High Carb & Low Carb Diets: How To Avoid The Dangers

There's a two hundred year history of people prescribing both high and low carb diets for weight loss. So how does one choose? One factor you should consider is the dangers associated with each diet.

What is a carbohydrate, anyways?

There are three types of nutrients that every body uses: *Proteins in our diet usually come from Meat and soy products like tofu. Amino acids, the building blocks of proteins, are used to make muscles and enzymes (the proteins that do most of the work our bodies need to survive)

* Carbohydrates are sometimes described as "sugars," but they're not just white stuff in you find in the baking aisle. Simple sugars include the sugar you put in coffee; pasta, bread, and potatoes are among the source of starches, or complex carbohydrates. Most of your body uses carbs for energy, and it's the preferred energy source for the brain.

* Fats are long, chainlike molecules that are don't mix with water (oils are fats). They are an efficient way for the body to store energy.

You can see that all three nutrients are crucial for functioning. What happens if you take in more or less of a given nutrient than you need?

The Low-Fat Diet

The low-fat diet reduces fat intake, following the governmental food pyramid that suggests using fats sparingly. There are many good reasons to limit the amount of fat in your diet:

*cholesterol and fats can result in clogged up arteries, leading to heart disease and possible cardiac damage (in the form of a heart attack), stroke, and kidney disease

*fat packs a lot of calories - if you don't use those calories up in your daily activities, they will be stored in your fat cells and cause weight gain

Low-fat diets are often higher in carbohydrates than the average American's diet. Low-fat products take advantage of the fat-carbohydrate trade-off; if you compare "lowfat" cookies with their "normal" counterparts, you may notice that the fat per serving is lower but there is more carbohydrate per serving than the "normal" alternative. Because fat is flavorful, simple sugar and loads of salt may be added to lowfat products to enhance taste.

Carbohydrates are not as good a signal of satiety. In contrast, when you eat a bit of fat, your body "recognizes" it as a signal to limit the amount of intake. So, while a low-fat diet can help you stay healthy, a no-fat diet may encourage you to eat more than you need. If you make up in carb-calories what you lose in fat-grams, excess carbs will be stored as starch in the liver and fat in your fat cells! So even though your diet is low-fat, you may end up gaining weight if you eat more carbs than you use in daily activities.

Lastly, you need the right sorts of carbs to keep healthy and assist weight loss. Simple sugars are quickly absorbed and use little energy to process - in other words, they add lots of calories to your meal. In contrast, foods with more complex carbohydrates, like starches in whole grain breads - take longer for your body to absorb and use more energy. They also give your body time to recognize that you're full. Complex carbohydrates are more likely to have vitamins (like potato skins which have lots of B12) and fiber (like whole grain bread), both of which are important for good health.

Low-Carb Diets

Low-carb diets may help you lose weight by:

* making sure that you're satiated, since both fats are better signals to your body that "food's here!" than carbohydrates

* promoting ketosis: in ketosis/ Ketones are a byproduct of burning fats and proteins instead of carbohydrates.

* leveling out your hormonal response to carbohydrates. We make the hormone insulin in response to food, particularly sugar, entering the body. It's been hypothesized that large changes in insulin levels (for example, a large increase in response to a carb-heavy meal) trigger the storage of sugars as fat.

However, if decreasing carbs increases your fat intake, serious problems can result. In some studies, about 30% of people on low-carbohydrate diets showed an increase in cholesterol levels, even if they lost weight on the diet. Studies have also shown that low-carb diets may increase in kidney problems, especially in people who already had some kidney disease.

In addition, some studies suggest that ketosis in the Atkin's diet is not caused just by fat burn but by burning muscles instead. Muscle loss does result in weight loss, but is unlikely to give you the look you want, or to help you function. Lastly ketosis can be fatal in diabetic - if you're diabetic, you should speak with your doctor before starting any diet.

