Lies, Damn Lies and Mutual Fund Returns

How many times has this happened to you? You're at a social function and the conversation turns to investing. Pretty soon, people are comparing how well their investments are doing. As you might imagine, being an investment advisor this happens to me a lot. However, I recently had an experience with it that startled me.

Bob, one of the guys I was chatting with at a party, asked what kind of returns I had made for my clients with my methodical no load mutual fund strategy during the past year. I replied that they had unrealized gains of slightly over 29%, after management fees, for the 8 months that we were invested.

Bob countered with a smirk that he had made a 40% return. I raised my eyebrows and told him that was darn good-and suggested that maybe he ought to be managing my money. At that point we were interrupted and, as the evening went on, I began to wonder exactly how Bob had gotten his great return.

I cornered him a little later on and, upon digging a little deeper, the story looked somewhat different. Yes, he had made a 40% return on a mutual fund he had some money invested in, however, we were comparing apples and bananas.

He had a total portfolio of $100k. Being cautious, he had invested only $10k into a mutual fund, from which he profited $4k after he sold it. The balance of his portfolio ($90k) was sitting in a money market fund earning some 0.35% per year.

So, while he had made 40% on 10% of his investment, he had only made 4.35% on his whole portfolio. My methodology was also focused on protecting my clients' investments and it had increased their entire portfolio 29% (unrealized). That would be an apple to apple comparison when measuring my returns against his. Bob's one fund realized 40% return. However, had I approached it the same way Bob had, I could have described one of the funds I used that had realized over 49% for the same period.

Actually, Bob's not-so-good-news story didn't stop there. Bob admitted to having followed the losing Buy and Hope strategy through the bear market of 2000 and had finally sold out at a 50% loss a year ago, before committing $10k to a mutual fund investment.

I was pleased to be able to tell him that my methodology had gotten my clients out of the market before the bear took his big bite, and they suffered only minimal losses before finding safety in money markets accounts. And when my trend tracking figures directed us to move back into the market, they still had most of their money poised to start earning for them again-which it did and very nicely, thank you.

The moral of the story is to look past the surface and don't take any numbers thrown at you at face value. Remember, most people returning from a weekend in Las Vegas will shout about their winnings and mumble about their losses.

About The Author

Ulli Niemann is an investment advisor and has been writing about objective, methodical approaches to investing for over 10 years. He eluded the bear market of 2000 and has helped countless people make better investment decisions. To find out more about his approach and his FREE Newsletter, please visit: www.successful-investment.com.

[email protected]

In The News:

