To Tax or Not to Tax - This is the Question

To tax or not to tax - this question could have never been asked twenty years ago.

Historically, income tax is a novel invention. Still, it became so widespread and so socially accepted that no one dared challenge it seriously. In the lunatic fringes there were those who refused to pay taxes and served prison sentences as a result. Some of them tried to translate their platforms into political power and established parties, which failed dismally in the polls. But some of what they said made sense.

Originally, taxes were levied to pay for government expenses. But they underwent a malignant transformation. They began to be used to express social preferences. Tax revenues were diverted to pay for urban renewal, to encourage foreign investments through tax breaks and tax incentives, to enhance social equality by evenly redistributing income and so on. As Big Government became more derided - so were taxes perceived to be its instrument and the tide turned. Suddenly, the fashion was to downsize government, minimize its disruptive involvement in the marketplace and reduce the total tax burden as part of the GNP.

Taxes are inherently unjust. They are enforced, using state coercion. They are an infringement of the human age old right to property. Money is transferred from one group of citizens (law abiding taxpayers) - to other groups. The recipients are less savoury: they either do not pay taxes legally (low income populations, children, the elderly) - or avoid paying taxes illegally. But there is no way of preventing a tax evader from enjoying tax money paid by others.

Research demonstrated that most tax money benefited the middle classes and the rich, in short: those who need it least. Moreover, these strata of society were most likely to use tax planning to minimize their tax payments. They could afford to pay professionals to help them to pay less taxes because their income was augmented by transfers of tax money paid by the less affluent and by the less fortunate. The poor subsidized the tax planning of the rich, so that they could pay less taxes. No wonder that tax planning is regarded as the rich man's shot at tax evasion. The irony is that taxes were intended to lessen social polarity and friction - but they achieved exactly the opposite.

In economies where taxes gobble up to 60% of the GDP (France, Germany, to name a few) - taxes became THE major economic disincentive. Why work for the taxman? Why finance the lavish lifestyle of numerous politicians and bloated bureaucracies through tax money? Why be a sucker when the rich and mighty play it safe?

The results were socially and morally devastating: an avalanche of illegal activities, all intended to avoid paying taxes. Monstrous black economies were formed by entrepreneuring souls. These economic activities went unreported and totally deformed the processes of macroeconomic decision making, supposedly based on complete economic data. This apparent lack of macroeconomic control creates a second layer of mistrust between the citizen and his government (on top of the one related to the collection of taxes).

Recent studies clearly indicate that a reverse relationship exists between the growth of the economy and the extent of public spending. Moreover, decades of progressive taxation did not reverse the trend of a growing gap between the rich and the poor. Income distribution has remained inequitable (ever more so all the time) - despite gigantic unilateral transfers of money from the state to the poorer socio - economic strata of society.

Taxes are largely considered to be responsible for the following:

  • They distorted business thinking;

  • Encouraged the misallocation of economic resources;

  • Diverted money to strange tax motivated investments;

  • Absorbed unacceptably large chunks of the GDP;

  • Deterred foreign investment;

  • Morally corrupted the population, encouraging it to engage in massive illegal activities;

  • Adversely influenced macroeconomic parameters such as unemployment, the money supply and interest rates;

  • Deprived the business sector of capital needed for its development by spending it on non productive political ends;

  • Caused the smuggling of capital outside the country;

  • The formation of strong parallel, black economies and the falsification of economic records thus affecting the proper decision making processes;

  • Facilitated the establishment of big, inefficient bureaucracies for the collection of taxes and data related to income and economic activity;

  • Forced every member of society to - directly or indirectly - pay for professional services related to his tax obligations, or, at least to consume his own resources (time, money and energy) in communicating with authorities dealing with tax collection.

Thousands of laws, tax loopholes, breaks and incentives and seemingly arbitrary decision making, not open to judicial scrutiny eroded the trust that a member of the community should have in its institutions. This lack of transparency and even-handedness led to the frequent eruption of scandals which unseated governments more often than not.

All these very dear prices might have been acceptable if taxes were to achieve their primary stated goals. That they failed to do so is what sparked the latest rebellious thinking.

At first, the governments of the world tried a few simple recipes:

They tried to widen the tax base by better collection, processing, amalgamation and crossing of information. This way, more tax payers were supposed to be caught in "the net". This failed dismally. People found ways around this relatively unsophisticated approach and frequent and successive tax campaigns were to no avail.

So, governments tried the next trick in their bag: they shifted from progressive taxes to regressive ones. This was really a shift from taxes on income to taxes on consumption. This proved to be a much more efficient measure - albeit with grave social consequences. The same pattern was repeated: the powerful few were provided with legal loopholes. VAT rules around the world allow businesses to offset VAT that they paid from VAT that they were supposed to pay to the authorities. Many of them ended up receiving VAT funds paid the poorer population, to which these tax breaks were, obviously, not available.

