How to Pay Less and Get More: Discount Broker vs Professional

How do you invest? What do you really pay? At the end of the day, what are your real results? These are questions smart investors should be asking themselves (but usually don't). In this era of more fees, misc. charges, holding periods and back end redemptions, even at discount brokers, how are you really making out?

Working with a new client brought this all to my attention. I know what I found may not apply to everyone; however it will apply to many and very likely apply to you.

I need to preface this by saying that, unlike the majority of registered investment advisors, I have built my practice over the past 15 years by dealing with "small" investors. Many of them are first timers because my minimum account size is only $5,000.

I targeted this group because I enjoy the educational part of my business. A happy side benefit has been that by providing million dollar service to these so called "small" investors, they naturally refer me to parents, relatives, friends and business associates, often with considerably more assets than the original client. What a happy consequence.

Having set the stage, here's what happened with my new client who we will call John. John was 26, newly married with a one year old son. His wife was taking care of the child and John had a good full time job. After selling his house in California and moving to Florida he had $6,000 left for starting a long-term investment program.

Though he had been reading my newsletter for about a year, John decided to manage his 401k on his own. It was a noble effort but provided less than desirable results.

He then attempted to set up a brokerage account at a major discount broker. With his $6,000 he was told that the quarterly fee would be $45, and, of course, if he sold any mutual fund within the first 180 days, there would be an early redemption fee.

$45 per quarter would be equal to an annual fee of 3% of his starting balance. John called me somewhat frustrated and said that he'd be willing to set up an account with me, but how would it make sense if in addition he'd have to pay my advisory management fee?

That was a good question because it certainly doesn't make sense to have an account in any type of market environment and pay about 6% in fixed annual fees.

However, what John didn't know was that if you have an account with a registered investment advisor who is affiliated with custodial broker, the fee structure changes.

What did that mean to him? It meant that I opened the account for him as a new client. He now has no annual fees, other than my management fee, and his 180 day holding period for mutual funds is reduced to 90 days, minimizing, if not eliminating, the likelihood of an early redemption fee.

The net result was that he would receive the benefit of my experience-which he already trusted based on my track record of pulling clients out of the market in October 2000-and it would cost him no more, and likely less, than his discount brokerage account.

Needless to say, John was very relieved. In essence, he traded broker garbage fees for professional management at no additional cost to him.

And, since he itemizes his deductions on his tax return, all fees paid are tax deductible, which is just an added bonus to factor into the equation.

It turned out to be an all around win-win situation for John. I encourage you to review your situation and see if what looks like a discount in fees is actually costing you a premium.

About The Author

Ulli Niemann is an investment advisor and has been writing about objective, methodical approaches to investing for over 10 years. He eluded the bear market of 2000 and has helped hundreds of people make better investment decisions. To find out more about his approach and his FREE Newsletter, please visit: http://www.successful-investment.com; [email protected]

In The News:

