Name That Tune

Direct Answers - Column for the week of July 26, 2004

I have been married to a wonderfully grounded woman for nine years, and we have two young children. The problem? My mother-in-law lives from crisis to crisis. She claims to have a "plan," but it is always the wrong plan and my wife and I are constantly picking up the pieces.

A one year experiment of her living with us turned into a stressful five year stay. We are financially stable, but our oldest child is a special needs child who is draining our financial resources at a healthy clip. When our second child was born, we gave my mother-in-law an ultimatum, and she moved into a house with a female roommate 15 minutes away.

The arrangement lasted two years before the roommate had enough and booted her. She then traveled to California to stay with my wife's older sister and her family. That arrangement didn't last six weeks. According to our family in California, she showed more interest in her hair curlers than in her grandchildren.

My wife's mother is well-educated and in good health. Her first love is writing. She has been working on her "masterpiece" for 25 years, and I am sure it will never be submitted to a publisher. She refuses to pursue financially rewarding work, but she is a great talker. If she were paid by the spoken word, she'd have more money than Bill Gates.

If my mother-in-law knows there's a safety net, she'll use it. My wife knows this, too, but in the end she feels obligated to be her mother's savior. I've given plenty of warning in the past by saying if preventable "situation X" recurs, I will not be a party to it. Sure enough, situation X repeats itself, and I'm asked at the last minute to drop everything and provide a solution.

Just yesterday my mother-in-law enlisted our help moving again. She didn't ask until the moving deadline was less than 48 hours away. I want to support my wife, but I can no longer condone her mother's behavior. The one blessing is that my marriage is on a solid foundation.

Nathan

Nathan, whether it's heaven and hell, karma and rebirth, running a prison, or teaching a child, the one idea that runs through all life is that behavior has consequences. When behavior doesn't have consequences, disorder prevails.

As long as your mother-in-law doesn't bear the consequences of her behavior, you and your wife will. The problem is this. Your wife feels obligated to meet her mother's demands, whether those demands are legitimate or not, and your mother-in-law is a master at pushing her daughter's buttons.

In her book "Emotional Blackmail," Susan Forward writes, "Every time we capitulate to emotional blackmail, we lose contact with our integrity, the inner compass that helps us determine what our values and behavior should be." This is why you feel you have had enough of your mother-in-law's behavior.

Children learn by being given responsibility and suffering consequences when they don't act responsibly. But your mother-in-law, a grandmother, isn't learning anything. All these years she has been getting away with it.

Your mother-in-law doesn't feel bad about the repercussions to you. She is like a gambler gambling with someone else's money. She is like the teenager whose parents bail her out of every situation. The fewer the repercussions to her, the more destructive and thoughtless her actions can be.

In the old television show "Name That Tune," contestants competed to name a tune in the fewest number of notes. That is also the key to understanding people who manipulate us. When we can name a manipulator's tune from the first few notes, we can stop their controlling behavior the instant it begins.

The book "Emotional Blackmail" teaches you the blackmailer's tunes. It is the perfect antidote for people who feel they have lost themselves in trying to please others.

Wayne & Tamara

About The Author

Authors and columnists Wayne and Tamara Mitchell can be reached at www.WayneAndTamara.com.

Send letters to: Direct Answers, PO Box 964, Springfield, MO 65801 or email: [email protected].

In The News:

Girl code: Say no to ‘serious’ relationships  The StandardBut some of you serious men make dating such an uphill task for us; a simple joke is enough to break up a relationship that has stood the test of time.
Relationships are to be treasured – Ohio Ag Net  Ohio's Country Journal and Ohio Ag NetBy Don “Doc” Sanders. Some of you may have heard this story from years gone by, but one that is a favorite. Early in our veterinary career my wife, Judy, and I ...
Encyclopedia of successful marital relationships  The PunchAdeyemi Adebiyi. Tolani Salawu, no doubt, must have been driven by her experience as a relationship expert and marriage counselor to examine marital ...
Researchers: Gender, salary can have an impact on relationships  WWBT NBC12 News(WWBT/WXIX) - Women have come a long way in the workforce, but data from the Census Bureau makes it clear that we've still got a ways to go before female ...
Couples who use THIS one word have happier relationships, says a study  Times of IndiaAccording to a study, couples who use THIS one word while talking tend to share a blissful bond!
Marriage Advice For Healthy Relationships & Happiness For Couples | Mary Ellen Goggin Jerry Duberstein  YourTangoEvery married couple needs marriage advice in their relationship, especially if they find themselves unhappy, so here are 8 things that only the happiest married ...
Deal Breakers: Survey Reveals America's Biggest Issues in Relationships  InverseIf you could build the perfect relationship, what would it look like? Expectations for today's relationships are higher than ever. Relationship science suggests that ...
Here's How To Actually Let Go Of Relationship Baggage  mindbodygreen.comHow do you deal with emotional baggage when you find yourself in a new relationship? Here's what psychologists and therapists recommend.
A fear of regret can lock us into bad relationships, jobs and habits – here's how to break free  Irish ExaminerHow many times have you thought about starting a company, taking a year out to write that novel or leaving a loveless relationship but ended up doing nothing ...
How to Handle the End of a Business Relationship  LifehackerSince the journalism industry gets upended once a month or so, I consider myself an expert in business relationships—namely, what to do when you lose your ...
Topol hopes his review 'will repair patient and doctor relationships'  Digital HealthThe man behind the Topol Review has told Digital Health News the he hopes the document will rebuild relationships between patients and their doctors.
Katrina Kaif says 'I've had intense relationships; don't honestly know that I ever feel to date'  PINKVILLAKatrina Kaif talks about relationships, how she has never dated and what one should keep in mind when in a relationship.
The Real Reason Kendall Jenner Does Not Like Talking About Her Relationships  The Cheat SheetKendall Jenner is not the type to showcase relationships. Unlike her sisters, who share every aspect of their lives on with the world, Kendall Jenner is a little ...
ASK ZELDA: Our relationships expert Zelda West-Meads answers your questions  Daily MailI have always enjoyed my job but I now have a new boss who is very difficult to work for. He also has a short temper and gets irritated very easily. How do I ...
The Biggest Relationship Mistakes Can Happen Very Early  Psychology TodayWhen couples come to therapy to work on their relationship and present their problems, the therapist usually asks when these issues began. More often than not ...
How to tell if being single for a long time has made you bad at relationships  INSIDERThere's a difference between being lonely and being alone, and learning to be comfortable in solitude is vital for learning who you are.
10 Things Therapists Want You To Know About Communication In Relationships  BustleThere are many different factors that contribute to a relationship's success. But one thing that tends to get talked about more than anything else is communication ...
How Cheating Can Make Your Relationship Stronger  ELLE AustraliaNew studies reveal that cheating, or infidelity, can be the key to a happier, more long-lasting relationship and marriage... but is it true?
Shatta Wale gives tips on how to manage money and relationships  Pulse.com.ghDancehall sensation Shatta Wale has given his fans some tips on how to manage their investments and relationships.
How do I stop overthinking about my relationship?  Times of IndiaI am kind of restless and unhappy, and feel pressured for no reason. At times, I find it difficult to sleep at night as well. Should I go to a doctor.
Researchers find how to add more "love hormone" to your relationships  Big ThinkWith Valentine's Day upon us, are you looking for a way to bring more love into your relationship? Take an art class or pick up a new board game to play ...
How BioWare is handling relationships in Anthem  GamesRadarBioWare's Mark Darrah details the studio's decision to keep character interactions safe for work in Anthem. Comments. Shares. null. BioWare's Anthem game ...
Coach accused of having inappropriate relationship with student  WPECA coach at Seminole Ridge High School is accused of having an inappropriate relationship with a former student. School District Police arrested 36-year-old ...
How your smartphone is affecting your relationship  Science DailyThe allure of smartphones, and how they impact our interpersonal relationships, might be the result of our evolutionary history, according to researchers.