Here are the mutual fund favourites in April  MoneycontrolMaximum month-on-month change in value was seen in TCS, ICICI Bank and Kotak Mahindra Bank.
Sebi allows mutual funds in exchange traded commodity derivatives  Economic TimesNEW DELHI: The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) on Tuesday allowed mutual funds to participate in exchange-traded commodity derivatives ...
A young investor’s guide to mutual funds  Economic TimesMany young investors, who are barely a year or two old in their career, are eager to start investing in mutual funds. ETMutualFunds.com receive many queries on ...
Quant funds are suitable for savvy investors with equity portfolio  Business StandardA few fund houses are in the process of launching quant-based schemes to remove human bias in stock-picking. DSP Mutual Fund's (MF's) DSP Quant Fund ...
Large cap index mutual funds continue to outshine actively-managed large cap schemes  Economic TimesLarge cap index funds are outperforming the actively-managed large cap mutual fund schemes in the past one-year period. Kotak NV 20 ETF is topping the ...
Vetri Subramaniam, UTI Mutual Fund, talks about which stock segments he favours now  Economic TimesIndia's growth trajectory has been consistent over the past two decades and many firms have performed well across cycles, Vetri Subramaniam, Group President ...
Holding of mutual funds in private lenders at a fresh high in April  Business StandardThe holding of mutual funds (MFs) in private banks saw its weightage increase to a new high of 19.3 per cent in April — the seventh straight month of increase.
Should you invest in DSP Quant Fund NFO?  LivemintDSP Quant Fund to select stocks based on pre-determined rules to eliminate bias.The NFO of DSP Quant Fund will remain open till 3 June.
I want to invest Rs 1 crore in stocks and mutual funds for 5 years. How should I invest?  Economic TimesYou may consider the following asset allocation: 40% in large-caps; 40% in large and mid-cap, or multi-caps; and remaining 20% in mid- and small-cap funds.
Time to shop? 150 stocks at attractive valuations vs historical levels  MoneycontrolOnce short-term uncertainty subsides, investors are likely to chase value. Attractive levels are starting to emerge in the midcap universe and select opportunities ...
Stocks vs Mutual Funds: Which is a Better Option to Invest?  EntrepreneurStocks and Mutual Funds have their own set of hiccups, which are better to know before making your investments.
Hot and Cold Stocks of Mutual Funds in April 2019  MoneylifeIn April 2019, Larsen & Toubro and Hindustan Petroleum Corporation(HPCL) were the most preferred stocks of Indian mutual funds.
Retail Investors Should Take Exposure To Midcap Stocks Through Mutual Fund Route: Ankit Jain, Mirae Asset Global Investments  BW BusinessworldIn an interview with BW Businessworld, Ankit Jain, Fund Manager, Mirae Asset Global Investments (India), talks about Consumption led funds, lending rates and ...
How concentrated is your mutual fund portfolio?  LivemintA concentrated portfolio can backfire badly if the fund manager's strategy goes wrong.A portfolio with few stocks can fall sharply if share prices of most stocks in ...
Indians won’t invest in stocks, debt till election 2019 ends  QuartzInvestors in India are waiting the election out. In April, inflows into equity mutual funds (MFs) dipped to their lowest levels since January 2017, according to data ...
MF holdings of auto stocks at record low: Motilal Oswal study  BusinessLineMutual funds' holdings of auto sector stocks stood at a record low in April, finds a study by broking house Motilal Oswal Securities. The weightage of the auto ...
Why do wealth managers recommend multi cap mutual funds?  Economic TimesMany wealth managers believe multi-cap funds are a good starting point for long-term investors, specially those using SIPs for wealth creation.
Stay away from stock tips  LivemintIf taming the stock market was easy, everyone would do it.Losing money in market is real and facing volatility is part of the deal.
How to play likely Modi victory? Analysts say midcaps may shine  LivemintMumbai: A battered corner of India's $2.1 trillion stock market -- mid-cap shares -- may be ready to shine after exit polls in India signaled a second term for Prime ...
Closing Bell: Nifty holds 11,700, Sensex falls 382 points; Tata Motors loses 7%  Moneycontrol.comMarket Close: Indian indices fell 1 percent as they failed to maintain the strong up move which was recorded on May 20, on the back on exit polls for Lok Sabha ...
How Vanguard Patented a Way to Avoid Taxes on Mutual Funds  BloombergControversial heartbeat trades help the funds avoid taxable gains.
Regulatory forebearance: For the greater good  Economic TimesIn the Essel and IL&FS cases, mutual funds have sought leniency to ensure the net asset values of their units dont plunge.
Financial planners recommend new fund from Mirae Mutual Fund  Economic TimesConsistent performance of the existing equity mutual fund schemes at Mirae has prompted financial planners to suggest the Mirae Asset Focused Fund to ...
Equity funds record highest ever exposure in banking stocks in March 2019  Business TodayAs per the latest data available from the SEBI, overall deployment of equity funds in bank stocks grew around 52 per cent year-on-year (y-o-y) in the month ...
We have already done a course correction in Aditya Birla Frontline Equity  LivemintA Balasubramanian speaks about the performance of Aditya Birla Sun Life AMC's flagship schemes, the situation in debt funds, and more.NBFC exposure was ...
