The Old Fashioned: Two Recipes of an Underrated Classic

Like many mixed drinks, the Old Fashioned has a number of variations and a history.

It is one of the few cocktails that survived from the days of the Martini and the Manhattan. When prepared well, it is a full-bodied, delicious drink. It was one of my mother's favorites as a young woman in the 1940's and still carries the glamour of the era.

Accounts agree that the Old Fashioned originated at the Pendennis Club, in Louisville, Kentucky.

This Old Fashioned recipe appeared in a book written by George J. Kappeler, published in 1895, called Modern American Drinks.


Dissolve a small lump of sugar with a little water in a whiskey-glass; add two dashes Angostura bitters, a small piece ice, a piece lemon-peel, one jigger whiskey. Mix with small bar-spoon and serve, leaving spoon in glass.

Robert Hess, writing for, cautions that it is common for modern bartenders to top off the drink with an ounce or more of soda. In his opinion, the soda spoils the drink.

Here is another recipe from Famous New Orleans Drinks and How to Mix'em by Stanley Clisby Arthur.

Old Fashioned Cocktail
1 lump sugar
2 dashes Peychaud or Angostura bitters
1 jigger rye whiskey
1 piece lemon peel
1 chunk pineapple
1 slice orange peel
2 maraschino cherries

Into a heavy-bottomed barglass drop a lump of sugar, dash on the bitters, and crush with a spoon. Pour in the jigger of rye whiskey and stir with several lumps of ice. No shaking allowed! Let the mixture remain in the glass in which it is prepared. Garnish with a half-ring of orange peel, add the chunk of pineapple and the cherries with a little of the maraschino juice. Twist the slice of lemon peel over all and serve in the mixing glass with the barspoon.

It is suggested by some that it is best to dissolve the sugar into a small amount of water first since sugar does not dissolve well in alcohol.

The appearance of additional fruit became commonplace after the days of prohibition.

Try both versions and decide which you prefer.

About the Author

Ellen M. Zucker owns a site where you can find advice on party and event planning from Party Pros. It includes tips, interviews, and advice on putting your event together from professionals who make parties and special events happen.

In The News:

Wine & Spirits Show 2019 launches  The Drinks BusinessFollowing on from the success of the first show in October, the drinks business and The Spirits Business are proud to announce the launch of The Wine & Spirits ...
Exclusive news and research on the wine, spirits and beer business  Shanken News Daily•Patrón Spirits president and CEO Ed Brown will retire at the end of the year, following Bacardi's full acquisition of Patrón earlier this year. During his nearly ...
Zula, Amy Poehler’s Wine Store, Opens in Park Slope  Eater NYComedian and actress Amy Poehler is behind a new wine store that recently slid into Park Slope called Zula Wines & Spirits. Zula opened a few weeks ago at ...
When is the downtown York Fine Wine and Good Spirits store opening?  York Daily RecordIf you frequent downtown York you might have noticed that a Fine Wine and Good Spirits sign has sprouted up right next door to the I-ron-ic cafe window.
Holiday hours for Fine Wine & Good Spirits Stores in York County  York Daily RecordNeed to grab a last-minute bottle of wine for that holiday party or a bottle of champagne for the in-laws? Here are the extended holiday hours for the Fine Wine ...
Sioux Falls liquor business halts discount program, points finger at state regulators  Sioux Falls Argus LeaderA Sioux Falls liquor business has abruptly shelved its long-time rewards and discount programs after its owner say state regulators told him he were running ...
How Wegmans built a network of 'affiliated' liquor stores  Syracuse.comIt started to ramp up in 2007 and 2008: Members of the Wegman family -- operators of one of the biggest and most beloved grocery store chains in New York ...
What To Drink Now: Gifts for Wine and Spirit Lovers  D MagazineHere are a few wine and spirit gifts sure to make recipients swoon this holiday season. (Some selections were sent for editorial consideration.) Any gin expert ...
State turns down license application for giant 'Total Wine' warehouse store in Hartsdale  The Journal News | LoHud.comThe decision came after a three-hour special meeting in New York, with all three SLA commissioners voting against the license application.
Did your Pa. county's wine, spirits sales rise or fall?: liquor board report  PennLive.comA Pa. county-by-county list of PLCB sales during 2017-18 fiscal year, which ran from July 1, 2017, to June 30, 2018.
Purple Wine + Spirits is moving to Petaluma  Petaluma Argus CourierKey to a reconfiguration of Purple Wine + Spirits into a producer of higher-end beverages includes a planned shift early next year of its headquarters and dozens ...
Liquor retailer JAK'S Beer Wine Spirits to open pot stores in Vancouver and across B.C.  Straight.comJAK'S Beer Wine Spirits develops weed retail concept called Muse.
Amy Poehler opened a wine store in Park Slope  Brooklyn VeganMore wine: Amy Poehler has directed upcoming comedy 'Wine Country' that co-stars Tina Fey, Maya Rudolph and Rachel Dratch.
25 winners named for Wine Industry + Spirits Awards, WINnovation Awards of 2018  North Bay Business JournalThese winners of North Bay Business Journal's sixth annual Wine Industry + Spirits & Beer Awards and Wine Industry Network's WINnovation Awards will be ...
Viticulture briefs: Purple Wine + Spirits to move to Petaluma  The Santa Rosa Press DemocratPurple Wine + Spirits moving to Petaluma. Purple Wine + Spirits is moving its headquarters from Graton to Petaluma as owner Derek Benham wants to be closer ...
Target Wine: Bargain or Bust?  fox5sandiego.comWill Burtner, known as Will the Wine Guy, recently tested a variety of Target wines. Watch the video above for his review. SAN DIEGO -- Target rolled out ...
Inaugural Wine & Spirits Show proves a success  The Drinks BusinessProving that two heads are better than one, this year the drinks business teamed up with its sister magazine, The Spirits Business, bringing the world of wine and ...
Should You Worry About Marie Brizard Wine & Spirits SA’s (EPA:MBWS) ROCE?  Simply Wall StToday we'll evaluate Marie Brizard Wine & Spirits SA (EPA:MBWS) to determine whether it could have potential as an investment idea. Specifically, we're going ...
Compass Box debuts one-year-old 'sacrificial spirit'  The Spirits BusinessIndependent Scotch whisky bottler Compass Box has released two limited edition expressions including a one-year-old “sacrificial spirit” that contains liquid from ...
Actress Amy Poehler opens Park Slope wine store  Brooklyn Daily EagleComedian-actress Amy Poehler, a former “Saturday Night Live” regular who is best known for her role on NBC's sitcom “Parks and Recreation,” is one of the ...
Bridgeville wine, spirits store has grand opening | Business  Observer-ReporterThe state Liquor Control Board will have a grand opening of the Fine Wine & Good Spirits Premium Collection at 4 p.m. today in Bridgeville.
Wine Spirits 'n Taco Palooza  WTAJ - www.wearecentralpa.comThe Wine Spirits 'n Taco Palooza is scheduled for Saturday, November 17 at the Blair County Convention Center in Altoona from 12:00 p.m. until 5:00 p.m. Get ...
Beer & Wine Eatery Opens at Hellertown Giant  sauconsource.comAfter months of development and just in time for the holidays, a beer and wine store known as a Beer & Wine Eatery opened inside the Giant supermarket in the ...