7 Ways To Level Up The Bonding In Your Relationship  BustleYou may associate bonding with your partner with the early stages of your relationship. But whether you're six months or six years in, there are always more ...
Are relationships better without social media?  QuartzBeing loud and proud about your significant other might actually spell trouble for your relationship.
The No. 1 Trap That Keeps People In Relationships With Psychopaths  mindbodygreen.comGratitude isn't always a good thing. Especially if you find yourself in a relationship with a psychopath, it can keep you trapped in your relationship.
What The Age You Were During Your First Relationship Says About You  BustleHow old were you during your first relationship? Whether it was a hand-holding middle school love, a head-over-heels college moment, or a ...
The 6 Best Books for a Healthy Relationship, According to Authors and Psychiatrists  New York MagazineListen: we're not suggesting you buy your significant other a book on how to achieve a healthier relationship for Valentine's Day. Chocolates or flowers will likely ...
The interplay between relationships, stress, and sleep  Science DailyA new study documents how the quality of a person's romantic relationship and the life stress he or she experiences at two key points in early adulthood (at age ...
Kendall Jenner Reveals Why She’s Private About Love Life & Why She Ends Most Relationships So Quickly  Hollywood LifeKendall Jenner discussed in a new interview why she has kept her relationships and dating life so private. Read details inside!
Having a 'she shed' or 'man cave' can strengthen your relationship - Bizwomen  The Business JournalsAnne Stych, Contributing Writer Feb 19, 2019, 8:05am EST. A 'she shed' or 'man cave' can strengthen your relationship. Getty Images (Westend61).
Relationships, money: Share truth about your finances with your partner  Myjoyonline.comHead of Marketing at Old Mutual Ghana, Rita Boateng is advising couples to share the truth about their finances with each other.
The 8 Most Common Signs of a Rebound Relationship  Men's HealthWe talked with sex therapist Vanessa Marin and Sadie Allison, PhD, a sexologist and relationship expert, to explain eight signs that your partner is rebounding ...
Tick tock: Commitment readiness predicts relationship success  Science DailyNew research shows how a person's readiness to commit predicts the success or failure of relationships.
4 Things You'll Notice If You're Ready To Take A Break From Your Relationship  Elite DailyIf you're at all familiar with any of the 236 episodes of Friends, you probably know one of the most notorious running gags of the show: "We were on a break!
'Property' Probes Ways People's Belongings Become Intertwined With Relationships  WBURHere & Now's Robin Young revisits her conversation with author Lionel Shriver about her 2018 book "Property: Stories Between Two Novellas."
5 relationship milestones that say it's going well  Myjoyonline.comIn a new relationship, you are always careful of what you say, do, and portray. It's just that both you and your partner will be treading the ground safely, since you ...
Big band breakups, and how they mirror relationship breakups  QuartzThere are lots of sad songs about the break-up of romances, but not many about the breakups of the bands who sing them. But bands are a lot like marriages ...
10 science-backed relationship deal breakers  Times of IndiaAccording to experts, deal breakers are more important than deal makers in shaping the course of a relationship.
A.B. details relationship with Steelers in AMA  NFL.comAntonio Brown watch-slash-stakeout is in full effect, and the Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver continues to contribute to the offseason drama of his making.
Your Office Politics Playbook: Relationships Are Your Goal At Work  ForbesOffice politics is usually viewed as a bad thing, but it doesn't have to be that way. This series of articles will outline the psychology of office politics, and show you ...
Who are Cheryl Cole's ex's? The Greatest Dancer star's past relationships revealed...  HELLO! MagazineCheryl has had a handful of whirlwind marriages and relationships since she appeared on our TV screen back in 2002. The star is a true romantic and has ...
Bipolar disorder and relationships: Everything you need to know  Medical News TodayBipolar disorder causes alterations in mood, leading to depressive and manic or hypomanic episodes. These changes in mood can sometimes put stress on a ...
Do couples who sleep in separate beds have it right?  QuartzOur conception of what is and isn't acceptable in long-term relationships has expanded tremendously in recent years. From consensual non-monogamy and ...
Five Tips To Sustaining A Long Distance Relationship  Guardian NigeriaA lot of people believe that long distance relationships are never going to work out. Your family may discourage it, and some of your friends will probably advise ...
6 Ways To Improve Your Relationship If Your Partner Is A Workaholic  HuffPostIf work-life balance is a constant struggle in your marriage or dating life, check out these experts' tips.
7 Disagreements That Are OK 6 Months Into A Relationship, But Not A Year In  BustleRelationships look a lot different as they progress. Despite this, you may still feel that having serious arguments only six months in could be a relationship kiss of ...
How to deal with gaslighting in relationships - at home and at work  Telegraph.co.uk'Gaslighting' is the relatively new term used to describe someone who manipulates another person into doubting their own sanity. It's a type of controlling and ...