Why you should invest in multi cap mutual funds  Economic TimesMany advisors are recommending multi cap funds in the current environment to investors. This scheme which bundles large-, mid- and small cap stocks is often ...
Mutual Fund Update: Stocks sold by fund managers in July 2019  Dalal Street Investment JournalIn our last update we listed the top 5 stocks that attracted fund managers in the month of July 2019. Now let's have a look at top 5 stocks that witnessed a lot of ...
What India's biggest mutual funds bought and sold in July  LivemintInvestors in Indian equity mutual funds bought more last month, unfazed by the selloff that saw the nation's $1.9 trillion market log its worst July in 17 years.
Top 30 stocks that fund managers bought & sold in July; do you own any?  MoneycontrolMutual funds net bought Rs 14,846.75 crore worth of shares last month. Their inflows into equity funds also improved to Rs 8,113 crore in July, rising nearly 6 ...
Mutual fund investors keep faith in stocks despite market rout  LivemintMumbai: Investors in Indian equity mutual funds bought more last month, unfazed by the selloff that saw the nation's $1.9 trillion market log its worst July in 17 ...
Diversify your portfolio by investing a portion in US-focused mutual funds  MoneycontrolDeveloped markets such as US have delivered significant returns over market cycles.
When equity mutual funds offer negative returns, here’s what you do  Economic TimesThe need of the hour is to stay insulated from the panic in the market.
Invest in reliable outperforming mutual funds: Here are 8 of these  Economic TimesThese funds tend to score well on risk-adjusted metrics and hold dependable stocks in their portfolios.
Fund managers bet over Rs 8.5K crore on these 6 stocks in July; do you own any?  MoneycontrolFund managers added large-cap private banks, utilities, energy and select FMCG names.
Is it time to switch to index mutual funds?  Economic TimesBy Rishabh Parakh It is one of the hottest topics debated these days: is it time for mutual fund investors to switch to passively-managed index funds from their ...
Hot and Cold Stocks of Mutual Funds in July 2019  MoneylifeIn July 2019, IndusInd Bank and ICICI Bank were the most preferred stocks of Indian mutual funds.
7 Best HDFC Mutual Fund Schemes You Must Buy  GoodreturnsThose looking to invest in mutual funds have a number of options. However, if you are looking to specifically invest in HDFC Mutual Fund, here are 7 great ...
Stocks in the news: Igarashi Motors, Glenmark Pharma, Alkem Labs, Lupin and Future Retail  Economic TimesFidelity Investment Trust offloaded over 1.91 crore shares of LIC Housing worth nearly Rs 821 crore.
Tech Stocks Help This T. Rowe Price Mutual Fund Excel  Investor's Business DailyT. Rowe Price mutual fund manager Josh Spencer has tough shoes to fill. Tech stocks, especially software stocks, help him reach his goal.
Step up your SIPs in these mutual funds to benefit from the market correction  LivemintAn SIP will automatically accumulate more units in corrections such as the present one.If you wish to cautiously take advantage of the market correction, stick to ...
Mutual Fund Update: Stocks that attracted fund managers in July 2019  Dalal Street Investment JournalIf we look at the June 2019 data, we find that the financial sector was the one that was on top of the buying done by the fund managers. Even in the month of July ...
Mutual fund investors showing great appetite for assuming risk: Dhirendra Kumar  Economic TimesOne would have thought that new investors who came into mutual funds will be running away. But they are getting into riskier category of funds and the scale of ...
Equity mutual fund managers buy the dip amid a huge downturn in market  Business StandardDomestic money managers lapped up shares of several companies amid a huge downturn in the market last month. Equity mutual funds (MFs) bought shares ...
Mutual Funds: To stay invested or exit? Check these four points first  The Financial ExpressThe BSE Sensex is trading lower compared to the 1-year-ago and 3-months-ago levels, while it is flat compared to its level 6 months ago. In the past one year, ...
What 401(k) Investment Rules Are You Following To Get You Through Retirement  ForbesWhile you may have excepted your employer's default 401(k) investment, is it right for you? Are there alternative choices that are better for you?
Goldman Sachs Finds 5 Top Stocks Mutual Funds Have Loaded Up On  24/7 Wall St.These top stocks should come as no surprise as they make sense, being huge, dominating much of their specific business lines, being very liquid and looking to ...
Charticle: Top stocks that FPIs, MFs bought and sold during June quarter  Business StandardEquity markets witnessed some sharp upmove in the first half of the calendar year 2019 (CY19), first on the anticipation of the return of the Narendra Modi-led ...
DSP Mutual Fund takes 50% haircut; CCD group firms ask for 2 weeks  Business StandardRead more about DSP Mutual Fund takes 50% haircut; CCD group firms ask for 2 weeks on Business Standard. The haircut led to a 1.3 per cent hit on the net ...
Mutual Fund Trend: Infosys, REC and UPL among most sold stocks by MFs in July  Zee BusinessMutual Fund Report: Domestic equity mutual fund inflows continue to show resilience despite market volatility, with July inflows touching Rs 73 billion – a 9M ...
How to recession-proof your life  CNBCWith all the rumblings about a possible recession on the horizon, it pays to be prepared.
3 Funds to Benefit From Robust Home Sales  NasdaqPer the lates t report from the National Association of Realtors, existing home sales in the month of July increased more than estimated. The metric.
