Second Fiddle

I have been seeing a married man for the past nine months. He is unhappy but says he is not ready to leave his kids. They have a teenage daughter and a grown son, who is hers from a previous marriage. He is close to them and has a lovely home, which he worked hard for.

We pulled away from each other because we both felt guilty. However, we are still very close as we work on an oil rig in the North Sea and cannot help being around each other for great lengths of time. We feel we are soul mates.

Now he's found out his wife is having an affair with a man while he is offshore. She is unaware of me, and she is unaware he knows about her infidelity. I care so much about this man I felt his pain when he first found out. I want to support him through this. I don't want to be a destructive force that will be the catalyst to divorce.

I do believe in fate and hope the best situation arises.


Maya, if a conductor is hiring violinists and he knows one will only take first chair, she will get first chair. If first chair is already occupied, the conductor is hiring a second chair. If the conductor knows a violinist is willing to take second chair, why would he give her first?

You both know you are doing something which is in its essence wrong. He says you are his soul mate, but he chooses an unhappy marriage over you. He is willing to lose you. If he is willing to lose you, he doesn't love you. If he loved you, losing you would be the one thing he would be unwilling to do.

Hannibal Lecter said, "What do we covet? We covet what we see." Why did this man become involved with you? Because his opportunities were limited, and we covet what we see. But what role can he offer you except the role of helpful mistress?

If a relationship is not monogamous and leading to marriage, it is of no benefit to a woman at all.

Trust issues predominate in this situation. Until one or all of you decide to do what is right, nothing good will come of this. You are a single, available, unmarried woman. That is the basis from which you must proceed. Leave these two alone to deal with their mutual infidelity.

Ayn Rand said we are free to make the wrong choice, but not to succeed with it. The only path to your happiness will come from making right choices. You need to be in an open and honest relationship, with someone who is free to be involved with you.

Wayne & Tamara

Breaking Ground

After a two year relationship, I found out he was married. He assured me time and time again he was divorced, when I questioned his actions. I need to find out if there are any legal remedies to this relationship.


Natalie, we cannot give legal advice, but you raise an interesting question. Should a person be able to lie to another, to that person's detriment, and not suffer legal consequences?

Some people would lick their wounds, chalk it up to experience, and move on. But there are others who blaze new trails, make new laws, and fight the good fight. People like consumer advocate Ralph Nader. In the words of one former United States senator, he created a movement "whose sole purpose is to keep large corporations and the government honest."

Are you, like Ralph Nader, ready to blaze new trails? Then you might want to contact an attorney and see if something can be done. But first you need to answer one question. When you asked him again and again about his marital status, why did you continue in the relationship?


Direct Answers - Column for the week of October 25, 2004

About The Author

Authors and columnists Wayne and Tamara Mitchell can be reached at

Send letters to: Direct Answers, PO Box 964, Springfield, MO 65801 or email: [email protected].

In The News:

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at

Psychology Today (blog)

7 Characteristics of Resilient Relationships
Psychology Today (blog)
Did you ever wonder why some relationships endure even in the most stressful of times, while others are destroyed? Are there certain factors that seem to characterize strong, enduring, and resilient relationships? There are no easy answers to why some ...


12 Questions People In Polyamorous Relationships Are Sick Of Hearing
“Most polyamorous relationships aren't made up of a hierarchy of 'primary' relationships and 'secondary' relationships. Many polyamorous folks, like myself, have deeply honest relationships with their loved ones that are based on what they actually ...

The Good Men Project (blog)

The Practice of Relationship
The Good Men Project (blog)
Don't like ads? Become a supporter and enjoy The Good Men Project ad free. So many relationships end because of a lack of intimacy. So many relationships end because the love seems to fade and disappear. So many relationships end because we stop ...

and more »

2020 Census will ask about same-sex relationships
For the first time, U.S. Census will allow respondents to specify they are part of a same-sex couple. NBC News reported on the change based on documents submitted to Congress by the U.S. Census Bureau. The 2020 census will expand the responses related ...

and more »

Financial Times

University reputations risk being tarnished by business links
Financial Times
Business benefits from unblemished academic rigour. The social sciences, under fire for influential studies that cannot be replicated, would benefit from real-world testing. The mutual benefit of clear guidance in these relationships is clear ...