Dolly Parton denies reports that she's in a same-sex relationship with her longtime best friend  Business Insider AustraliaDolly Parton has denied reports that she's gay and in a relationship with her childhood friend.
Common Relationship Deal Breakers and Red Flags  Cosmopolitan.comEveryone has some ultra-specific deal breaker that they refuse to ignore (pizza is NOT spicy, thank you very much). Take our polls to find out if you abide by the ...
Why many women settle in their romantic relationships  Toronto StarA survey by online dating app Bumble of 1003 Canadian women between 21 and 37 years old, found 23 per cent of them settle rather than continue their search ...
Will Meghan Markle's Relationship With Her Father Ever Be Repaired?  The Cheat SheetThe strained relationship between Meghan Markle and her father has made headlines countless times. In fact, hardly a week has gone by that at least one ...
Long-distance relationships actually make couples come closer: Study | The  Times of IndiaLong-distance relationships are generally termed 'challenging' and many couples feel such relationships are doomed to fail because of the lack of physical ...
The Pill ‘numbs a woman’s emotions and is harming relationships’  The SunWhile women on the Pill can tell if someone else is happy or scared, they're 10 per cent less likely to pick up on pride or contempt.
New Investigation Into 'Complex Web of Relationships' Between Russia and NRA Launched by Democratic Lawmakers  Newsweek"We are disturbed by the lack of transparency the NRA has demonstrated surrounding the December 2015 trip to Moscow,” Representatives Ted Lieu and ...
India's Relationship With Saudi Arabia Independent, Say Sources  NDTV NewsAs India steps up the diplomatic offensive against Pakistan after the Pulwama terror attack, the question that geopolitical observers are asking is whether ...
I can’t get past my strained relationship with my mother  The GuardianIt's time to leave the past behind and forge a new bond, and the first step should be yours, says Mariella Frostrup.
A Look Back at Miranda Lambert's Relationship History  The Cheat SheetCongratulations are in order! On February 16th, singer Miranda Lambert revealed that she had gotten married. “In honor of Valentine's Day, I wanted to share ...
Taylor Swift and Joe Alwyn's Complete Relationship History  The Cheat SheetTaylor Swift is somewhat of a relationship professional. The singer is always finding new relationships to be in and they are never flings . No, Swift likes her ...
Tigers in Glover's top five due to NBA pedigree & relationships  247SportsNiven Glover included Memphis in his top five, and he has built a strong relationship with Memphis assistant Mike Miller.
Birth controlled? Hormonal birth control effects on relationships  WJLABirth control pills may alter the way you choose and view your mate. And not in a good way. There's some science that suggests you're not yourself when you're ...
Looking At Relationships On Singles Awareness Day  PembinaValleyOnline.comValentine's Day can be a difficult time for some; February 15 is Singles Awareness Day and a counsellor at Pembina Counselling Centre says it should be an ...
Money & Relationships: What to do if your adult children ask for money  Economic TimesMoney is known to mar even the best of relationships. The conflict over cash could invade the privacy of spouses over something as innocuous as spending ...
What Cheating Looks Like in a Polyamorous Relationship  VICEWhen I first met my husband, he told me in no uncertain terms that he viewed kissing as cheating. So it might come as a surprise to hear that, ten years later, we ...
How Parkland parents and lawmakers built relationships to help prevent school violence  Miami HeraldA year after Parkland, Republican officials like Marco Rubio who were vilified at a town hall built close relationships with parents to tackle issues like school ...
Psychiatrist fails to stop inquiry over alleged relationship with patient  The Irish TimesConsultant psychiatrist asked High Court to halt a Medical Council Fitness to Practise inquiry.
What a long distance relationship taught me about Valentine's Day  British GQThere are two things that have taken a while to master in my love life: the long distance relationship I've been in for six years and Valentine's Day. A few years ...
Victims First launch 'Know this isn't Love' campaign over coercive control  Oxford MailA GROUP that supports victims of crime and abuse across Oxfordshire, Berkshire and Buckinghamshire, has launched a campaign to raise awareness of…
Money matters that can make or break your relationship  The Australian Financial ReviewMost relationships have their deal breakers. For women, handing over financial control to a partner who "might" know more about money should be one of them.
How to kiss: Utah's most-Googled relationship question  KUTV 2NewsFebruary tends to bring relationships (or the lack thereof) to the forefront of people's minds--and their Google searchbars. However, Utahns may be taking their ...
The relationships in 'Dev' are progressive: Actor Rakul Preet to TNM  The News MinuteRakul Preet, who was last seen in H Vinoth's Theeran Adhigaaram Ondru, is back in Tamil cinema after more than a year. Her upcoming romantic drama, Dev, ...
Everything Jennifer Aniston and Brad Pitt Have Said About Their Relationship, Divorce  Us WeeklyJennifer Aniston and Brad Pitt were once Hollywood's most beloved couple. Though it's been more than a decade — and a second divorce for both the Friends ...