Loss Aversion Bias: Why are we reluctant to sell a losing stock or mutual fund?  The Financial ExpressBeing averse to losses is not necessarily always bad, but too much of it can skew your financial planning.
Explained: What is mutual fund NFO?  LivemintIn an NFO, you can subscribe to the units of the new fund, which is being launched, at an offer price which is usually set as ₹10.After the NFO, an open-ended ...
8 of the Best Investments During an Economic Slowdown | Portfolio Management  U.S News & World Report MoneyThe stock market is jittery over worries about an economic slowdown, and August's inverted yield curve added to those concerns. The stock market's bull run is at ...
The Best Investments You Can Make Right Now  NerdWalletBased on your timeline and risk tolerance, the best investments to make right now are high-yield cash management accounts, money market funds, CDs, bonds, ...
3 smart ways to deal with stock market turmoil  The Financial ExpressInvestors and spectators often go through an emotional roller-coaster every time the stock market goes up and down. So, what should they do when such phases ...
Stocks in the news: ITC, RIL, Nestle, NIIT, Coffee Day, DHFL, Union Bank, Bata India, JK Cement  MoneycontrolNestle India | NIIT | Coffee Day Enterprises | DHFL | Union Bank | Bata India and JK Cement are stocks which are in the news today.
Why This Investment Account Is Becoming More Popular  NerdWalletBrokerage accounts offer investors a lot more flexibility than retirement accounts, such as IRAs and 401(k)s. But that flexibility comes at a price: taxes.
Can This New Hawaii Venture Become The Stock Fund For Millennials?  Honolulu Civil BeatA Colorado portfolio manager has big plans for a $44 million S&P 500 index fund that he has brought to Hawaii.
Stocks Tumble As Trump Slams China In Tweet Storm  Investor's Business DailyStocks plunged after Trump tweeted "we don't need China, and, frankly, would be far better off without them." The president planned to speak this afternoon.
An easy solution to RESP investing, 10 TSX dividend stocks with earnings momentum, and the bond market bubble  The Globe and MailParents, here's a task to add to your back to school to-do list: Check the registered education savings plan you set up for your children's college or university ...
How to Pick the Online Broker That's Best for You  Yahoo FinanceNo broker can hit the bull's-eye for every type of client. Use our results to find the best one for you.
Why picking the right mutual fund is key in a tough market  LivemintWhy have mutual fund (MF) returns fallen? Mutual funds primarily invest in equity (stocks) or debt (bonds). On the equity side, mid and small cap MFs have given ...
Top 10 stocks that mutual fund managers bought and sold in March 2019  Moneycontrol.comData for equity flows into mutual funds for March came as a breather after a weak February. An increase in net inflows in equity and income category led to the ...
​Pattie Lovett-Reid: How to get the most bang for your TFSA buck  BNNBloomberg.caThe TFSA, or tax-free savings account, has been around for a decade, but that doesn't mean we are using them to get the biggest bang for our buck. A recent ...
MF shopping list: Top 30 stocks that fund managers bought & sold in June  MoneycontrolMutual funds increased allocation to private banks, consumer, utilities, technology, NBFCs, retail, metals and PSU bank stocks in June, an ICICIdirect report said.
Sensex's rise from 20K to 40K: 5 lessons for equity mutual fund investors  Economic TimesWe look at some critical lessons that equity fund investors learnt during the journey of Sensex reaching 40K.
What India's three largest mutual funds bought and sold in June  LivemintInflows into Indian equity mutual funds jumped the most in three months in June.India's top money manager HDFC Mutual Fund held $22 billion in equities.
Consider investing in direct stocks only if you can monitor portfolio proactively  LivemintDirect stocks can be considered if you have the ability to do research to identify the stocks to be bought as well as to be sold.You should be revisiting your ...
Should you invest in international mutual funds?  LivemintIf you were to sort all equity mutual funds available for retail investment by their one-year performance, international funds would come on top. The best ...
The Taxman Says, Stay Invested  Morningstar.comTiming the stock market is difficult enough, even without the IRS' contribution.
Mutual funds’ exposure to this space at all-time high; should you buy?  Economic TimesMoney managers on Dalal Street continued to shower affection on private banks for the ninth successive month as their exposure hit 19.90 per cent in June, ...
What India's top three mutual funds bought and sold in March  Economic TimesIndias largest money manager held 1.5 trillion rupees in equities.
A young investor’s guide to mutual funds  Economic TimesMany young investors, who are barely a year or two old in their career, are eager to start investing in mutual funds. ETMutualFunds.com receive many queries on ...
Here are a few mutual funds that stocked up on YES Bank in Q4FY19  Business StandardShares of YES Bank tanked 30 per cent in trade on Tuesday, after the bank reported a massive Rs 1,507 crore loss in the fourth quarter of financial year 2018-19 ...
Mutual fund SIPs don't make equity investing risk-free. Here's why  Economic TimesSIPs do reduce the risk of market timing & allow investors to buy more units when their price falls.