Moreover, VAT and other direct taxes on consumption were almost immediately reflected in higher inflation figures. As economic theory goes, inflation is a tax. It indirectly affects the purchasing power of those not knowledgeable enough, devoid of political clout, or not rich enough to protect themselves. The salaries of the lower strata of society are eroded by inflation and this has the exact same effect as a tax would. This is why inflation is called the poor man's tax.

When the social consequences of levying regressive taxes became fully evident, governments went back to the drawing board. Regressive taxes were politically and socially costly. Progressive taxes resembled Swiss cheese: too many loopholes, not enough substances. The natural inclination was to try and plug the holes: disallow allowances, break tax breaks, abolish special preferences, eliminate loopholes, write-offs, reliefs and a host of other, special deductions. This entailed conflicts with special interest groups whose interests were duly reflected in the tax loopholes.

Governments, being political creatures, did a half hearted job. They abolished on the one hand - and gave with the other. They wriggled their way around controversial subjects and the result was that every loophole cutting measure brought in its wake a growing host of others. The situation looked hopeless.

Thus, governments were reduced to using the final, nuclear-like, weapon in their arsenal: the simplification of the tax system.

The idea is aesthetically appealing: all tax concessions and loopholes will be eliminated, on the one hand. On the other, the number of tax rates and the magnitude of each rate will be pared down. Marginal tax rates will go down considerably and so will the number of tax rates. So, people will feel less like cheating and they will spend less resources on the preparation of their tax returns. The government, on its part, will no longer use the tax system to express its (political) preferences. It will propagate a simple, transparent, equitable, fair and non arbitrary system which will generate more income by virtue of these traits.

Governments from Germany to the USA are working along the same lines. They are trying to stem what is in effect a tax rebellion, a major case of civil disobedience. If they fail, the very fabric of societies will be affected. If they succeed, we may all inherit a better world. Knowing the propensities of human beings, the safe bet is that people will still hate to see their money wasted in unaccounted for ways on bizarre, pork barrel, projects. As long as this is the case, the eternal chase of the citizen by his government will continue.

About The Author

Sam Vaknin is the author of "Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited" and "After the Rain - How the West Lost the East". He is a columnist in "Central Europe Review", United Press International (UPI) and ebookweb.org and the editor of mental health and Central East Europe categories in The Open Directory, Suite101 and searcheurope.com. Until recently, he served as the Economic Advisor to the Government of Macedonia.

His web site: http://samvak.tripod.com

In The News:

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at https://news.google.com/news

Fox News

After Texas governor slams NJ's high taxes, NJ governor responds
Fox News
New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy, left, responded to Texas Gov. Greg Abbott's, right, op-ed with a slew of reasons why his state's future is worth betting on. (Reuters). Gov. Phil Murphy of New Jersey responded this week after Gov. Greg Abbott of Texas ...
New Jerseyans can now prepay their property taxesNews & Observer

all 32 news articles »

Bloomberg

Michael Cohen's Other Woe: Mounting Unpaid Taxes on New York ...
Bloomberg
Taxicab companies owned by Michael Cohen or family members just got hit with nearly $80,000 in new claims for unpaid taxes, according to records filed in New York. The bills show the declining fortunes of some companies linked to Cohen, the longtime ...

and more »

wivb.com

FCC: New York 'deceiving consumers' over 911 taxes
wivb.com
BUFFALO, N.Y. (WIVB) - The list of taxes that appear on landline and cell phone bills seems to grow every month. But one line that's appeared consistently for nearly a decade is the 911 service fee, or surcharge. That tax is intended to be collected by ...

and more »

Bloomberg

How to Bolster Social Security Without Raising Taxes
Bloomberg
But what I was discussing was the program's initial benefit levels, which are structured so that a person in the middle of the income distribution who retires 10 years from now gets a bigger check than a similar person who retires today. Second: Some ...
This is how the government will spend your taxes in 2018New York Post

all 59 news articles »

Washington Post

Congrats, you filed your 2017 taxes. Now it's really important to do one more thing.
Washington Post
I'll admit it: I filed my taxes on Monday. Every year I resolve to be more prompt, but I have a long track record of filing in April. I suppose I can at least claim some redeemable amount of dignity for doing them on my own (without the aid of a parent ...
Why We Pay TaxesHistory
IRS gives taxpayers one-day extension to file taxes after site crashesCNBC
IRS Website Crashes on Tax Day as Millions Tried to File ReturnsNew York Times
MarketWatch -Forbes -CBS News -IRS
all 1,146 news articles »

DesMoinesRegister.com

Q: How high can your Iowa property taxes go? A: Pretty darn high.
DesMoinesRegister.com
Abel Island wasn't an island at all when Chris Zearley's grandfather bought land near Guttenberg in the 1930s. Now riverfront property, some of that land, in far northeast Iowa, has more than doubled in price in the past couple of years — from $404 ...