For Valentine’s Day, a Vanderbilt biologist explains how animals love and what humans can learn from it  The TennesseanFor your Valentine's Day: A Vanderbilt biologist explains how animals cooperate with each other and what it can teach humans about getting along.
7 Signs Your Relationship Is Messing With Your Friendships  HuffPostHow to know if your romantic relationship is ruining your friendships, according to therapists.
Boruto: 25 Wild Revelations About Boruto And Sarada's Relationship  Screen RantBoruto: Naruto Next Generations features a complicated dynamic between Boruto and Sarada.
Dealing with a heartbreak? Zagreb's 'Museum of Broken Relationships' is for you  Times NowZagreb's Museum of Broken Relationships is not a regular museum. While it collects objects from the past, the ones on display have a direct connection to ...
How the Democrats plan to revive the special relationship after Trump  Spectator.co.ukLast weekend's Munich Security Conference could perhaps best be summarised by two sentences in the 102-page report produced by a group of Western…
How Does Meghan Markle and Kate Middleton's Relationship Compare to Fergie and Diana's?  The Cheat SheetRoyal sisters-in-law Meghan Markle and Kate Middleton are two of the most photographed and influential women in the entire world. Some believe they are the ...
China and Australia's political relationship enters year of living anxiously  The Australian Financial ReviewNo matter what happens to on-again, off-again trade wars between China and the US, the political relationship between China and Australia has already ...
Celebrating healthy relationships, more inclusive, no objectification: What Hindu College Hostel’s V-Day  Times of IndiaFor years, the Virgin Tree in Hindu College has been the symbol of love and romance. Generations of students have been offering puja at the tree on Fe.
'I got retrenched and it took a toll on my relationship' - on money and intimacy  CapeTalkMoney is one of the top causes of relationship fights and divorce. Dr Eve and callers discuss how it can affect sexual intimacy.
Big Barda and Mister Miracle have a loving relationship with plenty of sex  SYFY WIREFinding depictions of stable and healthy relationships in comics can sometimes leave one grasping at straws, but when they happen, they stick out for a reason.
The 5 Books That Helped Me Leave An Emotional Abusive Relationship  BustleI have to go." This line in Natalie Appleton's memoir I Have Something to Tell You mimicked my own thoughts as I lay awake every night in the same bed — but a ...
Mandy Moore addresses Ryan Adams relationship, new music  Alternative PressMandy Moore has opened up about the "unhealthy dynamic" she had with Ryan Adams and how their relationship brought her career to a halt.
A Visit to the Museum of Broken Relationships  Atlas ObscuraOne of the most unusual museums in Croatia is the Museum of Broken Relationships in Zagreb. The collection traces its origins to a real-life breakup, between ...
Six signs your relationship isn't working this Valentine's Day  The StandardFebruary 14 is the most romantic time of the year - but is your relationship actually working?
David and Victoria Beckham: A Timeline of Their Relationship  Us WeeklyDavid and Victoria Beckham's relationship began more than 20 years ago and is still going strong — relive their romantic journey!
3 Ways to Know If You Should Stay or Leave a Relationship  Thrive GlobalIt's not always easy to know when it's the right time to call it quits. If you're on the fence about breaking up, this relationship expert wants you to ask yourself these ...
The perfect Valentine’s Day gift for different stages of a relationship  Times of IndiaWhat you gift your loved one on Valentine's Day depends a lot on the kind of relationship you have with him or her. A thoughtful gift can determine the fate of a ...
Sharing Netflix, Spotify Accounts After Couples Break Up  NPRSharing of online streaming video and music passwords among sweethearts is a territorial marker, like wearing a boyfriend's sweater. But what happens to ...
How to rekindle a relationship: The biggest sex mistakes for couples  TODAYWant to rekindle the spark in your long term relationship? Dr. Ruth shares how to have better sex and the biggest sex mistakes couples make.
"How going off grid rebooted my relationship"  cosmopolitan.com (UK)My husband and I have what I think is a pretty good marriage. We're best mates, we love each other dearly, and we have a shared passion for dark ...
Malcolm Rewa claims he had a relationship with Susan Burdett  Newstalk ZBOn the seventh day of Malcolm Rewa's third trial he took the stand as a witness to testify in his own defence over the killing of Susan Burdett. He claims.
Age Matters: Patient-doctor relationship depends on communication  Roanoke TimesDear Dr. Camardi,. I must be doing something wrong. ... My new doctor here in Palm Springs ain't worth anything because he rushes through what he wants to ...
Your smartphone is killing your relationship — and evolution is to blame  MarketWatchLove & Money is a new MarketWatch series looking at how issues surrounding money impact our relationships with significant others, friends and family.
Are you having an 'almost' relationship? You need to read this  Times of IndiaThe world of love and dating is already complicated and matters turn worse when you are in an 'almost' relationship. Wondering what is an 'almost' relationship?

