Media Relations: Should You Pay For News Coverage, Part II

Last month, we told you about "pay for play," a practice in which news organizations charge sources to appear on their programs. In other words, if you ante up enough cash, these "news" programs will air a puff piece about your company or organization.

But in most cases, these pay for play outfits don't deliver what they promise. Not only don't they stand behind their "guarantees" of audience numbers, but the public regards their alleged reporting with skepticism. The public is smart enough to recognize the difference between a news segment and advertising.

Shortly after sending out our article on pay for play last month, PR Week Magazine reported a story on its front page about yet another scheme.

Terry Bradshaw, the former Pittsburgh Steelers hero, is hosting a television program called "The Winners Circle." The program honors companies for their "forward thinking and consistent principles." The segments air during commercial time on MSNBC, CNN, CNN Headline News and CNBC.

The problem is this ? the companies actually pay the producers of these spots $29,000 for their dubious honor. The producers never say that the alleged winners paid for the honor. Occasionally, they cryptically note that the commercial time was purchased. But in some cases, the spot has aired with no notice to viewers whatsoever that this was just a glorified commercial.

With the practice under increased scrutiny, my advice remains the same as it was last month ? in general, walk away from these offers.

There is one disclaimer here. While running the media shop at Conservation International, I received a call from the producers of "The Winners Circle." Like many pay for play outfits, they were aggressive. They wanted the sale ? and I got the sense that they couldn't care less whether or not the subject of the piece was actually a "winner."

I went to the producer's website to see if it listed criteria for what they considered a winner. It listed laughably softball criteria, such as, "What can viewers learn from your satisfied customers?" I suspect their real definition of a "winner" is anyone with $29,000 to burn.

YOUR RESPONSES

Last month, we asked our newsletter subscribers to tell us about their experiences with pay for play outfits. Here's what you had to say:

Doralisa writes, "We have been approached several times by exactly the same type of pay for play outfit you described in your newsletter. I've had experience with those companies at previous jobs, so I knew from the get-go what was coming after the first flowery sales pitch. Besides the obvious reasons for rejecting them (no guarantee of what markets and time slots it would air, and you'd end up with an infomercial of dubious credibility), the finished cost-per-minute was more than twice what it would cost for me to make the same video in-house, and at the end of the day, we still would not have the rights to the raw footage. If it sounds too good to be true ?."

Laura writes, "I think we got the same pitch as you did. As a non-profit with literally zero resources devoted exclusively to broadcast journalism, the idea "sounded" wonderful. But more probing made me nervous; they didn't really know our organization name, nor what our purpose was, nor what their story was ? they expected us to provide the hook and the main storyline! It was these problems that made me realize what the true motivations were. I mean, no true journalist doesn't know their own story."

Perhaps there are a few good pay for play operators out there. But watching these groups from both up close and afar has made me wary. My experience has taught me that companies and organizations can almost always invest their $29,000 more effectively. My advice is this ? when you get the pitch, take a walk.

Brad Phillips is the founder and president of Phillips Media Relations. He was formerly a journalist for ABC News and CNN, and headed the media relations department for the second largest environmental group in the world.

For more information and to sign up for free monthly media relations and media training e-tips, visit http://www.PhillipsMediaRelations.com

In The News:

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at https://news.google.com/news

The Verge

How Facebook's crisis PR firm triggered a PR crisis
The Verge
In time it will come out that this response including hiring a public relations agency whose work includes what is euphemistically referred to as “opposition research” and is more commonly understood to involve smear campaigns. These campaigns target ...
Facebook hired firm with 'in-house fake news shop' to combat PR crisisNBCNews.com
Facebook, Facing Backlash, Fires PR Firm It Hired To Discredit Soros, Other CriticsForbes
Facebook accused of dark PR tacticsBBC News
Daily Beast -Variety -New York Times -Facebook Newsroom
all 1,454 news articles »

Forbes

Why Purpose Is Important To Your PR Strategy
Forbes
While pursuing B Corp status aligned with our overarching goal of having a purpose beyond profit, it also became our most important and highest performing public relations (PR) story of the year. Many of the major travel outlets, and even business ...


Forbes

How To Reframe The Perception Between PR And Ego
Forbes
But here's the thing: Your content never changes, and PR should really be about connecting with the media to share the value you can bring to their audience. Therefore, it's really important for you to shape the context and your view of how you're ...


The Verge

Facebook-linked PR firm Definers pushed criticism of Apple, Google, and Bird
The Verge
As Facebook reels from a bombshell New York Times report published this week, much of the focus has been on a controversial public relations firm hired by the company. Definers Public Affairs, a DC organization, pressed reporters with information ...
Qualcomm reportedly hired crisis PR firm behind Facebook ...Engadget
Facebook's former PR firm seeded fake stories about bias at Apple NewsTNW
It's not just Facebook. GOP-linked firm “brought oppo research to Silicon Valley”Fast Company
CNBC -Yahoo Finance -Branding in Asia Magazine -New York Times
all 29 news articles »

Irish Times

Facebook's new PR disaster shows it has a lot of growing up to do
Irish Times
This came after it was revealed in a New York Times article that the company had hired a PR agency to discredit its critics by claiming they were agents of the billionaire George Soros, a frequent subject of anti-Semitic conspiracy theories, which are ...