Index mutual funds see 60% jump in assets in a year as actively managed funds struggle  Economic TimesIndex mutual funds — a category that aims to mimic returns of benchmarks, like Nifty or Sensex — have seen their assets surge 60% over the past one year as ...
Govt increases limit to disclose investment in stocks, mutual funds for employees  Moneycontrol.com*Service* rules say no government servant shall speculate in any stock, share or other investment.
Mutual funds shooting themselves in the foot?  Economic TimesWhat if banks take a leaf out of Kotak and HDFC Mutual Funds' decision to direct investors to come another day to get their money instead of paying them on the ...
What top mutual funds bought and sold last month  LivemintMumbai: Inflows into Indian equity mutual funds in January were the smallest in two years as heightened market volatility and political uncertainty cooled ...
Actively-managed large cap mutual funds poised for a comeback  Economic TimesDefying predictions of their imminent irrelevance, some actively-managed large cap mutual fund schemes have bounced back to the top of the return chart.
All you need to know about liquid mutual funds  Economic TimesThe NBFC crisis has brought liquid funds back in favour as they carry lower risk than corporate FDs.
Flows into mutual funds revive in May as Modi win seems to spur risk demand  LivemintFlows into Indian equity mutual funds in May rebounded from the smallest in 31 months as Prime Minister Narendra Modi's comfortable electoral win spurred ...
What India's top three mutual funds bought and sold in May  LivemintInflows into Indian equity mutual funds in May rebounded from the smallest in 31 months as Prime Minister Narendra Modi's comfortable electoral win spurred ...
Stick to MFs if you lack knowledge on stocks  LivemintWhile equity is surely the way going forward considering your age and the financial goals, how you buy in equity is important.Direct stocks work very well if done ...
Mutual funds or direct equity investment – which is better?  Economic TimesOne big question that often dogs investors is which investing option should they opt for: mutual fund or direct equity? Katalyst Wealth's Ekansh Mittal ends your ...
Should you invest in algorithm-based quant mutual funds?  Economic TimesQuant funds work on a data-driven model that relies on a mix of parameters and algorithms to identify the right stocks at the right time. But can they beat actively ...
MF portfolio doctor: Babji needs to exit direct investments in stocks, take mutual funds route  Economic TimesThe Portfolio Doctor assesses the health of the fund portfolio, examines the schemes and their suitability with regard to the goals.
Can mutual funds give multibagger returns like stocks?  Economic TimesStocks can be multibaggers. They can offer extraordinary returns in a very short period. Can mutual funds ever do that? This was a question thrown at Rajeev ...
How income from stocks and mutual funds are taxed for an individual  Moneycontrol.comCapital gains from transfer of unlisted share are considered as STCG where period of holding is less than or equal to 24 months, and LTCG when holding period ...
Investment limits Sebi prescribes for mutual funds  LivemintIn case of unrated debt instruments, a mutual fund cannot invest more than 10% of the portfolio in a single issuer and 25% in all such securities.In case of listed ...
Top 25 equity mutual funds failed to deliver positive returns in June  Economic TimesNEW DELHI: Top 25 mutual fund schemes, managing retail money in excess of $1 billion (Rs 7,000 crore) each, failed to deliver positive returns in June.
Why do wealth managers recommend multi cap mutual funds?  Economic TimesMany wealth managers believe multi-cap funds are a good starting point for long-term investors, specially those using SIPs for wealth creation.
Top 30 stocks that fund managers bought & sold in March; do you own any?  Moneycontrol.comData for equity flows into a mutual funds for March came as a breather after a weak February. Increase in net inflows in equity and income category led to the ...
What to do if your mutual fund scheme earns more return than your investment  Economic TimesAre the returns shown in your mutual fund account statement same as the returns delivered by your fund? It is quite likely that you might have earned less than ...
First-time investors can look at these mutual funds for long term  Economic TimesInvestors, who were waiting on the sidelines for the uncertainty to recede, are now looking to deploy their cash. But, valuations remain steep.
Equity funds record highest ever exposure in banking stocks in March 2019  Business TodayAs per the latest data available from the SEBI, overall deployment of equity funds in bank stocks grew around 52 per cent year-on-year (y-o-y) in the month ...
What India's top three mutual funds bought and sold in February  LivemintStock funds took in a net ₹5130 crore, a 17% drop over January, data from the Association of Mutual Funds in India show .Here's what the top three asset ...
The dangers of high mutual fund inflows  LivemintMutual funds have put ₹2.4 trillion into markets in the last two years.Equity mutual funds receive ₹8000 crore monthly through SIPs.
7 stocks most favoured by mutual funds over last one year  Economic TimesAs the markets hit a speed bump, stocks favoured by mutual funds appear to be safer bets.
Top 8 most common mutual fund investing mistakes and how to avoid them  Business StandardMutual funds, especially equity mutual funds, have played a pivotal role in helping retail investors create wealth over the last 25 years since they actually ...
