Cooperative Reciprocal Linking Networks - A Critical Analysis

Every webmaster who has personally tried promoting his or her site understands in some sense the value of reciprocal linking. Reciprocal linking refers to the agreement between website owners to mutually link to each others' sites in order to increase both exposure to each others' visitors as well as link popularity to search engines. Traditionally, this process has been very labor-intensive involving a number of steps to initiate contact, establish acceptable link parameters, and verify and police the reciprocal linking arrangement. Now, a controversial new linking tactic has emerged called "the cooperative reciprocal linking network."

The purpose of these reciprocal linking networks is ostensibly to utilize "unused advertising space available on the web." Here's how it works: the site owner puts a bit of code on each page of his or her site and it serves up hyper-linked text or graphic ads promoting the sites of other cooperative members. Each time a coded page is loaded, the ads change. This is much like how Google Adsense ads work except there is no correlation between the pages' topics and what ads are served--in other words, the ads are not contextual.

Although dynamically generated, these text ad links can be crawled by search engine spiders. In this sense, the ad linking network can be thought of as an automated method of reciprocal linking capable of providing a boost to each member site's link popularity.

Participation in the reciprocal linking network is generally free (hence the term "cooperative") and what one gets out of it depends on what one gives into it. If a webmaster agrees to display five ads per page and his or her site has 100 pages indexed by Google, then that webmaster's site is given a weight of, say, 500 (5 x 100). The higher one's "weight," the more often one's ads will show on other sites in the network. In order to be an eligible page, the page has to be indexed. The reciprocal linking network checks this using Google's application program interface or API.

So what's the controversy? Reciprocal linking network critics contend that because the links are crawl-able by search engine robots and the fact that ads may be irrelevant to the page's topic area, this is akin to having some sort of reciprocal link farm or scheme designed to influence the web page's link popularity and search engine ranking. Indeed, one well-known individual's web page showed up for a while in Google at No. 4 for the term, "eBay" purely because he designed his link ads so that the anchor texts had the word "eBay" in them. Carried across thousands of reciprocal linking participants in the network, it had automated the reciprocal linking process and, at the same time, boosted his page's link popularity for that particular term.

One would think that this is a bad thing from the search engines' perspective, right? Not quite. GoogleGuy, the unofficial Google spokesman who regularly posts to website marketing forums, responded to a thread at one forum on this topic. GoogleGuy said he was concerned about linking out to "bad neighborhood" participants in the network (like some Polish site that was apparently cloaking the cooperative ads). GoogleGuy did not say that the network was bad because it had the potential of manipulating rankings, rather he said the worry was "bad neighborhoods." So, does that mean that if the bad neighborhood problem was under control then the reciprocal linking networks are sanctioned? Maybe...

Here's how I look at these cooperative reciprocal linking networks: what if Google didn't exist? What if no search engine existed? What would I do to advertise my site? I would have to participate in reciprocal linking with other sites. But reciprocal linking willy-nilly would not cut it; it would have to be targeted, topic-based reciprocal linking. I would link reciprocally with other like sites. Would I participate in reciprocal linking networks if there were no search engines? Absolutely! It would greatly ease my reciprocal linking time. But the reciprocal linking networks are untargeted as they are currently configured--this is clearly something the operators need to address.

In conclusion, reciprocal linking via cooperative ad networks is a great idea. Google and the other search engines should not have any issues with them in concept. But concept is not reality; in reality, people are joining these networks and trading "weight" to influence link popularity and rankings in the search engines. So, it's not a perfect solution to the busy webmaster's reciprocal link management problems. Is participating in a reciprocal link network spamming the search engines? I don't believe so because the search engines have not clearly defined exactly everything that is or isn't a spamming technique, and in this business, whether a technique constitutes spamming or not often comes down to a question of degree.

(c) 2005 Philip Liu - All Rights Reserved Worldwide

Philip Liu is a freelance author and publisher currently based in New York City. Philip publishes regularly on his websites, Cell Phone News + Reviews (focusing on cell phone news, rumors and reviews from around the world), and DTVScoop - Plasma, LCD TV Reviews + News (focusing on digital television news and reviews).

In The News:

Neighbors push back on Hob Knob project  Martha's Vineyard Times
Town-by-town: Safe voting procedures  Lewiston Sun Journal
Technology more effective at managing traffic congestion than building more roads  The London School of Economics and Political Science

Submitting Your Articles To E-zines and Viral Marketing

Viral Marketing DefinedIt is allowing others to giveaway and use... Read More

Email Can Be Extremely Irritating

There are some extremely irritating things that have become an... Read More

DOUBLE HIGHWAY The Dual Importance Of Online Traffic

Online traffic, or the number of users who view your... Read More

8 Breakthrough Ways to Bring Free Visitors to Your Site!

Many websites have great ideas, excellent content, brilliant deals and... Read More

Link Popularity and Your Add URL Page

With all the buzz going on about the importance of... Read More

The Swank Meter - What Does Hilary Swank Have to Do With Page Rank?

Recently the wife and I were watching Million Dollar Baby.... Read More

Free Traffic Programs and How to Use Them

I try to use as many free traffic programs as... Read More

Increase Your Online Traffic in 60 Minutes or Less

Increasing your website traffic does not have to be a... Read More

Keyword Articles: Use Magical Keywords in Your Articles and Get Lots of Traffic

You get a flash of inspiration and an interesting topic... Read More

10 Tips to Avoid Getting Ripped Off by Web Traffic Experts

If you are looking at ways to increase traffic to... Read More

The FREE Web Traffic Explosion Method

Dear Friend,Many people like to listen to all the graphic... Read More

Traffic Exchange Primer

Traffic exchanges are everywhere. A traffic exchange is a clever... Read More

Expand your Website to Improve Traffic

One problem with websites is that they often go neglected... Read More

What Can Lots Of Content Do For Your Site?

Today there are so many web sites on the web,... Read More

How to Increase Link Popularity

Link Popularity refers to the number of links coming from... Read More

7 Ways to Increase Web Site Visitors and Boost Sales

Have you spent a lot of money on advertising with... Read More

How to Drive Traffic to Your Website

Everyone wants to know the big secret to driving traffic... Read More

Reciprocal Linking - A Business Partnership!

Link popularity is becoming the latest "in-thing" to get your... Read More

Common Sense Link Exchange

Creating a simple links page to exchange links for the... Read More

My Kind Of Targeted Traffic, Cheap

There are two types of tools I sometime use to... Read More

Do You Need to Marry The Daughter?

For the sake of this article let's forget about search... Read More

How to Quickly Gain Traffic to Your New Web Site

Have you spent a lot of money on advertising with... Read More

Why Traffic Touts and List Pushers Are Bad For Your Business

In this Article we look at the second competitive advantage... Read More

Triple Your Traffic with Top Keyword Strategies

Although the topic of keyword strategy and selection may appear... Read More

3 Ways To Swarm Your Website With Highly Targeted Traffic For FREE!

Targeted website traffic is the lifeblood of any website looking... Read More