Relationship Advice: After the Break Up - Creating an Exit Door in Your Heart

Q. It's been over a year since the guy I thought I would be married to broke up with me. He said he was just scared to make the commitment. I felt like I tried really hard and did the best I could in this one. Sometimes it feels like just yesterday. I can't seem to get over this no matter how hard I try. I'm afraid that there will never be anyone else that I can get that close to or who will understand me. I keep trying to figure out where I went wrong.

A. A year is a long time to feel bad, and usually much longer than is necessary.

I'm going to guess about a few things that might be going on here.

Reliving the relationship

Many times when a person is still feeling as bad as you do more than a year later, it's because you've spent the last year reliving the relationship. This comes in the form of trying to figure out exactly what went wrong, fueled by the inaccurate belief that if you could just figure out exactly what went wrong, then you could let go.

The reality is that spending so much time trying to figure out what went wrong keeps you attached to the relationship and prevents you from moving on.

Relationships are messy things, and many times we can never really know exactly what went wrong.

Our brains are very obedient at times. If you keep asking your brain to figure out what you did wrong, it's going to search for all kinds of reasons, and you are going to wind up feeling like a failure.

My guess is while the relationship failed, you did not.

If you are with someone who is just not ready to commit, you cannot fail.

This is because when there is no possibility of success, you simply cannot fail.

Differences between men and women

I'm about to speak in general about the differences between men and women, which is always a dangerous thing. But here goes: In general, men have two doors to their hearts, one marked enter and one marked exit. Women don't have an exit door to their hearts, which makes getting over someone much more difficult.

Creating an exit door

You need to create an exit door in your heart and then show this guy, and the pain and hurt, right out the door.

Relationships end.

If the desired outcome and measure of success is a committed marriage, then all the other relationships before marriage are failed relationships.

But if you handled yourself well, feel good about your behavior and choices, and even used what you learned in other relationships in this one, then you were successful.

Consider what you learned in this relationship that you can use to make the next one(s) better.

If you learned what a commitment-challenged guy looks like and that these relationships don't work out, then it was time well spent.

Make a list of all the things you learned from this one that will help you in the future.

Since this guy was too scared to commit, then he did you a favor by breaking up with you. Marriage to a commitment-challenged person is a disaster and a divorce looking for a place to happen.

Here's a fun little trick to help show this guy out the exit door of your heart:

Imagine a picture of the relationship in your mind. It feels like it's right out in front of you, a few inches from your face, and difficult to see past. Take that picture and imagine moving it off to the side of you, out of view. Feels better, doesn't it?

Practice this and you will be able to show him the exit door to your heart, and soon, you will picture it behind you altogether.

And then you will be ready to move on.

Leading relationship expert Jeff Herring is a Relationship Coach, Speaker, and Nationally Syndicated Relationship columnist.

You can read more practical tips, common sense relationship advice and occasional humor at his website

In The News:

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at

ASAE's Marketing, Membership, Communications Conference Emphasized Importance of Relationships, Leadership ...
PR Newswire (press release)
WASHINGTON, May 24, 2018 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- Nearly 950 association executives and industry partners gathered together to learn new strategies to build stronger relationships with their members at ASAE's Marketing, Membership, ...

Inside Higher Ed

Academe sees a new wave of faculty-student relationship ...
Inside Higher Ed
A number of colleges and universities banned faculty-undergraduate dating or otherwise shored up their consensual relationship policies after the Education ...

and more »


Cary Medical Center to Host Conference PTSD and Relationships
Caribou, ME-- The Meo Bosse Detachment 1414 Marine Corps League will sponsor an all-day conference on Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and Relationships at Cary Medical Center on Saturday June 2nd from 8:30 am – 3:00 pm. The conference will ...

The Sun

Here's why short girls and tall men have the best relationships, according to a new study
The Sun
Here's why short girls and tall men have the best relationships, according to a new study. Turns out, it's all down to evolution. By Lydia Hawken. 24th May 2018, 2:34 pm. Updated: 24th May 2018, 5:41 pm. ARE you a short girl who loves a tall guy? Well ...
Best Relationships Are Between Short Girls And Tall Men, Claims StudyLADbible

all 3 news articles »