Active mutual funds fail to reflect index gains  Economic TimesThe Nifty, which has hit all-time highs for the second time in April, has advanced 12% in the last one year. But these gains are yet to reflect in many mutual funds' ...
A look at mistakes committed by investors of equity mutual fund schemes  Moneycontrol.comBalwant Jain. The interest of investors has been shifting from direct equity investing to equity mutual funds over a few years. Though this is a welcome trend, ...
What top 5 money managers bought and sold in February  Economic TimesFebruary was the fourth consecutive month of decline in net investment into equity mutual funds.
I want to invest Rs 1 crore in stocks and mutual funds for 5 years. How should I invest?  Economic TimesYou may consider the following asset allocation: 40% in large-caps; 40% in large and mid-cap, or multi-caps; and remaining 20% in mid- and small-cap funds.
Stop! Too many stocks, mutual funds are not good for you; Buying too many may not get you more  The Financial ExpressHandling the overall risk of investments is crucial, but not at the cost of not meeting your financial goals. Over-diversification can do this.
Should you invest in mid- and small-cap funds now?  LivemintWith the new government taking office with a massive majority, it has the elbow room to push through the reforms. No wonder markets are expecting the ...
Defaults, downgrades hit debt mutual funds: What investors should know and do now  Economic TimesAs debt mutual funds land in trouble following multiple defaults and downgrades by bond issuers, ET Wealth addresses some key questions from worried ...
Here’s a better tool to judge mutual fund performance than simple 1-year, 3-year returns  Economic TimesOne invests in mutual funds to earn potentially higher returns than those in traditional investment products, and I'm sure everyone looks at the one-year, ...
Sebi allows mutual funds in exchange traded commodity derivatives  Economic TimesNEW DELHI: The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) on Tuesday allowed mutual funds to participate in exchange-traded commodity derivatives ...
ITR filing: Income tax department makes disclosing LTCG from stocks, equity mutual funds simpler  LivemintThe Finance Bill 2018 reintroduced tax on LTCG made from listed shares and equity-oriented mutual fund.You only need to disclose the total LTCG from ...
Are you looking for profits or to create wealth from mutual funds?  Economic TimesBy Ashish Modani I give you two mutual fund schemes to choose from – Scheme A and Scheme B. Scheme A has given stellar returns over a 15-year period.
Here are top 10 large, mid & small-cap stocks that MFs bought and sold in May  MoneycontrolAmong largecaps, Vodafone Idea, DLF, Bharti Airtel, HDFC Life Insurance and Piramal Enterprises witnessed highest buying during May 2019.
The best, safe mutual funds to invest for 15 years  Economic TimesI am 29 years old. I want to start an SIP of Rs 20,000 in mutual funds for a period of 12 to 15 years. Please suggest me the best and safe mutual funds? My target ...
Should investors with very long term horizon always pick small cap mutual funds?  Economic TimesMutual fund investors assume that their risk taking ability goes up if they have really long investment horizon.
Best mutual funds to build Rs 1 crore for my son’s education  Economic TimesI want to build a corpus of Rs 1 crore for my son's education. He is now 3 years old. My investment horizon is 15-20 years. I have been investing in the following ...
Allocating to passive mutual funds in one's portfolio is increasingly making sense  Economic TimesPassive investments makes sense today as increasingly active ones are unable to beat it most times.
Mutual funds sell several blue chips stocks, buy mid-caps in March  Business StandardDomestic money managers were seen pruning their holdings in several blue-chip stocks, including Reliance Industries (RIL) and Housing Development Finance ...
Mutual Fund Update: Stocks that attracted fund managers in May 2019  Dalal Street Investment JournalIf we look at the April 2019 data, media and communication sector stocks featured in the top buying done by the fund managers. However, story in the month of ...
Investment in equity MFs drops 35% to ₹1.11 lakh crore in FY19  LivemintNEW DELHI : Investors pumped in more than ₹1.11 lakh crore in equity-oriented mutual fund (MF) schemes in 2018-19, a decline of 35 per cent compared to ...
Heres why investors should make index funds a part of their core portfolio  Business StandardWe often hear statements such as “Localisation is the key to success in India” or “What works in the rest of the world does not work in India”. These statements ...
Flipkart co-founder Sachin Bansal may foray into mutual fund business  Economic TimesSachin Bansal, former co-Founder of Flipkart, is mulling a foray into the mutual fund space, according to a report by ETNow. The business news channel said ...
Mutual Funds increase holding in ‘attractively valued’ oil & gas stocks  Economic TimesMUMBAI: Mutual funds have been adding shares of oil and gas companies such as GAIL, HPCL, BPCL and ONGC over the last few months, encouraged by ...
Mutual Fund Update: Stocks that attracted fund managers in April 2019  Dalal Street Investment JournalIf we look at the March 2019 data, then the energy sector was the one that featured on top of the buying done by the fund managers. However, the story in the ...
Will these mutual funds help me to create Rs 8 crore?  Economic TimesIf you have any mutual fund queries, message on ET Mutual Funds on Facebook. We will get it answered by our panel of experts.

