Media Relations: Should You Pay For News Coverage?

Dear New York Times:

I'd like to be quoted in one of your news stories. Enclosed is a check for $500. Please call me to arrange the interview sometime this week. Evenings are best. Thank you.

Imagine how such a letter would be greeted in the New York Times newsroom. The recipient would likely laugh out loud and might even post it on the bulletin board so other reporters could walk by and enjoy a good chuckle.

The letter wrongly assumed that the New York Times would accept "pay for play," or would run a news story as long as a payment accompanied the request. It's preposterous, of course, and U.S. news organizations just don't work that way.

Or do they?

I recently booked a client on a Washington area radio talk show. After booking the client, I spent some additional time exploring the show's website. Here's what it said:

"Guest Opportunities: $600 to appear as a guest, 6 minute (minimum) interview."

Although the host agreed not to charge my client, it made me wonder how pervasive this practice is, and whether media relations professionals should ever take advantage of this type of pay for play.

It's not as uncommon as you might think. When I headed the media department for an environmental nonprofit, I used to get calls from production companies who were purportedly interested in producing half-hour documentaries on our group. The pitch was that they would then sell the completed program to a national network like Discovery or PBS, which would happily air it.

But later in the conversation, they would inevitably reveal their less than journalistic motives ? they wanted us, as the subject of the piece, to pay tens of thousands of dollars to "defray their costs." (Could you imagine Mike Wallace, after his recent interview with Russian President Putin on CBS, asking the Premier for a few grand to help 60 Minutes recover its production costs?)

When we asked the production companies what they could guarantee, they told us the show would appear on at least 80 PBS stations ? but they couldn't tell us in which markets and at what airtimes. In other words, they wouldn't tell us if we would be buying a 3:00 A.M. timeslot in a small town or primetime in New York City. Something seemed off, and we decided to walk away from it.

A few months ago, I met someone who tried it. According to the president of a well-respected cultural nonprofit organization, the producers promised her that for $60,000, they could guarantee her that the show would air in at least 80 markets. After the show started airing, she asked the producers repeatedly for a list of the markets in which the piece was running. She never heard a word. She suspects the number was closer to 12 than 80.

So what should you do if you're ever confronted with a pay for play opportunity? In general, I'd advise you to walk in the other direction. There are many news outlets that will report your story the right way ? for free. Plus, the public is savvy enough to detect the difference between a balanced piece of journalism and an infomercial, and is more likely to regard the former with more credibility.

Is there ever a time to say 'yes' to pay for play? Well, perhaps. If, for example, the pay for play offer allows you to own the rights to any raw video footage the production team shoots and you can use that material in other ways, it might make sense. Or, if the venue is a direct hit on your target audience and you have no hope of getting coverage with that outlet in any other way, it might be worth it.

But in general, be wary. Pay for play has a way of making its customers pray for pay ? in the form of a refund check.

Brad Phillips is the founder and president of Phillips Media Relations. He was formerly a journalist for ABC News and CNN, and headed the media relations department for the second largest environmental group in the world.

For more information and to sign up for free monthly media relations and media training e-tips, visit http://www.PhillipsMediaRelations.com.

In The News:

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at https://news.google.com/news

The Verge

How Facebook's crisis PR firm triggered a PR crisis
The Verge
In time it will come out that this response including hiring a public relations agency whose work includes what is euphemistically referred to as “opposition research” and is more commonly understood to involve smear campaigns. These campaigns target ...
Facebook hired firm with 'in-house fake news shop' to combat PR crisisNBCNews.com
Facebook Can't Explain the Difference Between Its PR Operation and Russian Troll FarmsNew York Magazine
Facebook is being accused of hiring a PR firm to smear its opponentsMIT Technology Review
Daily Beast -Forbes -New York Times -Facebook Newsroom
all 1,621 news articles »

Forbes

Why Purpose Is Important To Your PR Strategy
Forbes
While pursuing B Corp status aligned with our overarching goal of having a purpose beyond profit, it also became our most important and highest performing public relations (PR) story of the year. Many of the major travel outlets, and even business ...


Forbes

How To Reframe The Perception Between PR And Ego
Forbes
But here's the thing: Your content never changes, and PR should really be about connecting with the media to share the value you can bring to their audience. Therefore, it's really important for you to shape the context and your view of how you're ...