Shop Holiday: Gifts for wine and spirits lovers  Pittsburgh Post-GazetteHere are some ideas for making spirits — and wine and spirits lovers — bright.
Food Bank Teams Up With Area Liquor Stores For 'Cheers For Change'  WENY-TVThe Food Bank of the Southern Tier is teaming up with area liquor stores to help those less fortunate this holiday season.
Eye on RI: celebrate the season with festive events!  WPRI 12 Eyewitness NewsAshley Erling brings us "Eye on RI" featuring upcoming local events!
North Coast vintner Derek Benham's 36-year relentless pursuit of innovation  North Bay Business JournalHit wine brands Blackstone and Mark West are part of Derek Benham's nearly four decades of relentless pursuit of innovation. Find out why he's one of this ...
Cincinnati liquor store one of first to debut statewide branding  Cincinnati Business CourierA Cincinnati liquor store set to open on the East Side next week will be one of the first in Ohio to debut new unified branding designed to help overhaul the ...
Top 100 Spirits of 2018  Wine Enthusiast Magazine OnlineKentucky gin? Tequila aged in Napa Cabernet barrels? This year our Top 100 Spirits list has a few surprises alongside old standards. See what made the cut.
Amy Poehler has opened up a new wine store in Brooklyn  Lonely Planet Travel NewsFans of Amy Poehler - or just wine - can celebrate at the actor's new wine store, Zula Wine & Spirits, in Brooklyn, New York.
PREMIUM COLLECTION: Yardley Fine Wine and Good Spirits store to celebrate grand opening with ribbon cutting, one-day sale  Bucks Local NewsYARDLEY BOROUGH > The Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board (PLCB) will cut the ribbon on its new Fine Wine and Good Spirits store on Monday, Nov.
South Africa's wine growers see new demand from China  CNNSouth Africa's L'Huguenot Vineyards doubled exports by securing access to one of the largest wine consumers in the world: China.
Wine and Spirits Class Helps Seniors to Palate Esoteric Subject - DrexelNow  Drexel NowThis piece is part of the new DrexelNow series showcasing "A Day in the Class" for some of Drexel University's most interesting and impactful courses. Stepping ...
Christmas drinks guide: How long can you keep that bottle for? - Virgin Media Television Xposé  virginmediatelevision.ieCatch-up TV, Entertainment, News, Sport, Soaps and all your favourite Irish and International shows from Virgin Media Television.
Sipsong Spirits of Sonoma County wins Wine, Beer + Spirits Industry Awards of 2018  North Bay Business JournalThe first bottling of craft spirits from this one-woman show sold out in a week. Sipsong Spirits is a winner of North Bay Business Journal's Wine, Beer + Spirits ...
What's cooking at Taste! Lancaster food, wine, spirits festival this weekend  LancasterOnlineMany of the regional chefs and exhibitors who were at the 2017 Taste! Lancaster Festival of Food, Wine & Spirits are returning for this year's annual festival, ...
JUST IN: Game of Thrones Scotch Whisky coming to Dayton  Springfield News SunTwo southwest Ohio agency liquor stores will offer a limited number of all eight bottles of The Game of Thrones Single Malt Scotch Whisky Collection for sale at ...
Landmark trade deal: MEPs endorse EU-Japan free trade agreement, big market opportunities ahead  FoodIngredientsFirst13 Dec 2018 --- The European Parliament has endorsed a “landmark” EU-Japan free trade agreement which will remove most duties on EU goods exported to ...
Why champagne and fish go swimmingly together  Scottish FieldWHEN is a wine not a wine? When it's a champagne, of course. While champagne and other bubbles are the bottles of choice for aperitifs to start a meal, seldom ...
Gift guide: 8 food and drink gifts made in Nevada  Reno Gazette JournalFrom sourdough mixes to a lavish foie gras dinner to a potent bloody Mary two-pack, homegrown suggestions for the food and drink lovers on your list.
With opening of The Still House, Gervasi Vineyard expansion increases profile of destination winery resort  cleveland.comGervasi Vineyard has opened The Still House, a coffeehouse by day and cocktail lounge at night.
Penny Lane Wine, Spirits & Beer now open in Rehoboth  CapeGazette.comPenny Lane Wine, Spirits & Beer manager Dave Zacharko said at 600 square feet, he knows Rehoboth's newest liquor store can't have everything, but, he said, ...
NG pops cork on new Nottingham wine bar  East Midlands Business LinkA new wine bar has opened in Nottingham following a deal brokered by commercial property specialists NG Chartered Surveyors.
Police responded to an assault at Dinkytown Wine and Spirits  Minnesota DailyMinneapolis and University of Minnesota police responded to several auto-related incidents and an assault around campus this week.
Drizly Lands $34.5 Million in Series C Funding  Brewbound.comDrizly, a Boston-based on-demand alcohol delivery company, has secured another $34.5 million as part of a Series C fundraising round, according to a ...
Sydney River NSLC among three stores getting new signage  Cape Breton PostSYDNEY RIVER, N.S. — The Nova Scotia Liquor Corporation is preparing to highlight their upcoming new signature stores in the province with new signage.