Risk Control

Everything you invest in has risk so you want to... Read More

Momentum

One of the basic laws of physics states that a... Read More

Is The Bear In The Cage?

For the last few weeks we have seen the stock... Read More

Stock Market Investments

If there is one term over-used when talking about making... Read More

Dollar Cost Averaging

Dollar cost averaging is one of the most popular ideas... Read More

Investment Capital Gains

Have you bought any mutual funds this year or late... Read More

Does Japan Matter?

For the last 12 years we have seen the Japanese... Read More

The Great Stock Market Secret

When the stock market is going up and all your... Read More

Dont Ask Your Broker

Unfortunately, most of you who are reading my column are... Read More

VooDoo Training For the Stock Market

If you go to Haiti or other places in the... Read More

Market Globalization

Just 30 years ago the stock market was a shadow... Read More

Catnip of the Stock Market

I have watched my cat play with a bag of... Read More

Robert Rodriguez Weathers the Stock Market

Robert Rodriguez likes to buy stocks at their lows. When... Read More

Wall Street Paradigm

In 1960 an engineer working for a watch company in... Read More

Intervention

Intervention. Now don't let that big word scare you. The... Read More

Performance Funds

Mutual funds are doing more and more to discourage investors... Read More

Buying Mutual Funds

It looks like the market is ready to start up... Read More

NASDAQ 800?

In November of 2000 when the NASDAQ was trading at... Read More

Protect Your 401K

Checked your 401K lately? Going back to about a year... Read More

The POWER of a Proven Stock Investment Plan

When you invest in the stock market for ever-increasing cash... Read More

Box Of Chocolates

Ever have one of those sample boxes of candy? Each... Read More

Why This Bear?

People are constantly asking me why is the stock market... Read More

The Stock Market - How Just One Question Will Tell You All You Need To Know About Your Stock Broker

Last time we looked at the real performance of the... Read More

Buy and Hold: How to Perpetuate Your Investment Losses

A recent cartoon in my daily newspaper showed two guys... Read More

The Seven Mistakes All Novice Traders Make and How to Correct Them

We learnt the following the hard way! If any of... Read More