Selecting a Web Content Management Product

So you want to take a look at a real Web Content Management (WCM) product. How do you go about evaluating all the different products and vendors? What should you be looking for in a WCM package? Is it better to build your own, buy or use Open Source?

The best way to answer this question is to compare the products on an apples to apples basis. You can do this objectively by building a product evaluation matrix based upon your specific needs. The first column can list out the functionality categories (e.g. Security). The second column can be the specific needs (e.g. integrates with Active Directory for roles and authorization) under each of the categories. The next columns would be your products, one per column for each product you want to consider. For each product then you would give a rating (1 to 10 scale) on each specific need.

You can then add a column for weighting each specific need, or do this at the topic level. For example, flexible workflow may be much more important to you than your ability to customize the presentation. You can then add some more columns to calculate the weighting against the rating to arrive at a realistic assessment number for each product on each of your organization's specific needs. Sum these all up per product to arrive at a total product assessment score.

Of course, you can't forget to check customer references, or if it's an open source product, go dig around some sites which are using the tool already.

Below is a list of some topics/specific needs which may apply for you. At a minimum, these should provoke some thought on your part as far as what you are looking for in a WCM product and give you a good start on your product evaluation matrix.

Workflow

  • Support for multiple workflow models?
  • Complex workflows (parallel and serial)?
  • Role/Group integration with flows?
  • Ability to create workflow templates for re-use with different content types?

Security

  • Will the product integrate with your security architecture?
  • Do you require security for content submission?
  • Do you require security for content consumption?
  • Is there support for roles and groups?
  • How is this implemented and managed in the product?

Content submission

  • What are the creation/submission vehicles e.g., via an Office application, HTML/File upload, WYSIWYG, etc.
  • Are there templates to force content managers to adhere to a common content structure (e.g. all posts must have a title, sub-title, body, and who to contact fields)

Presentation customization

  • Extensive presentation customization capabilities?
  • Extensive support for CSS integration?
  • Ability to create presentation templates which can then be re-used for different content types?
  • End-user creation of presentation templates or does it require a developer?

Integration with search

  • Does the product provide its own search engine?
  • Or, will it effectively integrate with your current (or planned search engine)?
  • Security integration with search (i.e. a user can only see search results for what he/she has access to view)

Common document management functionality

  • Versioning
  • Expiration
  • Metadata
  • Check-in/Check-out
  • Collaborative authoring
  • Content history tracking

Architecture

  • If your organization uses Web Services or has an established Service Oriented Architecture, you may demand the product can expose content through Web Services so other applications can present content.
  • Portal integration (e.g., JSR168 support, WSRP support, etc.)
  • Open and documented API available?

Cost

  • Acquisition
  • Maintenance
  • Technical staffing to support (check with customer references)

Administration interface

  • Robust yet easy to use?
  • Complete control of all content in the lifecycle?
  • Role/group management

About the author
Bryan Mjaanes is the creator/editor of Intranet101.com a community-based forum for Intranet Portal professionals.

In The News:

The 7 myths that hold back agencies from growing web development  AdAge.comPantheon shares lessons from its partner network of over 2500 agencies to dispel the seven most common myths about growing your web development and ...
Top 5 editors / Text IDEs for web programming  ToolboxIn web developers, there is always a need to find the best web development tool. It can be a text editor, a specific framework for project creation, etc. I will focus ...
@Pika/web Frees Modern Web Development from the Complexity of Package Bundling  InfoQ.compika/web, part of the pika tool chain, aims at improving web application developers' experience by turning often-complex bundling processes into an opt-in ...
This $29 bundle can get you savvy with Google’s own programming language  The Next WebYou may know that Google processes over 3.5 billion search requests per day, owns YouTube, and is a regular entrant on Fortune's list of the Best Companies ...
How To Find A Stellar Web Development Agency  ForbesWhen you're looking to hire an agency, act as if you're hiring an employee.
Know About Role of PHP In Web Development  Customer ThinkIt is a well-established fact now that for any company to flourish it needs to have its presence on the digital platform. While social media can be the right place to ...
Web Development Company NYC, Huemor, Lists and Explains the Elements of an Effective Website  PRNewswireNEW YORK, June 21, 2019 /PRNewswire/ -- Three out of four brands are unhappy with their website redesign. With so many considerations going into a website ...
Why use Vue.js for UI web development?  JAXenterIf you are looking to start a new project and you are not sure if Vue.js would be the right choice for you, check out this overview of the popular framework.
IoT, the Real Game Changer of Web Development!  CIOReviewFREMONT, CA: With the growing emergence of technology and the evolving requirements of individuals as well as companies, there has been an increase in ...
IoT in Web Development Market 2019 to Witness Astonishing Growth With Dot Com Infoway Limited, Upwork, GoodFirms  Market Research ReportIoT in Web Development Market Research report presents a complete assessment of the market and contains a future trend, current growth factors, attentive ...
PHP VS JAVA: Which Is The Best Option For Web Development?  Promotion WorldDifference Between PHP VS JAVA To develop a website, the developers need a programming language which is best suited. PHP and Java are the most.
Obsessing over first-page load time sabotages ecommerce businesses  The Next WebA flawed approach to page speed measurement is sabotaging ecommerce sites. There, I said it. Now I know this might be an exaggeration, but it really is time for ...
This cheap online course will teach you all about front-end web development  MashableInteractive buttons. Scannable layouts. Flashy graphics. Beautiful typography. Elements of a website — or any digital product for that matter — that make you go ...
Web design and development  IndivigitalWe build user-friendly websites that help small brands standout in competitive marketplaces. We believe a website should and can be more than an obligatory ...
Measuring PR correctly  PRWeekEarned media is transforming. Take it from the journalists themselves. According to Cision's recent 2019 State of the Media report, the number one concern to ...
Website Development Handoff Checklist: What Your Developer Needs to Be Successful  Business 2 CommunityWebsite mockups are completed and client-approved. Pages and templates have yet to be built. It's time for a website development handoff. A website ...
5-Step Web Design Process to Create Winning Websites  Business.comA stellar design isn't merely focused on how pretty the interface looks.
KSM Consulting Acquires Web Development Company  Inside INdiana BusinessIndianapolis-based KSM Consulting is adding to its portfolio. The firm, which specializes in technology, data analytics and management consulting, has acquired ...
Edge, Chrome, Brave share updates on upcoming releases, recent milestones, and more at State of Browsers event  Packt HubLast month, This Dot Labs, a framework-agnostic JavaScript consultancy, conducted its biannual online live streaming event, This. JavaScript – State of ...
How to set up a Ruby on Rails development environment with Docker  TechRepublicFind out how to use Docker to build a Rails development framework that will make app programming and web development more efficient.
The Top 26 eCommerce Software Development Companies of 2019, According to Top Software Development Companies  PR WebSoftwareDevelopmentCompany.co uncovered the best eCommerce software developers who can build custom solutions and help eCommerce brands grow ...
Django Vs Flask: A Detailed Comparison Between Python's Most Popular Frameworks  Analytics India MagazineHere is a detailed comparison between the two web frameworks of Python called Django and Flask.
We’re Hiring A Visual Journalist To Cover Sports, The 2020 Election And More  FiveThirtyEightFiveThirtyEight's graphics and interactives team is growing! We're looking for a savvy visual journalist to contribute to daily graphics production, collaborate…
Internships 2019: Applications open for internship with Department of Health & Family Welfare, Delhi  Scroll.inThe last date to apply for the 3-month internship for 'Project Connection-Aid' is 24 June, 2019.
Top 5 Programming Languages For Machine Learning  TechopediaWhile there are several programming languages that work especially well for machine learning, each of them comes with unique advantages and ...