Women have some special issues to think about when looking at a low-carb diet. Some studies show that people on these diets lose a lot of calcium, which makes them a bad idea for women at risk for osteopenia or osteoporosis. In addition, some low-carb diets do not include the right foods for a balanced intake of vitamins; while a few days of missed vitamins aren't a problem, chronic deficiencies can lead to skin, eye, and bone damage. And for women who are pregnant or trying to become pregnant, ketones can be dangerous for a fetus as well as for you.

Which Diet Should I Use?

The keys to weight loss are moderation and tailoring. If you're interested in losing weight, talk with your healthcare provider about tailoring a weight-loss plan that takes into account your current health and weight-loss goals. Lowering calories and balancing nutrients, rather than focusing on a single "culprit" gives you the best chance of long-term weight reduction.

Auchincloss, E, "Byron's Weight," Times Literary Supplement, 4896, p 15, 1997

Bravata DM, et al." Efficacy and safety of low-carbohydrate diets: A systematic review," Journal of the American Medical Association, Volume 289, issue 14. p 1837?1850. 2003.

Meckling, K, "Comparison of a low-fat diet to a low-carbohydrate diet on weight loss, body composition, and risk factors for diabetes and cardiovascular disease in free-living, overweight men and women," Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, Volume 89, issue 6, pages 2717-23

Westman, EC, et al "Effect of 6-month adherence to a very low carbohydrate diet program," American Journal of Medicine , Volume113, p. 30-36, 2002

Olsen, M., et al,"A low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet versus a low-fat diet to treat obesity and hyperlipidemia," Annals of Internal Medicine, Voume 140 pages769-777, 2004

Copyright (C) Shoppe.MD and Ian Mason, 2004-2005

Learn more about health, diet and exercise at our weight loss forum.

PhenForum.com is a popular discussion forum for weight loss programs, diet tips, and support to help you burn more fat and lose weight permanently.

In The News:

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at https://news.google.com/news

CNN

Low-carb diets might be best for maintaining weight loss, study says
CNN
If you were to describe The Perfect Food, it might go something like this: healthful, delicious, bigger than a morsel and filling enough to fight hunger for hours. "Foods that promote satiety" -- a feeling of lasting fullness -- "do exist," insists Dr ...
For weight-loss maintenance, a low-carb diet may be bestToday Show
Study: Low-carb diets might be best for maintaining weight lossKSAT San Antonio
Low-carb diet helps maintain weight loss: studyFRANCE 24
The BMJ -University of Glasgow -Boston Children's Hospital
all 85 news articles »

Wheeling Intelligencer

Is Exercise Still Important To Weight Loss?
Wheeling Intelligencer
For 10 years, I have been studying the epidemic of failed weight loss attempts and researching the phenomenon of hundreds of millions of people embarking on weight loss attempts – then quitting. In the meantime, exercise remains the most common ...


NBCNews.com

How did this couple lose 130 pounds? Coaching and support
NBCNews.com
“I thought, 'Oh, it's just another weight-loss plan. I've tried them all.' If there was a diet I tried it,” she says. “I'm 48 and my goal was to lose weight by the age of 40. That never happened — I had let myself down. Everything else had failed. I ...


Knoxville News Sentinel

Want to drop 180 pounds in a year? Here's how an East Tennessee school teacher did it.
Knoxville News Sentinel
He came close to opting for a gastric bypass surgery, which aids in weight loss by reducing the amount of food a person's stomach can hold. However, during the preparatory diet before the surgery, Sarshuri chose to instead lose weight through diet ...


Daily weighing may help with weight loss
Healio
CHICAGO — Adults who monitor their weight frequently with daily weighing may be more likely to lose weight and maintain a healthy weight than those who weigh themselves rarely, according to data presented at the American Heart Association Scientific ...


WKYC.com

What trendy weight loss plan works best? We tested a few to find out
WKYC.com
Most weight loss plans start in January as part of a resolution, but we started ours at the end of summer hoping it would help us get a jump start on keeping off those holiday pounds. The “rules” were simple. Pick a plan and do your best to stick with ...