Ariana Grande Has an Important Reminder for People in Toxic Relationships
Yahoo Lifestyle
Though we do not know exactly what Grande's relationship with Miller was like, boundaries are often hard to set with loved ones struggling with addiction. According to Psychology Today blogger John F. Kelly, Ph.D., boundaries are essential when ...
Ariana Grande Calls Mac Miller Relationship "Toxic" & "Scary"Refinery29
Ariana Grande Reveals Mac Miller Relationship Grew 'Toxic' and 'ScaryComplex
Ariana Grande Calls Relationship with Mac Miller 'Toxic'Papermag -Twitter -Twitter
all 141 news articles »

The County

Conference to highlight PTSD and relationships
The County
CARIBOU, Maine — The Meo Bosse Detachment 1414 Marine Corps League will sponsor an all-day conference on post-traumatic stress disorder and relationships at Cary Medical Center on Saturday, June 2. Slated from 8:30 a.m. to 3 p.m., the conference ...


Going To ISTE? 9 Educators Share How Entrepreneurs Can Build Relationships With Teachers
The ISTE Conference and Expo is an essential part of the education system that spans the globe. It is the most extensive educational based technology conference in the world. ISTE stands for International Society for Technology in Education. ISTE is a ... (blog)

15 Relationship Quotes That'll Give You All of the Warm Fuzzies (blog)
Whether you've been married for decades or are in a brand new relationship, these quotes about love and relationships will give you serious butterflies. Share these romantic messages with the your significant other to remind them just how much they ...

KDLT News (blog)

Sioux Falls Police Department Builds Better Relationships in the Community
KDLT News (blog)
“I build relationships with the citizens of sioux falls, different organizations, different religions, different groups of people,” said Officer Lieuwen. Lieuwen is one of two community resource officers with the Sioux Falls Police Department. They ...

Pretty 52

New Study Claims Short Girls And Tall Men Make The Best Relationships
Pretty 52
No, this has nothing to do with his undercarriage - we're talking about height because apparently the best relationships form between short gals and tall fellas. Studies show that the taller the husband and the more inches between him and his wife ...

Google News

Unprofessional Conduct

Direct Answers - Column for the week of June 14,... Read More

Be Glad That There?s Quarrel in Your Relationship

Is your love relationship smooth? Have the both of you... Read More

Does a Woman Want a Strong Christian Man?

Most women say they want a strong religious man who... Read More

Its Your Fault I Had An Affair!

When you read it like that, out of context, you'd... Read More

Getting an Exciting Life After a Break Up

Breaking up.The End. The journey is over. You feel rejected.... Read More

A Look at Interracial Relationships

There's something about America, our history, our values or maybe... Read More

Five Telltale Signs That A Role Reversal Relationship Could Be Right For You

Powerful, accomplished women intimidate some men, but fascinate others. If... Read More

Single in a Couples World

Advertising for St. Valentine's Day seemed more relentless than ever... Read More

Improve Your Relationships Through Vastu

Do you want be in a relationship that brings you... Read More

Jewish Dating: It Pays to Date Other Like-Minded People

Searching for the perfect mate can be one of life's... Read More

Relationships That Really Last: Is This the Secret?

In my e-book, How to Build Relationships That Stick, I... Read More

Want To Strengthen Your Relationship

Open your mouth. What do I mean? Talk ? say... Read More

Conflict In Faith

Direct Answers - Column for the week of July 19,... Read More

Rekindling An Old Flame

Dr. Nancy Kalish, a psychology professor at California State University,... Read More

27 Characteristics of Loving Men

Every woman dreams of meeting that special man that knows... Read More

Setting Boundaries: Business Clients and Boyfriends

Setting boundaries is necessary in any human relationship.Whether you're dealing... Read More

If You Cannot Make Friends, Make Foes

There are few desires (if any) stronger than the deep... Read More

Wow, Grandma Is Dating!

Wow, Grandma Is Dating!When Lena, 52, began dating, her son,... Read More

10 Fast Ways to Re-ignite the Flames of Love

Enhance Romance today.When Men and Women enter into a relationship,... Read More

Tom Cruise & Katie Holmes--Celebrity Romance

Actors Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes are having a hard... Read More

Home For The Holidays: Start That Conversation

Annie waited too long to have that talk with her... Read More

Relationship Conflict: The 3 Cs of Resolving Conflict

"And they lived happily ever after.........."Yeah right.Perhaps I'm a little... Read More

Love is not Something you Say, Its Something you Do

Many have problems with communication and using that "love" word.... Read More

To Love Forever

Emotionally healthy men and women almost always share their lives... Read More

Why You Should Be Happy You Caught Your Partner Cheating

The dictionary defines infidelity as "unfaithfulness to a sexual partner".... Read More