Unstructured Settlement

Me'Lisa Delaney, 43, is brain-injured as a result of a 1984 medical error that caused a stroke during surgery. The hospital agreed to settle via a structured settlement, as overseen by a county conservatorship.

Delaney soon married Terry, who took over the conservatorship of the settlement and proceeded to make loans against the settlement, which equaled about $350,000. It wasn't long before all the money was gone. According to the civil complaint filed by Me'Lisa, Terry had used the loan money to purchase "controlled substances, illegal drugs, jewelry, liquor and other non-business items." Of course Delaney is suing for 10 million in punitive damages.

A lot of time energy, and effort was put into structuring a settlement in the best interest of Me'Lisa and it was too easily undone. Should we consider making settlements "unstructurable"? There is some concern that "factoring" or "cash out" companies take advantage of customers, taking a large portion of the settlement in exchange for a significantly smaller lump sum.

In Me'Lisa's case it makes sense to put in place more safeguards to protect her rights and interests in her settlement, specifically because she is brain injured. We should look to protect minors, senior citizens, and mentally impaired or injured settlement winners. Everyone else has access to resources and information to help them make the best choices and should be entitled to choose whatever they wish. I personally know of cases where cashing out was life saving, dream fulfilling, and absolutely a positive choice. I am also personally aware of situations where customers have cashed out their settlements and it was absolutely a bad decision. Unstructuring a settlement seems to be a great American Freedom, but it doesn't have to be as morally insipid as what happened in the Delaney case.

Jason Rigler
"Settlement Advocate" and consultant for Prosperity Partners Customer Service Department.

In The News:

HAROLD KAFFIE | Obituaries  Victoria Advocate
Using Structured Settlements  Palisades Hudson Financial Group
Pension board OKs firms to seek claim  Arkansas Democrat-Gazette
Will the Banks Collapse?  The Atlantic

A Revolutionary Fundraising Opportunity -- Life Settlements

Amid fundraisers' growing concerns about the current charitable giving climate,... Read More

The Target Capital Structure

Firms can choose whatever mix of debt and equity they... Read More

A Structured Lawsuit Settlement Seemed Like a Good Idea at One Time

You are receiving payments spread out over months, years, even... Read More

Should You Sell Your Structured Settlement?

The courts have just awarded you a settlement in the... Read More

How To Form a UK Limited Company

When starting a business, a large number of people go... Read More

Investing in Structured Settlements

Often some derelict will be awarded some huge amount of... Read More

Making Backwards Choices

I was reading this past week about a woman who... Read More

Options for Lawsuit Settlement Winners Receiving Periodic Payments

On January 22,2002, President George W. Bush signed into law... Read More

Class Action Lawsuits

First of all, let me say that anyone who has... Read More

What is a Structured Settlement

A Structured Settlement is an agreement between a personal injury... Read More


Have you ever looked around and wondered how everyone is... Read More

Cash For Structured Settlements - The Smart Way

For most people when they buy a house it is... Read More

Structured Settlement Factoring

Have you received a structured settlement recently? A structured settlement... Read More

What is Structured Settlement?

Because it is tailor-made for individual cases, the structure may... Read More

The Cost of Not Having Money

The self-esteem factor of not having enough money is underestimated.... Read More

Annuity Transfer - What Are the Risks

Many people who know in the back of their minds... Read More

Offshore Asset Protection Trusts for US Citizens

When it comes to discussing offshore anything and US citizens... Read More

Keeping the Lawsuit End in Mind

2 key points to stay focused on, as you are... Read More

When Should You Not Cash Out Your Annuity?

You should not cash out your annuity when it's not... Read More

Structured Settlements ? Should You Sell Yours?

In recent years, it has become more common for victims... Read More

Structured Settlement ? Guaranteed Income for those with Disabilities

Up until twenty years ago, anyone who won a lawsuit... Read More

Individual Voluntary Arrangements. IVA

What is an IVA?There is an alternative to bankruptcy called... Read More

Structured Settlements Are Like Ants

Ants are powerful creatures. The powerful ant legs are able... Read More

The Cash Now Question

If you have ever been in a bind for cash... Read More

What is a Trust and what are the Benefits?

Trusts are becoming a popular way to structure business and... Read More