Texas liquor giant Spec's sues Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission for "abusive" enforcement attempts  The Texas TribuneIn a case that alleges overzealous business regulation, Spec's, the state's largest liquor store chain, is suing the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission for ...
Wine prices set to rise in 2019 - here are four apps to help save you money  This is MoneyWine drinkers are being warned that the price of a bottle of plonk could be set to rise substantially in the next few months thanks to Brexit and tax hikes.
Wine Talk: Israel with a sparkle  The Jerusalem Post - Israel NewsThe winery lies empty and forlorn, turned into a car park no one uses. Tragically, much wine memorabilia, including historical documents and artifacts, went with ...
So you want to… sell your own spirits?  FarmersWeeklyProduction of spirits is going from strength to strength in the UK as an increasing number of consumers turn to premium brands as their choice of drink,
Countdown to Christmas in fine spirits with fun, boozy Advent calendar  Edmonton JournalIt's beginning to look a lot like Christmas. Time for a holiday gift guide for the wine and spirit lovers on your list.Opening those secret cardboard flaps on an ...
Four Thanksgiving wine strategies — and five great bottles for your table  Washington PostThanksgiving is supposed to be a celebration of a successful harvest and a healthy, happy family, but it often seems to celebrate stress instead. What size turkey ...
Online liquor store Drizly just landed $34.5 million in fresh funding  TechCrunchApparently, a lot of people realize at the last minute that they don't have either beer, wine or liquor in their home when they need it. It's certainly the most obvious ...
Sager and Dzelzainis concoct category-breaking Mexican spirits  Harpers Wine & Spirit Trade ReviewA partnership between Michael Sager and Marcis Dzelzainis of London venues Sager + Wilde, together with East London Liquor Company's Alex Wolpert, has...
Southern Glazer's Wine & Spirits Shares Holiday Gift Guide  Business WireSouthern Glazer's offers expert tips for great wine and spirit gifts this holiday season.
Greece ditches unpopular consumer tax on wine  Neos KosmosThe Greek government announced the policy as part of its commitment to support the wine industry. 13 December 2018 4:34pm. Facebook Twitter: ...
Meet the craft distillers of Native America | Nation/World  GazettextraRED CLIFF, Wis. — One of the last relics of federal prohibition may soon come to an end, after Congress two weeks ago voted to lift a 184-year-old ban that.
Chinese wine, spirits seek recognition at international competition  CGTNA Ningxia-based boutique winery won the award at this year's International Wine & Spirit Competition as Chinese wine and spirits are seeking recognition at one ...
Citadel Country Spirit USA Music Festival returning to Chester County  Daily Local NewsWEST VINCENT — The Citadel County Spirit USA Music Festival will return to Chester County for a second year.
What's Hot in Beverages? If They're Craft, Artisan or Locally Made, Line 'Em Up!  RestaurantNews.comCraft, artisan, and locally produced beverages are set to lead the beverage trends in 2019. What's Hot in Beverages? If They're Craft, Artisan or Locally Made, ...
Give the gift of holiday spirits for Boulder County booze fans  Boulder Daily CameraIt wasn't long ago that a gift of Colorado alcohol meant a six-pack of Coors or a bottle of Western Slope riesling. Times have changed. Today, Colorado supports ...
KellerGeist: One German immigrant's furniture store is another's German pub  Great Falls TribuneKellerGeist owners, Matthias and Jolene Schalper, opened the pub and debuted their mini bar at the 2018 Christmas Stroll.
First convenience store-style Hy-Vee opens in Davenport  Quad City TimesA first-of-its-kind convenience store-style Hy-Vee opened on the corner of Elmore Avenue and East Kimberly Road in Davenport Tuesday.
State fines Wegmans $1.1 million for illegally controlling liquor stores  syracuse.comThe Rochester-based Wegmans supermarket chain and five affiliated liquor stores in Upstate New York have been fined $1.1 million for violations of state ...
A bottle of extremely rare $75K whisky is being sold at this Vancouver liquor store  Vancouver Is AwesomeOne bottle of one of the world's rarest and finest whiskies debuted in Canada yesterday, and it is being sold in a Vancouver store. Indeed, The Balvenie Fifty: ...
The 11 best whiskies to buy for Christmas  Evening StandardWhisky is having a moment – just recently, a 1926 Macallan broke records when it sold for £1.2million at Christie's; last month, Bonhams sold a similar vintage ...
Cheers Morristown - A Beer, Wine & Spirits Fest - Jan. 19  NJNextCheers Morristown – A Beer, Wine & Spirits Fest – will be held Saturday, January 19th at the Morristown Armory at 430 Western Avenue, Morristown. Minutes ...
Looking for Arizona wine? 10 best local wine stores in Phoenix  AZCentralNext time you're headed to BevMo or Total Wine, why not try a local wine store instead? All of these Phoenix wine shops offer Arizona wine and more.
The day before Thanksgiving is the busiest of the year at Utah liquor stores  Salt Lake TribuneLimited parking. Empty shelves. Long checkout lines. That's what Dailene Christensen dodged by shopping at a Salt Lake City wine store Tuesday. “We wanted ...

