Stock Market Investing: Knowing When (and when not) to Sell

One of the greatest challenges of investing in stocks is developing a "sell discipline". Some of the most adept investors struggle with the decision of when to sell.

First, recognize that there are no absolute formulas to tell us to sell at precisely the right time. Instead, we'll need to consider a bundle of factors such as the investment's characteristics, the broad economy, and your own needs, with an eye to market trends. The answer will come from some combination of these hard-to-quantify characteristics.

If you'll need cash soon, for whatever reason, you should be more ready to sell, especially if a stock becomes less of a sure thing. Similarly, if the economy is weak, we might be more motivated to take profits (or even losses) in stocks which are sensitive to economic swings, while a strong economy might allow us to hold tight.

Most important, however, is the intrinsic value of the stock itself. A simple rule plays out here: buy when a stock is under-valued (when the stock sells for less than its intrinsic value), and sell when it is over-valued (priced above intrinsic value). The trick is measuring intrinsic value, which can be done many different ways. We'll talk about measuring intrinsic value more at another time, but regardless of how we measure it, we had to have an idea of what the company was actually worth when we bought it. So, if we reach that target, we can start thinking about taking profits. It isn't always necessary to sell out immediately, though. For a pure value stock, we should sell somewhere in that range, but if the company is expected to grow, we can wait longer and take advantage of that growth. Perhaps, as a rule of thumb, wait until the stock reaches a price double what we think it's worth. Of course, this is a personal decision, too, and depends on how patient you are, and how much you have invested. At this point, the "easy money" has already been made.

Market Trends. It is our firm position that market trends alone should never lead to buying or selling a stock. However, if we've already decided to sell, trend indicators, used carefully, can enhance profits. For example, if a stock is in a solid uptrend that shows no signs of slowing, it may be profitable to wait for the stock to approach a short-term top before selling. Beware that you don't hold too long. Better to sell early than late. Eventually the market will catch on to reality, so if your evaluation of the stock is right, the risk of holding on too long can be far greater than the small benefit from holding out for that extra dollar.

A few other errors to avoid:

Don't avoid selling because you're emotionally attached to a stock. Circumstances change over time. There's no reason to beat yourself up over it. Just dump the loser and move on.

Don't sell when panicked. Panic is an emotional response, and usually wells up when things aren't going your way but you can't tell why. Know why you want to act. Until you can make a judgment about why to sell, it's probably best to hold on and wait out the fear.

Don't sell when worried. In many ways, worry is similar to panic, if a bit milder. It is still an emotion, and one that should be controlled. Stocks are often said to "climb a wall of worry", which means that they will ease upward through difficult times. When news is worrisome, but not devastating, the only remaining catalysts are good things, as all the bad news has probably already been factored in by selling among the worrywarts.

Don't sell when bored. Just because a stock isn't moving doesn't mean it was a bad selection. It may just indicate that you're smarter (and therefore earlier) than the market hordes. If you're still convinced it was a good choice, hold firm and wait for everyone to catch on to your wisdom. Especially with value stocks, it can often take a year or longer before the mainstream recognizes a good stock, and that's when the price will start moving. Patience is a virtue.

In the end, every selling decision is a personal one, and must balance out all the factors we've mentioned. The most important rule, of course, is to sell when it benefits YOU.

To send comments or to learn more about Scott Pearson's Investment Management Services, visit http://www.valueview.net

Scott Pearson is an investment advisor, writer, editor, instructor, and business leader. As editor and publisher of Investor's Value View, a national investment newsletter, he provides general money tips and investment advice to readers, and demonstrates a special knack for locating the up-and-coming stocks in the burgeoning high-tech industries. As President and Chief Investment Officer of Value View Financial Corp., he offers investment management services to a wide variety of clients.

In The News:


Investor's Business Daily

IBD's Best Mutual Funds 2017 Awards | Stock News & Stock Market ...
Investor's Business Daily
Except for the Harlem Globetrotters, repeat winning is hard. Even our Best Mutual Funds 2017 Awards winners have few repeats from last year.
Should you invest directly in equity or via mutual funds?Economic Times
Are you risk averse? Give hybrid mutual funds a chanceFinancial Express

all 10 news articles »

Motley Fool

The Worst Funds for Your 401(k)
Motley Fool
And all three of these options are far cheaper than the average U.S. stock mutual fund's expense ratio of about 1.25%. However, notice that there is a 65-basis-point difference in gross expense ratio between the highest- and lowest-cost funds on the ...
Mutual fund group aims for fee transparency with 'clean shares'San Francisco Chronicle

all 4 news articles »

Bloomberg

ETFs Are Giving Mutual Funds a Run for Their Money
Bloomberg
Mutual fund ownership of equities is at its lowest level in nearly 13 years, according to a research note from Goldman Sachs Group Inc. Meanwhile, exchange-traded funds are becoming an even bigger force in the stock market, the team led by Chief U.S. ...