Best Web Development Company 2019 - Customer Experience – Winners at DCE Awards  IT News OnlineMumbai, India, June 05, 2019 --(PR.com)-- Website Developers India Pvt. Ltd. is the proud winner of the Best Web Development Company 2019 - Customer ...
WP Engine to Acquire Flywheel  Business WireWP Engine today announced it has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire Flywheel.
Save 92% on the Complete Front-End Web Development Course  Geeky GadgetsWe have a great deal on the Complete Front-End Web Development Course in the Geeky Gadgets Deals store today, you can save 92% off the normal price.
What is the web development lifecycle?  NewsPatrollingWeb Development Lifestyle is a definite difference in the general framework for developing any application development project. Complying with the same.
JRNI opens web development office in Manchester | Business  The Union LeaderMANCHESTER — A customer engagement company whose clients include U.S. Bank, LEGO, Nordstrom and Levi's has chosen the Queen City for its web ...
Senior Developers earn an average $109,957 per year—here are 9 other top tech jobs for new grads  CNBCUsing data from its platform, jobs site Comparably examined thousands of anonymous job records submitted by employees to see which tech jobs are the most ...
Meet Matt Slack: Michigan techie who is @slack on Twitter got an invite to Slack’s public debut  GeekWireMatt Slack has been on Twitter for 13 years with the handle @slack. Slack, the chat-based collaboration app, has been on Twitter for six years with the handle ...
The Basics Of Web Development That Will Shorten Your Time  TheUSBportWeb development means building and maintaining websites and is the work that takes place in the background and that allows a website to have an impeccable ...
Get your own Android app now with Codehesion  ITWebCodehesion is one of South Africa's top Android and iOS app development companies, and makes it quick and easy for businesses to get their own mobile app.
LKCS Receives Three Awards for Outstanding Web Development Projects  PR WebPeru, IL (PRWEB) May 28, 2019 -- LKCS has received three Awards of Distinction from the Communicator Awards for outstanding website design and ...
Employers, workers at odds on skills training: LinkedIn | My Business  My BusinessInsufficient training is causing one in three employees to quit, according to LinkedIn, which also identified a “misalignment” between employers and workers on ...
UK-based firm opens web development office in Manchester  New Hampshire Business ReviewCustomer engagement company JRNI Inc. has opened its first U.S. web development office at 66 Hanover St. in Manchester, part of what it calls an aggressive ...
Top 3 free courses on web development using WordPress  TechJuiceWe have compiled 3 free courses which will help you make your first website using WordPress.
Web Browser Makers Will Be Responsible For The Most Important Web Standards As W3C Backs Down?  AppualsApple, Google, Microsoft, and Mozilla, the leading web browser makers appear to have collectively stood their ground and gained against World Wide Web.
The Top 7 Qualities Of A Successful Website – Plus, The 23 Best Web Development Agencies, According To DesignRush  PR WebAlmost 40 percent of consumers will stop engaging with a website if it takes too long to load or is not beautiful to look at -- but DesignRush determined the top ...
Neo-Nazis on DeviantArt Radicalized a Woman Who Planned a Mass Shooting  VICEThe cutesy art site was the surprising birthplace for a number of players in the modern extreme-right movement.
Web Development Company NYC, Huemor, Discusses the Top WordPress Plugins Your Site Should Have  Yahoo FinanceNEW YORK, May 29, 2019 /PRNewswire/ -- With thousands of WordPress plugins to add to your website, it's important to know which plugins will enhance your ...
Web developer Wix creates 100 jobs as Dublin office opens  Newstalk 106-108 fmA cloud-based web development platform has created 100 jobs in Dublin with the opening of its new...
4 Useful Tools for Web Development  TheUSBportToday, websites can be massive and complex. Even the most experienced web developers need to have a good toolbox to do their job well. Therefore, here is a ...
FiveAI hits the streets of London, the state of autonomous vehicle industry in Europe: Will the slow and steady win the race?  Silicon CanalsAutonomous vehicles are a part of the tech-infused future we are all envisioning to be a part of. Imagine a scenario where you are ready to go to work and ...
Coding boot camp kicks off new partnership  Mirage NewsWith demand for skilled tech talent in Australia at an all-time high, the University of Adelaide and workforce accelerator Trilogy Education are...
Top Web Development Trends 2019  YourStory.comWeb Development Trends 2019 Do you know global internet users number have surpassed 4 billion in 2018? It is found in a recent study by We Are Social and ...
Waitr founder, CEO Chris Meaux named regional Entrepreneur of the Year  The Daily AdvertiserThe award qualifies Meaux for Entrepreneur of the Year 2019 National Award, to be announced at Entrepreneur of the Year National Awards gala.
A new coding boot camp designed for adult learners is soon to kick off at Adelaide University  The AdvertiserAdult learners who want to break into the coding sphere are being offered an alternative route into the profession through a new course being offered at ...
