine. Holland Engine will actually tunnel through the internet and connect to the desired IP address from, not your IP but rather from another, the one at the end of the tunnel."

In conclusion, if you choose to use pay-per-click search engines to advertise, watch your log files closely and report improprieties immediately.

Also don't put all of your eggs into one basket, by depending solely on pay-per-click advertising. Utilize a variety of ways to attract traffic to your website, such as ezines, newsletters, writing articles, offline advertising, etc.

About The Author

Dean Phillips is an Internet marketing expert, writer, publisher and entrepreneur. Questions? Comments? Dean can be reached at mailto: [email protected]

Make Money Online! Internet marketing expert, Dean Phillips will help you make money online, starting today...Guaranteed! For details just visit my website.

Website: http://www.lets-make-money.net

In The News:

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at https://news.google.com/news

Rocks Digital (blog)

David Szetela to Speak on PPC Advertising and Artificial Intelligence at Rocks Digital 2018
Rocks Digital (blog)
David Szetela is Owner and CEO of digital advertising agency FMB Media, and one of the world's best-known experts in online advertising. A former Apple Computer executive and serial entrepreneur, David's career has been dedicated to helping companies ...


PPC Land

Viacom will start using FreeWheel on connected tv and video ads
PPC Land
Viacom will use FreeWheel's unified operating platform for premium video, and will deploy features including Holistic Advertising Management to monetize across all screens, FreeWheel's Unified Monetization Platform and other powerful technologies ...


Vertical Measures (blog)

How New Privacy Laws Can Affect Your Lead Generation and Retargeting Tactics
Vertical Measures (blog)
This personal and behavioral information is invaluable, particularly to marketers, who are always looking for better ways to target promotional content. Because audiences are much more likely to engage with a brand who understands where their last ...

and more »

Search Engine Land

How to outdo the PPC robots in shopping ads
Search Engine Land
Automation driven by improvements in artificial intelligence and machine learning will bring significant changes to how we manage pay-per-click (PPC) in 2018 and beyond. There's still a role for humans to play, one of which is to use what we've learned ...
Optmyzr Introduces Optmyzr Express - Pay-Per-Click Optimizations Designed for Quick and Easy Campaign BoostPR Web (press release)

all 2 news articles »

Search Engine Land

Sarcasm aside, how strict PPC advertiser policies may actually benefit us
Search Engine Land
Arguably, in the AdWords program, Google doesn't just leave advertisers to fail on their own (say, by losing money), but they also compound the pain for that advertiser by baking some of these signals into Quality Score. Why? Because (1) they don't ...

and more »

Bitcoin Exchange Guide (blog)

BiNeuro ICO (BNR Token): Blockchain Google Adwords PPC Advertising?
Bitcoin Exchange Guide (blog)
Today we'll talk about a fascinating software which is having an Initial Coin Offering soon: BiNeuro. This company is a Google partner and has been developing solutions to be used in neuro ads by using the blockchain technology. Created by UTC World ...


Forbes

Four Ways To Get The Most Out Of Your Pay-Per-Click Strategy
Forbes
Having been in the paid search space for over a decade, I've seen a lot of changes and amazing advancements in the targeting, delivery and measurement of paid ads. But with all of those changes, there are still four fundamental tips everyone should ...


Search Engine Land

How to use good ol' PPC to support fun and creative branded content
Search Engine Land
... was brilliant: Unlike product placement within shows (another form of branded content), large soap manufacturers collaborated with the major television (TV) networks to underwrite the production cost of shows they knew their target audience would ...


Small Business Trends

How to Use Pay-Per-Click Advertising for your Small Business
Small Business Trends
While search engine optimization is an important marketing strategy for all businesses, big brands and companies receive the most hits because they rank higher in searches for wide-ranging keywords. Google doesn't feature small businesses and smaller ...

and more »

Modern Ghana (press release) (blog)

Why are PPC campaigns not effective in Ghana?
Modern Ghana (press release) (blog)
The motivation for this article was this very question asked during a Digital Marketing workshop Ibukun was facilitating a couple of weeks ago in Accra. PPC: What is it? PPC stands for Pay-Per-Click, a model of internet marketing in which advertisers ...

Google News

10 Inside Secrets to Google Adwords - Part 1

Let's face it... Google Adwords is not the only source... Read More

Google Adwords ? Online Riches Without Owning A Website Or Product!

Did you know that you can make money from Google... Read More

The Secret to Adwords Success

It seems at the moment that everybody is telling you... Read More

Dynamic Resource for Adsense: 3 Practical Models Quickly Earn & Maximize Google Adsense Revenue

Looking back in time, I could still remember standing in... Read More

Google AdSense - A Quick Overview For Beginners

In Google AdWords, the advertisers' links show up when someone... Read More

Using Google AdWords to Increase your Adsense Profits

I had been using Google's Adsense program to generate some... Read More

Adsense or Affiliate Programs?

As my sites get more and more search engine traffic,... Read More

How to Use Pay Per Click Advertising to Increase Web Site Traffic

Have you ever imagined what it would be like to... Read More

Organic Natural Search Engine Optimization versus Pay-Per-Click Search Engine Advertising

When you purchase visitors or "clicks" from a search engine,... Read More

Five Steps to Profit from Google Adwords

Although I was marketing online since 1997 and was making... Read More

What is PTRE and Is It Worth Your Time?

PTRE stands for Paid To Read Email programs. Online companies... Read More

What is Google AdSense?

AdSense may be one of the fastest and easiest ways... Read More

AdWords Campaign Set Up Tips

It's easy to overlook the basics of a strong AdWords... Read More

The Future of PPC Advertising

For those of you who haven't used a Pay Per... Read More

How Do You Make Money From Google Adwords?

Can you really make money from this?Late 2003, I think... Read More

Regarding the AdSense Update...

If you haven't yet got a Google AdSense account for... Read More

99 High Paying Keywords: The Secret Is Out!

Incorporating high paying keywords into your site is critical to... Read More

Click Fraud and How to Deter It

Pay per click (PPC) advertising continues to gain popularity in... Read More

Adlink Success - A New Advertising Style From Google Adsense

There is a new advertising style from Google Adsense that... Read More

Under The Covers: ClickBanks Affiliate Tracking System

The core principle of affiliate marketing is that the referring... Read More

Easy Clickbank Management with the Right Tools

Clickbank has been around for years and has earned an... Read More

Increase Your Click-Through Rate And Skyrocket Your Sales - 3 Quick Tips

Most pay per click ads draw amazingly low click through... Read More

Click Fraud ? Threatening the Internet Economy

One of the most popular forms of Internet advertising is... Read More

Advertising Click Fraud Rampant Online?

"Pay-per-click," by far the most popular form of online advertising,... Read More

How To Get Banned From Google Adsense In Just 2 Clicks

The darkest nightmare a hardworking affiliate webmaster fears is receiving... Read More