and more »

US-based stock mutual funds take in most cash in a year -ICI
Reuters
By Trevor Hunnicutt NEW YORK, March 1 Fund investors' aversion to riding the market's highs showed signs of waning as stock mutual funds attracted the most cash in a year in the latest week, Investment Company Institute data showed on Wednesday.

and more »

Moneycontrol.com

Time to be careful: Fund managers are shying away from stocks
Moneycontrol.com
A look at the portfolio of ICICI Prudential Balanced Advantage Fund, the largest mutual fund scheme In India investing in stocks reveals that the exposure to stocks have been cut over last one year. The net equity investments of this scheme are down to ...

and more »

Barron's

ETFs Chasing Mutual Funds as Stock Buyer
Barron's
Mutual funds' outflows since last year have driven their equity ownership to a nearly 13-year low, according to Goldman Sachs. ETFs, meanwhile, are growing by leaps and bounds as a stock market force. “Corporations and ETFs will continue to drive ...


Mutual funds invest over Rs 2000 crore in stocks in February
Economic Times
Mutual fund managers purchased stocks worth a little over Rs 2,000 crore in February --- making it the seventh straight month of positive inflow in equities --- on sustained participation by retail investors. Fund managers have been investing ...

and more »

The Indian Express

Mutual Funds' exposure to bank stocks hits record Rs 1.2 lakh crore in February 2017 end
The Indian Express
Mutual Fund managers seem to be bullish on bank shares as they raised their allocation in the sector to an all time-high of over Rs 1.2 lakh crore at the end of February, primarily on account of cheaper valuations. In comparison, fund managers had ...

and more »

Utility Stocks for Retirement Investors: 1 Stock, 1 ETF and 1 Mutual Fund
Investorplace.com
While utility stocks have taken it on the chin lately with the Federal Reserve starting to raise rates, the reality is, they still make sense for retirement investors. Utilities For Retirement Investors: 1 Stock, 1 ETF and 1 Mutual Fund. Source: 401(k ...


CNBC

Why mutual funds could be on their way to another lousy year
CNBC
The improvement comes amid multiyear lows in the tendency of stocks to correlate up and down together, as well as an elevated level of dispersion, or the difference between returns for various sectors. Stock pickers in actively managed mutual funds ...
Stock pickers lift performance in battle of the benchmarksFinancial Times

all 4 news articles »
Google News

Trading Systems

To become a successful trader you must have some kind... Read More

Quality Investment Information: Standing Firm In the Face of Opposition

THERE'S SOMETHING TO BE SAID FOR standing firm in the... Read More

Structured Settlement; Lawyers in NY and Mutual Funds

Minority Report the movie may not be far off if... Read More

The Stock Market - How Just One Question Will Tell You All You Need To Know About Your Stock Broker

Last time we looked at the real performance of the... Read More

On Line Stock Trading: Small Cap & Micro Stocks Go Up and Down - How Can You Profit?

Success in small cap & micro cap stock trading like... Read More

Stock Market Investing: Knowing When (and when not) to Sell

One of the greatest challenges of investing in stocks is... Read More

Learn to Calculate a Stock?s Pivot Point

Stocks breakout from properly formed bases everyday but many investors... Read More

Stock Market Diversification

In one of my previous articles (Investing in the stock... Read More

War Market

There is no question that the stock market is being... Read More

Shorting Stocks ? The Basics, Part I of II

What does it mean to short a stock?This means that... Read More

Investing in Trash Company Stocks

Refuse is a serious issue in any society, about as... Read More

Mindset

In 1960 an engineer working for a watch company in... Read More

How to Read an Annual Report

Every publicly traded company is required by the SEC(Securities and... Read More

Selling Strategies - Setting a Stop Loss

Sometimes the best way of lowering exposure to risk is... Read More

Different Ways of Buying Stocks

Let's say you are interested in this one company. You... Read More

I Love To Lose Money

Well, not really. What I mean is I don't mind... Read More

The Big Bad Bear

The big bad bear is stirring again. So far he... Read More

The Surgeon General

The Surgeon General of the United States says that smoking... Read More

How to Evaluate Load vs. No Load Mutual Funds

If you have been dealing with mutual funds for any... Read More

Investment Clubs

Because you don't feel too sure about which stock or... Read More

What Our Investment Advisor Wont Say Off The Bat

Most advisors will tell you they can beat the market.... Read More

Buy and Hold Investment Philosophy

Wall Street has been preaching the doctrine of Buy and... Read More

Overseas Investing: Going Against the Mainstream

TOO OFTEN, INVESTORS SIMPLY CHOOSE TO follow the crowd. This... Read More

What is the Most Important Indicator of All?

Most stock market traders have a favorite technical indicator.The one... Read More

Investing in the Stock Market - When To!

Is really not as important as to how you invest... Read More