What political leaders invest in: Mutual funds, Reliance shares and even Kingfisher Airlines  Economic TimesShares of Mukesh Ambani- led Relaince can be found in the portfolios of several leaders.
What Type of Mutual Fund Schemes Should You Invest in? Know Here  News18Equity funds are mutual funds which invest majorly in equity stocks of listed companies. They are considered to be risky but they tend to give higher returns in the ...
IT, pharma and telecom top sectoral picks for MFs in April  Economic TimesFund managers have been sellers in select public sector companies.
How to Choose Between ETFs and Mutual Funds  U.S. News & World ReportInvestors can add either mutual funds or ETFs to their portfolio.
7 High-Dividend Mutual Funds to Buy Now  U.S. News & World ReportHigh-dividend mutual funds are a popular choice among people seeking to receive current income on their investments. "In good economic times, dividends ...
5 Mutual Funds to Buy on Demand for Lower-Cost Funds  NasdaqMutual fund investors in the United States tend to invest more of their mutual fund assets in lower-cost funds, a report by the Investment Company.
Look who is sitting on a cash pile to buy stocks after election result  Economic TimesMUMBAI: The domestic equity market is likely to trade in a narrow range until the election results, with foreign fund flows slowing down and mutual funds opting ...
Mutual Fund Update: Stocks that attracted fund managers in April 2019  Dalal Street Investment JournalIf we look at the March 2019 data, then the energy sector was the one that featured on top of the buying done by the fund managers. However, the story in the ...
What Makes Berkshire Hathaway Shares Better Than an Actively Managed Mutual Fund?  Motley FoolTo start with, the company is a lot more than Warren Buffett's carefully selected stock portfolio.
Stop! Too many stocks, mutual funds are not good for you; Buying too many may not get you more  The Financial ExpressHandling the overall risk of investments is crucial, but not at the cost of not meeting your financial goals. Over-diversification can do this.
A Hated Wall Street Strategy Helps This 88-Year-Old Fund Beat the Market  BloombergAt least one investor is winning with Wall Street's worst-performing trade. While cheaper stocks have underperformed in the last decade, Eaton Vance ...
Swedes Become World Champions With 100% Stashing Cash in Funds  BloombergSwedes are the world champions in mutual fund saving. In fact, when including the privatized part of the government pension fund system, 100% of working ...
Shadow banks feel sting as mutual funds cut exposure  Economic TimesMF investments in commercial paper and bonds dropped to Rs 3.24 lakh crore at the end of March.
Yes Bank plummets 29% in a day; Is it a value buy now?  Economic TimesMUMBAI: Shares of Yes Bank plunged 29% on Tuesday after reporting its first ever quarterly loss, leading to an erosion of Rs 16,000 crore in market ...
People Want to Buy Uber Stock  Bloomberg“Uber IPO Is Oversubscribed by Day Two of Roadshow,” it says here, but I would say that Uber Technologies Inc.'s initial public offering was oversubscribed by ...
Stocks in the news: YES Bank, Bharti Airtel, Federal Bank, Bharat Road, Reliance Capital and ICICI Bank  Economic TimesL&T's software arm LTI will be hiring around 3800 freshers this fiscal.
Best And Worst Of Q2 2019: Industrials ETFs And Mutual Funds  Seeking AlphaThe Industrials sector ranks seventh in Q2'19. Based on an aggregation of ratings of 426 stocks in the Industrials sector. ITB is our top-rated Industrials sect.
3 Invesco Mutual Funds to Invest in Today  NasdaqFounded in 1978, Invesco Ltd had preliminary assets under management of $954.8 billion as of Mar 31, 2019. With nearly 750 investment professionals.
Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF 'VTI" - Time To Invest?  ETF TrendsThe Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI) has been in existence since 2001 and is a passively managed index fund that is intended to replicate the ...
For First-time Investors, Here's All You Need to Know about About Mutual Funds  News18It is that time of the year again when the question of where to invest your money clouds your head. If you are a new investor planning to put in money in mutual ...
Aditya Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund seeks SEBI nod for banking ETF  MoneycontrolAditya Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund has sought the Securities and Exchange Board of India's approval to launch Aditya Birla Sun Life Banking ETF, according to ...
Here's Why Arrowhead Pharmaceuticals Skyrocketed 12.7% Today  Fox BusinessThe clinical-stage developer of RNAi therapies is being added to the S&P 600 index.
Reliance Nippon Life: Soft FY19 earnings, but ADAG stake sale may move the needle  MoneycontrolHighlights: - Total AUM growth in FY19 moderates, but finer details are encouraging - Business and customer mix changes favourably with higher equity and ...
Is Fidelity Select Banking (FSRBX) a Strong Mutual Fund Pick Right Now?  NasdaqIf you've been stuck searching for Sector - Finance funds, consider Fidelity Select Banking (FSRBX) as a possibility. FSRBX bears a Zacks Mutual Fund Rank of ...
Top 10 stocks that mutual fund managers bought and sold in March 2019  Moneycontrol.comData for equity flows into mutual funds for March came as a breather after a weak February. An increase in net inflows in equity and income category led to the ...
