Stock Market Investing: Knowing When (and when not) to Sell

One of the greatest challenges of investing in stocks is developing a "sell discipline". Some of the most adept investors struggle with the decision of when to sell.

First, recognize that there are no absolute formulas to tell us to sell at precisely the right time. Instead, we'll need to consider a bundle of factors such as the investment's characteristics, the broad economy, and your own needs, with an eye to market trends. The answer will come from some combination of these hard-to-quantify characteristics.

If you'll need cash soon, for whatever reason, you should be more ready to sell, especially if a stock becomes less of a sure thing. Similarly, if the economy is weak, we might be more motivated to take profits (or even losses) in stocks which are sensitive to economic swings, while a strong economy might allow us to hold tight.

Most important, however, is the intrinsic value of the stock itself. A simple rule plays out here: buy when a stock is under-valued (when the stock sells for less than its intrinsic value), and sell when it is over-valued (priced above intrinsic value). The trick is measuring intrinsic value, which can be done many different ways. We'll talk about measuring intrinsic value more at another time, but regardless of how we measure it, we had to have an idea of what the company was actually worth when we bought it. So, if we reach that target, we can start thinking about taking profits. It isn't always necessary to sell out immediately, though. For a pure value stock, we should sell somewhere in that range, but if the company is expected to grow, we can wait longer and take advantage of that growth. Perhaps, as a rule of thumb, wait until the stock reaches a price double what we think it's worth. Of course, this is a personal decision, too, and depends on how patient you are, and how much you have invested. At this point, the "easy money" has already been made.

Market Trends. It is our firm position that market trends alone should never lead to buying or selling a stock. However, if we've already decided to sell, trend indicators, used carefully, can enhance profits. For example, if a stock is in a solid uptrend that shows no signs of slowing, it may be profitable to wait for the stock to approach a short-term top before selling. Beware that you don't hold too long. Better to sell early than late. Eventually the market will catch on to reality, so if your evaluation of the stock is right, the risk of holding on too long can be far greater than the small benefit from holding out for that extra dollar.

A few other errors to avoid:

Don't avoid selling because you're emotionally attached to a stock. Circumstances change over time. There's no reason to beat yourself up over it. Just dump the loser and move on.

Don't sell when panicked. Panic is an emotional response, and usually wells up when things aren't going your way but you can't tell why. Know why you want to act. Until you can make a judgment about why to sell, it's probably best to hold on and wait out the fear.

Don't sell when worried. In many ways, worry is similar to panic, if a bit milder. It is still an emotion, and one that should be controlled. Stocks are often said to "climb a wall of worry", which means that they will ease upward through difficult times. When news is worrisome, but not devastating, the only remaining catalysts are good things, as all the bad news has probably already been factored in by selling among the worrywarts.

Don't sell when bored. Just because a stock isn't moving doesn't mean it was a bad selection. It may just indicate that you're smarter (and therefore earlier) than the market hordes. If you're still convinced it was a good choice, hold firm and wait for everyone to catch on to your wisdom. Especially with value stocks, it can often take a year or longer before the mainstream recognizes a good stock, and that's when the price will start moving. Patience is a virtue.

In the end, every selling decision is a personal one, and must balance out all the factors we've mentioned. The most important rule, of course, is to sell when it benefits YOU.

To send comments or to learn more about Scott Pearson's Investment Management Services, visit http://www.valueview.net

Scott Pearson is an investment advisor, writer, editor, instructor, and business leader. As editor and publisher of Investor's Value View, a national investment newsletter, he provides general money tips and investment advice to readers, and demonstrates a special knack for locating the up-and-coming stocks in the burgeoning high-tech industries. As President and Chief Investment Officer of Value View Financial Corp., he offers investment management services to a wide variety of clients.

In The News:

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at https://news.google.com/news

Investopedia (blog)

Four Strategies For Managing A Portfolio Of Mutual Funds
Investopedia (blog)
This is the most commonly seen mutual-fund strategy. How does it work? Basically, if your portfolio does not boast a plan or structure, then it is likely that you are employing a wing-it strategy. If you are adding money to your portfolio today, how do ...


Pensions & Investments

Here's why small-cap stocks could be vulnerable to ETF outflows
MarketWatch
Exchange-traded funds are among the most popular ways for investors to get exposure to nearly any asset class, region, or strategy in global financial markets. However, rather than providing safety in numbers, this could become a risk factor for some ...
Sustainalytics finds a quarter of ETFs, 15% of mutual funds have ...Pensions & Investments

all 4 news articles »

New York Times

Three Funds Find Routes to Top Performance in a Rough Market
New York Times
500 sputtered to a 1.2 percent loss and many sectors sagged, the managers of three of the top-performing mutual funds scooted ahead by betting on growth stocks and Latin America. Christopher J. Bonavico, of the Jackson Square SMID-Cap Growth Fund, said ...