What are the latest web development Trends For businesses In 2019?  YourStory.comIt's impossible to go along with web development trends; because it is subject to change. Rarely, a week passes without any release of a new JS framework, ...
Highest paying part-time jobs in Singapore – The Independent News  The IndependentTutors who have credentials from top learning institutions and who are able to teach the most difficult subjects could be earning as much as S$100 per hour.
Things to consider before going into web development  JAXenterWe normally don't offer beginners' guide for aspiring developers but this time around we are making an exception! Amit Jat has a set of extremely useful ...
Internshala Trainings launches The Web-Dev Battle - A web development contest  Knn IndiaInternshala Trainings has launched The Web-Dev Battle for the students who are passionate about building their ideas from scratch using their creativity and ...
Top 10 Image Formats That Are Best for Web Development  YourStory.comWeb application development is one of the biggest trends in this era because now a day's software has tons of functionality that cannot work properly on our ...
The Crucial Role of AI in Web Development  Analytics InsightArtificial intelligence is undeniably no longer a buzzword in the web development space. AI in web development is used to design automation, integrating into ...
What makes Laravel the most Preferred PHP Framework for Web Development  Customer ThinkOne of the most daunting tasks for any business is choosing the right PHP development framework to build a robust web application. PHP frameworks are not ...
A Quick Primer on Managing Your Web-Development Tasks  EntrepreneurNeed to modify your website or app? Here are the tips you'll need to do that right.
Safari Technology Preview release 83 now available for macOS Mojave and macOS High Sierra  Packt HubThe team at WebKit announced that Safari Technology Preview release 83 is now available for macOS Mojave and macOS High Sierra. Safari Technology ...
Solve Web development issues to Drive Business to Your Website  Customer ThinkHave you ever had to develop a website? I do not mean to sit down to program it but have to, at least, order it and work with the person or team that carries it ...
Wix.com opens customer support centre in Dublin  The Irish TimesThe Israeli web development company's Irish office employs 100 staff.
Top 5 WordPress Development Companies in the World  YourStory.comAre you searching for top WordPress development companies? We are providing you the list of top and best WordPress development companies in the world.
Are You Missing This Important Puzzle For Web Development Success? – Test Driven Development  YourStory.comAs a Web Development Company, there are many aspects of your business that determine your success. You can choose to create your application as cheap as ...
Web Development on an iPad  Laravel NewsThe idea of working entirely from an iPad has always appealed to me. The portability, the battery life, and of course the touch screen makes it an excellent device ...
Cosmic JS wants to simplify web development so you can focus on content  TechCrunchIf you are a web developer, you know how complex many of the traditional web *content* management systems have been. One of the big problems has been ...
Stefan Judis, a Twilio web developer, on responsible web development with HTTP headers  Packt HubAt this year's JavaScript Fwdays, Stefan Judis, who works at Twilio as a frontend developer, talked about how web developers can make their sites secure with ...
Future of web development in India  Daily News & AnalysisFuture of web development in India - Web development, as a career, has witnessed a boom all over the world, including India, since the time e-commerce has ...
5 Ways in Which Data Science Is Revolutionizing Web Development  Analytics InsightTechnology is a highly dynamic field where new advancements keep coming every day. The data is the next big thing about this modern digital age.
How AI is reshaping web development | Articles | Big Data  Innovation EnterpriseHow AI is enabling are reshaping web development and giving developers everywhere hope about the future of tech.
Top 12 Python Web Frameworks of 2019 Programmes Should Know  Analytics India MagazinePython is a very versatile programming language. A new developer survey about Python by the Python Software Foundation and developer tools vendor ...
Internshala Trainings launches The Wed-Dev Battle — A web development contest  APN NewsAn opportunity for the students of India to learn the top in-demand skill and earn rewards worth INR 1 lakh. Internshala Trainings has launched The Web-Dev ...
AI Needs to Develop to Impact Web Design  Business.comArtificial intelligence has had a big impact on web design and development, but it still has a long way to go.
Harness web development skills to create better desktop applications  The GuardianIntegrating best of breed desktop applications from Adobe Creative Suite with web tools can provide a better experience for creative staff. Sakib Supple.
JavaScript and Web Development InfoQ Trends Report  InfoQ.comThis InfoQ Trends Report looks at the current trends with JavaScript, HTML, CSS, and web development, exploring technologies and options gaining further ...
What Skills Should You Look for in a Web Developer?  Customer ThinkIntroduction. Choosing a web development company is one of the most important decisions a business can make in today's marketplace. Simply put, how a ...