What India's top three mutual funds bought and sold in March  Economic TimesIndias largest money manager held 1.5 trillion rupees in equities.
Can mutual funds give multibagger returns like stocks?  Economic TimesStocks can be multibaggers. They can offer extraordinary returns in a very short period. Can mutual funds ever do that? This was a question thrown at Rajeev ...
Govt tweaks rules, increases limit to disclose investment in stocks, mutual funds for employees  Economic TimesNew Delhi: The Centre has increased the over 26-year-old monetary limit on disclosure of investment in shares and mutual funds by employees to six months of ...
7 stocks most favoured by mutual funds over last one year  Economic TimesAs the markets hit a speed bump, stocks favoured by mutual funds appear to be safer bets.
Active mutual funds fail to reflect index gains  Economic TimesThe Nifty, which has hit all-time highs for the second time in April, has advanced 12% in the last one year. But these gains are yet to reflect in many mutual funds' ...
What top 5 money managers bought and sold in February  Economic TimesFebruary was the fourth consecutive month of decline in net investment into equity mutual funds.
Mutual funds or direct equity investment – which is better?  Economic TimesOne big question that often dogs investors is which investing option should they opt for: mutual fund or direct equity? Katalyst Wealth's Ekansh Mittal ends your ...
Mutual funds shooting themselves in the foot?  Economic TimesWhat if banks take a leaf out of Kotak and HDFC Mutual Funds' decision to direct investors to come another day to get their money instead of paying them on the ...
Mutual Funds increase holding in ‘attractively valued’ oil & gas stocks  Economic TimesMUMBAI: Mutual funds have been adding shares of oil and gas companies such as GAIL, HPCL, BPCL and ONGC over the last few months, encouraged by ...
Mutual funds bet big on these 30 stocks in November; do you own any?  Moneycontrol.comThe Indian equity market rose about 5 percent in November but what was more heartening to see was inflows into mutual funds. Investors pumped Rs 1.4 lakh ...
Mutual funds sell several blue chips stocks, buy mid-caps in March  Business StandardDomestic money managers were seen pruning their holdings in several blue-chip stocks, including Reliance Industries (RIL) and Housing Development Finance ...
27-year-old rule changed: Disclosure limit on MF, stock investment up for bureaucrats  Economic TimesGroup A and B officials had to intimate government if total transaction in shares or MFs exceeded Rs 50K.
Should I increase investments in mutual funds once I have more money to invest?  Economic TimesI am a 19-year-old student. I want to invest Rs 2,500 per month in mutual funds for 7-8 years. Can I increase the investment amount with time—once I have more ...
Here’s a better tool to judge mutual fund performance than simple 1-year, 3-year returns  Economic TimesOne invests in mutual funds to earn potentially higher returns than those in traditional investment products, and I'm sure everyone looks at the one-year, ...
Investors sent net $3.99 bln into U.S. stock mutual funds, ETFs last week -ICI  Yahoo FinanceBy Jennifer Ablan NEW YORK, April 24 (Reuters) - Investors sent a net $3.99 billion into mutual funds and exchange-traded funds that hold U.S. stocks last week ...
What top mutual funds bought and sold last month  LivemintMumbai: Inflows into Indian equity mutual funds in January were the smallest in two years as heightened market volatility and political uncertainty cooled ...
Check out what top five mutual funds bought & sold during October selloff  Economic TimesNEW DELHI: Mutual funds stood resilient as industry's asset base increased to Rs 22.23 lakh crore in October in spite of a heavy correction in the domestic ...
Why your core equity portfolio should be in index mutual funds  Economic TimesInvestors flock to the performing fund “after” it has beaten the index. Fund selection is not an exact science, and there will be hits and misses.
New SIP investors feel the pain as equity fund returns disappoint  Economic TimesSip by sip: That's how the average Indian had a taste of equities in the past couple of years. But the steady road to riches, which involved monthly mutual fund ...
What India's top three mutual funds bought and sold in February  LivemintMUMBAI: Inflows into Indian equity mutual funds in February were the smallest in more than two years as savers held back investments amid market volatility ...
5 funds that outperformed the recent surge in Nifty returns  Economic TimesFunds that bet on banks and financial services managed to outperform during this period.
Mutual funds may need smart bets on smallcap stocks to beat ETF show  Economic TimesSmallcap stocks could see up to ₹1 lakh cr inflow as fund managers look for potential winners: Analysts.
How stocks picked by mutual funds over 2014 to 2017 have performed  Economic TimesWhile the most wanted stocks of 2014 and 2015 have done well, the recent picks have disappointed.
Debt mutual funds with Zee exposure send investors into a tizzy  Economic TimesMUMBAI: Worries about the prospects of debt mutual funds holding securities of Subhash Chandra's Essel Group entities have resurfaced after Kotak Mutual ...
What India's top three MFs bought and sold in January  Economic TimesStock funds took in a net Rs 6160 crore, the least since January 2017.