Nasdaq

3 Mutual Funds to Make Good as the Tax Season Wraps Up
Nasdaq
Tax Day should have been Apr 17 this year. But, the IRS has given tax payers an additional day to file and pay returns after the webpage for paying tax bills using their bank account crashed. Tax Day has always been special for the stock market ...
3 Mutual Funds to Make Good as the Tax Season Wraps Up - April ...Zacks.com

all 1 news articles »

Investorplace.com

Alibaba Group Holding Ltd Seems Like High-Risk Mutual Fund
Investorplace.com
Alibaba Group Holding Ltd (NYSE:BABA) stock has paused in recent months. A rise in geopolitical risk and a selloff in tech have lead investors to close positions in Alibaba stock. A low multiple and the company's high growth could attract many buyers ...
BABA Stock Quote and Analysis of Alibaba Group Holding Ltd - InvestorPlaceInvestorPlace
Alibaba Group Holding Limited - BABA - Stock Price Today - ZacksZacks
Free Report for BABA - Zacks.comZacks

all 152 news articles »

CNBC

Indians are starting to ditch gold and property investments for stocks and mutual funds, survey shows
CNBC
Indians hold a relatively low percentage of their total wealth in financial assets but that trend might be changing, according to a recent Credit Suisse survey. The investment bank has released its latest version of a Emerging Consumer Survey that ...

and more »

Investor's Business Daily

Trade-War Olive Branch Fuels Rise By Stocks In 'Best Mutual Funds'
Investor's Business Daily
Many individual investors and top stock mutual funds benefited. Take AB Large Cap Growth Fund (APGAX), a 2018 IBD Best Mutual Funds Award winner. The fund tacked on 0.35% on Monday as the S&P 500 gained 0.36%. All but one of the fund's 47 stocks were ...


US 'junk' bond funds take in most weekly cash since 2016: Lipper
Reuters
NEW YORK (Reuters) - Investors stormed back into the market for the riskiest corporate debt during the latest week, Lipper data showed on Thursday, pumping the most cash into U.S.-based, high-yield bond funds in over 16 months. The resurgence in demand ...

and more »

TheStreet.com

Mutual Fund Managers Love These Stocks and You Should Too
TheStreet.com
As the stock market continues in its ninth year of an impressive bull run, mutual funds have enjoyed stellar gains. In 2017, U.S. diversified stock mutual funds averaged a gain of 18.26%, just off the heels of the S&P 500's 22% gain last year. While ...
This unique mutual fund charges less than an index fund if it underperformsMarketWatch
Is Putnam Small Cap Growth A (PNSAX) a Strong Mutual Fund Pick Right Now?Nasdaq
Is Laudus US Large Cap Growth (LGILX) a Strong Mutual Fund Pick Right Now?Zacks.com

all 17 news articles »

Investor's Business Daily

Best Mutual Fund Managers See Silver Lining In Weak Q1 Stock Performance
Investor's Business Daily
31. Only 10.4% of eligible U.S. diversified stock funds made the Best Mutual Funds Awards list. "A drop in valuations is good," he added. Meanwhile, how weak was stock market performance? March's 2.54% setback marked the S&P 500's second straight ...
MFs weekly wrap: Net inflows into equity mutual funds fell 59% MoM in MarchMoneycontrol.com

all 4 news articles »
Google News

Paddle Your Canoe

At some time in your life you have been on... Read More

The 401(K): How The Insider Has Stolen Your Retirement!

Mutual funds were moderately successful in creating a presence in... Read More

Making Outsized Returns in the Stock Market - Using the Dow Theory

The Dow TheoryCharles H. Dow... Read More

Municipal Bonds

Because there are so many stocks that are NOT paying... Read More

Online Investing & Online Stock & Share Trading: Difficulty in Taking Stop Losses in the Market

This is an extract of an article which was first... Read More

Mutual Fund Expense Lies

When purchasing mutual funds we are cautioned to read the... Read More

Trading vs Investing

I often hear from people, "I don't trade. I invest.... Read More

What To Buy Now

I am sure that if you have a brokerage account... Read More

So, What is This Stock Market Thing Anyway?

We've all heard of the stock market and probably have... Read More

Stock Market Education; Day Trading for Beginnners; How to Pick Stocks

The trading method you employ to approach the stock market... Read More

Enronization

Even if you don't own any of their stock or... Read More

Stock Market System ... ONLINE STOCK TRADING ... Beyond Day Trading Basics & Tips

Day trading is all about making buy and sell decisions.... Read More

Lies, Damn Lies and Mutual Fund Returns

How many times has this happened to you? You're at... Read More

Value Investing: Selecting From The Bargain Bin

Picking a beaten-down stock requires a different kind of selection... Read More

Losses, not Profits, will Stop You from Trading in the Market

Should the market turn against you, it is important that... Read More

401K-itis

Are you one of those many people who dread reading... Read More

Stuff

I continually hear from economists, talking heads, other market letter... Read More

What Can Model Airplanes Teach You About Trading?

I was devastated!I just couldn't believe it. I was 10... Read More

Stock Trading Secrets?

How often have you come across an advertisement or e-mail... Read More

Political Investing

We have two candidates for president that have really different... Read More

Successful Trading ? Taking Profits - Part 2

Suppose your position has made a big move and you... Read More

Exchange Traded Funds Primer

Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) are a group of passive index... Read More

How To Beat The Mutual Fund Companies At Their Own Game

You'd have had to be living on a desert island... Read More

The Secret to More Winning Trades is as Simple as Avoiding This Common Mistake

If you're a normal human being, your need to feel... Read More

Using Sector Funds to Construct Diversified Mutual Fund Portfolios

'Sector funds are too risky.' 'I doubled my money with... Read More