The Origin of the Cocktail

The cocktail has the distinction of being an original American... Read More

Carignane Wine

The Carignane grape variety is one of the most widely... Read More

Overcoming Red Wine Spills

Red wine spills can be a disaster whether they occur... Read More

The Truth About Red Wine and Heart Disease

Red Wine, Heart Disease, Hungry Sharks and Knights in Shining... Read More

Sauvignon Blanc Wine

Sauvignon Blanc wine is crisp, high in acidity and light-... Read More

Uses of Mirror Tinted Contact Lenses

Mirror tinted contact lenses have become a topic of interest... Read More

Australian Wines

Australia's wine industry has boomed in the past ten years.... Read More

Beer, Wine and Your Bones

If you like the taste of a good brew, then... Read More

The Harmony between Wine and Food

Wine is a social drink which should be enjoyed in... Read More

France Car Hire

Here is a quick summary of the different French wine... Read More

Alchoholism, A Major Diesease?

Alcoholism can be given a lot of definitions and all... Read More

How To Open Champagne

I manage a highly regarded web community for corporate flight... Read More

An Idiots Guide To Wine Tasting

Have you ever seen those stiff upper-lipped types doing a... Read More

Counting Carbs With Wine

The recent health claims that wines have antioxidants... Read More

Enjoy Your Favorite Wine - But With Some Rules

The mere mention of etiquette brings to mind various images,... Read More

Using Cooking Wine

Cooking wine is sort of a holdover from prohibition. People... Read More

The Cocktail Party

A cocktail party can be more daunting than a dinner... Read More

The Harmony Between Food and Wine

Wine is a social drink which should be enjoyed in... Read More

Choosing that Perfect Wine for a Dinner Party

So, you find yourself having been invited to a dinner... Read More

Riesling Wine

The most famous cool climates for Riesling wine are in... Read More

The Mystery of Decanting

Decanting is a strange word to many people. Some do... Read More

Build Your Own Wine Rack (In An Afternoon)

A good drink is what even Gods enjoy and to... Read More

Start Your Wine Cellar The Right Way

One of the great joys of wine is to be... Read More

If You Plan On Drinking, Do These Critical Things Before You Leave The House

Buy a BreathalyzerA Breathalyzer is a portable hand-held device in... Read More

A Private Owners Guide to Bottling Fine Whisky

The majority of private owners of whisky casks are looking... Read More