Learn Full-Stack Web Development With 80% Off This JavaScript Bundle  InverseThis E-Degree program has been designed as a one-stop solution for learning web development with JavaScript and other crucial programming languages.
App Development and Design Trends that will mark 2019  YourStory.comIntroduction One of the most significant technology markets is the mobile application division as proven by the Statista report that predicted that mobile apps ...
Controlism IT Solutions: Web Development 360 Degree  Siliconindia.comIT empowered solution small, medium and large organizations worldwide which executes innovation to transform their thoughts into activities.
Trends You can Expect in Web Development for 2019  Customer ThinkThe current generation of website developers is ideal employees in consideration of web development spectrum. Most of the modern people respond quickly to ...
Creative UI/UX approaches to deliver high-performance Web Development solutions  Customer ThinkOver time, software design has had different approaches that have evolved and become enriched both in their tasks and in the variety of possible techniques to ...
Web Development: What's Big In 2019?  HackadayI try to keep up with web development trends but it's hard to keep pace since it's such a fast evolving field. Barely a week goes by without the release of a new JS ...
Lean Web Development with the Best Teachers Online  Digital InspirationMeet the best online teachers for learning modern web development including React, TypeScript, JavaScript, Golang, Flutter, Nodejs, Docker and more.
Yale, Flatiron School create web development bootcamp for summer session  Yale NewsYale Summer Session is collaborating with Flatiron School to offer a Web Development Bootcamp for Summer 2019, which will carry two Yale College credits, ...
.NET Core releases May 2019 updates  Packt HubThe team at .NET Core released the .NET Core May 2019 Update. The updates include security, reliability fixes, and updated packages.
Looking For Coding Jobs? These 8 Programming Languages Are In Highest Demand Right Now (2019 Data)  Trak.inCoding jobs are evergreen jobs: But the platforms keep on changing. Here are the 10 programming languages which are in highest demand right now (2019 ...
.NET 5 arriving in 2020!  Packt HubYesterday, on the first day of Microsoft Build 2019, the team behind .NET Core announced that .NET Core 3.0 will be .NET 5, which will also be the next big ...
6 Software Development Concepts You Can Learn Through Online Courses  TechopediaWhen it comes to understanding the process of software development, there's a lot to learn. These courses can help you up your software development game.
Done Role of IoT in Web Development  Customer ThinkWith the increasing advent of technology and the ever-changing demands of people as well as businesses, there has been a rise in technologies which have ...
10 Topmost Web Design & Development Companies in Chennai – 2019 [Updated List!]  YourStory.comThe list of Top 10 Web Design & Development Companies in Chennai is sorted out through a research methodology. These companies are well verse in Web ...
Master web development with this JavaScript master class  Boing BoingWhen it comes to website development, JavaScript is the language that underlies it all. If you want to learn that language well enough for a career, you'll need ...
JavaScript and machine learning: Google shows what's possible using the web programming language  TechRepublicFrom head-controlled Pacman to browser-based upload filters -- here are some of the best uses of TensorFlow.js.
Tech internships in IoT, web development social media; highest stipend Rs 15,000  The Indian ExpressHere is a list of internships in the technology domain, from the latest internet of things (IoT) to social media, Bangalore has many openings. Students with ...
Eclipse announces support for Java 12  Packt HubThe team at Eclipse announced that Eclipse now has support for Java 12.
Ten Basic Things Every Web Developer Should Know  HTML Goodiesten things you need to know if you plan to build a web site.
Decoupled Drupal Delivers Flexible Approaches to Web Development - Free eBook  NeowinMeet new experience mandates across channels and devices with flexible decoupled development modes provided by Acquia and Drupal. You can claim your ...
How will AI change the web development in future?  Customer ThinkAI is present everywhere – from chatbots to virtual assistants, AI is used in day to day activities. Virtual assistants like Siri and Cortana are helping the users by ...
6 Reasons Why Angular is Better for Web Development  CIOReviewIn this digital era, the market is witnessing the ever increasing demand for web developers. There are millions of websites on the internet, and the numbers are ...
Web development trends 2019 - Ponder on them to make a difference  ITProPortalThe world of web development experiences demand constant transformation every year, whether it is related to tools, services, coding, languages, or designs.
Web Development Issues: 7 Reasons Why Your Website Isn’t Driving Business  Business 2 CommunityIs your website failing to drive business? You may be having problems with your web development. Read more here. website development. You launched your ...
5 Common Questions About Website Accessibility  TechopediaA company's website is the virtual portal to their business, but many limit their audience by neglecting accessibility features.
The new new web  TechCrunchOver the last five years, almost everything about web development has changed. Oh, the old tech still works, your WordPress and Ruby On Rails sites still ...