It's All About the Relationships
Modern Distribution Management (blog)
It wasn't that long ago that the personal relationship your outside salesperson had with customers and suppliers was the dominant driver of the business. I've heard or said, “This business is all about relationships” hundreds of times in my ...

Vilsan '19: Relationships 101 - The Brown Daily Herald
The Brown Daily Herald
Let's talk about relationships. The word has romantic connotations, but in reality, relationships are central to every part of our lives, from the personal to the professional.

and more »

Nestle evaluating North America agency relationships - Ad Age
Nestle seeks cost-cutting with new agency structure.

and more »

Duke University considers policy banning all undergraduate-faculty romantic relationships
According to the article, the proposed amendment to the faculty handbook prohibits all undergraduate-faculty sexual and romantic relationships and limits relationships between faculty and graduate students to circumstances where the faculty member does ...


Ahem, Gwyneth Paltrow Says She's In Her First 'Adult Relationship'
The Oscar winner, of course, was famously involved with Pitt and Affleck before her 10-years-plus marriage to Coldplay frontman Martin, which resulted in two children and a “conscious uncoupling.” She announced her engagement to Falchuk in January ...
'I've been in relationships with men who had intimacy issues' - Gwyneth
Gwyneth Paltrow describes Brad Falchuk romance as her 'first adult relationship'
Gwyneth Paltrow Says Brad Falchuk Relationship Is Her First 'Adult ...Entertainment Tonight
Us Weekly -Fox News -The Times
all 61 news articles »
Google News

Finding a Life Partner

Dear Candace,I'm 35 years old and ready to open my... Read More

Improve Relationships With Style

Have you ever felt that relationships are messy? These messes,... Read More

What Does a Dangerous Man Look Like?

When you are dating you try to keep from a... Read More

If He Insists That You Work...

Once, when asked about her life, former First Lady Barbara... Read More

How To Change A Loved Ones Annoying Habits

Is there someone close to you who has an annoying... Read More

Relationship Advice: 3 Kinds of Love

There are three kinds of love:love as a feeling, love... Read More

Cheating Spouse: Is Spying an Invasion of Privacy?

My, how the cheating spouse cries foul when he/she discovers... Read More

Proper Flower Etiquette

Flowers are great gifts for practically any occasion, but there... Read More

Dumped? Get Set for a New Life

Welcome to Dumpsville. Population - you!You've been dumped for a... Read More

Reaching the Ultimate Level in Human Relationships

I want to tell you a little story. Not about... Read More

Authentic Relationships - 5-Question Exercise to Explore How You Show Up In Relationship

The focus of this article is to explore what it... Read More

My Concept

From my own personal experiences with relationships I believe in... Read More

Relationship Conflict - Blow Up or Blow Through

Every now and then I hear a "relationship expert" say... Read More

How to Turn Down Invitations Gracefully

All of us occasionally receive social invitations that we don't... Read More

Great Relationships - 3 Things to Avoid, 3 Things to Do

"Almost no one is foolish enough to imagine that he... Read More

Finding Your Feng Shui Power Spots for Love and Romance

The first step in using feng shui to attract a... Read More

Energize Your Relationship By Celebrating Hoodie-Hoo Day February 20th

What is Hoodie-Hoo Day and what does it have to... Read More

Setting Up Boundaries in Relationships

Setting up personal boundaries is important in all types of... Read More

True Friendships - How to Get True Friends and Friendships

True Friendship - RecognitionHow can we find true friendships in... Read More

Why You Should Be Happy You Caught Your Partner Cheating

The dictionary defines infidelity as "unfaithfulness to a sexual partner".... Read More

Has The Magic Gone From Your Relationship?

Kathleen and Dan have been together for several years now.... Read More

Learn the Six Secrets of Chemical Romance

What is Chemical Romance? It's a scientific approach to seduction... Read More

Say, Whats On Your Mind, Partner?

Stan is an incurable romantic. Ever since he started courting... Read More

Buying Underwear For The Woman In Your Life - The Golden Rules

There are two golden rules for choosing underwear for the... Read More

Everything I Know About Relationship Success I Learned At The Playground

It happened again!I was enjoying an evening with my little... Read More