Long-Term Phentermine for Weight Loss Appears Safe, Effective
Medscape
NASHVILLE, Tenn — Long-term, off-label use of the weight-loss drug phentermine appears to be effective and safe, new data suggest. Findings from an electronic record analysis involving nearly 14,000 adult phentermine users were presented November 14 ...


Runner's World

He Learned He Was Going to Be a Dad—So He Vowed to Set a Healthy Example for His Son
Runner's World
The weight loss came fast and furious because there was so much to lose. It was motivating. It was what kept me going. When I didn't feel like running, it was easy to look in my journal and see that I had lost five pounds the week before and the main ...


Bariatric embolization targets ghrelin for weight loss
Healio
At 6 months, the researchers observed a nonsignificant mean weight loss of 16.6 lb, which was 7% of total body weight and 13.7% of excess weight lost, according to Syed, and ghrelin decreased by 9.95%. In the participant with diabetes, HbA1c decreased ...


In Touch Weekly

'90 Day Fiancé' Star Nicole Nafziger Shows Off Weight Loss In Tank Top And Leggings
In Touch Weekly
She's on a mission! Nicole Nafziger is staying on her grind with her fitness journey and she proudly showed off her weight loss progress while clad in gym wear. The 90 Day Fiancé star shared a brand new photo on Nov. 14, where she's rocking a black ...

Google News

Close Kept Secrets to Weight Loss Lesson #12

Are you just exploding with the presence of light all... Read More

The Miracle of a Cheat Meal

One of the greatest tricks that I use to stick... Read More

Could False Memories Be An Efficient Diet Helper?

Speculating on the scientifically proven memory unreliability, the memory specialist... Read More

Healthy Recipes for Low Carb Success

Using healthy low carb recipes are an important part of... Read More

20 Ways to Lose Weight

20 WAYS TO LOSE WEIGHT1. Take it one step at... Read More

Ultimate Weight loss: Ephedra is it Good or Bad?

I have had some e-mails come in and everyone is... Read More

The Truth About Fat

Fat has had a lot of bad press and for... Read More

Relieve Stress at Your Workplace: It Might Just Help You Manage Your Weight!

No doubt about it, when we feel stressed we want... Read More

The Ultimate Weight Loss Product Guide

Are you one of the many who may be tempted... Read More

After WLS: Goodbye Self-Loathing! Hello Self-Loving!

You won't believe what happened to me today!I was getting... Read More

Little Known Facts About Changes In Our Diet

To say that Americans are obsessed with dieting is an... Read More

Lost Weight with Gastric Bypass? Hints for Great After Pictures

I clearly remember how much I loathed having my picture... Read More

Weight Loss Surgery: Successful Patients Embrace Four Stages of Growth

Weight Loss Surgery (WLS) is often viewed as a quick... Read More

1-2-3, Weight Loss & Maintenance Has Become So Easy

Millions of people spend billions of dollars, hoping to achieve... Read More

Dieting While Partying!

It's really difficult for a person to socialise if he... Read More

When Emotional Eating Becomes an Eating Disorder

More and more people are starting to recognize that they... Read More

The Type Of Food and Nutrition That Can Help You Lose Weight Fast

The following are diet tips that can help you shape... Read More

10 Tips for Dining Out

There is no doubt about it; Americans are eating in... Read More

Top 5 Reasons Why Women Over 30 Dont Lose Weight And Keep It Off

Have you heard about it lately? Everywhere you look, women... Read More

Good Food/Bad Food Whats Left to Eat?

We've entered the Twilight Zone when it comes to the... Read More

I Can, I Cant

One common question I receive is, "What do you do... Read More

Just the Cold Hard Facts About Diets, Weight Loss, Exercise and Losing Fat

This is a layman marketer's observations on diets and weight... Read More

No Fuss Weight-Loss

To lose weight and keep it off you need an... Read More

Caution! Watch Out For The Net Carb Trap!

As a low carb dieter, you have probably been bombarded... Read More

Weight Loss: Keeping Your Results Over the Summer

Having just returned from a week of basking on a... Read More