Website Sales: 10 Reasons Why People Dont Buy From You

You've put up a website to promote a product or... Read More

Ebooks for Webmasters

Internet has opened a whole new world for web developers... Read More

How to Listen on the Web

When building a relationship, listening is more important than talking.A... Read More

Maintaining Your Business Website

QUESTION: Should I build and maintain my business Web... Read More

Websites: You Get What You Pay For!

So you finally decided to invest in a web presence... Read More

Website For The Company Store

If your company own one or more stores, you might... Read More

Setting Up Your First Website

Q. Hey, Cathy: I'm just setting up a website. What... Read More

Internet Marketing Website Promotion -The 7 Biggest Mistakes I See People Make With Websites!

1. Many people are not getting good or complete advice.... Read More

Website Value - Whats Your Business Website Worth?

If you were asked to put a value on your... Read More

Let Your Customers Redesign Your Website!

When you purchase a new item from a Yahoo! Store,... Read More

3 Ways To Increase Your Websites Conversion rate

Everywhere you look these days, people are telling you that... Read More

Up The Sandbox!

Go to any internet marketing forum you want these days... Read More

Make Your Communication Come Alive

Design and layout can make your communication come alive and... Read More

Credibility - 10 Ways to Build it on Your Website

If you have your own business website and you are... Read More

Web Development Processes and Technical Environments

The process of Web application development is critical to the... Read More

Successful Commercial Sites

Do you make your website just to entertain yourself or... Read More

The Power Of CPanel

cPanel is a control panel for your website and allows... Read More

How Your Own Website Helps Your Small Business Grow

What do you mean, you don't have a website for... Read More

Business Website Building Do?s and Don?ts

First, using a lot of web graphics, flash, banners and... Read More

The Two Most Common Mistakes That Scare Away Web Visitors

Can you imagine the hypocrisy of spending thousands of dollars,... Read More

Is Your Website Doomed for Failure Before Youve Built It?

One of the things that many people overlook when building... Read More

What is Blogger.com?

In the late 1990's three San Francisco based web developers... Read More

3 Rules of Website Designing and Layout

Now that you have got your domain name registered, your... Read More

5 Ways to Build a Website

If you are like me you have wanted to build... Read More

Building a Web Store on Shoestring Budget in less than Four Hours

Starting a business online is no longer as difficult as... Read More