Newsday

LI school districts weigh adding security, programs vs. cutting taxes
Newsday
Surveys of Long Island school districts' proposed 2018-19 budgets confirm that taxes are increasing at a greater pace, with much of the extra money earmarked for security guards and other safety measures. A Newsday sampling of district spending plans ...


CNBC

Big banks saved $3.6 billion in taxes last quarter under new law
CNBC
An analysis by The Associated Press shows the nation's six big Wall Street banks saved at least $3.59 billion in taxes last quarter, thanks to the recently enacted Trump tax law. Banks typically kick off the earnings season, and their reports for the ...
Big banks save billions in taxesThe Register-Guard
Big banks saved $3.6B in taxes last quarter under new lawWTOP
GOP tax law saved big banks $3.6 billion: APThe Hill
Investopedia (blog)
all 10 news articles »

TCPalm

2 school taxes may be too rich for Martin County, but board members trying anyway | Analysis
TCPalm
MARTIN COUNTY — Hitting up voters for two tax increases less than three months apart, both to benefit local schools, is an unusual, if not risky, move, experts say. School Board members see the tax hikes as a last-ditch effort to make teacher salaries ...


News & Observer

Durham businessman didn't hand over $65000 in tax revenue, state charges
News & Observer
A Durham businessman is accused of failing to hand over $65,000 in sales-tax revenue and not filing personal income tax returns for five years. Preston Ray Swift, 54, who lives on Little Rogers Road in Durham was arrested Thursday on 23 felony charges ...

and more »
Google News

Fiscal Deity: Tax Consultant

Strategic planning throughout the year results in a minimal tax... Read More

Identity Theft ? Impacting Your Taxes?

If your identity is stolen, your finances can quickly become... Read More

Need a Copy of Your Tax Return Information?

Taxpayers have two easy and convenient options for getting copies... Read More

Tax Tips to Save Money on Taxes - Get the Corporate Kick and Save Loads of Money

Why a Corporation Helps Save You TaxesThe Tax Rates (Notice... Read More

Tax Secrets - How Drew Miles Helped Me

How about a Tax Tip?As we all know Taxes are... Read More

Are You Overpaying Taxes If You Use Tax Preparation Software?

For many business owners the answer to this quandary is... Read More

Hurricane Katrina ? How To Use Your Business Loss To Get A Refund on 2004 Taxes

With the massive losses caused by Katrina, the economy of... Read More

Tax Reform, My Way

We need real tax reform and we need it now.... Read More

Another Tax Loophole

Just image, you are a small manufacturing company, business has... Read More

Tax Deduction for Alimony Payments? - Yes!

Over 50% of marriages end in divorce in the United... Read More

The Tax Man Cometh... To Search

You're at your office, or home, and the doorbell rings... Read More

Deducting Points On Home Refinances

Deduction of Refinance PointsAny points that you pay in the... Read More

Rearrange Your Affairs For Maximum Tax Savings

One way to maximize your business profits is by reducing... Read More

Save Money on Taxes - Let Uncle Sam Pay for Your Fun!

"Deducting Meals and Entertainment"O.K. You've been working really hard on... Read More

Marriage or Divorce ? Check Your Social Security Number

Newlyweds and the recently divorced should make sure that names... Read More

IRS Certifies 2006 Toyota Hybrid for Clean Fuel Deduction

The Internal Revenue Service has certified the 2006 Toyota Highlander... Read More

Back To School ? Educators Deduct School Expenses

As teachers and students head back to school following a... Read More

Truly Bizarre Taxes: The Tax on Illegal Drugs

One can never underestimate the enthusiasm that politicians have for... Read More

Understanding Basic Tax Terms

If your like many, you don't always understand what people... Read More

IRS Obtains More Than 100 Injunctions Against Tax Scheme Promoters

The IRS has obtained civil injunctions against more than 100... Read More

Navigating The Internet Sales Tax Laws

QUESTION: I have been contacted by my local city... Read More

I Havent Filed a Tax Return with IRS in Years, What Do I Do?

In elementary school, kids come up with creative excuses why... Read More

The Internet Tax Man Cometh

Q: I was contacted by the city tax collector to... Read More

Organizing Your Taxes

Does this scene sound familiar? It's April 7. You haven't... Read More

Tax Strategy - Let Washington Pay for Your Corvette, Porsche, or Air Plane

Deducting Your Auto ExpensesAuto deductions are a very complex topic.... Read More