New York Magazine

Facebook Can't Explain the Difference Between Its PR Operation and Russian Troll Farms
New York Magazine
That Facebook would hire a PR firm to protect itself is not that surprising. Mark Zuckerberg described it as a “typical D.C. relationship” in a conference call on Thursday and said he only learned about Definers from the Times' report. If Definers is a ...
Facebook is being accused of hiring a PR firm to smear its opponentsMIT Technology Review
Senators send letter to Mark Zuckerberg asking for more details on the opposition PR firm Facebook hiredCNBC
Breakfast Briefing: 5 (Facebook) things for PR pros to know on Friday morningPRWeek
Investing.com -IDG Connect (blog) -MuMbrella -New York Times
all 210 news articles »

New Zealand Herald

WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange hires Kiwi PR guru Richard Hillgrove
New Zealand Herald
Controversial WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange has hired a Kiwi PR guru to bolster his global image while he remains holed up in a London embassy. New Zealand publicist Richard Hillgrove, whose previous employers include Charles Saatchi, Dame ...
US Is Optimistic It Will Prosecute AssangeWall Street Journal
Julian Assange has been charged, prosecutors reveal inadvertently in court filingWashington Post
Court filing indicating possible Julian Assange charges - DocumentCloudDocumentCloud

all 2,037 news articles »

The Indian Express

Amid sting row, Chhattisgarh PR commissioner transferred
Times of India
RAIPUR: Just before assembly elections in the state, Chhattisgarh government has shifted out its commissioner for public relations Rajesh Sukumar Toppo, two days after opposition Congress complained to Election Commission demanding action against ...
Chhattisgarh PR Commissioner transferred amid sting rowAll India Radio
PR secretary Toppo relieved of responsibility on EC's instructionUnited News of India

all 24 news articles »

New York Times

A Fugitive Financier's Charm Offensive Has PR Firms Proceeding With Caution
New York Times
The owner of one public relations firm hired by Mr. Low's legal team, James Haggerty, said in one filing that he believed all of his work fell within the litigation exemption to FARA. But Mr. Haggerty, who is also a lawyer, wrote that he registered ...


PrinceGeorgeMatters.com

Prince George PR referendum ballots cast climbs slightly ...
PrinceGeorgeMatters.com
On Nov. 6, less than three per cent of Prince George had sent their proportional representation ballot to Elections B.C., but as of today (Nov. 16), there has been ...
Kamloops among top cities to return PR referendum ballots ...Kamloops Matters

all 3 news articles »
Google News

Does the PR Blueprint Work?

Managers, please take a minute and read two sentences: People... Read More

How to Use Community Relations to Grow Your Business

Community relations is one of those marketing strategies that isn't... Read More

33 Reasons To Do A News Release

News releases are not the best way to get major... Read More

Media Relations - Ten Essential Tips to Use The Media to Market Your Business

In the 'Age of Scepticism' gaining media coverage is one... Read More

Writing a Press Release: The Medias Dirty Secret

There's a dirty little secret about press releases that the... Read More

How About MANAGING Your Own PR?

It's one thing for a senior manager to approve story... Read More

How to Write a Press Release

Why You Should Write Press Releases: A press release is... Read More

Trade Show Tactics Revealed

Being part of a trade show gives small business a... Read More

The Power of Radio - Tips for Great Radio Interviews

Many people are intimidated by radio interviews, whether live or... Read More

Did You Know That Even TV Remote Control Units Can Get Press and Media Coverage?

Did you Know That Even TV Remote Control Units... Read More

Public Relations Primer Part III: 10 Donts

There are all kinds of smart moves professionals can make... Read More

Talk Radio Success

You do not have to hire a publicist or advertise... Read More

Make the Media Your Friend

The media (newspaper, radio, television) can be of enormous help... Read More

Publicrelationistas?

Is that what we are? Fanatic, over-the-top disciples of some... Read More

PR for Brand New Managers

Just promoted to manager?Here's something you need to know.Whether you... Read More

Managers: PR More Than Tix and Plugs?

You bet! And in three ways vital to you as... Read More

Public Relations Going O.K?

Yes?Good!Still, as a business, non-profit or association manager, if you're... Read More

Do You Have Issues?

Every organization has issues that could affect its operation. The... Read More

Cultivating Positive Media Relationships

Some people think that publicity is all about paparazzi snapping... Read More

Permanent Press: Using Press Releases to Keep Your Company in the News

When is your best advertisement not an advertisement? When it's... Read More

PR: Focus on What Matters!

Sure, as a manager, you have a talented member of... Read More

Media Training - Essentials for ALL Office Professionals

Often the first point of contact the media has with... Read More

Custom Reasons for Custom Publishing

Once considered the stepchild of the publishing industry, custom publishing... Read More

Financial Planners Publicity - Dont Wait, Media Folks Want Your Free Publicity

Looking to get your name into a magazine? You need... Read More

Publicity - The Right Media Person to Call for Free Publicity

You won't accomplish much if you call the gas company... Read More