Mutual funds garner over Rs 65,000 crore in Jan  Economic TimesMUMBAI: The mutual fund industry added assets worth Rs 65,439 crore in January 2019, taking total assets under management to Rs 23.37 lakh crore.
Why it is a bad idea to always look for outperformers while investing in mutual funds  Economic TimesOne of the most important features that any investor, wealth adviser or anyone in the financial media looks for in an investment product is its track record in ...
Mutual funds' exposure to banks hits 3-month low of Rs 1.88 lakh crore in Sept  Economic TimesMutual funds' holding of banking stocks declined by over Rs 21,600 crore to Rs 1.88 lakh crore in September, driven by the correction in equity markets.
Flows to equity mutual funds rebound as rally spurs risk appetite  Economic TimesStock funds took in about 118 billion rupees ($1.7 billion), the highest since October.
Which mutual funds are good to invest Rs 25 lakh for 10 years?  Economic TimesWhich is the best way to invest Rs 25 lakh in a mutual fund. I don't need the money for the next 10 years. I am happy with 12% returns. And what are the funds I ...
How income from stocks and mutual funds are taxed for an individual  Moneycontrol.comCapital gains from transfer of unlisted share are considered as STCG where period of holding is less than or equal to 24 months, and LTCG when holding period ...
Diversify equity portfolio with international funds  Economic TimesAs a part of diversifying your equity portfolio, wealth managers believe investors should diversify geographically using mutual funds. They can do this by ...
BJP’s Amit Shah has diversified stock investment portfolio; Rahul Gandhi prefers mutual funds  Economic TimesShah held shares worth Rs 17.56 cr as of March 22, while Gandhi has MFs worth Rs 5.19 cr.
Quantum Mutual Fund uses cash pile to buy stocks cheap  Economic TimesQuantum Long Term Equity Value Fund, where value investing is the pronounced fund allocation theme, has brought down the level of cash at its plan to the ...
Top 30 stocks that fund managers bought & sold in March; do you own any?  Moneycontrol.comData for equity flows into a mutual funds for March came as a breather after a weak February. Increase in net inflows in equity and income category led to the ...
2019 is the year of SIP, says S Naren of ICICI Prudential Mutual Fund  Economic TimesNSE Nifty 50 price-to-earnings ratio reached the highest level of 29.24 on April 2. Does it mean markets are overvalued? Should new investors enter in the ...
Quant-based mutual fund schemes are coming. Should you invest?  Economic TimesMany mutual fund advisors believe quant-based mutual funds are the future of the Indian mutual fund industry.
At least 100 MF schemes own these stocks; that should mean something, right?  Economic TimesDomestic institutional investors have become one of the key market drivers in recent years.
Three large mutual funds opposed to L&T’s takeover of Mindtree  Economic TimesMUMBAI: Three large mutual funds holding shares of Mindtree are opposed to L&T's hostile takeover attempt of the mid-sized software company.
Is it time to invest in mid cap and small cap mutual fund schemes?  Economic TimesMany market pundits believe this is the right time to enter in small cap and mid cap segments.
How your mutual funds played the balancing act during stocks crash  Economic TimesBy Bhavana Acharya The last three months has been a bumpy ride for largecap stocks. The year so far has been unkind to the midcap and smallcap set.
Why stock market volatility is beneficial for mutual fund SIP investors  Economic TimesWhile investing through systematic investment plans, you make more money precisely because the markets are facing volatility.
Should you shift from large-cap mutual funds to index funds?  Economic TimesThe index fund category of mutual fund schemes is slowly gaining traction among investors. The fortunes of index funds are changing as not only are they being ...
Best mutual funds to invest in 2019  Economic TimesEveryone wants to invest in the best mutual funds. In fact, it is the sole reason why many investors keep on postponing their investments forever. Most mutual ...
Best small cap mutual funds to invest in 2019  Economic TimesHere is the monthly update on our recommended small cap mutual fund schemes. We are happy to inform you that there are no changes in the recommendation ...
Sebi issues new format for mutual funds' monthly report  Economic TimesFrom April 2019 onwards, AMCs will have to submit the MCR to Sebi in the new format by the third working day of each month.
The dangers of high mutual fund inflows  LivemintMutual funds have put ₹2.4 trillion into markets in the last two years.Equity mutual funds receive ₹8000 crore monthly through SIPs.
Shariah-compliant investments through mutual funds  Economic TimesWithin the mutual fund industry, investors have a choice of two equity-oriented schemes and one gold scheme that are shariah compliant.
Top 8 most common mutual fund investing mistakes and how to avoid them  Business StandardMutual funds garnered Rs 8,022 crore of its assets by way of SIPs in December 2018, 29 per cent higher than the previous year | Illustration: Binay Sinha ...
Best multi cap mutual funds to invest in 2019  Economic TimesHere's the monthly update on our recommended multi cap mutual funds. In May, there is a small change in the recommendation list. Since Mirae Asset India ...

