A Common Sense Approach to Religious Freedom

Down through the centuries and all over the world, the battle for religious freedom has been a bitter one. The United States has been no exception. Although most of those who founded this country came here seeking religious freedom, it has been a source of contention from the beginning and remains so today. There are fanatics on both sides of this issue. On one side, we have those who think their religious freedom is being violated if they are not allowed to force their religion down everyone else's throat. One the other side, we have those who believe it's their inalienable right to never be exposed to any element of religious life. Both extremes are wrong. Government should be neither hostile to any religion nor an enforcer of it. Instead, those who possess common sense should be capable of assenting to a happy medium.

Contrary to popular belief, the phrase, "separation of church and state", cannot be found in the U.S. Constitution. That phrase is misleading anyway as many people interpret it as "protection of the state from the church." Most of our Founding Fathers frequently, and often publicly, expressed their faith in a Creator, so it should be obvious to anyone that they never intended to banish expressions of religious faith from the public square. Any separation of church and state that they had in mind was to serve only four major functions: (1) allow people to freely practice the religion of their choice (or no religion at all) without interference from the state, (2) forbid any religion or denomination from being set up as the "state church", (3) prevent the state from having the church do its bidding, and (4) protect the church from being regulated and having its practices dictated to it by the state. From these principles, I think we can derive a common sense approach to religious freedom.

Our common sense approach should allow for verbal religious expression and for the display of religious symbols and materials in public and government venues. Although all religions should have equal access and rights regarding those expressions and displays, the majority religion would obviously have a major advantage here. But so be it. No one would be hurt or forced to practice any religion against his or her will. If anyone is offended, that's their problem. No one has a right to not be offended, although many people think they have this right. Being offended once in a while is the price one has to pay for living in a free and open society. If someone has a major problem with that, they are free to leave this country any time they wish.

Our common sense approach should also allow for limited amounts of prayer and religious teaching in public schools. It should not be the focus of any public school, but it should be permitted and based on the religion favored by the majority of the parents in a given school district. The majority of parents could opt for no prayer or religious teaching at all in a given school district, if they so desired. All parents would have the option of not having their child (children) participate in or be present for the prayer and religious teaching. Although the teaching of evolution would still be mandatory, creationism could be taught as part of any religious curriculum.

Another tenet of our common sense approach would be to make sure that all religious speech, no matter how offensive or "hateful" some people might find it, is always safeguarded. We do not want to follow Canada's lead of coding political correctness into law and banning some forms of religious speech. For example, in some parts of Canada, a person can be fined or jailed for proclaiming that homosexual activity is sinful. Too many people don't want to hear sin called sin anymore, but we must make sure that people always have the right to condemn anything that their religion says is wrong. This even includes the right of a Muslim, for example, to denounce our culture. As long as someone doesn't yell "fire" in a crowded theater, explicitly threaten anyone, or call for someone else to do harm, their speech should be protected.

Another element of our common sense approach to religious freedom would be to prohibit any laws (1) that are based solely on religious beliefs and (2) that punish those who do not follow them. For example, laws ordering that stores be closed on Sunday should be banned. Now, just because some law correlates with someone's religious belief doesn't mean it should be invalidated. Many valid laws, even those against murder, correspond to religious commandments. What I'm talking about are laws that exist expressly for furthering a religion. The state has no right to enforce anyone's religious beliefs, even those of the majority religion. Besides, what's the use of forcing someone to obey religious laws? Does it make them any more righteous? Does it make the community or the nation any more righteous? I don't think so.

The final component to our common sense approach would be to ensure that we protect speech or entertainment that might be offensive to any particular religion or even religion in general. Once again, no one has a right to not be offended. Many fundamentalist Christians are so outraged by anti-Christian speech or entertainment that they would like to see it banned, censored, or at least driven from the airwaves. However, if we're going to have unlimited freedom to promote our religion, then others should have unlimited freedom to demean it. If we don't allow the free exercise of anti-religious speech, we are not much better than an Islamic theocracy and we are not practitioners of true religious freedom. Besides, if one's religion can't hold up in the face of criticism, it is evidently quite weak anyway.

Terry Mitchell is a software engineer, freelance writer, and trivia buff from Hopewell, VA. He also serves as a political columnist for American Daily and operates his own website - http://www.commenterry.com - on which he posts commentaries on various subjects such as politics, technology, religion, health and well-being, personal finance, and sports. His commentaries offer a unique point of view that is not often found in mainstream media.

In The News:

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at https://news.google.com/news

Religion News Service

Redefining religious freedom as religious privilege
Religion News Service
(RNS) — The First Amendment Defense Act. It's a name that Big Brother would be proud of, seemingly plucked from the bowels of the Ministry of Truth in George Orwell's “1984.” The Senate bill is not the bulwark its name suggests but the latest salvo in ...


Religion News Service

Religion News Service appoints G. Jeffrey MacDonald as interim Editor-in-Chief
Religion News Service
COLUMBIA, Mo. — Religion News Service, a news agency dedicated to secular coverage of religion, ethics, and spirituality, welcomes G. Jeffrey MacDonald as interim editor-in-chief. An award-winning journalist and author who has written for Religion ...