Revenge ? Serve It Cold!

Whether you caught him in bed with the local bimbo,... Read More

Communication Is The Key To A Lasting Relationship

"If you are trying to find ways to lead a... Read More

When Attracting Sexy Women, Remember... Time And Circumstance Change Everything

Many guys are just too intimidated and full of anxiety... Read More

The Fine Art of Flirting

Did you know that it is not necessarily your looks... Read More

Are You Really Ready For a Relationship?

So often I hear, I want a boyfriend, I'm married... Read More

Relationship Advice: How to Ignore Your Spouse or Partner

Marriage can be one of the quickest and most effective... Read More

Relationship Advice: Closeness and Connection

In my work with couples, certain themes have emerged that... Read More

Why Men Cheat

"Big, little or short or tall, Wish I could have... Read More

Improve Your Relationship by Taking Care of Yourself First

It's important for you to take care of yourself before... Read More

Diamond Promise Rings ? For When You Mean It

Diamond promise rings are quite common, but many are not... Read More

He Said, She Said

The Relationship TriangleMost people get involved in a relationship for... Read More

Apologizing When We Hurt Our Friends or Partners

In every relationship there will be occasional misunderstandings and hurt... Read More

7 Myths About Good Guys

It is every woman's dream to meet a "Good Guy"... Read More

Relationship Advice: Grieving Before Going On

Q. I got married for the first time when I... Read More

The Three Rings of Relationships

Glenna Trout is an international authority on face reading whose... Read More

Conflicts Dont Have to Mean a Fight to the Death

Although conflict in marriage is inevitable, fighting is optional.The secret... Read More

Adultery as Sexual Addiction: Should You Stay Married?

I outline 7 kinds of affairs in my E-book, "Break... Read More

Want To Strengthen Your Relationship

Open your mouth. What do I mean? Talk ? say... Read More

Q & A: Reuniting With a Lost Love

>1. Who are the prime candidates to rekindle a romance?The... Read More

Do You Enable?

We all have behaviors, tendencies, patterns, and the keen ability... Read More

Five Easy Steps to Creating Your Dream Relationship

Millions of singles across the world are looking to create... Read More

Energize Your Relationship By Celebrating Hoodie-Hoo Day February 20th

What is Hoodie-Hoo Day and what does it have to... Read More

Second Time Around the Block

Divorce happens. I'm not going to debate the causes or... Read More

The Womans Guide to Younger Men

I often awake to find Beverly, my older wife, wrapped... Read More

Reaching the Ultimate Level in Human Relationships

I want to tell you a little story. Not about... Read More