The Verge

Facebook-linked PR firm Definers pushed criticism of Apple, Google, and Bird
The Verge
As Facebook reels from a bombshell New York Times report published this week, much of the focus has been on a controversial public relations firm hired by the company. Definers Public Affairs, a DC organization, pressed reporters with information ...
Qualcomm reportedly hired crisis PR firm behind Facebook controversyEngadget
It's not just Facebook. GOP-linked firm “brought oppo research to Silicon Valley”Fast Company
Facing scrutiny, Facebook reportedly hired a PR firm that wrote negative articles about rivals Apple, GoogleCNBC
TNW -Yahoo Finance -New York Times
all 29 news articles »

Irish Times

Facebook's new PR disaster shows it has a lot of growing up to do
Irish Times
This came after it was revealed in a New York Times article that the company had hired a PR agency to discredit its critics by claiming they were agents of the billionaire George Soros, a frequent subject of anti-Semitic conspiracy theories, which are ...


Hollywood Reporter

Governors Awards: By Honoring Marvin Levy, the Academy Recognizes Its Debt to PR Experts
Hollywood Reporter
No industry has ever created a more effective public relations and marketing device for itself than Hollywood did when — with the financial backing of the studio chiefs and the help of PR and marketing specialists — it created the Academy Awards some ...

and more »

New York Times

A Fugitive Financier's Charm Offensive Has PR Firms Proceeding With Caution
New York Times
The owner of one public relations firm hired by Mr. Low's legal team, James Haggerty, said in one filing that he believed all of his work fell within the litigation exemption to FARA. But Mr. Haggerty, who is also a lawyer, wrote that he registered ...


Plattsburgh Press Republican

Vacation over for annual PR photo contest
Plattsburgh Press Republican
PLATTSBURGH — Cinderella's castle and the Sydney Opera House were the backdrops for this year's winners of the final Press-Republican Vacation Photo Contest. The popular contest, which encouraged vacationers to photograph themselves with their ...


PR machine on overdrive as unpopular slow tram costs triple
Scoop.co.nz
Rather than thinking again, Minister Twyford is pushing ahead regardless and evidently upping the PR campaign. While Minister Twyford lent heavily on 'experts' in his recent Herald article, Gammie refers to various 'studies' to justify the official ...

and more »

LSFI PR wins campaign at 2018 African excellence awards
The Nation Newspaper
Joining the league of global agencies such as Edelman, WE communications, Clockwork media and many more who are also award recipients this year, Bidemi Zakariyau (Founder & Current CEO of LSF|PR said “We're honoured to be recognized as an ...

Google News

Do You See PRs Real Value?

As a business, non-profit or association manager, do you see... Read More

Best Approach For Free Advertisement

Product/service publicity is the superhighway to business success everyone dreams.... Read More

PR Essential to Your Success

Whether you are a business, non-profit or association manager, your... Read More

What to Do When the Reporter Calls: Five Tips for New (and not-so-new) Business Owners

New business owners often miss out on publicity opportunities because... Read More

Effective Public Relations: Why Did Bec And Lleyton Do It At 3:15AM?

If you are in Australia at the moment, it is... Read More

3 Reasons to Tap into the Power of Publicity

Publicity is obtaining editorial coverage or features for your business.... Read More

Managers: Heres a PR Template for You

Let's start out with a caution for business, non-profit and... Read More

Media Savvy - How To Lead, Persuade, And Influence

Media management has become one of the strategic tools for... Read More

The Four Seasons of Publicity - Building an All-Year Publicity

If you're like most publicity seekers, you probably think oneproject... Read More

Writing a Press Release: The Design Basics

Big corporations like General Motors and Coca-Cola spend thousands of... Read More

Imagine PR Like This Helping You

As the kids say, how cool is this?You're a business,... Read More

Want To Join the Bandwagon? Be Sure It Has Wheels!

Here are two to-the-point questions recently posed by several association... Read More

Publicity: Write a Letter to the Editor for Free Publicity

Ever wonder why papers devote a page or more to... Read More

Interviews - Five Tips To Handle Tough Questions From Reporters

Journalists are trained and often experienced at getting information out... Read More

Know What Matters Most About PR?

When, as a business, non-profit or association manager, you are... Read More

How to Generate Free Publicity for Your Product, Service, or Cause

One of the most misunderstood and most underutilized promotional tools... Read More

Forget The Story Youre Promoting ? Heres What Journalists Really Want From PR People

Although it seems less common these days, there are still... Read More

Preparing For Your Media Interview

Media interviews are an important part of an overall public... Read More

Your Organization: What Role PR?

As a manager, does your current business, non-profit or association... Read More

A Winning Game Plan

You want to sell your products or services, and that... Read More

Media Training: Exposing Reporter Tricks -- Three Tactics Designed to Get You

A reporter's job is to get the most accurate and... Read More

Is This the PR You Thought You Were Getting?

You know, where you do something positive about the behaviors... Read More

How Managers Hurt Their PR Results

Business, non-profit or association managers hurt their own public relations... Read More

If I Were Coaching You

If I were coaching you as a business, non-profit or... Read More

Custom Reasons for Custom Publishing

Once considered the stepchild of the publishing industry, custom publishing... Read More