Religion News Service

My open letter to Natalie Portman
Religion News Service
Where some of my eighteen-year-old friends spend their nights in bunkers sleeping with their helmets on. Where security guards are the only jobs in surplus. Where my grandparents were not born, but where they were saved. Where political parties ...
Israelis lament Natalie Portman dropping out of Genesis PrizeThe Jerusalem Post
Natalie Portman on Instagram: “My decision not to attend the Genesis Prize ceremony has been mischaracterized by ...Instagram
Natalie Portman snubs 'Jewish Nobel,' angering Israeli leadersNBCNews.com

all 122 news articles »

Religion News Service

Who owns “never again”?
Religion News Service
Ever since the mass shooting at Marjorie Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida, many student activists and their allies have used the following phrase: “Never again!” To be clear: for decades, “never again!” has been associated with the ...

and more »

Psychology Today (blog)

The Handmaid's Tale, Feminism, and the Dangers of Religion
Psychology Today (blog)
The Hulu series The Handmaid's Tale launches its second season tomorrow. Although it is based on Margaret Atwood's novel of the same name, the first season ended where the book did—so the second season will almost necessarily go beyond it. Where they ...

and more »

Religion News Service

Father: Sick UK child surviving after life support withdrawn
Religion News Service
LONDON (AP) — The father of a terminally ill British toddler said the child is surviving after being taken off life support, surprising doctors who had argued he should be allowed to die. Tom Evans said that his 23-month-old son, Alfie, survived for ...

and more »

BU Today

Scholar of Religion Nancy Ammerman to Retire | BU Today | Boston ...
BU Today
Sociologist Nancy Ammerman is retiring after 15 years at BU.

and more »

Irish Examiner

Religion teaching jobs 'swept away' | Irish Examiner
Irish Examiner
Making religion an optional subject for students at hundreds of second-level schools has forced trainee teachers to look for work abroad, an educationalist has warned. Minister Richard Bruton: Made religion an optional subject. Education Minister ...

and more »

Religion News Service

Willow Creek responds to new allegations against former pastor ...
Religion News Service
SOUTH BARRINGTON, Ill. (RNS) – The elders of Willow Creek Community Church are pledging to renew their investigation of the church's former pastor, Bill Hybels, as more allegations of inappropriate conduct with women surface.

and more »

Sports Illustrated

Ex-Dolphins cheerleader alleges religion and gender discrimination
ABC News
A former Miami Dolphins cheerleader has a filed a complaint against the NFL and the team, alleging she was discriminated against because of her religion and gender. In the complaint with the Florida Commission on Human Relations, Kristan Ann Ware says ...
Former NFL Cheerleaders Offer to Settle for $1 and a Meeting With GoodellNew York Times

all 16 news articles »
Google News

Rebuilding Society and The Tax Protest Movement: Part Three

Part Three continuedIt is important to recover and relearn the... Read More

3 Clues To Know Where You Fit In Ministry Part 1

Clue Number 1: You Have TalentYou were born with at... Read More

Knowing Hinduism or Hindu Religion

Hindus are concentrated in India, Nepal and Sri Lanka and... Read More

The Rise And Fall Of Babylon

According to the Book of Revelations, the city of Babylon... Read More

The New Heaven And New Earth

Now that Satan, all of his fallen angels and all... Read More

Religion has Served Its Usefulness for Mankind

As the world becomes closer and closer together, there seems... Read More

War of the Worlds: Signs of the End of the Age

Jesus said there'd be days like this.The disciples came to... Read More

We Must Be Ready. But How?

Revelation 19:7 states, "Let us rejoice and give honor unto... Read More

Following In the Masters Footsteps

In these interesting times of change, millions of people the... Read More

Do We Really Need God?

The human being is endowed with ability. We have the... Read More

Fellowship Forever

Today I would like to share with you the word... Read More

Let Her Be Covered Part Three

Now, let's recall again the text: "Let her be covered."... Read More

The Power of Stories and Testimonies

As I am sure you all can tell by now,... Read More

Jihad

Jesus spoke as much about Heaven as He did about... Read More

The Emmaus Journal ~ Strangers In A Strange Land

The Emmaus Journal Strangers In A Strange LandDo you often... Read More

Cut Off Your Hand!

Cut off your Hand!Arguably the most bizarre command of Christ... Read More

Christian Book Stores are a Great Indicator of the Popularity of the Religion in Demography

Have you ever wondered how exactly would someone find out... Read More

Amos and Social Justice - Part 1

Amos was a shepherd who lived in the region of... Read More

Popping the Balloon of Belief

I'm really excited. I just got a bigger soapbox, and... Read More

Top Ten Religion Quotations

Review your religious beliefs with these revealing quotations all about... Read More

Who Me? Wear a Clerical Shirt?

Clothing says a great deal about one's profession, and this... Read More

Prophetic Ministry: Affirmations From Scripture to Teach Us Who We Are In Christ

To learn who you are in Christ, you must know... Read More

How to Solve a Wonderful Mystery

The first issue we must recognize is the way God... Read More

Serving

Some people may ask how do we serve God and... Read More

End Time Events and the 2nd Coming of Jesus

In part 1 of this series of end time articles,... Read More