Stock Options Trading Strategies - Lean

Professional stock options traders use the term lean to refer... Read More

Why Investors Use Financial Planners

Do you have a financial planner? Does one of your... Read More

Wal-Mart: Discount Store, Discounted Stock?

As GuruFocus updates the stock buys and sells of gurus,... Read More

Investing in the Stock Market

From the book 'The Stockopoly Plan' by the author Charles... Read More

Buying New Issues

Has your broker been calling you recently with the "great... Read More

High Price/Earnings Ratios and the Stock Market: a Personal Odyssey

After some forty years of banking and investments, I retired... Read More

Expense Ratios

Mutual funds and brokers are always preaching not to buy... Read More

More Window Dressing

Two weeks ago I wrote about what the Securities and... Read More

Valuation

Every day I hear from the "experts" on CNBC-TV and... Read More

Why Technical Indicators

The fight continues to rage among traders who use technical... Read More

How to Pay Less and Get More: Discount Broker vs Professional

How do you invest? What do you really pay? At... Read More

Hot Stock Trader: How to Pick Momentum Stocks with Ease and Simplicity

Most stock traders know that momentum trading can be a... Read More

The Importance of Using Stop Loss Orders When Spread Trading the Financial Markets

A Guide to Using Stop Loss Orders Stop losses are... Read More

Successful Trading ? Establish Your Risk Level

Before you embark upon a journey of trading stocks or... Read More

365/7/24

What does it take to be a stock trader? It... Read More

The 10 Commandments

Wall Street has been preaching for years and years to... Read More

?Fears Only Enemy Is Action?

What a great statement!I just heard someone use it in... Read More

Look Out The Window

Quick, look out the window. It's raining. No, the sun's... Read More

Your Job

There are so many kinds of work that needs to... Read More

9 Deadly Trading Mistakes!

The following are a list of nine things you want... Read More

Mutual Funds are Dead

You may have wondered why your mutual funds have been... Read More

Municipal Bonds

Because there are so many stocks that are NOT paying... Read More

Analysts - Do They Really Know The Stock Market?

When you become interested in a stock or mutual fund... Read More

Stock Market Investments

If there is one term over-used when talking about making... Read More

The Stock Market - Part 1: Believe It Or Not, Its Always Been Your Best Friend And Always Will Be

Regardless of the fact that the world's stock markets have... Read More